Yaphank Community Pizza

I was looking for a pizza nearby and found this place. Didn’t know what to expect but just a normal regular pizza but got surprised by how good it was. I just got a plain pie with half pepperoni and it was really scrumptious. One of the best long island pizzas I’ve ever tried.

The Best pizza ever! I have been going there for as long as I can remember. I'm always greeted with a smile and hello. They are super friendly. The food is fantastic. I've eaten inside and picked up. Their salads are delicious, homemade cheesecake people! They are to die for. Once you try it, you'll be hooked!

I have been ordering food from them q my family for 20+ years. Pizza is amazing....love love there pineapple pizza...there Greek salad is absolutely amazing....not matter where I go.....nobody does a Greek salad like them!!! Great local pizza shop!! Life time customer here!!

Probably one of the best pizza places here on Long Island. The food is always fresh and delicious. The workers are extremely nice and welcoming. I love their pizza and their garlic knots. Definitely worth stopping by!

Ordered dinner and wings here for the first time 12/26/21. We ordered the Italian trio, Buffalo wings, and two slices of pizza. Our kids enjoyed the pizza and my wife and I really enjoyed the wings, lasagna, chicken parm, and ravioli. The sauce was tasty and everything was well cooked. The place was clean and the people there were very friendly. Will definitely be ordering dinner from here again in the near future!

The owners here are wonderful. We've been coming here and getting delivery for years. Best garlic knots in the area. I also recommend the cheesy garlic bread, and they make excellent antipasto salads. The penne a la vodka is excellent. You'll get enough for two meals in one order. And their heroes are delicious.

This place is wonderful. The delivery service is top notch. I order food for a friend and when they delivered no one was home. They went above and beyond to contact me and redeliver the food. I highly recommend them as they truly care about their customers.

I love this place so much anytime I come in there they give me free waters. The staff is so nice and their pizza is the best pizza I’ve had out here I recommend this place to anybody who wants to come to Yaphank

Gerald Waldron

5-25-25 It was a recommendation from a work friend. The meatball parm hero was sooo good. We got 2 more meals from it. It was reheated and tasted better for the second meal. We also had the fried ravioli. It has 8 pieces and was delicious. The side sauce was not too sweet or too garlicy. The price for both was very reasonable. Gotta try the pizza next. We'll be back. 6-20-25 We went back and ordered the lasagna and a side it meatballs. So so delicious. The food is seasoned and cooked just right. We will go again to try something else. I highly recommend this place.

Daius Velazquez

I love this place so much anytime I come in there they give me free waters. The staff is so nice and their pizza is the best pizza I’ve had out here I recommend this place to anybody who wants to come to Yaphank

Rachel

I was looking for a pizza nearby and found this place. Didn’t know what to expect but just a normal regular pizza but got surprised by how good it was. I just got a plain pie with half pepperoni and it was really scrumptious. One of the best long island pizzas I’ve ever tried.

Michelle Formisano

I have been ordering food from them q my family for 20+ years. Pizza is amazing....love love there pineapple pizza...there Greek salad is absolutely amazing....not matter where I go.....nobody does a Greek salad like them!!! Great local pizza shop!! Life time customer here!!

Janice Pedone

This place is wonderful. The delivery service is top notch. I order food for a friend and when they delivered no one was home. They went above and beyond to contact me and redeliver the food. I highly recommend them as they truly care about their customers.

Better Shope

Absolutely scrumptious! We frequent this spot nearly every Friday evening, and there's never any remnants. The pizza is simply divine. Additionally, we indulge in heroes from this establishment, and they're exceedingly delectable, substantial, and satisfying. Even if I'm unable to polish it off, I must persevere because it's incredibly fantastic. I highly recommend that everyone give this pizzeria a try.

Will Fassino

Always delicious! We go here almost every Friday night and there are never leftovers. The pizza is just so good. We also order heros from here and they are very good, stacked, and filling. Even if I can't finish it I have to because it's so damn good. Would recommend everybody try this pizza place.

Tara McGovern

Best pizza around. We've tried pretty much every pizza place from center moriches to middle island and they have the best pizza by far. I drive 20 minutes to go here. Their cheesecakes are amazing too!

Victoria Elizabeth

Probably one of the best pizza places here on Long Island. The food is always fresh and delicious. The workers are extremely nice and welcoming. I love their pizza and their garlic knots. Definitely worth stopping by!

Dorisann Kraniak

The Best pizza ever! I have been going there for as long as I can remember. I'm always greeted with a smile and hello. They are super friendly. The food is fantastic. I've eaten inside and picked up. Their salads are delicious, homemade cheesecake people! They are to die for. Once you try it, you'll be hooked!

Rachel Tomasky

We finally stopped in the other day. It was small quite little place. We got some pizza, and it was very good. We haven't tried anything else yet but overall we were very happy. The woman behind the counter was super nice.

