Full Moon Pizza

We had several large orders for a summer camp and Full Moon Pizza was able to delivery far and beyond. They accomodated all of our dietary needs and even threw in delicious snacks at no extra charge!! Would definitely use this restaurant again :)

We stopped for a quick and easy meal with two children under 4. Pizza was excellent, and the owner was extremely attentive and considerate. He made sure the slices we ordered for the kids came out first, weren’t too hot and was cut into smaller pieces for us. Prices were reasonable as well. Great experience!

Fantastic experience. Very excellent pizza. Speciality slices are very good. Top notch ingredients used. Typically pizza style counter with a touch of class.

Let me tell ya. This is far more than a pizza joint. Gerry (the owner) makes you feel at home. The menu has various fine Italian dishes that take you back in time as if you were having “Sunday Dinner” at your grandma’s house;from the fresh ingredients,spices,care,and time that Gerry’s cooks put into the food they cook. Now….getting to the pizzas from a plain pie to a monster combo; I’m very picky of my pizza places and Gerry and his right hand man Paul have made me a lifetime customer with all the pizzas they create and by the way their large pie is a hearty 18 inch vs other pizza places offer a 16 inch pie as a large pie option. The pizza is extremely flavorful,fresh dough daily, and cooked to perfection. God Bless you Gerry and Paul. When Gerry or Paul tell ya you’re having an Arthur Ave dining experience in Bronxville they’re not joking. I’m a daily patron of this establishment and I am never disappointed. Keep up the great work Gerry and Paul!!!!!

Stumbled on this gem via Uber Eats. Boy oh boy am I happy I did. The pizza is so delicious! It's fresh, along with all the toppings. I also ordered chicken fingers—im pretty certain is was hand-made and not frozen, so good! You've got a customer for life.

Sissin

Stumbled on this gem via Uber Eats. Boy oh boy am I happy I did. The pizza is so delicious! It's fresh, along with all the toppings. I also ordered chicken fingers—im pretty certain is was hand-made and not frozen, so good! You've got a customer for life.

Sara Mount

We had several large orders for a summer camp and Full Moon Pizza was able to delivery far and beyond. They accomodated all of our dietary needs and even threw in delicious snacks at no extra charge!! Would definitely use this restaurant again :)

Paul Cohen

Fantastic experience. Very excellent pizza. Speciality slices are very good. Top notch ingredients used. Typically pizza style counter with a touch of class.

Becky Devlin

We stopped for a quick and easy meal with two children under 4. Pizza was excellent, and the owner was extremely attentive and considerate. He made sure the slices we ordered for the kids came out first, weren’t too hot and was cut into smaller pieces for us. Prices were reasonable as well. Great experience!

James Inside Outside Improvements

Let me tell ya. This is far more than a pizza joint. Gerry (the owner) makes you feel at home. The menu has various fine Italian dishes that take you back in time as if you were having “Sunday Dinner” at your grandma’s house;from the fresh ingredients,spices,care,and time that Gerry’s cooks put into the food they cook. Now….getting to the pizzas from a plain pie to a monster combo; I’m very picky of my pizza places and Gerry and his right hand man Paul have made me a lifetime customer with all the pizzas they create and by the way their large pie is a hearty 18 inch vs other pizza places offer a 16 inch pie as a large pie option. The pizza is extremely flavorful,fresh dough daily, and cooked to perfection. God Bless you Gerry and Paul. When Gerry or Paul tell ya you’re having an Arthur Ave dining experience in Bronxville they’re not joking. I’m a daily patron of this establishment and I am never disappointed. Keep up the great work Gerry and Paul!!!!!

Friday date night. We both love pizza and had been meaning to try this spot for a while. The place was not too busy and tables were available. Menu is more or less typical pizza shop menu. We ordered a few things to get a good feel for the food. Everything was very good. The service was great - there were a couple of people that were welcoming and personable.

