Simple Italian restaurant that's been serving Pizza for over four decades. Classic style ambiance inside, with homemade style pizza and Italian dishes. The food is excellent

The best pizza in Syracuse area. The sauce is one the best I ever tasted. The place is always clean and the staff very friendly. Bob Wilburn

Every time we order from here, they never disappoint! You guys are the best! ❤️

Excellent pizza. Good prices. Friendly service. Did not have their italian entrees but will be back to try them

Pizza was perfect! And the wings, with their house sauce, are phenomenal! In my opinion, one of the best pizzerias around.

This was one of the best pizzas I've ever had (and I've had a lot of pizza!).

Best pizza ever, we have been known to drive hours to come here!! Best tasting, largest wings too!

Seriously underrated restaurant. It has the best pizza in the area, huge wings, huge chicken parm, flavorful house sauces and dressings, and really great atmosphere.

Love the food and the prices. I always leave with a full belly and money left in my wallet. Have been a retun customer for a few years now and the staff are amazing and rememder us and our family

The food is Italian and is made from scratch. Very tasty and friendly and helpful staff

Food was delicious and very reasonably priced. Service was very friendly and prompt. Kids loved the fried dough bites.

Always a great place for pizza. Their pizza dough is always fresh. Excellent service and staff!

The best wings and awesome pizza and Italian food at very good prices. Good atmosphere and fun staff.

Excellent pizza! Excellent service! Best pizza in Cicero. Their dinners are amazing as well. Highly recommend the steak casserole.

Amazingly delicious! Like I remember from the 70s...in town visiting and just had to go.felt like home so delicious thin crust everytime

Today was the 1st day I ordered from Cicero Country Pizza! I was trying to find someplace different from my usual places for pizza and wings! So that is what brought me here from Liverpool! I had the medium thin crust pizza with sausage, mushrooms and peppers! It was incredible and I could even fold it as that is the way pizza should be eaten. I also ordered the regular wings with mild red garlic sauce! OMG! They were the best wings ever! I asked the guy who brought me my order how to reheat the pizza because I live alone and cannot eat more than 1-2 slices at a sitting! So tomorrow I will have a great lunch with the leftover pizza and wings....or maybe a small late night snack! I will definitely be back and anyone who is looking for a great place...this is it!

Tried all the local spots and this is our favorite since moving here two years ago. Consider a family of new regulars in Brewerton.

I had the best lasagna I ever had in a restaurant. I was fresh and delicious. We love to dine there. The waitresses are the BEST!!

Almost drove right passed this gem. Took a chance and turned in. Best decision I've made in a while. Decor simple yet inviting. Friendly wait staff. Food on a whole other level. My companion ordered the chicken parmigiana and I ordered the Italian special. Both came with salad, bread, and pasta. Salads were served promptly and were excellent. Bread followed- still warm from the oven. The entrees were excellent. The chicken cooked perfectly with a perfect amount if cheese and sauce. Italian special consisted of a healthy portion lasagna, and both a sausage and a meatball. First, the sausage. Mouth watering and able to cut with a fork. The meatball was, at first, too soft for me. But then I realized it was a blend of meat, breadcrumbs, and seasonings that worked beautifully together. The lasagna was probably the best I've had at a restaurant. Seasoned perfectly, sauce was amazing, just right amount of meat and cheese. Truly a find.

Stopped here for the first time on Mother's Day. The server was scarastically hilarious 😂 and fit our personalities well with 2 of our kiddos. Highly recommend the Gigantic Calzone. Not too busy and didn't wait too long. I'd say it's a hidden gem and we'll be back! Spent about $50 for the 4 of us and the kids Combo meal was a home run for an indecisive eater. 😊

I've been eating pizza and wings from here since I was young. It's a good place to eat. I think the wings are the largest and best around. The appetizers and dinners are very good here as well. The dining experience was very pleasant.

READ THIS: These guys are awesome! It's New Year's Eve, they had already closed and here I walk in. Hooked me up with the last slices of pizza they had. It was broccoli and cheese and it was delicious… Huge New York style sliced pizzas too! Don't worry fellas about breaking your new year tradition, 2016 is going to be a great year for you all!!!

