Gadi Aharoni

We had one savory and one sweet pie. Both were absolutely delicious. Prices are very reasonable. Nice, young, atmosphere. Recommend!

Matthew Menendez

I just experienced four and 20 blackbirds for the first time and I had gotten there lemon chess pie and I kid you not, it is quite literally the most delicious lemon chess pie I have ever had in my existence, almost, if not truly the best thing I have ever tasted. The tartness is just a symphony of delicious and the crust just perfectly flaky and layered and delicious, if I ever had to be on death row, that would have to be part of my last meal

Riki Rosenthal

I’ve been eating pie from this place for years but finally made it down to the mothership to try it in person. The place is cute! Lots of seating options. K so about the pies- they are delicious, I’m writing this a week post pie and honestly want to go back today because I need some more strawberry rhubarb pie in my life immediately. (I’m pregnant lol). I’m more of a fruit pie girl and would recommend any of them. I’m sure all the lies are great though. Coffee is good! I left my purse accidentally (did I tell you I’m pregnant?) and they kept it safe till I came to pick it up. Overall 10/10 and need to go back!

Angie h

Friendly staff and delicious pies! Must try the salty honey! The apple is also drool worthy. Wasn’t huge on the coconut and chocolate varieties. Large tables for enjoying your slices/coffee and a tiny bathroom with cute floor.

+1

Sabih Rahman

Pies are no longer as buttery and flakey as I remember. They are still good and the pricing has surprisingly not increased but they are no longer the best in NYC.

Yomalis Rosario

tried a slice of the cranberry sage & salty honey. both were great, especially the salty honey. cortado was great, too! i really liked the simplicity of environment. there was more seating space than i expected. service was chill/neutral. thank you!

got the black sesame pie of the month for a cny party, which was my favorite out of the three (black sesame, hojicha, and black bottom oat). black bottom oat was not good. been getting pies from here for the past few years and it seems like the quality has shifted a bit

curtis little

a must-visit for pie lovers 🥧. The crusts are buttery and flaky, and the creative seasonal flavors make each slice special. A cozy spot that always feels like a treat.

+1

Collins Lu

Came all the way from NJ expecting a warm slice of pie, but the service was kinda cold. Latte wasn’t hot, pie wasn’t warmed up, and no one offered. You’d think a pie shop would be all about warmth. Anyway it’s my second visit, not great.

Lynn

A pie store with different kinds of pei. The apple pie is nice and can have ice cream together 🍦🍎🥧but all pies are made before the day and can not heating when you eat it, it's a pity⋯ Href’s have lots seats with the charging so you can spent time here. Also offer coffee for take in or take out.

+6

Lily Milholm

Lovely pie, good coffee, charming interior. All that is why I'll keep going. It's the kind of place though where the service is subtly hostile. You're fine if you, the customer, set the tone heavy with respect and propriety. If you ask for anything that could be interpreted as an inconvenience, you'll receive an attitude that implies you're the problem and how dare you be so entitled and not imagine what it's like for them to be on the receiving end of that question. I stayed until 5:57 the other day and felt like I was being pelted by bad vibes, called out "thanks" as I walked out and was met with what felt like a pointed silence. For context, I'm in hospitality. Being hospitable is not very hard, unless you fundamentally don't believe in the spirit of hospitality.

nico h.

I wanted to love this place- but I didn’t. I ordered a slice of the caramel apple and the coffee custard. The custard was perfect in texture but the coffee flavor was a bit off. I expected a richer flavor. The caramel apple I thought would be tart and sweet but it tasted like simple apple cinnamon pie. Not much caramel sweetness. I ordered an ice coffee which was also ok. Although not as great as I had hoped I would return to try different pies as they alternate pies. It is 6.00 for a slice and about 45 for a whole pie 🥧

+1

Yuliya Berezovskaya

Not a great experience. Walked in to order a few places of pie, we normally go a few times a year and came in excited to pick up the pie. We were immediately met with an attitude like we were impeaching on their alone time, the plave had one other customer there. I initially said I wanted a few pieces of pie, she asked " Well how many is a few", I was originally going to do 4 or 5 but wanted some recommendations or to be treated with respect not as a nuisance. Ended up ordering 3 pieces, and they messed up one piece. So on top of the terrible service they also messed up our order. I also never leave bad reviews or any at all, but we were met with an attitude when we were here 6 months ago too but decided to come back and give them another chance. The pie itself ( the pieces that were correct) however the service sucks.

escaped goat

Rude staff with attitudes. I don't expect them to be overly friendly or nice but it's not necessary to be unpleasant and rude. Pies are decent and on the sweeter end but plenty of good pie places in NYC without a dash of attitude on the side. Not worth the bad experience.

Bao

Went in to order 1 lemon chess pie and 1 slice for my birthday but was met with attitude. I do not expect overly friendly service but the way I was spoken to made me felt uncomfortable. The lady taking my order was very snappy and repeated herself loudly when I didn't respond immediately. The pie overall was actually decent but the attitude you get from the staff is not worth the trip.