Molly Lewis

Went for lunch and ordered the Smokey club and French fries. The staff was very knowledgeable about my dairy allergy. Cute places to sit inside and outside with parking on the premises. 100% will be back.

Amelia PHW

We stopped by about 45 minutes before they closed but the very kind host assured us there was no rush. We ended up staying in to have our sandwiches. The brisket Philly Cheesesteak was sooo delicious as was the Aztec sandwich! The tamarindo didn’t really taste like tamarind but I mixed mine with lemonade and it was delicious. We’ll definitely return to try their other sandwiches. The 6” sandwiches were more than enough and very filling without any sides!

+7

Kathryn S

Ugh this place is the BEST. Stopped here for a quick bite to eat on a road trip and was so surprised. The sandwiches are sooo good, fresh and flavorful (as seen by my half eaten sandwich - couldn’t wait to take a pic)! There’s a lot of options for everyone. It’s very cozy inside and the staff are so friendly and sweet. Definitely recommend the chicken garden sandwich & the lemonade

The other day i was asked for a good spot in Yorktown to get a sandwich. We have plenty of Deli's, chain stores and supermarkets but the Little Cabin is the only "sandwich shop" I could think of. Exclusivity doesn't guarantee a good meal but in the case of the Cabin they are good sandwiches. I have been there a few times and liked what i got. If they are crowded there's a little wait so plan for that.

Neal Burstyn

Delicious turkey sandwich, very big. Only complaint is that the hero wasn’t the best quality bread. Also quite pricey. Very friendly service and clean bathroom.

Bryan Lavetan

Decent sandwich. The outdoor seating is nice. I was expecting a lot more meat but the value wasn’t too bad.

+3

Kelley L.

Loved that they had outdoor seating. They do not require masks inside when ordering which I didn't love. There is no table service here it's order and pick up at the counter. Food was good but not out of this world. I had the corned beef reuben and my guest had the brisket burger, we shared fries and ordered small watermelon juice and a small Arnold Palmer, $40. $40 y'all!!! If the sandwiches were larger I could see charging the $12 each, but they were average bun and bread size which at the deli I could've gotten these same orders, same prices on hero's. Wayyyy overpriced in my opinion for what we received. Quality of food was good but I wouldn't get their custom drinks again as we felt they needed sugar and were watered down. Would recommend to try, but most likely won't be back as there's many other places out there to try and nothing wowed us enough to add it to our favorites list.

+1

Michael Price

We had been wanted to stop in since it opened up but it's just a little out of the way for us. We were not disappointed Nice little place. Has the same mom/pop vibe you find in the local BBQ places. As it's just a shack with 1 guy running it, it's not very warm in the winter fyi. Not a deal breaker by any stretch. Also, any slight inconvenience is irrelevant when faced with old school customer service. This guy will make you whatever you want and genuinely wants to make sure you're happy. Honestly, when was the last time you had that kind of service? You know, that feeling like someone actually wants your business. Prices are fair Not going be be ready super fast but not a bad wait at all. Portions are good. I didnt get a good pic of my hero, as I devoured it too quickly. We'll be back soon.

+5

Joseph Beckelman

I paid $25 for a sandwich that half of it didn't even have anything on it. This place used to be much better and I thought $25 would have been worth the price but if this is what I get when I go there I'm not going back. This was in the Bedford hills location

Timothy Smith

The food tasted good but the prices were way too high for what we received. A $10+ sandwich and $20+ bowl where the bowl was mostly rice, even when I paid .99 for additional toppings. The sandwich was on normal size bread and not what you'd expect for the price.

Ernie Taddei

Sorry- I had high expectations just seeing this place from the road- Excellent sense of arrival- signage "Smoked Meats Sandwiches "! The rustic Texas BBQ look, typical ranch items as lawn ornaments, fantastic hand written menus the size of a wall. Overheard an Associate recommend the West Coast Brisket Sandwich so I ordered it. Ordered a full size ( grinder roll) with fries. The servers were fantastic- hard working, smiles, friendly and efficient. Unfortunately the sandwich was a big fail. The ratio of filler to brisket was horrible. Way too much lettuce, tomato, pickles, russian dressing sauce and thick grinder roll bread all drowned out the thinly sliced layer of meat. I swear I could not even taste the brisket. ..and the small amount didn't even cover the width or length of the bread. The fries looked good- thin Julienne cuts- but they were room temp if not cold and since they were so thin and soft I suggest offering plastic forks to help diners pick them up. Have you ever had an Italian grinder and the proscioutto and other meats are like 3 to 4 inches thick? The brisket was barely a 1/8" inch layer. The price of $21.99 should have been enough to sink my teeth into a thick multi- layer of tasty, smoked beef brisket. At other BBQ places for that much you get a platter with 2 meats, beans, potato salad or corn on the cob and corn bread! Sorry-maybe the preparer missed the recipe card directions?

T T

I drove by this little sandwich spot a million times and decided to give it a try. Inside is Very nice and feels homey and welcoming. So now to the actual reason we’re there; the food! My brother and I ordered 2 sandwiches, side of rice beans and 2 drinks and it was 54$. The sandwich was tiny, average tasting, and not filling. Place is way overpriced for the portions. Won’t be back.

bel v

I’ve been wanting to try this place for a while. I got a Reuben with the corned beef. Very little corned beed, cheese and sauerkraut. There were 2 slices of thick marble rye. I got a hefty serving of fries however. Over $20. :(

+1