Suzie Que

We were staying at the Marriott right off of I90. We ordered 2 pizza’s and a fish dinner. It took almost 3 hours to get our food, because our driver went to the wrong hotel and was waiting there. When we finally did get our food delivered it was cold. Such a shame too, because the food was really good. I don’t think I would order delivery again, but I would definitely do pick up!

Sir ZAP

Okay, My order was for a large thin pizza with cheese, pepperoni, light onions, mushrooms, and sausage. A little too salty, otherwise very good! I ordered a large pie, which I haven't done in a long time. The reasons why I wanted pizza "Specifically" from Mr. Pizza is simple! I not too long ago went to La Nova Pizzeria. How they stay in business serving up that slop, I have no idea! After eating what they call pizza, I told myself I am never eating that pizza again! I went there because they're close to where I live, and I was being lazy! On a scale of 1-10 I give La Nova's pizza about a 4.5. It's nothing great. After eating that slop I was really craving a much better tasting pizza and told myself "I should have just went to Mr. Pizza!" Here's why Mr. Pizza makes a way better tasting pizza than La Nova. 1 Mr. Pizza's sauce taste's lively! La Nova's = flat. 2 Mr. Pizza I believe uses a better quality cheese. 3 Mr. Pizza's dough, this is important because I believe it separates a so so pizza into a way better tasting pizza. The dough from Mr. Pizza has a crunch to it! No, it's NOT burnt, it's just awesome! Not only that, but the dough also seems like there's a touch of sweetness to it. It's very subtle, but very good. Whoever came up with this recipe, knew what they were doing! This is what makes Mr. Pizza like one of the best tasting pizzas EVER! There are a lot of pizzerias out there, but Mr. Pizza's pizza is like Gourmet in comparison! La Nova's is a beautiful place, but their pizza is like eh! 4.0-4.5 on a scale of 1-10, It's nothing great. Mr. Pizza's pizza on a scale of 1-10, I would give them a solid 8. So why even mention La Nova? Well if it weren't for that slop they sold me that they call pizza I would have never longed for such a greater tasting pizza such as Mr. Pizza's pizza! Mr. Pizza's Pizza Is Simply Better! Like "WAY BETTER!" Zap

Nette Jones

1st time ordering from here And they did not disappoint. Ordered a medium pizza ( 1/2 ch. and pep) with a double order of chicken fingers (med. and mild). Everything was well seasoned and delicious. My only suggestion would be to cook the french fries a little bit longer and season them with a little bit of salt. Otherwise, no complaints.

J H

Mister Pizza has been a staple of Buffalo for years. It’s very understandable, why they have been in business for so long. There food is just so good. As busy as this place can get, you still receive your food in a timely manner. Prices are very reasonable and the quality of the food is on point. Wings- pitted bbq wings were crispy and saucy. Chicken fingers- garlic Parmesan fingers. Very well seasoned and the fingers were tender and juicy. Pizza- Both pizzas was really good. I like the fact the amount of sauce was just right. The toppings used was fresh and very good quality.

Phi E

It's fine. Not great, not horrible. Personally, I've been blacklisted for about 10 years and I've only been in recently to pick up an order. I've heard they have a wide selection of toppings and other options for the pies. I've had consistently better experiences with other nearby pizza parlors. Word of warning: is you're getting delivery tip well or you'll be in the same boat as me.

I ordered pizzas for an event and I was honestly embarrassed. The pizzas came in a plain white box and wings came in a random box with the word “pizza” on it. All Unbranded! The tissue inside the box…unbranded with weird random text on it. You might think it doesn’t matter but not everyone wants to order off-brand pizza for their event. It’s not a good look. It gives cheap. It gives people don’t know what they are eating. Why would you run an unbranded pizza business? I understand that the business was taken over by a new person but why? Another thing that’s worth mentioning is the dirty environment. The windows are very dirty, the floors are dirty.. it looks like no deep cleaning has been done and it’s not a good look for a place that makes FOOD. Please get your business needs sorted before you open for business & take people’s money. It’s not a good look!

