Wagon Wheel

The staffs were very nice and friendly. I always visited with kids, and the staffs already remembered what we want to order. We like their pizza, best in town. The crust is light and fluffy. The sauce is just right for us, not too sour, not too acidic taste. They talked friendly with customers. It make me feel so warm and friendly when I dine in there.

I went here with my uncle about 7 years ago & I still haven't stopped telling people how this place had the best pizza I ever had & how awsome the owner was! I hope to visit yall again sooner than later!

The pizza is amazing. Crispy with a fluffy crust. No bland pizza sauce here. Flavorful and delicious. The owner Pizza Pete is friendly and has a great sense of humor. Authentic New York style pizza. Best pizza west of Italy!!!!

Cheers to Wagon Wheel Pizza and Pete the owner who couldn't have been nicer when we placed a large order for our wedding after party. He worked with us to revise our order a few times and kept us updated on its status. Needless to say it is the best pizza in the area. Our only problem is we should have ordered more!

We ordered a mushroom pie and two meat lover slices, everything was excellent. The sauce isn't acidic and the crust is light and fluffy. Tasted great reheated as well. The owner is friendly and has been in the area for decades. Cash only but there is an ATM on site. I highly recommend this spot.

I am in my 50's and remember my mom bringing me to the Wagon Wheel as a very young boy after she made her trip to the Mid Hudson Savings Bank on Mill St. I think the interior has remained the same through the years. Pete makes excellent pizza. You can also purchase fresh pizza dough to make at home (also excellent!)

Now his pizza is the Best. Every Pizza is really good but his is different has a unique style with lots of good toppings my favorite is pepperoni it's really good and delicious yum... My 9 year old Ramsey

HANDS DOWN AMAZING PIZZA! When you walk into the place your like um what the heck did I walk into....... One pizza oven, one guy, pizza made to order this isn't gonna be good BUT let me say I've eaten at many pizzerias up and down the east coast. Wagon Wheel Pizza is easily in top 3 if not the BEST!!! I was literally in shock and blown away by how good it was. I'll be back here many many times!!! Keep it up Pete!!!

No other pizzeria could compare! This family run place is always kind and welcoming to customers new and old. The pizza itself is so fresh, and made right in front of you. The crust is crispy on the outside and soft on the inside and the sauce is nothing like other places. Would highly recommend coming here! Heads up: cash-only! Yes, atm is available.

Best pizza in Dutchess County

What a find! Our group was in town for a cross country meet and after reading the great reviews we decided to give Wagon Wheel a try. First, the owner (Pete) is extremely kind, professional and went above and beyond for us. When I went in to place the order it was so nice to learn it was a multi generation business and his father handmade all of the tables and booths. We ordered 10 pizzas and probably should have ordered 20 since it was some of the best we have ever had. Thank You! We look forward to coming back the next time we are in town.

Alice Mauch

By far the best pizza in town nice crispy crust with flavorful sauce and good cheese. Owner is super friendly. I highly recommend ….prices are great also.☺️

Anita S

What a find! Our group was in town for a cross country meet and after reading the great reviews we decided to give Wagon Wheel a try. First, the owner (Pete) is extremely kind, professional and went above and beyond for us. When I went in to place the order it was so nice to learn it was a multi generation business and his father handmade all of the tables and booths. We ordered 10 pizzas and probably should have ordered 20 since it was some of the best we have ever had. Thank You! We look forward to coming back the next time we are in town.

John Gomez

Peter is the man. Haven’t had this great of a pizza in many years. We came in and Peter had a perfect pepperoni pizza ready within 20 mins. Perfect crisp, perfect thickness, perfect sauce and cheese. I highly recommend this place. I would come here again. Thanks Pete !!!!

Dave Scott

This was our first time at Wagon Wheel, but it was definitely the best pizza in the region! Crust was perfect, sauce was homemade and not too spicy, high-quality ingredients and all for a great price. Pete offered great, personal service and the restaurant is family friendly. Bring cash; no credit cards. Great pizza, Pete! We will definitely be back.

