Menú
Marios Pizza
PosDo

© 2026 PosDo · v3.0

Commack

Marios Pizza

★★★★ 4.2 · 100 reseñas

En Marios Pizza, te invitamos a disfrutar de auténticos sabores italianos en un ambiente informal y acogedor. Somos conocidos por nuestras pizzas especiales, incluyendo las irresistibles con bacon, elaboradas con ingredientes frescos y de la mejor calidad. ¡Ven a descubrir por qu...

Marios Pizza

Italian · Commack

4.2 · 656 ressenyes Google

Ofertes disponibles

Sigues flexible, estalvia més

Sigues flexible, estalvia més

commack.mariospizzeria.com
Yelp 3.5 (157) TripAdvisor 4.2 (20) Uber Eats 4.6 (2,230) Yellowpages 3.7 (3)

Sobre Marios Pizza

En Marios Pizza, te invitamos a disfrutar de auténticos sabores italianos en un ambiente informal y acogedor. Somos conocidos por nuestras pizzas especiales, incluyendo las irresistibles con bacon, elaboradas con ingredientes frescos y de la mejor calidad. ¡Ven a descubrir por qué nuestros clientes...

En Marios Pizza, te invitamos a disfrutar de auténticos sabores italianos en un ambiente informal y acogedor. Somos conocidos por nuestras pizzas especiales, incluyendo las irresistibles con bacon, elaboradas con ingredientes frescos y de la mejor calidad. ¡Ven a descubrir por qué nuestros clientes nos dan una valoración de 4.2 estrellas!

Què diuen els clients de Marios Pizza

Mario's Pizza in Commack is highly praised for its delicious food and exceptional customer service. Daniela, Chris, and Makaila are frequently mentioned for their warm and welcoming attitudes. Customers rave about the pizza and pasta dishes.

Plats populars

pizza (7) Linguine Alfredo pepperoni roll garlic knots Eggplant Parm Grandma Pizza chicken franchise

Ideal per a

Grups Famílies Informal Ràpid Locals

Tip: The staff is warm and friendly, making it a pleasant experience. Be sure to say hi to Daniela!

Services

🅿️ Parking 🚗 Delivery Accessible 🍽️ Déjeuner 🌙 Dîner 🥗 Vegetarian Coffee
🎯 Casual 👨‍👩‍👧 Family 👥 Groups

Preguntes freqüents sobre Marios Pizza

Marios Pizza es troba a 17 Vanderbilt Motor Pkwy, Commack, NY 11725, Commack.
Marios Pizza ofereix cuina italian.
Marios Pizza té horari d'atenció. Consulta el perfil per horaris actualitzats.
Marios Pizza ofereix els serveis següents: menjar al local, per emportar, lliurament.
Els plats més recomanats a Marios Pizza segons les opinions dels clients són: pizza, Linguine Alfredo, pepperoni roll, garlic knots, Eggplant Parm.
Marios Pizza és ideal per a grups, famílies, informal, menjar ràpid, locals.
Mario's Pizza in Commack is highly praised for its delicious food and exceptional customer service. Daniela, Chris, and Makaila are frequently mentioned for their warm and welcoming attitudes. Customers rave about the pizza and pasta dishes.
The staff is warm and friendly, making it a pleasant experience. Be sure to say hi to Daniela!
656
Ressenyes

Opinions de Marios Pizza Commack

4.2
656
5★
63%
4★
18%
3★
7%
2★
3%
1★
9%
Ressenyes (100)
E
Elizabeth Davis

We had a holiday party for work here. We sat on a beautifully decorated room. The staff was super helpful and the food was delicious. The chicken marsala was especially good. The mini cannolis were to die for. I cant wait to come back and taste their pizza!

C
Champagne Polanco

The food was amazing! I usually never eat salad but salad never tasted so good until ate the ceasaer salad slice from Mario's. It was popping, and the service was too. Thanks again John! Definitely recommend this place dine in or take out.

