The phoenicia diner is the best breakfast diner around thay have the best food you will find and breakfast all day! The service is very good and my family and I have been going here for years, in the photo I got the wittenberg bagel and the kids pancakes and the make your own omelet with a salad the food is great I would recommend the side of potatoes and overall the food is the best around.

Really liked this place. A very sophisticated menu, good food and a good bartender. I ordered a Benny with roasted foraged mushrooms, fresh spinach and a side of cheese grits. All excellent. The potatoes were over fried and brown but I don’t eat much of that anyway. Definitely recommend.

Regie Noel

Definitely one of the best tasting pancakes I've had. My fiance isn't too crazy about pancakes and she absolutely loved them. The steelhead trout platter was also delicious. Overall, great food and top tier personalized service. We will definitely be back!

We ended our trip with breakfast at the iconic Phoenicia Diner. It was a bit busy when we arrived, but the system was smooth, you’re given a number and can wait by the bar. The bar itself is worth mentioning, a large drink menu filled with specialty coffees, teas, and even alcoholic options. We ordered a latte and a matcha. Both were good and hit the spot, though nothing particularly memorable. The wait went by quickly, and the service was fantastic, friendly, efficient, and welcoming despite the crowd. Now, the food. This place absolutely lived up to the hype. Taco Skillet – The portion was perfect, and the flavors were bursting in every bite. It was hearty without being overwhelming, and I finished the entire thing without hesitation. Full Phoenicia Breakfast – A true staple. It had everything you’d want in a classic breakfast plate. The over-easy eggs were cooked perfectly, the sausage was juicy and flavorful, and the grilled tomatoes were a delicious addition that tied the whole plate together. The Pancakes – Let me start by saying we are not pancake people. But these were highly recommended, so we gave them a shot and wow. They were fluffy, soft, and easily some of the best pancakes we’ve ever had. They didn’t even need syrup. We genuinely regretted not coming here for lunch or dinner during our trip. If the Phoenicia Diner is on your route or even slightly out of the way, it’s absolutely worth the stop. We’ll 100% be back

Shane Sloan

When here for breakfast before climbing Hunter Mountain. My friend said it was her favorite place to eat in the area. She wasn't wrong. The food is great. The portions are good. The majority of the food seems to be locally sourced. After we climb the mountain we came back for boozy milkshakes. The same server was there and remembered us. Somehow we even got our own table back from earlier. Hoping Katy and I make that our own personal table for several visits to come

Clare Chen

Vintage chic diner serving quality, local, “real” food. We loved the 3500 plate comes with little bit of everything you want for a diner food: one pancake, one piece of french toast, one pork sausage, some bacons, and eggs. We also ordered the scrambled eggs with smoked trout that comes on a hot skillet served with toast. everything tasted fresh and was well made. will come again! plus, the swags are cute!

+2

Baotri Nguyen

It was an honor to dine at such an institutional establishment. They have a spacious outdoor space if you want to dine outside with a camper serving drinks. We opted to wait inside. We came towards the tail-end of brunch service so the wait was about 30 min but it cleared out quickly once the afternoon hour hit. Food was delicious and the staff were all very kind and attentive. The place gets really busy for breakfast so I recommend coming early to put your name down. I’d definitely get the hash browns again. Order highlight! My only gripe is that the toast slices were super tiny. Please give us larger pieces!

Barbi V.

Phoenicia Diner is a cozy, homey spot that instantly makes you feel welcome. The space is beautifully decorated for the holidays, giving it a festive, comforting vibe, and the staff were friendly, attentive, and genuinely kind. The food overall was solid, though a bit mixed. The eggs and sausage were flavorful and well done, while the pancakes were good but not particularly memorable. The juices are advertised as freshly squeezed, but they tasted more like concentrate than fresh, which was a little disappointing. That said, my breakfast special was exceptional. The seasonal turkey with fennel, fried Brussels sprouts, Phoenicia potatoes, and eggs was standout and absolutely worth ordering. It felt thoughtful, hearty, and satisfying, especially on a chilly fall/winter day. Despite a few misses, this is a welcoming, family-friendly spot in a great Catskills location. I’d definitely return with the kids for the atmosphere, comfort, and friendly service alone — and I’d happily order the specials again.

+5

abu wang

This is the kind of restaurant you'll definitely want to try if you happen to pass by. In this small town with a small population, it's one of the few restaurants with a full parking lot. If the locals love to eat there, it's highly likely that the food is genuinely delicious and has a great reputation. The restaurant's decor is full of historical charm, and you can even press your own commemorative coin with a silver coin. It also has a bar area, perfect for relaxing and socializing. The music selection was excellent, and our server, Barbara, was very friendly. The overall atmosphere and music were fantastic! And of course, the food didn't disappoint either!

+6

I drove past here on my way back from the mountains. I'd seen it a few times, but never stopped. This diner was a perfect choice! The place is old-school, clean, and the service is super friendly, helpful, and fast! I'm really glad I stopped here, it felt like time stop therell! I felt like I was visiting my aunt or grandmother for dinner!!! The food is great, the portions are large, I didn't even have room for dessert!!! I ordered the split pea soup - it was perfect!! And the chicken & biscuit pot pie - very tasty!!!! Exactly the kind of meal I needed after hiking!!! I really recommend it, enjoy!!! Oh, I almost forgot - the prices are very reasonable!

