Brothers Pizza

I would highly recommend this place, this is our last day in Margaretville and we wished we found it earlier. We ate at several solid restaurants here (both in Phoenicia and Fleiscanns) and this was the best food. Not much of a place to eat in. We are pizza snobs and it’s on par with with some of NYC’s better places. We had a complicated order (half meatball, half pesto, + ricotta) and they got it right. Crust has a great crisp and sauce had solid flavor. Prices were reasonable. I feel like going back for more tonight.

Yum! Veggie lovers pizza is delicious, lots of broccoli and olives. Crust is so goooooood! Not super thin, but I like the medium crust anyway. Highly recommend Brothers, and so happy it’s here! ❤️

I ordered half cheese half pepperoni large pizza. The pizza was perfect and delicious. The crust was crispy and soft the cheese was perfectly melted.

Very tasteful pizza. It's probably the best I've ever had.

Just returned to find this pizza shop revamped, painted and open. Can get slices. Excellent and priced $$. I had the mushroom slices and wasnot disappointed. Crust A+.

Phil Grocholl

Great pizza, with a soft crust (easier to chew) good flavor, and didn't take long to get the pizza either. One of the better pizza joints in the area.

Crystal G

Very tasteful pizza. It's probably the best I've ever had.

Jeantet Fields

Simply great. This area has needed a great pizza shop, and we finally have one. The pizza is tasty, crust is thin and crunchy, sauce isn't too sweet or too tart, it's just a great slice of pizza! I was adventuresome and tried the buffalo chicken ranch slice and it had some kick to it! Whew! And the pepperoni slice was good too, but had trouble competing with the intensity of the buffalo chicken. I should have eaten them in the reverse order. I enjoyed the entire slice right through the crust, which says a lot. The dining room is simple if not a little sparse, and was very clean. I took advantage of the lunch special where two slices and a drink are very reasonable, and I loved the fact the point of sale system didn't guilt me into a tip on my take out order. Welcome to the neighborhood! I will be back, a lot.

char roberts

We have really enjoyed the pizza and wings from here for the past 6 months. The crust is airy and very tasty. The specialty pie is our favorite. The wings are the best. Keep up the good work

luxin obscuro

I ordered half cheese half pepperoni large pizza. The pizza was perfect and delicious. The crust was crispy and soft the cheese was perfectly melted.

K. Mehert K. Selam

I love this pizza of shop. Its tucked away in a small town between margaretville and arkville. The pizza is handmade. I always try to go and grab us fresh slice out of the oven of either cheese or mushroom pizza right before work. They even make the bottom a little crispy for me just the way I like it.

Kayur Patel

I would highly recommend this place, this is our last day in Margaretville and we wished we found it earlier. We ate at several solid restaurants here (both in Phoenicia and Fleiscanns) and this was the best food. Not much of a place to eat in. We are pizza snobs and it’s on par with with some of NYC’s better places. We had a complicated order (half meatball, half pesto, + ricotta) and they got it right. Crust has a great crisp and sauce had solid flavor. Prices were reasonable. I feel like going back for more tonight.

Pat Gonzalez

Just returned to find this pizza shop revamped, painted and open. Can get slices. Excellent and priced $$. I had the mushroom slices and wasnot disappointed. Crust A+.

Trish Kositzky

Yum! Veggie lovers pizza is delicious, lots of broccoli and olives. Crust is so goooooood! Not super thin, but I like the medium crust anyway. Highly recommend Brothers, and so happy it’s here! ❤️

I thought the margherita pizza was great, especially the dough. Good amount of cheese, not too salty, recommended. I had it there while it was hot, the restaurant itself is pretty barebones.

Javier Kohen

I thought the margherita pizza was great, especially the dough. Good amount of cheese, not too salty, recommended. I had it there while it was hot, the restaurant itself is pretty barebones.

Small town pizzeria offering a variety of pizza parlor foods. The pizza is pretty good and not crazy in price. I hope they stay around for a long time! Very nice people, try them out!!

Pizza was excellent. Very few tables for dining-in and tables needed cleaning with dish cloth-had to request this. Would recommend this place for take-out only. We had 1 cheese pizza and 1 meatball pizza.

Kathy H

Small town pizzeria offering a variety of pizza parlor foods. The pizza is pretty good and not crazy in price. I hope they stay around for a long time! Very nice people, try them out!!

Beverly Santo

Pizza was excellent. Very few tables for dining-in and tables needed cleaning with dish cloth-had to request this. Would recommend this place for take-out only. We had 1 cheese pizza and 1 meatball pizza.

This pizza is not good. Ordered a Margherita pizza that had no flavor whatsoever. Not even the tomatoes on top tasted like tomatoes.

Very underwhelming pizza. Saw them putting frozen eggplant in oven for the parm. Sauce was bad. Don't waste your time.

Prince Jewell

This pizza is not good. Ordered a Margherita pizza that had no flavor whatsoever. Not even the tomatoes on top tasted like tomatoes.

Jeff B.

Very underwhelming pizza. Saw them putting frozen eggplant in oven for the parm. Sauce was bad. Don't waste your time.

Ordered 140 dollars worth of pizza to go and needed some plastic cups so the crew could have something to drink and they charged me money for the cups. I couldn't buy the soda from cause they had no 2 liter bottles in stock or I would have bought from them. Pizza at best is mediocre crust was doughy hardly any sauce and pretty skimpy with the toppings. The wings were ehh. If someone wanted a slice of sausage from the pie they were gonna be disappointed with the slice in picture.

Andrew Tubby

Ordered 140 dollars worth of pizza to go and needed some plastic cups so the crew could have something to drink and they charged me money for the cups. I couldn't buy the soda from cause they had no 2 liter bottles in stock or I would have bought from them. Pizza at best is mediocre crust was doughy hardly any sauce and pretty skimpy with the toppings. The wings were ehh. If someone wanted a slice of sausage from the pie they were gonna be disappointed with the slice in picture.

It’s horrible. We ordered 2 Margherita pizzas- they have no idea what a margherita pizza looks like. Cheese is poor quality. Sauce has no taste. It smells like a kitchen sponge. And two pies were >$50!!!!! Just don’t.

It was shortly after the 11 AM time to open, we were outside the business...the door was locked and they would not answer the phone...despite someone inside working. I would suggest if you are to open at 11 AM you get to work sufficiently early to prep. We will not be going back.

Brenda Ramal

It’s horrible. We ordered 2 Margherita pizzas- they have no idea what a margherita pizza looks like. Cheese is poor quality. Sauce has no taste. It smells like a kitchen sponge. And two pies were >$50!!!!! Just don’t.

Gary C

It was shortly after the 11 AM time to open, we were outside the business...the door was locked and they would not answer the phone...despite someone inside working. I would suggest if you are to open at 11 AM you get to work sufficiently early to prep. We will not be going back.