K
Kim Aquilia

The pizza was crispy and delish, the staff was friendly and helpful, and they did not charge a Suffolk County cop for his slice or drink, which is what really makes me want to come back. Thanks for the meal and for supporting our men in blue who support us every day ❤️

D
Danielle Pfeifer

Their food is always wonderful! We order it for my office all the time and have never had any complaints. They have a great variety so everyone can find something they like. Their penne ala vodka is amazing!

B
Brittany Milano

Manager John is an absolute asset ! He made our first experience there out of this world. For him, this is now the only pizzeria we order from. The renovations came out wonderfully, staff is great, food is out of this world, ALSO SUPER CLEAN!!

T
Tammy Marino

Great pizza love the sauce and salad was delicious

T
Trish Angeli

We had a lovely visit to your place. Minestrone soup was delicious. Wings & pizza yum!! Our server Cindy SO NICE, so attentive but not annoying.

L
Lee Sa

Wonderful holiday party catered by Mario’s. The food arrived nice and hot. Thank you to Mario’s for great pricing, food and service.

L
Laura Ando-Antino

Delisiouso. My food was hot they way it should. To the pizza, and soup.awesome

M
Mike Passaretti

The buffalo chicken salad is pretty awesome. This is a nice place with a friendly staff. I would definitely recommend it.

S
Sal

Very friendly staff Food was fast and excellent

K
Kevin Fabian

Me and my girlfriend have been coming for 2 years and we love your food .we’re always satisfied.

S
Sheryl Morgan

It was a beautiful experience . Warm and friendly atmosphere food excellent.

T
TV JAM

Pizza tastes really good! Roasted vegetable minestrone soup is a must to try .

F
Fayjai Mike

Ordered via 2G2G. Amazing experience. The employees are so friendly and it usually includes a full bag of delicious garlic knots and assorted pizza slices! Just pop it all into the oven and it comes out hot and amazing!

R
Richard Wong

Great pizza. Multi flavor soda machine

c
chris Drago

We always order pizza for Mario's always great thank you

J
Jordan Grace

10/10: great service, great food, great for church meetings, etc.

J
Joel Marmol

Staff is amazing, Daniela helped me out so much.

Y
Yasemin Kasal-Pinar

I ordered a pepperoni & mushroom slice. It was delicious. Nice crispy crust and super stretchy cheese. The establishment is clean, very family friendly and the staff are wonderful. So glad I decided to stop in when I was in the area, will definitely dine there again.

A
Andrea Allen

Great food and wonderful staff… Five star pizzeria,

J
John Guli

Went here for a work luncheon for roughly 20 people. First, they were able to accommodate us on less than 24hrs notice...big thumbs up for that!! We were set up in an overflow dining room for privacy, and although staff were coming in and out frequently it was not too disruptive. With such a large group,I was able to see lots of different dishes including small pizzas, salads and entrees. Everything looked delicious and was well presented. I ordered sausage parmigiana with a side rigatoni and it was great! I should also mention that everyone's food came out promptly and all about the same time... pretty impressive considering the size of our group and the fact that it was right in the middle of a busy Friday lunch day! We had our room for 3hrs+ with no pressure to hurry out. Fresh cannolis, cookie and brownies with coffee put the finishing touch on a great experience. Special thanks to John for being so accommodating to us! I will definitely be back!!

D
D C

Delicious pizza with great variety. So clean and organized with lots of room to sit and enjoy a slice or a meal without being on top of people. The staff is so friendly, they even bring your pizza to the table. And the music playing was awesome, too! My new fav place!

a
antoniette woolfson

2nd time ordered pizza extra cheese and the pie comes with all cheese to one side. Complained first time gave them a second chance and happened again. Or complaining this time just won’t ever go back. And good is not that great either

S
Shannon Aurigema

Delicious pizza options, as well as healthy AND delicious. I very much enjoyed the whole wheat crust fresca slice with fresh mozzarella, tomato, basil- perfect. I also had tried the buffalo chicken, which had a good amount of chicken and well-seasoned. Garlic knots were tasty- a good size and not overly greasy. After choosing slices and paying- you are given a number sign and can sit while waiting for your pizza to be brought to you. Everyone was very friendly and helpful.