If you want a New York style pizza in Cicero this is the place to go, always a good bake on the pizzas, their sauce and toppings are also excellent. Their Chicken Parm and Veal Parm meals are also terrific and have really large portions for the money. Definitely our favorite order out place for Italian, has been for years.

I've been going there since the 70's! Excellent pizza, and Italian food. I've also had excellent service with friendly local help. I recommend you try it, you won't be disappointed!

Favorite local place. Been going since i was little. Love their pizza!!! Their house wing sauce is incredible, and i hate bleu cheese but their homemade bleu cheese is amazing!

Let's start with the basics. I ordered a large thin crust pizza with pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms, anchovies and extra cheese, to go. I asked for a crispy crust. 20 minutes later they delivered the goods. Everything was exactly as ordered. The crust was thin and sturdy enough to hold a loaded slice with one hand. Try that at any other joint in town. Everything was delicious. CNY is home to many quality pizza restaurants. Cicero Country Pizza is at the head of the class.

I usually order on grubhub so i can get this great establishments excellent food. They are awesome, always contact by phone to check about order if they see something out of ordinary. Pizza and wings are soo good. Recommend highly. Thanks so much.

Delicious food and a fun atmosphere! We bring our family and friends here all the time! The waitresses are really funny and make everyone feel welcome!

Cicero Country Pizza is a small time pizza shop serving up big time meals. Once inside, you feel like part the family and when the food comes, you think your bill is going to extravagant because of how much food you get and how good it is, but it's always priced Right. Great pizza, great menu, I highly recommend you visit Cicero Country Pizza.

The pizza was perfect! A little crunch on the bottom nice and cheesey on the top ! Wing were really good and not over done!

The pizza here is good and the red hot garlic wings are amazing. Even for a guy who used to live in Buffalo, these are still some of the best wings I've ever had.

I have been going to this pizzeria since I was only 10 yrs old or so..... I am now 35 n i still love visiting at least every year for my bday dinner with all 6 of my children!!! I have always favored their pizza over many others between the over load of toppings to just the right amount of sauce n the dough is just as good!!!

Great place for pizza. Take out or eat in. I love being able to eat in. The bring the pizza right to the table on one of those risers. Nice and hot. Great staff and service. Highly recommend for a weekend dinner.

Always good food, and a fun time for the family. Still a wonderful place! Only thing I don't like is that we can't go there for lunch....and customers wanting to eat there more is a great problem to have 😁

Old school place. Pizza is off the charts and good staff

My family has made this place a favorite for over 40 years! Most of us live outside the area and it's one of the must do things whenever we come back to visit mom! Pizza wings and salad!! Staff is awesome too!

Excellent food and service only complaint was not having a big enough car to take the left overs home in. (Joking of course) :). Had the chicken parm and a pizza. Both excellent.

Best pizza and wings around Syracuse Area!

Phenomenal pizza! We got a pepperoni and garlic pizza. We chose this place because of other reviews and they were definitely right. Amanda was our waitress and she was great- quick, friendly, and knowledgeable. We also tried the fried dough, which I definitely recommend. Overall, great experience.

We were in town for a few days for a local event and discovered this restaurant. Pizza was delicious and cooked to perfection , we also ordered a salad and it was abundant and tasty. Amanda was our waitress, she was very friendly and made us feel welcome. Definitely recommend this restaurant and will certainly be back. Thanks to all the staff.

I stopped by myself after shopping at Walmart hadn’t been here in years but I remember it was very good . I came in and was seated quickly the waitress came over and asked what I’d like to drink. I ordered a drink and placed an order of chicken cacciatore, and asked to keep the menu so I could order something to go . Probably 3 tables of people mostly eating pizza and wings. After a little bit my huge plate arrived I waited for some Parmesan cheese to throw on top . It was very good and the waitress was so nice and polite . I ordered 2 calzones for lunch for tomorrow. Which by the way were huge and excellent. I ate 1/2 for lunch and 1/2 for dinner very filling . I will Be back to try pizza which looked great and they said they had their own homemade wing sauce . The waitress was so nice, one waitress was waiting on everyone and doing a great job, it is a treat to be treated so well at a restaurant nowadays I will be back because of good food and her.