I ordered a chicken club today and for $12 dollars you gets this nonsense. There’s one flat piece of chicken and a big piece of bread. My office ordered and the food was not great today and they usually are better than this. Not acceptable As an update to the above review, I received a personal call from the restaurant owner. He was very concerned about what happened with my food and stated that it was not made according to their standards. He has offered to correct the issues we discussed. For this action, his taking immediate accountability, I am upgrading my service review to 4 stars. Maybe just an honest mistake, but nice to know somebody does care enough !

Slices are big. Too big. Pizza flops because of the weight. Tastes ok

Izzy P

Friday date night. We both love pizza and had been meaning to try this spot for a while. The place was not too busy and tables were available. Menu is more or less typical pizza shop menu. We ordered a few things to get a good feel for the food. Everything was very good. The service was great - there were a couple of people that were welcoming and personable.

Anthony Morales

I ordered a chicken club today and for $12 dollars you gets this nonsense. There’s one flat piece of chicken and a big piece of bread. My office ordered and the food was not great today and they usually are better than this. Not acceptable As an update to the above review, I received a personal call from the restaurant owner. He was very concerned about what happened with my food and stated that it was not made according to their standards. He has offered to correct the issues we discussed. For this action, his taking immediate accountability, I am upgrading my service review to 4 stars. Maybe just an honest mistake, but nice to know somebody does care enough !

While the Sicilian slice was great here, I also order the mozzarella sticks and they were burned both on the inside and outside, there was barely any cheese on the inside as for it was hollow. All I am gonna say is yall got great slices but need better mozzarella sticks

This pizza is uniquely thin and flavorful. Very good plain slice, with that said, the prices are on the higher side, compared to other pizzerias. I got their plain slice, beef patty with cheese, and what they called a pepperoni roll. The beef patty with cheese didn't seem as full of beef as other beef patties I have had but did have a lot of cheese. Also, the menu's says to add cheese or pepperoni to the beef patty, which is $1 more, but as you can see, my receipt I was charged $2. I'm not salty about the overcharge, but it would have been nice to mention. "Hey, the add of cheese it now $2. The menu says one thing, but the charge is this now." The pepperoni roll I thought was ok but definitely was too expensive, $6, for the size and not enough pepperoni. It was very cheese and has a great flavor and a visually unique with the chopped up basil. Cash and credit are both accepted. There is a service charge for credit payments. Bathrooms are available for customers. Meterd street parking only. 01/2024

aaron mariani

While the Sicilian slice was great here, I also order the mozzarella sticks and they were burned both on the inside and outside, there was barely any cheese on the inside as for it was hollow. All I am gonna say is yall got great slices but need better mozzarella sticks

Space Dandy

This pizza is uniquely thin and flavorful. Very good plain slice, with that said, the prices are on the higher side, compared to other pizzerias. I got their plain slice, beef patty with cheese, and what they called a pepperoni roll. The beef patty with cheese didn't seem as full of beef as other beef patties I have had but did have a lot of cheese. Also, the menu's says to add cheese or pepperoni to the beef patty, which is $1 more, but as you can see, my receipt I was charged $2. I'm not salty about the overcharge, but it would have been nice to mention. "Hey, the add of cheese it now $2. The menu says one thing, but the charge is this now." The pepperoni roll I thought was ok but definitely was too expensive, $6, for the size and not enough pepperoni. It was very cheese and has a great flavor and a visually unique with the chopped up basil. Cash and credit are both accepted. There is a service charge for credit payments. Bathrooms are available for customers. Meterd street parking only. 01/2024

I’m not judging the food because I haven’t tried it, but my negative feedback goes to the service and the atmosphere. I moved to the area from Italy 4 years ago, and one day I was curious to try the pizza here. I went in and started looking at the options, but the person behind the counter became impatient, even though there was no one else in line. I asked about one pizza, and he replied, “This is a Margherita.” I said, “Sorry, what?” because it didn’t look like a Margherita at all, and he responded, “Have you ever had a Margherita in your life? Do you know how it’s made?” I’m Italian, so I’ve probably had more Margheritas in one month than he’s had in his entire career. Maybe he doesn’t know how a Margherita should look like. His tone was really rude, and I decided to leave. I happened to run into my neighbor on my way home, and they recommended a different pizzeria on Pondfield Rd where the pizza is not only good, but the staff are friendly too. The pizza at Full Moon might be good, but because of my experience, I didn’t feel welcome enough to give it a try.