D
Dee Dom

Amazing Food! Amazing Customer Service! Amazing Accuracy! Their giant house slice is extremely filling. I even love the 10"pie. Most pizzerias won't send a well cooked pie. I never have to worry about cheese sticking to other slices when I separate them from the pie. Completely foldable and never limp with ample sauce. I order from them whenever I can. Both over the phone or on their website, which is also not complicated at all. The prices are a little high on certain items but it is well worth it. They also email me constantly with deals. Some I could use others not so much. I highly recommend if you are in the area especially after shopping in the complex that's like a minute away. I stop there after a Wal-Mart trip, completely curving McDonald's. Sorry not sorry lol. Keep up the good work. They definitely made me a fan.

K
Kathleen Dilg

Food is dependably good. I was surprised they had chocolate chip cookies. I ordered one, it was surprisingly low priced and delicious! One of my favorite places

S
SP D.

This is the best pizza spot!! I have a gluten allergy and this is the only place I can order from and enjoy the gluten free pizza without getting sick. Love you guys!!

S
Steven Cherkes

Hey. I have a brilliant idea for this pizza parlor. Follow up with the customer after they get did deliveries. People are getting more and more upset about payin a ransom for food that is not really food. SHOW The customer you care when. It's still possible to fix the problem. Not after they get Upset. You will make a ton of money and the customers will be happy.Wow what a deal. And stop sending texts about Grandma's pizza. Can't you save us money on something else like a regular pie hello.

C
Chris Larsen

Great food here through Uber Eats delivery! But I'm disappointed not to see the lunch pasta portions no longer available to order on the food delivery sites! Hopefully they bring them back

G
Giana Torres

Amazing food, service and very clean environment

M
Manny

I am more than pleased with the service and quality of food. The upgrades to this location are stellar. The holiday decorations are very nice as well.

L
Lynn Bourinaris

Came in from NJ for a funeral and staying at Holiday Inn Express. I am a native Long Islander. The food was great the delivery was fast and had all utensils included. I have been a chef and Culinary instructor with over 40 years in business. Your customer service was top notch 😃 Thank you for making me feel at home again ❤️

A
Alexandra Powers

Great food! Staff is kind and helpful! It's my go to work lunch spot!

A
Ashley Lipton

My first time here was amazing, I got a buffalo chicken pizza slice and garlic knots. Everything was phenomenal. Austin is the best, super kind and helpful for my first experience! Thank you

B
Beth N.

This is probably one of the best, most caring, and conscientious restaurants that I have ever had the pleasure of dealing with. They are affiliated with Too Good To Go so they are super conscious of food waste and helping out their community which is how I came to know of this place. I ordered their Surprise Bag. It was full of amazing food. The first visit was 6 slices of specialty pizza and a dozen knots. Every single item was well made and delicious. My second visit was a tough one and not because of this wonderful place but they made sure that I not only walked away happy and satisfied, but amazing well-fed. I was having a terrible time trying to get Uber to do my pick-up, it just wouldn't go through. My friend called them and said would you please just put our order outside and we will have someone get it (as they were at closing time). Instead the staff went above and beyond. They personally delivered my order and not only that but gave me this abundance of food I was incredibly grateful for. They have definitely earned my loyalty. I will forever be a customer here because their skill in the kitchen, their kindness, generosity, and understanding is an example to us all and deserves to be supported.

L
Luis Maseda

Incredible work ethic and delicious food. Highly recommend this. Thank you Mr Lucas for the hospitality.

K
KINI CLARKE

Food and Service was amazing, Would definitely recommend. Daniella and Chris were amazing 💯

P
Paulette

Great food! Easy to order on the website and easy convenient pick up

l
lbsunshine

We have enjoyed your pizza for lunch a million times over at Sloan Kettering, and let's face it, a good slice helps everyone get through their day! I haven't had the pasta but the pizza is great (especially the balsamic one) even reheated later.

r
richard cubillos

Personally thought everything was perfect shoutout to Lucas to for being an amazing manager 10/10 recommended

R
RUTH GUZZONE

I just ordered chicken francese w. Broccoli rabe from this place on Uber eats sent to my job. BEST I EVER HAD BEST SAUCE IM IN HEAVEN!!!! I’m so picky with Francese this is the best!