+6

The pancakes were to die for perfectly fluffy and delicious. Dog friendly diner!

This spot is not just any ordinary diner!!! We drove by and decided to have breakfast. It was a busy morning. But that did not stop us from waiting only 20mins tops! We had such a nice waiter who knew football and was very easy to talk too! I wish I got her name! She was extremely nice and easy going! We thought they were out of fresh squeezed OJ but she was able to get some for us. It was fresh & delicious! My husband ordered the vegan pancakes with Phoenician Potatoes and I got the Avocado toast with a poached egg and bacon with French fries! I can see why everyone loved the pancakes! They are worth a try! So warm and fluffy! You would not regret it! The food was freshly delivered to our table in a little than 15 minutes. The Oatmeal Pecan cookies was delicious and moist! We also got Hot Chocolate on the go and it was really good! Highly recommend coming by if you're near the area! This place sure knows how to run a busy hungry crowd!

+2

Phoenicia Diner has become a go-to every time we’re in the area. Set in a beautiful rural spot surrounded by hills, it strikes the perfect balance between nostalgic diner charm and a menu that’s fresh, local, and a little unexpected. Breakfast....great coffee, pancakes, and creative takes on Benedicts. Portions are generous, and everything tastes thoughtfully made with high-quality, locally sourced ingredients. The staff is always warm and welcoming. If you’re a fan of the show Severance, you’ll get an extra kick out of visiting—they even have merch. Bought a diner mug that’s now a favorite at home. Highly recommend, and we’ll definitely be back… again.

We had wanted to go there for a while, but we always seemed to be in the area on days when it was closed. We finally got there, and it was well worth the trip. I ordered a stack of buttermilk pancakes with strawberries and maple syrup. When it arrived, there were 5 thick pancakes in the order. They could have listed it on the menu as serving two. They were, by far, the best pancakes I have had anywhere. I took home three of them and had them for breakfast two more times. You can purchase their pancake mix or just the recipe to make them at home. My wife ordered the Arnold Bennett Skillet. It was scrumptious, and the portion was so large that she took home more than half of it. We also ordered a side of onion rings. They were freshly made to order and couldn't have been better. Some of those also went home with us. We can't wait to go back there again.

Having been here a few times, i felt i had to write a review. The cosistency is great. The ambience and staff have been great every time we’ve done. Even when they are slammed we haven’t waited longer than 15min to be seated. The food comes out in a timely manner. I have nothing but great things to say. The food! Wow talk about putting your “touch” on something. It feels like even their simplest dishes have a sense of uniqueness. It’s wonderful. Specifically the chicken sandwich and pasta dish pictured were so amazing i can still taste it. Thank you Phoenicia Diner.

Great place amazing prices got there around 8:30 am on saturday and had no wait as we sat it became more busy the food is delish and very affordable the staff is friendly this place lives up to the hype will go back

+3

This dinner is so good we went twice in a long weekend. The food is delicious and the service is great. There are vegetarians and vegan options as well as a kids menu. My kids loved the pancakes.

+1

There was some waiting time to get a table inside but is Memorial Day. They have a great system, staff is super nice and food was great. I'm coming back to get pancakes, they looked delicious

+1

Food was fantastic. A bit of a wait but worth it. Friendly staff. I ordered the fried chicken sandwich. Just go!!!!

We had a great experience at the diner. Susan, our server, made a positive impression with her kindness, attentiveness, patience, and watchfulness. Her efforts to ensure we were well taken care of and received the attention we deserved likely contributed significantly to our enjoyment of the meal. Despite visiting during a busy lunchtime on a Sunday, the food arrived exceptionally fast, which is always a pleasant surprise. The quality of the food was good, and the portions were generous enough to leave you feeling satisfied. The affordability of the prices further enhances the diner's appeal. Moreover, the availability of ample parking both in the front and back of the diner is convenient for guests. Clean and well-maintained restrooms are always a plus, ensuring comfort throughout the visit. Overall, it sounds like the diner provided a pleasant dining experience with excellent service from Susan, delicious food, reasonable prices, and convenient amenities.

+6

What a treat!!! We love to check out diners wherever we are and the Phoenicia Diner is a definite DESTINATION SPOT. This diner is in the middle of nowhere Catskills in New York State, and yet you will find so many people traveling there just for the experience. The friendly greeting by the staff and then there’s THE FOOD!!! The portions are great and absolutely delicious. And no matter what food you choose, you will be astound. We had breakfast but also had to have their outstanding onion rings(the best!!!) And to add to the experience, the staff were extremely efficient and so friendly. This is a DESTINATION place well worth going out of your way to visit.

+2

Finding an honest to goodness diner with vegan options is amazing and luckily this was close to our cabin so making a stop here was a no brainer. We got the breakfast burrito and pancakes with home fries. And of course, some damn good coffee. Really pleasant staff too. Get there early, we didn’t have to wait more than ten minutes but we were there fairly early on a Sunday.

