Theresa L

Food is pretty good, but pricey. 2 meals (see pictures) with drinks was $25. Their chicken finger sub and fries are my favorite. Staff is nice and friendly. The booth we sat at was a bit dirty. I did see the staff cleaning the tables, though. I would visit here again.

George Pierce

Order a whole chicken finger sub, and finger dinner. Delivery was fast but only received two fingers on a whole sub and the sauce containers were a sloppy mess.

C B

Tuna is disgusting and not fresh, the sub was thrown together with soggy tomatoes. The entire sub was a soggy mess. The personal pan pizza was cold. No warmth at all. Usually order from Bella because of past disappointment. Wanted to give Blasdell another chance and I regret it! Back to Bella.

Jason Miszuk

Used to love this place, however lately it’s been hit or miss. Food quality has been either great or average. Not very consistent. Overall score is a two for my experience I just had today. I ordered a pizza for my wife to pick up on her way home. When she got there she was told I already picked it up. This in fact was not the case so I called to clear this matter up. The manager on the phone was beyond rude and needs some training in customer service. He told me first that someone gave them my phone number which is pretty ridiculous to think someone could just guess my phone number. I was in a hurry because I’m taking my kids to a concert tonight and was hoping they could make up for this error by delivering me the pizza to which he came back and just stated there was nothing he could do for me and I’d have to call back tomorrow. I was a bit upset because it seems like the least they could do given they gave my food away but he persisted to interrupt me, talk over me and dismiss me. No care at all for real customer service. Will probably not be visiting this location again anytime soon which is a shame because this used to be my favorite pizzeria in the Southtowns.

Janine Manzoni

I ordered a large white pizza. Probably my fault for not reading what’s on it but I never had a white pizza with peppers. This was loaded with red and green pepper. Hardly any tomato. It tasted like a cheese pizza with peppers and I really don’t like peppers. It says roasted peppers but these were not. It cost $30. Very disappointing.

richard seyfang

It’s a shame that this place can’t get a simple order right, every time we go there. We’ve gotten a barely cooked pizza, we’ve gotten a burnt pizza. No matter if I order in person or through door dash, they consistently mess up my order. If I order a sub without cheese or other ingredients, I can be sure they will put it on there. I’ve given this restaurant many chances but they keep failing. Funny, the location in Blasdell is consistent and delicious. Update, redelivered through DoorDash tonight after the first order was messed up, they messed it up again.

Jake Ortel

9/12/25 at 8:10 went we walked in the women off the bat was rude once she found out if we were ordering to eat and not a pick up. The women had no patience, she interrupted us twice while ordering to give us the price. She through the food on the table and stormed off. It’s 2 hours before closing, got the impression they were cleaning up for the night. Never coming again

Christina Zielinskigjftlc

Ordered mozzarella sticks and a chicken finger dinner. Got home to discover no blue cheese was given with order. The mozzarella sticks had salt all over them so could not eat. Spent over $20 on a meal that could not be eaten. Will not be returning and do not recommend.

Sandi Bird

They need to replace the person who cooks the pizza’s. For the past few months they have been burned black! The chicken wings have also been burned and rock hard. If you door dash a sub it doesn’t matter what you order on it, they just throw everything on it. Their pizza used to be great. Even the slices in their single slice case are burned. If you order a single slice to eat there they don’t heat it! Served cold. The woman that works at the counter is fantastic! Friendly, efficient and just all around great!

Kenneth Carrick (SomePlumber)

Just had an AWEFUL experience with Blasdell Pizza. I placed an order online for delivery. There is a section to write a note for the delivery driver. I wrote "please leave it at that front door. Thank you!" Simple, polite. I get an email that the order is out for delivery. A half hour goes by (I was less than 5 minutes away but very busy), nothing. I check the front door in one of my neighbor says they came, knocked at the door and left with the order. My wife calls and told them that I left a note, they have the audacity to say a note was never left. Then they called back and said that it's not policy to leave food at the door. So which is it? The website didn't mention anything about a policy. Another phone call later they ask my wife for permission to leave the food at the door, which was kind of in writing when the order was placed. The guy comes back with the same order from about an hour ago. The subs were room temperature. The fries were completely soggy, cold and inedible. Not a single fry was eaten, the entire thing went right into the garbage. My mind is just completely blown at the stupidity here. I would advise that you think twice about ordering from Blasdell Pizza.

Kevin Kevin

I don’t know what’s going on here but I’m done with this place. We’ve given it the benefit of the doubt at least 5 times now and they continually disappoint. BBQ wings not put on the pit, undercooked pizza, toppings on pizza incorrect, long waits after pick up time, attitude from teenage staff, just bad tall around. The staff is obviously poorly trained in both food preparation and customer service. In the evening there never seems to be anyone over the age of 21 around let alone a owner or manager who actually cares. I don’t want to lump everyone together, there are some friendly employees there who seem to care, but I’ve also encountered some very rude non caring ones. The pizza tonight was the last straw. It was barely cooked. Peel back the cheese and it’s totally raw. How do you even put that garbage in a box and charge good money for it is beyond me, not worth the box it’s in. I get every place has its bad days here and there but this place has been going downhill for a couple years now. Too bad because it used to be great back in the 90’s through early 00’s before the original owner passed. You have lost the privilege to take any more money from me and my family.