A
Adrian Stachura

The staff are cool i like them. I get the too good to go its a gamble though. Sometimes i get lucky other times its depressing. For the times i got crazy amount of food 5/5.

C
Catherine Lang

Love the new Monday special for Grandma pies. This is the only place that can make a gluten free and dairy free pizza for my son. He loves when we get pizza!

T
Tatiana Shapiro

This pizza spot always spot on in quantity and consistency. Great location ,atmosphere.and clean. Everyone that work there are nice, attentive and polite. I personally go twice a week.

G
Gancedo Catalina

i had such a wonderful experience here!! the pizza was way better than i expected and daniela was the best, she was super nice and attentive! will definitely have to go back

Biggie
Biggie

I ordered through Uber eats. Pizza and pinwheels were delicious. The garlic knots were a bit hard and overcooked. I will definitely be ordering again. I definitely recommend this pizza place.

Jannelly Avelaine
Jannelly Avelaine

Walked in was taken aback by the spacious clean aesthetic of the place. My eyes were drawn to the wide selection of pizza flavor combos. Daniela and Makaila were so patient and super friendly, they helped me choose when I was so undecided. Chris attended our large party of over 15 with so much ease and care. It’s my first time coming and will definitely continue after this. The pizzas were so fresh! I had the tomato balsamic was a 10/10 and each bite had that perfect crunch, IYKYK!

Jennifer England
Jennifer England

This has been the best experience I’ve ever had at a pizzeria on Long Island! From the absolutely delicious grandma pizza I ordered to the warm and friendly staff up front, everything was perfect. A special shoutout to Daniela, the glowing young lady who took care of me—her kindness and professionalism made the visit even better. I truly felt welcomed the moment I stepped in, and that warmth carried through the entire experience—from ordering to eating, and even when my plate was picked up as I was leaving. Everything about this visit showed care, consistency, and genuine hospitality. Can’t wait to come back! 🍕✨

Alva Vasquez
Alva Vasquez

Mario’s Pizzeria is one of those places you walk into and immediately feel comfortable. The food is always delicious, but what really makes it special is the customer service. The staff is welcoming, friendly, and makes you feel at home. Daniela, especially, is always smiling and charismatic she makes every visit better. Honestly, they deserve more than just five stars.

Samantha
Samantha

Chris and Austin take our order every week. They are always friendly and make us feel like their favorite customers. They check the order before it goes out with our special requests making sure we all enjoy our meals.

Alexandra Grunin
Alexandra Grunin

Mario’s was a great experience today! Delicious food and great service. Daniela Chris and Makaila were very welcoming. The chicken franchise was great! Can’t wait to try the empanada later! Will definitely be back.

Marvele Jean-Baptiste
Marvele Jean-Baptiste

I enjoyed my experience so much. I received Amazing service. The food was so good. The servers Daniella and Chris served me and my table so well. Will definitely be back and recommend other people to come!

Jonathan Colon
Jonathan Colon

Mario’s Pizza in Commack is top-tier! The food is always incredible — fresh, flavorful, and made with care. The pizza is perfectly cooked, the pasta dishes are delicious, and everything tastes homemade. But what really makes the experience stand out is Daniela’s amazing hosting! She’s warm, welcoming, and always goes above and beyond to make you feel at home. Great food and even better service — can’t ask for more. Highly recommend! 🍕❤️

Stephanie
Stephanie

The food is absolutely delicious, and the service is amazing! Daniela at the front is such a doll—so warm and welcoming. Chris was wonderful too! Definitely a place I’ll be coming back to.

