Joseph Lanzarotta

Finally got to try this local spot while I was in the area for work and I came in hungry and came out stuffed and had an amazing sandwich! I had the roast beef with the works and it all was assembled so well and wasn’t all over the place the meat was cooked perfectly just the right amount of toppings and the fresh mozzarella was outstanding too I wish I could have tried all the sandwiches but that will have to be another time and the cannoli was so fresh and delicious perfect amount of sweet to it definitely can’t wait to visit again and the hospitality could not be beat felt like I came home to my relatives and they made me feel welcomed and at home and they really care about the community great people definitely support them they are great!

Sandra Pellegrini

We got turkey with the works and bologna with the works. Sandwiches are Fantastic! Staff is great, old school Brooklyn at its finest!

Randy Amado

The most friendly and good natured employees you’ll find anywhere. Got the chicken parm with garlic aioli and mini cannoli. 10/10

Kate Zaremba

Victor and his staff were so welcoming and helpful. We loved the whole experience. Cannoli was delicious. My family tried the original Italian, the spicy Italian, the chicken cutlet with garlic aioli, and the BLT. The sub rolls were the perfect texture of chewy and soft. I highly recommend and can’t wait to go back.

Bella Jay

New review: The man who works there is very nice, down to earth and humble, took my brother here to eat, because he has not eaten here yet, and was greeted with the best services 💖 Thank you for the sandwich, macaroni and potato salad. It was all delicious. 👌🏼 Old review: My mother and I came here during the summer, My mother knew Jimmy and wanted to come since best its been years since she has been here. My mother says the sandwiches are just as they were back in days. Best hero's sandwiches in town!

Andrew Kievsky

I come here all the way from Hoboken to enjoy the best there is in all of Brooklyn. Jimmy’s is a true Brooklyn staple and the quality of every little ingredient is consistent year round. If you want to have the best sandwich of your life come here! Also, Jimmy is a class act gentleman, cheers to him!

Greg Farrell

Had an excellent experience here. Heard all about this place from the Internet and stopped on our way to the beach. Ordered the fried eggplant they cooked it up fresh right in front of us and it was the best sandwich we’ve ever had. Connoli was great too. Excellence service. service talk about a sandwich artist! Definitely worth trekking down there unassuming chill vibes best sandwich you’ll have all year.

Lindsay Meyers

This place has the nicest staff ever! The heros are delicious! We had the chicken cutlet with garlic mayo and fresh mozzarella and the hot Italian, we weren’t able to finish them they were so big. Both were delicious, wish we had time to try everything!

Matt China

Jimmy's Famous Sandwich shop makes some of the best sandwiches in the Sheepshead Bay area. The sandwich maker Vic, is such a great guy, also his wife and crew are all the best! I threw him for a loop & got a chicken cutlet & roast beef sandwich with garlic mayo lettuce tomato s&p oil &vinegar. It came delicious! Will be ordering this again for a cool summer sandwich. Disclaimer/not they were running low on bread the sandwich with rb & chicken cutlet is a half hero portion. The pics after Vic's photo are full hero pics(with plastic half pints of mac & potato salads). The salads were free gifts from this awesome shop. These guys are the best in the neighborhood, come here when you have a hankering for a well made sandwich!

+2

Vincent Gesualdi

All I can say is WOW!! FREAKING DELICIOUS!! From the bread OMG to the Meats!! Classic old school sandwich shop. The owner and the workers are great, there so friendly they make you feel like family!! MANGIA

David Rodriguez

The best SANDWICH hands down. THE BEST ITALIAN BREAD. Garlic mayo chicken cutlet and fresh mozzarella was to die for. The moment I walked in I was greeted by Vic and I felt at home. Really great food and customer service. HIGHLY RECOMMENDED!!!!

Daniel Pino

Jimmy’s Famous Heros Est. 1938 Layout/atmosphere *Straightforward sandwich shop; photos with celebrities & the neighborhood on the wall; self service coffee station; owner Victor Spadaro was there (and working) Service *Sandwich was made in record time Food/drink *Roast Beef & Cheese with the works (mozzarella cheese/lettuce, tomato, olive oil & vinegar) - Good; solid bread; mozzarella was fresh; sandwich was filling but not overstuffed