Howard Albertsen

The cheese pizza slice I had was great ! The price is REALLY great for the taste. Most affordable slice I've had in the city so far. If u want good quality for a good price, come here.

Morgan Rudluff

We showed up for late night pizza and it was excellent. Dough was exceptional, actually. Flavorful, a bit greasy (in a good way!), and big slices. Mustafio himself is super nice!

Alex Little

I come here a few times a week and love this place. The pizza is great and the owner gives great conversation. Also they are open until 4am, which is rare these days.

Christina

Mustafio's isn't just a pizza place — it's an experience. Hands down, this is some of the best pizza in San Francisco. Each slice is exactly what pizza should be: the crust is perfectly cooked (none of that half-done doughy stuff), and the flavor is spot on. The guy behind the counter is kind, welcoming, and genuinely human. You feel like you’re being taken care of, not just served. The place is small (about three tables), but that just adds to the charm. It's cozy, real, and full of heart. Whether you're a local or just passing through, do yourself a favor and grab a slice. Mustafio's is a gem that gets it right.

Suomaf Reven

Love coming over here great service great pizza one of my mandatory stops if you like pizza this place is a must! Really Really!

Aaron Salazar

I recently visited Mustfio’s on February 13, 2025, and had an outstanding experience! From the moment I walked in, the service was impeccable—definitely a 10/10 for their attentive and friendly staff. The highlight of my visit was undoubtedly the Chicken Pesto Pizza. It was bursting with flavor, featuring perfectly seasoned chicken, a rich pesto sauce, and a delightfully crispy crust. Every bite was a treat, showcasing fresh ingredients and expert preparation. Overall, I'd give Mustfio’s a solid 5-star rating. If you're in the mood for delicious pizza paired with exceptional service, this is the place to be. Highly recommended!

Ricky T

Good energy! Pizza great chicken pesto! Open till 4am come thru and say hello! The man is from India ask about his journey!

Yerena Duran

I’ve been coming here with my husband every time we come to SF. Most people get hotdogs after a concert/show we get pizza and this place is a must for us. The slices a huge it’s equivalent to 3 normal slices it’s very cheesy and the dough is so crispy from the outside and moist from the inside (chef’s kiss) I love that they just put the right amount of sauce. This pizza is perfect in my opinion. I highly recommend this place.

Lawrence “Larry” Di Mare

Great pizza period. I have been eating pizza here for the last 10 years. Whether getting a full pie or just a slice. Affordable , delicious and friendly. The management and staff do a great job in remembering you and your order. When was the last time you had that experience. Go check them out in the Polk Gulch.

Roy C

I walked here, pretty far out of my way, because of all the excellent reviews. If you like soft, greasy, soggy pizza - which apparently some people do, more power to them - this is the place for you. Otherwise, friendly service and average to below average pizza. Not a 4.7 star pizza.

T W

I don't understand these 5 star reviews. The pizza I had was very underwhelming. Maybe because it was late at night, but given the raving reviews, I was expecting more. Soggy crust, undercooked toppings, and very bland flavor. I literally threw the entire 14" pizza away. Are we eating the same food? And $12 for a really basic side salad with highschool cafeteria Caesar dressing? This is not a 4.7 star rating restaurant.

Brandon Johnson

The owner will blatantly pick out the worst piece of pizza he has in the window for people he THINKS are paying with EBT. When I first started going there, I’d get decent slices until the first time I paid with EBT. Since then I’ve been getting the burnt corner pieces of the OLD pizza in the window when the people before me get fresh slices. I continued going, usually multiple times a week, just giving him the benefit of the doubt, but it has continued to be the case every time I go in there. I just said something about it to him, and left with a heat lamp burnt middle piece of the old pie instead of the burnt corner piece he initially grabbed like he always does. Mind you, there are 2 more of the same pizzas in the window that both have slices sold from them. Happens every time and it’s my last time going in there. He just lost a consistent customer.