Mommy Me
Mommy Me

First off, I’ll start by saying how lovely that staff is. We were affectionately greeted by the warm staff. Which I’ll get to in a bit. (Huge shout out to the young lady Daniela) Prepare yourselves for an extensive review: Parking lot is huge. Vast amount of parking space. Located near so many stores, and near highway. $$$ 🥗This has got to be one of the best Mario’s I’ve ever been to ( best pizzeria/ restaurant) Food is immaculate. Prices are incredibly fair. Newly renovated, modern aesthetic— real spacious, wheelchair ♿️ accesible. Amazing !!!! From top to bottom, from customer experience, cleanliness, great atmosphere and food. Each dish is done with fresh ingredients. Carrying one of the most- if not- the best- alla vodka sauce in town. No other vodka sauce like Mario’s! Employees are warm, sweet and readily available to serve even going the extra mile each time. Great management, great ppl, great food. Ambiance is phenom! Music is great. Important to mention; big TVS ! Pizza’s are one of the yummiest—most affordable in town. If you ask them to make your slice crispy they make it crispy & to perfection, or if you want it well done likewise. They fulfill every order as requested specially if you’re feeling creative and want something specially done. They’ll do it and even surpass your request🤤 giving it what I call ‘the extra Mario’s touch’ I love you Mario’s. I need your secret recipe immediately. Mario’s future is bright, I see Mario’s pizzeria growing and being historically known! Can’t wait. Well deserved!

James Virgilio
James Virgilio

Such a great experience! Best service and food you could get. Would 1000% recommend coming here. It is definitely worth your while. Amazing job! Well done! I will be coming back.

R. McAllister
R. McAllister

Literally shocked. Had to run some errands out in Long Island and figured I’d make a quick day trip of it. As a Brooklynite, I’ll be honest I was skeptical about Long Island pizza. But this spot completely surprised me. The slice was perfect & crisp. The woman behind the counter, with long jet-black hair, was super sweet and attentive. She made sure everything was right and had a really pleasant vibe. Def going back.

Ava-Dawn Gabbidon
Ava-Dawn Gabbidon

Love this place! I started coming here regularly at the beginning of the year with a group for meetings, and every single time the food and service have been outstanding. The staff is warm and friendly, the atmosphere is inviting, and it’s clear the owner truly cares about creating a great experience. It’s become a place that feels like part of the community. I’ve only ever seen professionalism and genuine hospitality—highly recommend!

Cookie Queen
Cookie Queen

Everytime I come into the shop, Daniela is always at the forefront ready to handle anything. She is the sweetest person and always takes the best care of me. Her positive attitude and ever present smile make coming in here one of the most pleasant experiences. 10/10 customer service here, from everyone, it’s truly a family.

Vanessa
Vanessa

I took my parents there on Friday, Sept 5th for lunch. It was the first time they ever ate there. The food was great and Daniella the lady at the counter was a doll! She brought our dishes over to us and we chatted for a bit. She was friendly and professional! The eggplant parm dish I ordered tasted great! My parents enjoyed their lunch too! We’ll be back again!😊

Lauren
Lauren

I’m not from the area, but I got Uber eats late on a weeknight from my hotel room, and boy did I make the right decision. I got a pepperoni roll, that boy was way bigger than I had hoped and a great value for sure. I also got linguine Alfredo, it tastes homemade and a large portion. I would definitely get food from here again if I come back to Long Island! Thanks y’all! <3

Gianna Borrelli
Gianna Borrelli

If I could give 10 STARS, I would!!! Jonny, the manager, was so incredible to my group who came in for a Heart Shaped pizza for Valentine's Day. We ended up order a few other menu items which were amazing as well. The staff was incredibly helpful and so accommodating. It's been a while since I've had a good slice of pizza and Mario's KILLED IT. Even the interior of the restaurant is so beautiful and SUPER CLEAN. I can't wait to recommend this spot to all my friends and family. Thank you for everything, can't wait to come back!

S
Steven Gildin

For basic, quick serve pizza, this is a good option. NY has come a long way from basic toppings and this place has many varieties that would make a traditional, old world pizza maker from Italy question reality. Whether you're a traditionalist or modernist, you will find it here. All sorts of Pizza, salads and Italian entrees. There is no waiter table service, but that is part of the appeal. You order at the counter and grab your own table. No fuss, no muss. A quick, yummy meal.