Amazing food and service! The burger Mac and cheese burrito was amazing, as were the fries, and the pancakes were sooo good! Texture and taste of the pancakes was amazing! So fluffy! 😋🤤

A charming local gem with a history and good food. The service was warm and welcoming, making the whole experience feel like a step back in time in the best way. Their buttermilk pancakes were fluffy perfection, and the corned beef skillet was hearty and flavorful. If you’re in the Catskills, this place is a must-visit—classic diner food done right!

It has a classic old diner feel. The menu has more of a slant on healthy and creative menu options to go along with your dinner fare. The parking lot is large and the diner stands out along Route 28 with beautiful views of the Catskills. It can get busy here and you might have to wait for a table. The service is always friendly and efficient even when busy. I had the Taco Skillet ($18), my wife had a bowl of the Braised Pinto Bean & Kale Soup ($9) and Sourdough toast. Our friends had the Veggie Reuben ($17) with a mocktail and the Chicken Pot Pie with a beer We have been here a number of times over the years. This time we were meeting friends to take a walk along the Ashokon Rail Trail but it was pouring rain so we decided a late lunch was a better option. We have been here after skiing at Belleayre or kayaking the Esopus. If you are driving down Route 28, you owe it to yourself to stop in for a meal or a quick snack and enjoy being part of the Catskill life.

Phoenicia Diner is the kind of place that makes you feel like you’ve stumbled into a movie set about the perfect Catskills weekend. Cozy retro vibes? Check. Big mugs of coffee that magically refill just when you need it? Check. A menu full of comfort food with just enough twists to keep it interesting? Absolutely. If you’re up this way, don’t skip it. Bring your appetite, bring a flannel, and lean into the charm

Love this gem of a diner and make sure to stop here whenever we are in the Catskills. Service is always wonderful and the food is always delicious. French toast, crispy bacon and the best most pulpy delicious fresh squeezed orange juice!

A classic diner with great ambiance and food that lives up to the hype. Perfect for breakfast or lunch. The wait was very minimal during a Thursday lunch rush and we were seated within 15 minutes. The taco skillet had the right amount of spice and the Mac and cheese burrito was amazing. The onion rings were too much for two people and would opt for a different side next time.

Came for lunch on a Columbus day. It was so busy with at least 45 minute wait but it was totally worth it. Good food with excellent service. Thank you Christine for a very lovely service

Amazing place! Went for lunch, it was very busy but I got served quick. The food lookes and tasted great. Service was spot on too!

This is a gem! Atmosphere and food amazing. Worth the wait if you get there at a busy time. You’ll be glad you did!

Cozy, old-school diner vibes that make you feel instantly at home. Portions are huge, the pancakes and turkey club were incredible, and the milkshake could solve most of life’s problems. Get there early…there’s usually a wait, but it’s absolutely worth it.

This place has the most amazing buttermilk pancakes I have ever eaten! The other food, drinks, and service were also great! Highly recommend!

Pure GOODNESS!!!! Best onion rings in the world! Clean, friendly and very nostalgic place to eat with gorgeous mountain views! Worth the drive!! I cannot wait to go back!!! TY Phoenicia Diner!

+1

Charming retro diner with an updated diner menu. The buttermilk pancakes are the best I've ever had. Mona was a darling sweetheart ❤️

Cute, roadside diner with delicious homemade dishes. Love the use of local farms and homemade foods. A little on the pricey side for diner food but it was all fresh. Service was a little lacking for our table but they were on the busier side. All in all, we had a great breakfast for dinner. Want to come back when outside dining is available.

I can't say enough good things about this place! We came here during our Severance-filming-location trip, and man, was it worth the drive. The pancakes had us in tears they were so good, and we're still thinking about them several days after our trip. Awesome waitress, great atmosphere, and delicious food. I wish we lived closer so we could go every day!

I'll be honest. I usually do not eat at Diners. This place is a landmark eatery and was highly recommended. The service was excellent and the food was delicious. The Buttermilk Pancakes were amazing and I decided to get a chocolate malted to drink. My wife got an egg cream and a chorizo and eggs sandwich ! I bought their buttermilk Pancake mix to make at home!

These are the best pancakes I’ve ever tasted. They look burnt but they’re not, they’re perfect in every way. Also the breakfast sausage is amazing, and our waitress, Barbra, was very friendly. The food also comes out super fast so it’s a nice fast stop if you’re on a road trip in the area. Totally worth it getting off I-87 on our way to Montreal. It’s super busy though so it can be a little hard to find parking.

Can honestly say I have never had yummier pancakes than the ones you will find at Phonecia Diner. Everything is lovely sourced and fresh and the waiters we go on both day we visited were lovely. If you are in that Catskills area this place is worth a drive!!

+3

A must visit if you’re in the area particularly for the pancakes. Really delicious. Decent covered outdoor seating area if you have dogs. I haven’t tried anything other than the pancakes each time I’ve been here, but I definitely would.

We were staying at the Emerson in Mt. Tremper and were directed here by a staff member because we missed lunch service at the Catamount. We loved it so much we came back two mornings in a row for breakfast. The Phoenicia serves delicious food made from locally-sourced ingredients. The portions are generous. Mona and Barbara are outstanding waitresses who greeted us warmly and took care of all our needs. If we lived closer, this would be our regular!