I don’t know where to begin. This place stinks. I went there for the first time today after visiting an ill family member over at the hospital across the street. When I got in, it was around 8:45 PM. We asked for 3 slices of pizza which they had and they just heated it up. They got us our food around 8:53 and we were happy, we asked the owner if we could eat inside because he said they were closing at 9. He told us yes if it was quick, we agreed that we wouldn’t be there for more than 10 minutes as we were just eating one slice each. As soon as we paid, he said “I’m sorry guys you gotta go because we close at 9 and we still have to sweep”. First of all, he basically tricked us into thinking we can eat inside until after we paid and then he revealed his true colors. Second of all, if he is the owner, he should make the decision to let us stay for 5-10 minutes to eat one single slice of pizza and then leave. We were forced to eat pizza outside with no table and the owner and the crew left at 9:00 on the dot. He could’ve swept up while we ate our pizza and we would have been out of his hair by the max 9:05. This is not the right way to run a business, I have been to many many places before who lock the doors to not let customers in, but allow the customers who got in before closing to finish their business before leaving. I don’t understand why he had to kick us out and couldn’t wait an extra 5 minutes.

I do not like to leave unflattering reviews, but I simply have to comment on my order. I ordered a regular 16 inch pizza and a meat calzone. The pizza arrive, looking like it was jammed into the box. It had more folds than a used one dollar bill. The flavor was blasé. The calzone was burnt on the outside. I will never order from here again.

Picked up a margarita pie for $30. A margarita pie is fresh plum tomato, and fresh mozzarella. What I received was a pie loaded with pizza sauce that tasted like someone spilled a jar of oregano in it. There was little to no mozzarella on this pie and worst of all when you lifted it up, the entire slice collapsed from the weight of the cheaply made pizza sauce that soaked through the dough. An absolute disgrace. We threw half the pie out. Nobody wanted a second slice, some not finishing the first due to heartburn from the sauce. I don’t know how anybody could rate this pizzeria more than ONE star and If so, it’s because you don’t know what a real margarita pie should taste like. What a mistake ordering from this place.

The wings are stringy and taste of freezer burn. Stick to pizza, guys 20 bucks for 10 frozen wings and the slop you call blue cheese?? No thanks. I got my refund right away from grub hub. Then to wait over an hour when I’m right across the street from you is CRAZY Update: someone from the pizzeria called me back to voice their concern for why I left a bad review about their bad food. Wow! How about instead of getting mad at customers, do a better job about your food, and stop promising to “fix it” after the fact. Some of us have lives and can’t wait on you to remedy your lackluster food. Second update: the Bronx Full moon pizzeria has gotten so many complaints about the bronxville location, they no longer associate with them. At this rate, you guys won’t be around too long. Nasty food and nasty attitudes = FOH Stop getting mad at customers that complain about your food. Do better. Your wings taste like freezer burn. You can’t fix that with all the sauces in the world. You haven’t been slinging pizza out of there 50 years. You’re not even associated with the REAL full moon pizzeria on Arthur Ave. I called and they told me. So not only is the food bad, you guys are liars. And that’s Mr. Massie to you, gerardo More updates: this gerardo guy had his daddy call me to ask why I’m complaining about the food🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