The very best pizza in the area. Friendly staff and fair prices. I judge other pizzas by comparing with Cicero Country’s. Usually no comparison! Salads are absolutely amazing, everything fresh and crunchy! Pizzas have fresh peppers, onions, etc., so they are not mushy!

Pizza was very good (filling with thick cheese, yet still thin enough overall to be considered New York style) , but what made this a wonderful experience was the nice staff. Definitely will be a place I’ll be returning to regularly.

Great small town pizzeria with many Italian dinners and great pizza/wings. Staff seem to know everyone by name. You’ll want to check out this gem. Friday night and VERY busy.

I haven’t had a soft crust pizza like that in a while! The wings were huge and cooked perfectly. Their house salad dressing was great too! I should post a pic of my stuffed belly but no one wants to see that.

I had the garlic pizza and Buffalo Wings and they were amazing! The garlic pizza was loaded with mozzarella cheese and plenty of garlic. The wings were perfectly cooked and had the right amount of sauce and heat!

We love Cicero Country so much we had their pizza for our rehearsal dinner years ago. The decor of the dining room is a bit plain Jane but it's a comfortable place to take the family and it's really about the food!!

This pizza shop is the "Hidden Gem" in the community. The pizza is excellent, the wings are always crispy and the house sauce is perfect for someone that likes a hearty sauce with a kick. They have several Italian dinner options that provide large portions and great homemade taste. This has become our go to place. PS: Be sure to get extra blue cheese. It is some of the best around!

I haven't been here in 10 years, it was even better than I remembered. I may be a little biased but my family is currently making plans to go again this week. The best thick crust pizza around, easily.

Grew up on this pizza and have been eating it for 40 years! The owners and staff are wonderful people who are always welcoming and back it up with a very tasty product. Not just the pizza, everything across the board has a really good flavor. Enjoy!

Kip Kemak

I haven't gone to this place in over 30 years after moving away. Had to visit again since I was back in town and it's as delicious as I remember. Same recipes that I remember. Pizza, wings, and fried dough. Nostalgia was running high as I remembered frequently eating here with family that are now gone. Thank you for tradition and delicious memories.

Nicole Trabucco

If you have never been here, then you HAVE to go. Everything they have is great, but their house saucy wings are to DIE FOR. I’m not sure how to describe them or what is in the sauce, but it is not buffalo sauce. It is like a combination of tomato sauce with a little hint of bbq. I make a total disastrous mess of myself eating them, and I enjoy every minute of it.

Danielle Jaskulski

A childhood favorite. Get the pants pizza extra cheese. And if you like ranch to dip your pizza ask for their ranch.

Deborah Dunn

The BEST pizza ever!!! The girls that work there are the kindest, nicest people!!!!

Bob Wandtke

Got to love a place that asks if you want your wings more crispy! We had the pizza and wing special and the food was fantastic!

Dave Allison

Four of us southerners from North Carolina searched through all the reviews from all the local pizzerias in the area and chose Cicero Pizza. We are so thankful we did. Clean, fast, local, scratch made food. Amanda was our waitress, and honestly of all the places we ate at during our stay in NY, was the best, period. Polite, sweet, and professional, with a splash of northern charm. Highly recommend eating at Cicero Country Italian Restaurant if you’re staying in the Syracuse/Cicero area. 12/10 rating.

Erin Rushford

We have been going here for years. It is one of our favorites! You never leave hungry. Their sauce is amazing and service is great!

Rebecca D

We order pizza and take out from Cicero Country Pizza often. The pizza is great, the staff is always friendly and welcoming and really know how to make you feel at home. If you’re a pizza lover, I highly recommend giving them a try.

Tina Gallo

I’ve been going to Cicero Country pizza since 1996. It’s one of my Favorite pizza’s. I’ve introduced it to several friends and families, I like it that much. The o Lu thing is I wish they were open with longer daytime hours.