Best. Pancakes. I’ve. Ever. Had. Pancakes can typically be filling, but these are so delicious, light, and fluffy, it is impossible to stop eating them. Absolutely loved the vibe in here. You can tell that there were some modern updates while still keeping the integrity of the vintage look. If you’re looking for a true diner experience, this is it.

+3

Ahhh officially my new FAVORITE spot! Absolutely genius! The food was delicious & hot ( no sitting in the kitchen window). The atmosphere was cozy and even though they always seem to be extremely busy we were greeted and sat right away. Our waitress, Lisa went above and beyond for us! Making us feel welcomed and taken care of. She was a delight. Will definitely be back to try more of the yummy dishes and will be requesting our same waitress. Check it out!!

Only good things to say about this place! The staff is warm and welcoming. The pancakes were some of the best I’ve had. They’re pretty filling too. They offer a side of 3 pancakes for $8 instead of 5 pancakes for $15, I’d recommend that. Breakfast burrito was full of fresh ingredients. However, I did wish I tried the taco skillet instead. Home style potatoes were crispy and delicious. If you’re in the Catskills, do not miss this place!

+1

This place as delightful. The service was excellent. The food was delicious. The pot pie was delicious. It was hearty and filling. The tuna melt was delicious too. Very good. It was a first time going and will look into going back again in a near distant future.

Stopped by Phoenicia Diner on a rainy Saturday morning and waited about 20 minutes to be seated ,totally worth it. The food was absolutely delicious! I had the full breakfast plate with fluffy scrambled eggs, thick-cut bacon, sausage, pancakes, and toast .Everything was cooked perfectly and full of flavor. I couldn’t leave without trying their giant cookie, and OMG… soft, warm, and loaded with chocolate. Also — shout out to our waitress, she was phenomenal. Super friendly and on point the whole time. Definitely recommend!

+3

Learned about this diner from the Severance TV show (among the locations they filmed in the Catskills), found out they have a vegan menu and had to check it out. The vegan pancakes are the best I’ve ever had!! So fluffy and delicious!! Great coffee, super friendly service. All around great experience. Looking forward to going back again soon.

+1

We’ve visited this diner several times over the years, it’s always lovely, but this visit was a stand out. It was a busy Saturday, but it was a cozy 20 minute wait thanks to their delightful lounge service while you’re waiting. The mocha latte was to die for, and I need to order some Fruition chocolate immediately! The bar staff was kind and welcoming. Our party of five had delightful breakfasts, with the pancakes and the jalapeño popper hashbrowns being particularly good. The real star however, was our server Tommy! She gave us such great recommendations, and was so funny and warm! All the staff we encountered were lovely!

what is there to say that hasn’t already been covered?!! get there early and get the buttermilk pancakes! the trout skillet is tasty too. we arrived at 11:20 AM on a Friday and waited 15 minutes for a booth for 2

Very good food. The menu selection is extremely varied to fit the tastes for everyone. We did have to wait, butbthere were games we could play to pass the time.

Amazing dinner! Food is DELICIOUS! They have lattes! Try curry tarts and pancakes! We had breakfast twice at this place and we loved it! Staff is very welcoming! Great place for families with small kids.

+5

It doesn’t get better than this. Lives up to all of its hype - the food, the staff, the ambience. I will dream of this place. Please never change Phoenicia Diner. Your pancakes are the best I’ve ever had! 🫶🤧😭🥞

Drove by and thought, “Hmm, this place looks familiar”—turns out it’s the diner featured as Pip’s Diner in Severance! I stopped in just for fun, and when I saw the parking lot was packed, I figured it might be all the show fans. But nope—the food really is that good. The interior has a fun retro diner vibe, and the atmosphere was relaxed but lively, with a mix of families and couples. The food was outstanding—fluffy, flavorful pancakes and a perfectly cooked chicken pot pie that was cozy and delicious. The onion rings were a surprise: each one was basically the size of a donut! The batter is heavy on the black pepper, which I personally liked, but heads-up if that’s not your thing. Such a great place to stumble upon—I’d definitely come back for a laid-back, satisfying meal next time I’m in the Catskills.

We had driven past a few times and it was always busy so we figured it had to be good. I love diners and the Phoenicia Diner did not disappoint. Since it isn't open late we made sure to stop in late afternoon. Portions were large and reasonably priced. Everything was delicious, the pancakes were so tasty we bought some of the pancakes mix on the way out. Definitely recommend checking it out of you are in the area.

What a must stop in spot! The vibe is exactly what you’d hope for amidst the mountains upstate with a flair of modernity. It was bustling on a Saturday morning but we found seating at the counter to be speedy although the service itself was on the slower side. The food however was so flavorful and fresh I couldn’t have had it better. We ordered granola+yogurt and the pancakes with bacon. These were the best pancakes ever and loved the fresh maple syrup. Overall, this is a must visit and I recommend!

Got the famous pancakes and the cinnamon roll. The pancakes were some of the best I've ever had, they were fluffy and thick. The cinnamon roll was also really good, fresh, fluffy, and taste great, a bit pricey than I had expected believe it was $7. Nice meal to grab pre/post a hike in the catskills.

