James Rodgers

The best place in town to get a birthday cake. Definitely our go-to. They have a really pleasant cafe also and a great outdoor patio, very centrally located in Homewood. Parking can be a little bit tough sometimes but worth it

+2

Jason Morris

I loved this place. Great breakfast - cinnamon rolls and egg and cheese tortillas! I was so impressed with the selection of desserts that I had to buy them at breakfast! Go here for sure! I will be back.

Phes M

This was my first time here and I enjoyed it. I really did enjoy the pesto chicken sandwich. I give them a thumbs up.

+10

I LOVE Edgar’s. I’ve been going to multiple Edgar’s locations for years. The one in Homewood is close to where I work, so I come in for lunch occasionally. I have to say at this location, customer service is so hit or miss. Today, after a procedure I had to fast for, I came in for a late lunch around 2pm. I told the cashier what I would like and she laughed at me, and said “Yeah, ok”. She then proceeded to sigh and walk to the kitchen and say “you have an order” like it was something to be annoyed about. Then, she proceeded to act annoyed throughout the rest of my order, and walked away as soon as I tapped my debit card. I didn’t exactly see what was wrong about ordering lunch at 2pm, considering they’re open until 6pm…so it’s not like the kitchen was closed or was about to close… Overall, I just felt like a nuisance to her/the kitchen staff.

A Flou

The store looks very good, the service is good but not that friendly. The problem with the test of the cake, i paid around 50$ for this cake which looks very nice from outside but the test was really bad, very sweet and heavy! I throw away most of the cake.

Tena J

The young lady did offer to fix it but I personally don't like returning anything to be fixed. Cake was good to eat but writing was a failure. All of the As were Qs I fixed them as best as I could. The young lady said she writes all of her Ps like that, but I told her the issue wasnt the Ps it was all of the As. Didn't realize how bad it was until we got home. Didn't want to mess it up so we just told my mom on her Christmas birthday it was birthology the study of people as old as her. We all had a good laugh and ate the cake.

Patrick Krechowski

Seemed like a good place for a quick breakfast. Cold brew was from a premade bottle and was sour/gross. Bagel was barely warm, hardly any sour cream. Service team could have cared less.

jewel cooper

Picked up some cupcakes the other day, unfortunately they were stale and dry. I'm not sure what the issue is with quality and ensuring products are properly rotated, but it's really disappointing to continue trying to give places an opportunity but the same issue persists, especially when it concerns wasting money. Update: went back last Saturday, because my boyfriend wanted to order a cake for his birthday to be picked up today. We paid that day, came to pick up today, and there was an error to where the order didn't get placed so there was no cake. We ended up just having to get a cake out of the case, and it wasn't what he originally wanted, the manager did say we have store credit. It was just disappointing, I get mistakes happen, I do, but it's unfortunate when something like this happens on your birthday, a refund would have also been appreciated since it was not what we ordered, and the error wasn't on our end. Went in 30min before closing, there were about 4 other ppl in there. I wanted to purchase a cake slice, a few cupcakes & a cookie, the woman behind the counter looked visibly frustrated. She also seemed to be rushing, which I get closed to closing, but it doesn't make customers feel welcome. I could better understand if it was 5min to close. Lastly, the cake slices being 4.50 are not cut the same consistently, the size for that price is not even worth it. Furthermore, it was dry. Again, paying that much for a slice, isn't the issue, it's the fact of the value & quality. Everything IZ has cake slices, they are worth the money, and much better quality.

I really wanted the good quality cake this place is known for but that wasn’t the case. I looked at the slice case and there was so many well cut slices yet the one flavor I wanted they had 2 slices that looked like they cut it with a pair of thrift store dentures. Both slices were hacked up. I Asked if they had anymore because they looked really bad and they said no. I asked was there any pricing adjustment they said no. After debating against my better judgement purchased the better looking of the two because already made the trip. Sadly it was dry and not enjoyable. The employees excuse was “the new person cut it”. But there should be a standard and slices that looked bad shouldn’t be sold or shouldn’t be sold at full price. But I guess the new person over baked the cake as well. The oatmeal cookie was half decent so I guess there’s that. Update. Called as requested and he literally had me repeat my review and told me have a love say and hung up. Not sure how that made it right just confirms the low grade experience and poor customer service.

Terrible experience all around: servers have no idea what they’re doing, tables are left dirty and no one came to clean them after we asked TWICE, and the croissant I ordered went directly to trash. Never going back there again.

I was at the Homewood store..I ordered 2 heart cakes and 4 cupcakes. The employee appeared annoyed when I asked for the cupcakes to be packaged separate. Snatching of the packaging was uncalled for..she noticed that I picked up on the attitude but it was too late. I truly feel my business is unwanted..I will not be returning and anyone asking me about Edgar, Homewood.. I will give my true experience.

Astrid Beatty

This was one of the most frustrating dining experiences I’ve ever had. I attempted to order a breakfast sandwich and was told that only ciabatta bread was available. After payment was taken, I was then informed that ciabatta bread was actually the only thing they were out of.... which should have been communicated before checkout. When I asked to order croissants, the cashier was unaware that croissants were even offered/sold. When we tried to order a latte, the cashier didn't even know how to use the espresso machine.... I would compare the dining experience to that of a hospital cafeteria. The food took an excessive amount of time to be prepared, the staff was not friendly or helpful, and the food itself was very poor in quality. Come for the baked goods and avoid everything else.

Susana Lecce

On Wednesday, August 27th, my husband and daughter bought a chocolate cheesecake from Edgars in Homewood for my birthday. Sadly, we had to throw it away—it tasted absolutely awful, like sour milk. When my husband told me he had paid $45 for it, I almost fainted! He paid for the location instead of flavor or quality. Highly disappointed. This wasn’t my first disappointing experience there. I’ve been with friends to have coffee, and instead of serving it in ceramic cups like any proper coffee shop, they serve it in cardboard cups. Even so, we sat down to chat and enjoy our coffee, but because the place was about to close, we were asked to leave. Between the unfriendly service, poor presentation, and overpriced food, I can honestly say this place is highly disappointing.

Bonnie Simmons

We had a terrible experience at this place today. My son and I went in to get a cake for his 21st birthday, no one greeted us or asked if we needed any help. I’m not sure what was going on but another person came in and he was treated the same way. I probably would not have noticed it but one of the workers was helping a customer when we walked in and after she finished she just walked away without saying anything. I know we all have bad days but how can 3 people be having a bad day at the same time lol. Do better Edgar’s!!!