Gervaise Brown

On 11/16 I placed on online order for a large chicken Caesar salad and a taco salad at 1925. The food wasn't ready until 2030. It really takes over an hour to make 2 salads on a Sunday night??? I've had the wings and pizza here, which both were good. Due to the crumby customer service, I won't be back!

On Super bowl Sunday I had a terrible experience with this place. I live in Grand Island and I decided to head down there to buy pizza because in Grand Island they do not have good pizza and chicken wings. So the lady up front however mistakes happen and when I get home we find out it was plain cheese no pepperonis, when I ordered a large cheese and pepperoni with dirty wings. Now I call and the guy that answered the phone had no patience whatsoever wow my wife and I were deciding who will go down there, back to Buffalo to pick up our pepperoni pizza, now he starts yelling on the phone what do you want me to do so I told him sir calm down I'm trying to outweigh our options. So he says whatever and hung up on me. I call back and he ignores my call. So I call with another number and they decide to pick up now. The lady that handles the register had the patience and was very level-headed and understood, what's I understand it was a busy day but the guy that answered the phone was disgustingly ignorant, he's the one in his mid-40s to '50s what's black hair and short. I was so shocked and how disgusting that guy was on the phone screaming and hollering. That right there made me want to stop going there and go to just Pizza or La Nova's for now on. It's sad how he was very unprofessional and I've never experienced that at mister Pizza. He knew I was coming from Grand Island because I told him before he hung up on me. Now when I get back to just Pizza he was like a nervous mouse, he was lucky my daughter came with me because there were more words said that came from his mouth! I wouldn't recommend this place while he is working there!!

No seasoning on the burger at all would not order again not giving smash burger at all it supposed to come with sauce they had no more smh but I didn't know that till I bit my burger and went in to the store to get extra sauce because I didn't taste anything also paid for a drink and turn to look and there's only Diet Coke available lol

Nick Standish

Ordered food for delivery at 11:55 last night they told me a hour for the food... 2 in half hours goes by I call them and ask where they are they tell me should be there soon 3hours goes by and I call again just for them to say there not coming because there driver got pulled over and then stated well I don’t think your getting your food tonight after waiting 3 hours. Worst service don’t like writing bad reviews but when you wait that long for a medium pizza is crazy

Robloxtrollers 23

Always have ordered from here but lately it has been very very underwhelming and today this was the last time I will order from this place ever again I place and order today at 412pm and they told me they where busy and it would take and 1hour and 1/2 to deliver which i understand i order a sheet and 50 wings and a sub they charge my card it is now 723pm and still haven't seen my order and when I call them i was placed on hold twice for twenty minutes and then they finally answer the third time and all I get is rudeness because I'm asking about my food you already charge me for. Update just finally delivered my food 730pm

Kristine Mitchell

I'm so mad I spent $55 on a large pizza and wings and the pizza looks sad it tasted like j was eating dough the cheese was nasty I don't know how people eat their pizza ugh I'm really mad thank wasted my money. And why is it cut like this I said 7"8 slices

Tom Carlin

Sauce is straight from the can, no salt, no pepper, no anything. Dough while bland, was overworked and tough, but also undercooked and gummy. The pepperoni didn't even have flavor somehow. Overall, Papa John's would have been a better choice. Wings were the best part and they were average.

Travis Wood

Saw a video posted on TikTok where one of the cooks spread the pizza sauce on the dough with his bare hands. Not cool at all and should be violation enough to be shut down actually. Don’t ever EVER do that again

Steven VanVooren

We ordered 2 subs to be delivered. Only 4 minutes away from the restaurant. On a Wednesday night. After 1&1/2 hours they still hadn’t delivered them even after two phone calls to find out why. I finally canceled the order. Then they were rude when I canceled! Won’t give them another chance.

Sharon Kelley

They always send cold soggy French fries this is my last time ordering from here im tired of cold soggy food and they dont even apologize for it juat take tour money and so what if your food is soggy and cold we got out money