I am so appreciative to have Phoenicia Diner to visit every time I go back home. As a local who grew up in the area, I think it’s wonderful that they really try to honor the community with local ingredients and a feel that is uniquely the Catskills. They integrated so beautifully and have become probably one of the best, if not the best, diners in the country. The food is everything you hope (especially the pancakes, get the pancakes) and I promise it’s worth the wait (you can even order a drink and wait outside for your table to be called). The service is so friendly and authentic and the vibes are impeccable too. This post was made in connection with a Toast promotion.

Fluffy pancakes, ginormous onion rings, crispy fries, and a bunch of delicious breakfast and lunch options. Kind and attentive staff as well! Would recommend stopping by if you’re in the area.

Our self-guided Severance TV show tour stop was a success! The diner offered tasty and flavorful food, although some dishes were a bit too oily. The ambiance was pleasant, complemented by nice service from friendly and attentive staff.

+6

Was a big Severance fan and wanted to come here for that reason, but even if you have no clue about the show…this place is worth the trip. We waited about 20-30 mins for a table for four, and got coffee in the area outside (chai latte was fantastic and my husband got the muddy water which is a maple cold brew with oat milk, also delightful). Inside we got pancakes for the table (a move you should replicate) and they were fluffy and light and delicious. There’s a full vegan menu which was awesome and I ordered the falafel sandwich which was part of the specials for the day. The falafel was so tasty and not at all dry but had a great crumble. My husband and I both got mezcal drinks and both were incredibly good. Service was so fast and so friendly. We bought some vegan pancake mix on the way out. Def worth the visit and trip!

We were able to get a seat the bar right away at around 10:45am on a Friday after hiking all morning at Kaaterskill. I had the pancake/french toast breakfast combo with eggs and sausage and bacon and it was so delicious! My boyfriend had the vegan pancakes and really enjoyed them too! We bought pancake mix to bring home also. Our server was so helpful and the atmosphere is really comfortable and lovely - right in the middle of the mountains! Can’t wait to come back!

This was recommended to us by a friend as the perfect way to start our weekend in the Catskills and I am so happy we listened to her.\n\nOn a Friday afternoon we got a table right away (which was hon…

When I imagine a classic American diner, this is what I picture. You must get the buttermilk pancakes (comes with 5 pancakes, berries, and housemade syrup) and the breakfast burrito. Those were the h…

When I imagine a classic American diner, this is what I picture. You must get the buttermilk pancakes (comes with 5 pancakes, berries, and housemade syrup) and the breakfast burrito. Those were…

I feel like this place is an icon and it's definitely worth it! We went here because hello, it's a staple of New York mixed with the fact that it was recently featured in a very famous Apple TV telev…

Ask anyone for Catskills food recommendations, and Phoenicia Diner is almost always at the top of the list.\n\nWhile it did take some time to get seated, the wait was worth it for the pancakes alon…

A true American diner. Little shabby, but very cute. service was fast and pleasant and the food was EXCELLENT. I got the cowboy avocado toast on a GF bread with smoked salmon and I wish we discover…

Coziest spot in the catskills to get some damn good pancakes. We love this spot from the pancakes to the lunch to the drinks and the fresh squeezed OJ. the maple syrup is NY maple syrup and wow i…

Coziest spot in the catskills to get some damn good pancakes. We love this spot from the pancakes to the lunch to the drinks and the fresh squeezed OJ. the maple syrup is NY maple syrup and wow it …

This place is great! My husband and I had breakfast here with our daughter during our recent Catskills trip and was really impressed. There was a wait, which was to be expected but it wasn't very l…

Amazing food and service! The burger Mac and cheese burrito was amazing, as were the fries, and the pancakes were sooo good! Texture and taste of the pancakes was amazing! So fluffy!

Phoenicia Diner is very popular in the area but absolutely not overrated and if there's a wait for a table, it's worth it. The food is outstanding. The decor and vibe in there is of a retro diner, …

This was a great find after a hike up Overlook Mountain. The service was great, food fresh and tasty and ambience reminiscent of an old fashioned diner.

ambience was very old school diner vibes! I loved that they had a place to eat outside and have a airstream to sit and eat as well! Their potato's are bomb ! And I had a vegan avocado toast with a …

We went here on a Sunday afternoon after skiing around 2 o'clock. We waited about 10 minutes for a table (for 2) and had a coffee at the bar while we were waiting. It's nice that you're able to get…

Apparently people come from far and wide - breakfast food is outstanding- lots of options and relatively reasonable - serious diner

Apparently people come from far and wide - breakfast food is outstanding- lots of options and relatively reasonable - serious diner

Stopped in for a very late lunch / early dinner (5:15 pm) - they close at 6 pm. More or less classic NY diner - the food was fabulous! The place was crazy busy. Our entrees included a patty melt…

We had an early morning midweek breakfast here in October. Our server, Mona, was super friendly and gave us great service while being the only server there when we first got there and plenty of…

We had an early morning midweek breakfast here in October. Our server, Mona, was super friendly and gave us great service while being the only server there when we first got there and plenty of tab…