Daniel Horwith

Awesome pizza, every slice is guaranteed to be delicious. Great prices. The owner, Pete is such a great guy. Hands down, best pizza in Wappingers.

John Ciccone

Hands down the best pizza in Wappinger. Pete is a great guy who runs a clean, well-organized shop and takes pride in serving consistently delicious pizza. Fresh ingredients, perfect crust, and friendly service make this place a local favorite.

Arcadia

I went here with my uncle about 7 years ago & I still haven't stopped telling people how this place had the best pizza I ever had & how awsome the owner was! I hope to visit yall again sooner than later!

Alex Basile

Multi generation real deal quality Pizza that only existed long ago! The owner makes his own dough and sauce each morning. Not the oily cardboard stuff we've learned to accept. Tastes amazing!!! Can't get enough...

Bronx Bomer Pito !!

Now his pizza is the Best. Every Pizza is really good but his is different has a unique style with lots of good toppings my favorite is pepperoni it's really good and delicious yum... My 9 year old Ramsey

Maddalena Petrillo

I love the village feel of the place. Plus Pete is just a real stand up guy. Food is always hot, not greasy, exceptional value! Just wish he'd make me a calzone 😆.

Jacob Rheinstein

Cheers to Wagon Wheel Pizza and Pete the owner who couldn't have been nicer when we placed a large order for our wedding after party. He worked with us to revise our order a few times and kept us updated on its status. Needless to say it is the best pizza in the area. Our only problem is we should have ordered more!

Daryl Thorpe

Pleasantly surprised! Discovered the Wagon Wheel on my way to another (unnamed) pizza place. Pizza was flavorful, the crust was nice and crispy. Definitely will return.

Julie Truncali

The pizza is amazing. Crispy with a fluffy crust. No bland pizza sauce here. Flavorful and delicious. The owner Pizza Pete is friendly and has a great sense of humor. Authentic New York style pizza. Best pizza west of Italy!!!!

Fernando DaCunha

We ordered a mushroom pie and two meat lover slices, everything was excellent. The sauce isn't acidic and the crust is light and fluffy. Tasted great reheated as well. The owner is friendly and has been in the area for decades. Cash only but there is an ATM on site. I highly recommend this spot.

DaDa

The staffs were very nice and friendly. I always visited with kids, and the staffs already remembered what we want to order. We like their pizza, best in town. The crust is light and fluffy. The sauce is just right for us, not too sour, not too acidic taste. They talked friendly with customers. It make me feel so warm and friendly when I dine in there.

Louis Jansen

HANDS DOWN AMAZING PIZZA! When you walk into the place your like um what the heck did I walk into....... One pizza oven, one guy, pizza made to order this isn't gonna be good BUT let me say I've eaten at many pizzerias up and down the east coast. Wagon Wheel Pizza is easily in top 3 if not the BEST!!! I was literally in shock and blown away by how good it was. I'll be back here many many times!!! Keep it up Pete!!!

Robert Stoffel

I am in my 50's and remember my mom bringing me to the Wagon Wheel as a very young boy after she made her trip to the Mid Hudson Savings Bank on Mill St. I think the interior has remained the same through the years. Pete makes excellent pizza. You can also purchase fresh pizza dough to make at home (also excellent!)

The pizza was worthy of the Bronx truly old school pizza place you can watch them make the pizza and toss it in front of you while you sit at the counter or at your booth. The night we went it was just the owner and he did it all made the pizza and waited the tables. The pizza was delicious and sauce had nice flavor, the crust was crispy and not to thick nor to thing and folded perfectly.

Ralph Tony Francisco

The pizza was worthy of the Bronx truly old school pizza place you can watch them make the pizza and toss it in front of you while you sit at the counter or at your booth. The night we went it was just the owner and he did it all made the pizza and waited the tables. The pizza was delicious and sauce had nice flavor, the crust was crispy and not to thick nor to thing and folded perfectly.