Matt Kranz

Ordered dinner and wings here for the first time 12/26/21. We ordered the Italian trio, Buffalo wings, and two slices of pizza. Our kids enjoyed the pizza and my wife and I really enjoyed the wings, lasagna, chicken parm, and ravioli. The sauce was tasty and everything was well cooked. The place was clean and the people there were very friendly. Will definitely be ordering dinner from here again in the near future!

Jessica Sullivan

The owners here are wonderful. We've been coming here and getting delivery for years. Best garlic knots in the area. I also recommend the cheesy garlic bread, and they make excellent antipasto salads. The penne a la vodka is excellent. You'll get enough for two meals in one order. And their heroes are delicious.

Finding this place was a stroke of luck. Gave it a try and found it to be a great place for lunch. The Grandma's Pizza was great and the Meatball pizza was loaded with meatballs and cheese at a very very reasonable price. After eating the pizza and reading the menu we decided that we'll return for dinner soon. I'll post additional comments after dinner.

I went to this pizza place on the invite of others to meet for a lunch special. Two slices and small soda for $6.75 along with 2 garlic nots. I had Sicilian slices for a paltry 20 cents more. Very good pizza though those that like a real cheesy pizza should like it even more than I did as i prefer a more saucy flavor. The crunch and texture and cheese was spot on. There is also a Ziti special that is also very cheesy for about 50 cents more. I say about because these prices only recently went up and I did not notice the current price of the ziti special. The soda is self serve and refills are free

John Blair (jb)

I went to this pizza place on the invite of others to meet for a lunch special. Two slices and small soda for $6.75 along with 2 garlic nots. I had Sicilian slices for a paltry 20 cents more. Very good pizza though those that like a real cheesy pizza should like it even more than I did as i prefer a more saucy flavor. The crunch and texture and cheese was spot on. There is also a Ziti special that is also very cheesy for about 50 cents more. I say about because these prices only recently went up and I did not notice the current price of the ziti special. The soda is self serve and refills are free

Richard Deir

Finding this place was a stroke of luck. Gave it a try and found it to be a great place for lunch. The Grandma's Pizza was great and the Meatball pizza was loaded with meatballs and cheese at a very very reasonable price. After eating the pizza and reading the menu we decided that we'll return for dinner soon. I'll post additional comments after dinner.

Better pizza choices in the area, first time in there the slices, even a plain cheese, looked and tasted like they'd been sitting around for too long... maybe days. The one thing I did enjoy was the garlic knots, that's my go-to at every place and these had significantly more greasy clumps of garlic on and around them than any I've ever seen... THAT was delicious

Bill Glueckert

Better pizza choices in the area, first time in there the slices, even a plain cheese, looked and tasted like they'd been sitting around for too long... maybe days. The one thing I did enjoy was the garlic knots, that's my go-to at every place and these had significantly more greasy clumps of garlic on and around them than any I've ever seen... THAT was delicious

This place is a disgrace to Italian culture When I fist walked in it smelt like a smelly gym , the food looked like it’s been sitting out for 3 plus days my grandma slice was so greesy I couldn’t even eat it I also got a speciality slice chicken bacon ranch that was also so gross I couldn’t even it I never write bad reviews but I feel that this was much needed you guys are hanging on my limbs it feels like there is a reason nobody is ever in there 2 or my buddies tried the pizza a few weeks ago didn’t like it either I feel that this is the owner fault or who ever is making the pizza and running things around here the lady was even touching my pizza with no gloves with a dirty band aid on This is just neglect to your Buisness and obviously no effort shown to care about your Buisness more needs to be done food needs to be better and more fresh , place needs to be cleaned way better including behind the counter I hope something is done about this I don’t like seeing small Buisness go out of Buisness

John Yeager

This place is a disgrace to Italian culture When I fist walked in it smelt like a smelly gym , the food looked like it’s been sitting out for 3 plus days my grandma slice was so greesy I couldn’t even eat it I also got a speciality slice chicken bacon ranch that was also so gross I couldn’t even it I never write bad reviews but I feel that this was much needed you guys are hanging on my limbs it feels like there is a reason nobody is ever in there 2 or my buddies tried the pizza a few weeks ago didn’t like it either I feel that this is the owner fault or who ever is making the pizza and running things around here the lady was even touching my pizza with no gloves with a dirty band aid on This is just neglect to your Buisness and obviously no effort shown to care about your Buisness more needs to be done food needs to be better and more fresh , place needs to be cleaned way better including behind the counter I hope something is done about this I don’t like seeing small Buisness go out of Buisness

Robert Cooper

Not happy. I spend $70.00 everytime I go here. Today a pie with 2 toppings, a second pie with 2 toppings, and a third with 1 topping, + dozen garlic knots. I get home and one of the 2 topping pies had slid completely off the dough. I called and was told "it's the last pie that came out of the oven. Maybe it didn't sit even". But, my other pies were perfect..... You lost me as a customer. I will no longer give you my business. You had an opportunity to correct it and made no effort. I will spend my money elsewhere. Mr. Cooper.