The food at this location was far better than typical diner fair, however, diners do get the full diners’ experience. Our waitress, Susie, was wonderful. My boyfriend got a Reuben and I enjoyed som…

We had already had breakfast but our GuideAlong app told us this was a must stop. Coffee was great, my wife's muffin perfect and my smoked trout bagel incredible. Next time we will wait on breakfa…

We had already had breakfast but our GuideAlong app told us this was a must stop. coffee was great, my wife's muffin perfect and my smoked trout bagel incredible. Next time we will wait on breakfas…

This diner was located close to where we were staying for the weekend. We had planned to eat an early breakfast, but when we saw the number of cars in the parking lot the night before our breakfas…

Though crowded we got a table without much of a wait. The staff had the large crowd under control and service was prompt. A good number of breakfast choices and we enjoyed ours.

We stopped here for lunch after our railway trip. parking lot was full so we were concerned about wait time. No worries at all! Service was fast and friendly and the food was delicious! Burgers …

Perpetually tourist-slammed, with expected waits on weekends, but nothing too bad. It's great diner food - certainly a cut above the typical greasy spoon, but nothing mind blowing.

+3

Adriana Laser

Can't Give 5 stars on reputation. We all just got full on reasonable food, nothing special. Overall we felt it's overrated. Kept hearing about this place for years. Driven by and long lines of people outside & cars lining the road that didn't fit in parking lot. We caught it on a less busy time. If we had waited a long time, I really would have been frustrated. My teen liked the breakfast platter but wouldn't eat the large sausage. The beet reuben was tasty but too cheesy for a vegetarian /healthier version. My husband just picked the beets out of the 2nd half. My chili was veg, but flavor was one sided. No cornbread :[

Jennifer C

They were rlly busy but even then I feel like were patient and not once rushed the servers. We waited over 40 minutes to be sat and when we finally did sit down the server went to other tables that had sat down after us. She kept telling us we had to be patient multiple times despite us not saying a single thing and her spending a long amount of time with the table next to us right after. Our server also passed us multiple times and went to said table to ask if they needed anything despite me trying to get her attention to clarify our order since she didn’t bother to ask if I wanted my coffee hot or cold or etc when we first ordered. overall good food but I felt like we weren’t valued as customers compared to other people in the restaurant. Not sure if it’s a race thing as we’re Asian and other customers are white, but it tends to feel that way when I’m in predominantly white food establishments and the only poc. Sucks as I do try to be positive and patient especially when this is a place I had highly anticipated going to and it was very busy so I understand longer wait times.

It’s a Catskill relic, so it was only right that we went! What a cute little diner!!! We got there right when it opened because its first come, first serve. That was a power move on our part. It started to get packed quickly! The food was good! I got the biscuits and gravy. The biscuits were nice and buttery. So soft. The gravy was great, too. It was lacking a TAD bit of flavor. I wish the sausage pieces were a little larger, too. The pancakes, which they are known for, were good! They were soft and pillowy. Delish. The service was good. Our waiter was spread thin for a little while her coworkers came in about an hour after we were seated. They had merch to buy and of course I had to partake! Such cute little souvenirs! Overall, a great place to visit!!! Especially if you’re a Severance fan! 😉

+1

I haven’t had good diner food in a while at Phoenicia Diner more than hit the spot. Everything was fresh, delicious, and the people working here are so friendly. The menu is huge and everything is served all day long (both breakfast and lunch). I really enjoyed the big breakfast here which allows you to try a little bit of everything. Definitely stop by if you’re nearby and want to be filled up for a great price. Also the vibe inside is both cozy, busy, and old school!

Very very popular spot. Corn beef was fine. Market vegetables were my favorite. Perfectly cooked. I wouldn't go so far out of your way.

Phoenicia Diner menu offers fresh healthy options, perfect for breakfast. Outdoor seating, ordered via the food truck, avoids indoor wait times, but service can be slow due to crowds. Post-rain, the pet-friendly outdoor area had some puddles but remained enjoyable.

We came here on a Sunday afternoon, and the place was packed. We ordered the Andouille Sausage & Grits and the Burger Mac & Cheese Burrito. The burrito was really creative and delicious. The sausage was a bit hard to chew and tasted like salami, which made it more sour than we expected. We sat close to the Airstream, and for some reason, it smelled like farm animal 💩😓

This place seems 2 always be packed & I just recently found out why. The food is freshly made upon each order, service is fast & made just right. The atmosphere is phenomenal because even with cold weather people actually sit outside with family & friends to enjoy their meal. I recommend any1 go & enjoy sum yumliciously good tasting food whether it's breakfast lunch or dinner I guarantee u'll walk out satisfied & wanting 2 go back.

Super overhyped, place been around for years but need to pay attention to food temperature (Chicken Tortilla soup was barely warm), Meatloaf sandwich was described on the menu as it comes with grilled pineapple (came with a teaspoon of minced pineapple from a jar). Avocado toast with corn and poached egg was on point, same with beer battered onion rings. The best thing we had was Bourbon Milkshake (13$). Will give another try when in the neighborhood, but left disappointed, to say the least. Bring cash, to get 3% discount on the bill

Only one piece of bread cut in half for toast that was so hard that if you threw it at somebody it would have knocked them out. My dish was supposed to have included grilled tomatoes, which I'm still looking for. Full Phoenicia Breakfast | 18 two eggs anyway, sausage, bacon, baked beans, grilled tomatoes, phoenician potatoes, toast Other than that it was pretty good...