Karen Stein

We hadn't ordered from Cicero Country Pizza in a long time. Not for any reason other than we don't always think about driving to Cicero when we do order pizza take out. I do want to say that the pizza and wings were both EXCELLENT, and the young lady that waited on me when I went to pick up the pizza was friendly, pleasant and efficient.. we will definitely be ordering from here again. 😊

Meghan Fountain

Cicero Country Pizza is our number one spot for a family dinner out! They are kid friendly. Our favorite dishes include the calzone (literally a full pizza folded in half), any pasta dish, or the fried fish 🐟 They have a kids menu, as well. Their service is always friendly and fast. We also often order pickup to take home. The restaurant is always clean.

Amanda S

Best friends and our moms dined in tonight. Shared a pizza, fried dough, and fried veggies. All delicious and fresh. Waitress Amanda was awesome!

Vino Subramanian

Fantastic pizza and wings. There's something special about their wing sauce. It's hot but also has a lot of flavor. I wasn't overwhelmed by vinegar. The thin crust is a little thicker than I expected, but happens to be exactly how I like it. On top of that, it's run by lovely people. It's out of my way, but I'll definitely be back.

Emily DeFazio

I have NEVER left a review before but after our experience here, I must! Not one part of our experience was less than perfection. Portion sizes were huge, prices were extremely reasonable and our waitress was the best! She managed to engage a bunch of teenage boys in the best of ways. These boys were starving and they must have known b/c our party of 11 had our food in record time! A must go if you haven’t been and if you have, I don’t need to tell you to return!

Jennifer George

We ordered tonight after not ordering from there in a while. Everything was Perfect! The fried cauliflower can't be beat, the fried dough was amazing and I can't believe how big the calzone still is. Super delicious, friendly service and reasonable prices for delicious food. Thanks for a great meal.

Good food, nice waitress. Regulars who were there seemed welcomed and comfortable, and as first timers we were equally made to feel welcome.

It’s a dollar for a cup of the ranch. It’s all I get here. Ranch is 🔥 👍🏼👍🏼

Omg..the simple small chef salad was delicious.service was astounding.wings were ok...maybe a bit old..we are making this small business a place to visit more often.cmon cicero let's give this place some life..

We had a great meal here not only is the pizza delicious but their entrees are as well!

The pizza, wings and desserts are very good here, sometimes the chicken fingers are over cooked but still edible. I go Wednesday nights and play Trivia which is great fun. The wait staff is kind and conscientious but adding one more wait staff just on Wednesday's would help the 2 ladies a lot because I think that is the busiest night and we wouldn't have to wait so long for food maybe, I'm really not sure.

I remember having this pizza as kids now I go back a couple of times a month. Pasta is great comes with fresh baked bread and salad 10 dollars. I am off work today going to try the fish sandwich for lunch. GREAT place, GREAT people, clean and affordable. They aim to please.

Great food and friendly staff, been going there for a long long time. 1 of the few places that have anchovies. My wife loves the eggplant dinner for sure. Italian platter also is great ! house sauce for wings and the homemade Italian bread always a winner in my book :)

Cicero Country Pizza is a standout pizza restaurant that delivers delicious, well‑crafted pies with a flavor that keeps customers coming back. The crust strikes a great balance — crisp on the outside yet tender inside — and toppings are generous and fresh, whether you choose classic pepperoni, veggie‑loaded options, or specialty pies with creative combinations.

First timers.🍕 The pizza was good, the wings were ok. But the calzone was manly bread. They charge extra for ricotta cheese👎🏻 (calzone only comes with mozzarella). Set up was a bit odd but overall decent pizza joint.

Angel Meloling

First time going there. The food was good. Ordered The Italian platter and chicken parm. A pizza and wing special to go. Which that was really good. The waitress was good. Took a lot longer to get our food than expected considering it really wasn't busy in there. Maybe not enough kitchen staff there at that time. We would eat the food there again, but probably just call and pick it up next time.

Alrity

We got a pizza to go. The pizza here is really really good. No shortage of any toppings and the flavor was amazing. The staff was friendly and the service was quick. This is our new go-to for takeout pizza in Cicero.

David Farrington

Great place for an Italian dinner. I think I have had almost the entire dinner menu. Haven't had a single bad dish. The servers are always great. Though they do tend to spread themselves thin sometimes, but all in all great service.