Lee Massie

The wings are stringy and taste of freezer burn. Stick to pizza, guys 20 bucks for 10 frozen wings and the slop you call blue cheese?? No thanks. I got my refund right away from grub hub. Then to wait over an hour when I’m right across the street from you is CRAZY Update: someone from the pizzeria called me back to voice their concern for why I left a bad review about their bad food. Wow! How about instead of getting mad at customers, do a better job about your food, and stop promising to “fix it” after the fact. Some of us have lives and can’t wait on you to remedy your lackluster food. Second update: the Bronx Full moon pizzeria has gotten so many complaints about the bronxville location, they no longer associate with them. At this rate, you guys won’t be around too long. Nasty food and nasty attitudes = FOH Stop getting mad at customers that complain about your food. Do better. Your wings taste like freezer burn. You can’t fix that with all the sauces in the world. You haven’t been slinging pizza out of there 50 years. You’re not even associated with the REAL full moon pizzeria on Arthur Ave. I called and they told me. So not only is the food bad, you guys are liars. And that’s Mr. Massie to you, gerardo More updates: this gerardo guy had his daddy call me to ask why I’m complaining about the food🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

Michela Montagnoli

I’m not judging the food because I haven’t tried it, but my negative feedback goes to the service and the atmosphere. I moved to the area from Italy 4 years ago, and one day I was curious to try the pizza here. I went in and started looking at the options, but the person behind the counter became impatient, even though there was no one else in line. I asked about one pizza, and he replied, “This is a Margherita.” I said, “Sorry, what?” because it didn’t look like a Margherita at all, and he responded, “Have you ever had a Margherita in your life? Do you know how it’s made?” I’m Italian, so I’ve probably had more Margheritas in one month than he’s had in his entire career. Maybe he doesn’t know how a Margherita should look like. His tone was really rude, and I decided to leave. I happened to run into my neighbor on my way home, and they recommended a different pizzeria on Pondfield Rd where the pizza is not only good, but the staff are friendly too. The pizza at Full Moon might be good, but because of my experience, I didn’t feel welcome enough to give it a try.

casandra tolentino

We got some takeout today but the only thing that was good was the pizza pie. I will admit, very good. The rest though was not. The potato croquette barely had potato (almost all cheese which was odd), the penne vodka was inedible, the minestrone and pasta fagiole were bland. Really really disappointing.

Walter Faust

I do not like to leave unflattering reviews, but I simply have to comment on my order. I ordered a regular 16 inch pizza and a meat calzone. The pizza arrive, looking like it was jammed into the box. It had more folds than a used one dollar bill. The flavor was blasé. The calzone was burnt on the outside. I will never order from here again.

Lady K

I must say that I was truly disappointed in the slice of plain cheese pizza that I purchased from this place. Not only was the slice over $4, but it was overheated, barely any cheese on it and lacked any flavor…big disappointment! I hadn’t eaten all day after visiting a sick friend in the hospital and decided to go across the street just for a simple slice of pizza…Highly disappointed. Nice place, good staff..just do better with the plain slices of pizza.

Elvis Oliveros' channel

I don’t know where to begin. This place stinks. I went there for the first time today after visiting an ill family member over at the hospital across the street. When I got in, it was around 8:45 PM. We asked for 3 slices of pizza which they had and they just heated it up. They got us our food around 8:53 and we were happy, we asked the owner if we could eat inside because he said they were closing at 9. He told us yes if it was quick, we agreed that we wouldn’t be there for more than 10 minutes as we were just eating one slice each. As soon as we paid, he said “I’m sorry guys you gotta go because we close at 9 and we still have to sweep”. First of all, he basically tricked us into thinking we can eat inside until after we paid and then he revealed his true colors. Second of all, if he is the owner, he should make the decision to let us stay for 5-10 minutes to eat one single slice of pizza and then leave. We were forced to eat pizza outside with no table and the owner and the crew left at 9:00 on the dot. He could’ve swept up while we ate our pizza and we would have been out of his hair by the max 9:05. This is not the right way to run a business, I have been to many many places before who lock the doors to not let customers in, but allow the customers who got in before closing to finish their business before leaving. I don’t understand why he had to kick us out and couldn’t wait an extra 5 minutes.