We ate at Phoenicia Diner. The food was pretty good and although it was busy, service moved quickly. The setting by the side of the mountain was really nice, and the retro diner vibe made it feel unique. Definitely worth checking out if you’re in the area.

I had been here a few times a few years ago and I remembered loving the place, but on my most recent visit, not so much. It was very crowded and very loud, so maybe we just came on a super busy day. It wasn't as clean as I remember it being in the past, both of my glasses were dirty and I just felt like the glassware really needed a deep clean. We went for lunch and were there for almost two hours, mostly waiting for our order to be taken and for the bill to arrive. It may have just been a really busy day but I was a bit disappointed compared to my previous experiences a few years ago. The server told us to split the bill with the cashier but the cashier was kind of spacing out and messed up the split. Although she apologized profusely, it was just another little inconvenience and we left it because we needed to get out of there. I gave 5 stars for food though, because the food is fresh and tastes great, they have great serving sizes, and there are great unique menu options, not just typical diner fare. The atmosphere is that of a diner but the food is restaurant quality, in my opinion. Update - Revisit 02/24/24 We decided to give it another shot after my last visit left me feeling a little ehhhh. The cleanliness definitely wasn't an issue this time, glasses and silverware were both very clean, I think last time was just an off day. We did not get stuck there for an extra long amount of time, and our server and the check out staff were both excellent and personable. The place was definitely just as loud as last time though, where it was actually quite comical that we felt we were yelling to hear each other over the crowd and the very loud music. Music was good though. Food was also still sooo good. I edited to a 5 star rating for service and I still stand by my 5 star rating for food. New photos added.

+3

Definitely good food but not with a special drive. We got the giant ledge and the pulled pork mac and cheese. The potatoes were the best part of the omelette. The bread crumbs were not good on the mac and cheese unless they were in the bbq sauce , which oddly was not on the pulled pork.

+1

Enjoyed our lunch at Phoenicia diner. The staff was very friendly, we requested booth seating and were accommodated. The food was pretty good. Unfortunately the diner has no appetizers. Their side orders could be served as an app so we got beer battered onion rings. They were pretty good. I enjoyed my burger, but wish it had cheese.. I didn’t realize until I got my order and didn’t want to overwhelm the kitchen to remake it. If you want cheese on your burger, ask before. Not sure if they have but doesn’t hurt to ask. Overall a good experience.

Busy diner open only between 8am and 6pm. Clean with a vintage flavor. Decent prices. Cinnamon roll is dry. My dining companion didn’t enjoy their meatball sandwich nor the chocolate shake or bread (thinks it needs salt.) Likes the muffins. Hot chocolate was good. Enjoyed the eggs. Potatoes were overdone.

+2

this place was good! the food was yummy but the wait was a little long. we sat outside because i brought my puppy but there were so many bees around that it made everyone a little nervous. but the food itself was good

Do not go out of your way to come here lol. We were influenced by TikTok and thought the diner itself is cute I guess, but the food is very mid. Not really seasoned, lackluster...

I know it's a busy weekend, but my food came out cool, while everyone else's was warm to hot. \n\nThe bacon was so greasy and too undercooked for my liking, but that's on me for not specifying. T…

Phoenicia Diner is a well known spot, so we knew we had to stop on our drive back to the city. We were seated promptly and greeted with friendly service. The vibe is classic and welcoming, your qui…

The long awaited Phoenicia Diner experience has finally arrived. There are no reservations, got here around 11 am on a Saturday morning was told an hour wait, which wound up being about an hour and…

I had so much about the famous Phoenicia Diner, so we had to visit! The food and menu is pretty standard American diner fare. I really liked that they had a good mocktail selection. My favorite asp…

Long waits and high prices for okay food and a mediocre dining experience. There are thousands of better diners and brunch spots throughout the Hudson Valley and Catskills and I genuinely don't und…

We sat outside, where you order from the counter. The person taking our order was very pleasant and lovely to speak to. We started with vodka and fresh squeezed orange juice. We had the macaron…

We sat outside, where you order from the counter. The person taking our order was very pleasant and lovely to speak to. We started with vodka and fresh squeezed orange juice. We had the macaroni an…

Raina Kavangal

Super fun diner! The buttermilk pancakes and the onion rings are the best things we got - def can’t miss those. Nice area and great outdoor seating. Service was nice too :)

Abby Rayos

Cool place but, man, the food was terrible. Definitely did not match how it looked. If you are in the area already, stop by for a drink. We made the drive out specifically to visit and unfortunately the food just wasn't worth it. I have wanted to go here for years and it did not meet my expectations. I couldn't even cut through the eggs benedict. Also, there WILL be a wait. It gets packed, even on a random weekday.

Samantha Silverman

The food here isn’t worth coming. The eggs Benedict (one of my fav foods) tasted bad & the sauce was sour ☹️and the potatoes were burnt as you can see. The cappuccino was good. Friendly service and great atmosphere- it’s a shame.