First time ordering pizza was good,was shorted on the wings charged for 10 I only got 8.. called to ask about this no one would answer the phone.. Bad 1st experience, hopefully this was an oversight and not a rip off..

Sadly would of loved to ordered for first time but no answering phones for over and hour trying and they say open?

THAT EMPLOYEE WITH THE TATTOO CALLED ME A W H O R E!!! I WAS BAFFLED AND DISTRAUGHT, MY CHEESE WAS DRIPPY, LIKE FALLING OFF OF THE DOUGH!! AND A GREMLIN CAME FROM THE OVEN AND GAVE ME A LARGE SLOPPY, WITHOUT MY CONSENT, I WILL BE PRESSING CHARGES!

We absolutely loved their pizza. Always said it was the best in town but we just picked up our normal order and we’re not sure what was wrong but it was not good at all. We ordered the thick crust and it wasn’t thick. The sauce was soooo bland and dough was not good at all. It had black marks on the bottom-not over cooked-actually under cooked. We haven’t ordered in a little while but it was definitely not the pizza we’ve been getting for years. Don’t know if it was because it was hot out today or new pizza cookers but I called and let them know too and Tommy made it right and he said he would keep an eye on it. THANK You-hope it was a one time thing. I look forward to going back and having our great pizza back.

Normally I would give 5 stars as the food is great. But on my last visit, a phone order with a scheduled pickup time. I stood 10 minutes waiting for ANY acknowledgement at the window, 3 girls looked over but then ignored me. The whole time the pizza maker pretending I didn't exist, as I was walking out the door(was going to leave empty handed after being ignored) he finally said something. I give my name and he walks over and pulls it off the oven, it had been sitting up there before I had walked in the door. Food wasn't that good this time either, wings were cold, pizza was warm but didn't have that fresh look I'm used to. Debating on whether I will continue to be a customer, was not happy as timed pickups are for a reason. Also this was the first experience for a couple of my guests who wondered why I highly recommended to order from Cicero Country Pizza, they were not impressed either!

Chris R

The Good: The food is good, freshly made, decent sized portions and the staff are competent and friendly enough. The Bad: They don't show any pricing on their website and there's an upcharge for almost everything; a fact that is also not detailed on the menu on their website. We spent $34 for a calzone and an order of 10 wings this past weekend. Toppings for the calzone? $2 each. Ricotta in the calzone? Add $2 Marinara dipping sauce for the calzone? Extra "Saucy" wings? Add $2 Paying with a credit card? Add 4% Likely our last meal there, unfortunately. We will drive a little further for better pizza at Twin Trees where you aren't nickel and dimed to death.

I had previously given Cicero Country Pizza 5 stars. Unfortunately, the pizza & wings were way under-cooked the last three visits.

Pizza had good crust but no flavor. Pasta overcooked. Table next to us sat with dirty dishes our entire stay.

I wish the meatball recipe was different. They taste like nothing. Please tell me we’re not the only ones who think this???

So I did a pick up order first time trying this place the food was lacking in flavor big-time the wings were cooked perfect but had no flavor to them what a big disappointment.

Had 3 separate orders of chicken riggies for 3 people. Each of us agreed that there is almost no flavor and they are the worst chicken riggies of our lives.

I always heard good things about the food here so I finally tried it and the pizza was lump and soggy and the wings were stale and dry,really not edible, it would be funny if the people who made this garbage had to eat it.Do not waste your money at this place .

Allison Douglas

There wasn’t a single thing right about our order — not even the time it was supposed to be ready. We waited 20 minutes past the scheduled pickup time, only to realize the food had clearly been forgotten and then rushed together last minute. The pizza was completely undercooked with barely any pepperoni, and the calzone was doughy and mostly empty. The fried cauliflower was also undercooked, and the portion size was terrible for the price. We tried to call when we noticed the issues, but the phone was constantly busy — it seemed like it was taken off the hook. So we drove the entire order back, and when we got there, the staff was rude and completely unapologetic. No accountability and no effort to make it right. Extremely disappointing experience from start to finish.