Haw Kor

Nice diner, friendly service but they could not get fried eggs without runny yolks right. My wife had ordered medium eggs. When it has come out runny she asked if they could cook it so the yolks weren't runny. They remade the eggs but it was still runny as the first. She asked if they could just give her eggs that had hard yolks. The third time, one would expect to be correct but the eggs were still as runny as the first. She finally gave up and ate around the yolks, resulting in a disappointing experience. The rest of our meals turned out fine. I had also ordered a coffee which never came.

+2

It's mid at best. I can see why it's so highly rated for the area but it's so lack luster. The iced coffee drinks were the best part. Atmosphere is pretty chill though and speedy enough service.

Wonderful atmosphere, we ate outside with all the fall trees in beautiful weather and surroundings. Cold brew coffee was pretty solid. The food was pretty meh especially given the cost, it felt low end diner quality but at higher end prices. I got a bagel with smoked trout and also a breakfast sandwich with eggs ham and tomato jam. Trout was good, bagel less so. I wasn’t expecting an NYC bagel but was expecting something at least better than a supermarket bagel. The sandwich was pretty good. Potatoes though were soggy and kinda gross. All around, good for the vibes but not the best for food.

Drove an hour and a half on a recommendation from friends…. Who went with me. A quaint older diner with a decent amount of seating. From what I can tell this place gets packed!! Indoors and outdoors. Service was good and quick for taking our order but one of the meals was MIA for several minutes. Enough for my amazing corned beef hash to get wayyyy too cooled off and my toast trash. The corned beef hash is a medium sized skillet and I ordered sourdough toast. Which was swapped with the other order of white toast. And it’s only one slice of bread cut in two. The missing breakfast was a bummer. The pancakes were very good but when you pay $14 for 5 pancakes and 4 are the size of a small cup saucer and the middle one like a silver dollar again I was bummed. This place has huge potential but if mistakes are made it too will go by the wayside of old diners who just get along and make it. Would I drive and hour and a half again? Probably in hopes of a near perfect experience…..

+6

The food here is ok, better than most of the grub served up on the east side of the Catskills, but nothing to get wow'd by. Nice presentations, average diner fare, one extra star for a great outdoor seating area.

I do like this spot but I do think it is very overhyped and over priced as a result. The atmosphere is true retro diner vibes and the service was lovely despite the fact its always bustling. We sha…

I do like this spot but I do think it is very overhyped and over priced as a result. The atmosphere is true retro diner vibes and the service was lovely despite the fact its always bustling. We sha…

I do like this spot but I do think it is very overhyped and over priced as a result. The atmosphere is true retro diner vibes and the service was lovely despite the fact its always bustling. We s…

We were in town for a wedding and we were looking for a spot that served “clean” ingredients. It was a scenic 30 minute drive from where we were. The parking lot was full and we waited @ 20 minutes…

Been here many times and food has always been delicious and staff great. Unfortunately, this time we went during a “leaf looker” weekend . Place was very crowded so we ate at the counter. No problem …

Been here many times and food has always been delicious and staff great. Unfortunately, this time we went during a “leaf looker” weekend . Place was very crowded so we ate at the counter. No proble…

Been here many times and food has always been delicious and staff great. Unfortunately, this time we went during a “leaf looker” weekend . Place was very crowded so we ate at the counter. No proble…

Drove by many times, never stopped in until today, Tuesday late afternoon. On weekends, this place is always over-packed so I had to find out what was attracting all the locals and tourists. Extens…

I was disappointed with this place considering the reviews were good. First off, no American cheese, only Swiss and cheddar. No raisin toast either, only tomato juice no v8 but those were easy to accept!! Food comes out looks ok but once you start eating it it’s not. I got a western omelette with wheat toast and their famous home fries. Home fries clearly sat on the stove way too long as well as the dry omelette. Toast was super crusty and dry considering the glob of butter they slabbed on the middle. My husband felt bad and shared his meal with me but warned me it wasn’t good either. French toast tasted like white bread. Bacon was stiff haha. Anyways not my thang or my husbands.

This place used to be amazing. The food was average. Not bad but kind of what you'd expect at an average diner. The staff just couldn't be bothered. I'd rather wait a little longer and have someone attentive than someone just trying to turn over tables. I asked if I could substitute some sides (I have some food allergies) and I was told "the options are what they are, you can only pick one". I ended up having to separate the food myself. Now I'd be ok with that but it was the rush and the attitude that annoyed me. The bourbon milkshake was really delicious. I'd probably return for that. The Phoenician potatoes were regular potatoes. The eggs Benedict was good too.

If you are not a local skip this place as they will favor locals in the waiting list for a table, today they seated three same size parties that had came in after us before we got seated we waited…

I mean, this overpriced pig roast, the overpriced drinks, whoever decided to put the poorly cooked pig right next to the poorly staffed bar. Everyone I come here I wonder why it is so popular.

Did take out since it was very busy in the diner on a Saturday afternoon this past October. Took around two hours to order and get the food. But I was most disappointed that they would actually serve this. These were my young daughter’s pancakes… completely burnt on one side.