L
Linda Sherwood

I come here on occasion and really enjoy the pizza slices. I would give 5 stars but for some reason it always seems a bit discombobulated with ordering and serving and that it seems to take slight longer to get your order. Other than that the food is really good, my husband orders salad and specialty pies and he always enjoys them as well

L
Lizette Quiles

Prices are reasonable, the atmosphere friendly & most of all the food is very good. The meatballs are "meat" not majority breadcrumbs. The chicken parm,,the Hawaiian pizza all are very good. Plus,the free fountain drink refills is a nice touch

G
GINA

Pizza good a little overpriced. Trying to figure out why the slices are a decent size when you order from counter vs ordering a large pie to your home for same price. Makes no sense Overall, friendly pizzeria which speaks ALOT!

K
Keith matos

Great food, great staff. Thank you

D
Dominick Dalessandro

Food was very good. My kids loved the pizza. They entire order was exactly as requested and the customer service at the counter was excellent. The only reason I did not give 5 stars is because it was pretty expensive and the large pie looked more like medium. The slices were smaller than other places.

J
JKMudgirl

I really like the individual specialty pizza slices here, pretty much the best around. Their regular "Large" pizza pies are very small and very expensive. Not your standard 18" pie. The East Northport location started doing $15 pies on Sundays, which for their size is great. Best cold ceasar salad slices and buffalo chicken slices. Worth a visit.

D
Daniel C.

Pretty good pizza! But when I asked for half of my pizza to be spinach, I just got soggy spinach on half of a cheese pizza instead of traditional spinach pizza (white sauce, etc). For future reference, if someone asks for spinach they want a spinach pizza, not spinach as a topping on regular pizza.

AntonioUrbano
AntonioUrbano

Not sure if this Mario's is a part of the chain, but the pizza and service were both amazing. Walked in shortly before closing hoping something was still available. A gentleman behind the counter happily read off the options still available and prepped my order. I will be returning to this location as I work nearby. Thank you to the staff for being so friendly close to closing time. It's not unnoticed and it is definitely appreciated

B
B S

The food here is pretty good but it’s not consistent. I love vodka pizza and ordered the “drunken Sicilian” and it was so bad. It was dry, flavorless, and gave my family a horrible stomachache. I came here to dine in, went into the bathroom and the ceiling tiles are all open, which was kind of sketchy, I felt like someone was watching me. If you order at the store the food is a decent price, if you order on Uber, everything is a $10 up charge. For example, penne ala vodka is $12 in the store, and $22 on Uber. That’s pretty steep. The counter girls ignore you until they are done talking amongst them selves while you stand awkwardly in front of them in silence. Not my favorite place to come.

R
Real G

The prices have become so ridiculous that I cannot in good conscience go there any longer. I went because it was convenient. Certainly not for the food quality or prices. It appears to be gouging at this point and not "inflation." I compared their menu to another local place "MT's" (that has far superior food compared to Mario's mediocre at best food. Mario's has NEVER been anything more than mediocre). Chicken parm hero at Mario's is 13.95. At the other place it costs 9.90. That's a 40% difference! Chicken Francese entree at Mario's is 24.50. At MTs it's 18.95. 33% more! Large 16 inch pie at Mario's is 20.50. 16" at other place is 16.50. You get the picture. Guess the only way this stops is when everyone just says no to being gouged. In reality, you can go to a real Italian restaurant and dine with these prices, and get good food as well.

j
joe franklin

Tried Marios Pizza for the first time on 10/8/23. Got 2 slices and a soda. Was a little overpriced (by a little I mean a lot), but I never met a nicer counter staff. Mario and Austin were definitely busy, but kept a smile on their faces and were very kind. We were able to engage in conversation and I was looking forward to returning. When I returned again on 10/22 I was nothing but disappointed. I got a regular slice and a buffalo slice and an attitude by the female behind the counter. She seemed frustrated that I was ordering - and was one foot out the door (probably since her shift was ending). These employees were the complete opposite of Mario and Austin and that was disappointing. I am not expecting the over the top service like I got the first time each time, but I am expecting some sort of respect. At least put on a smile and not be frustrated when I come in. If it was my business that person would be fired. Anyways, I am hoping to return another time as I do love the style of the establishment. Would be nicer if the prices were a little lower, but I really only got frustrated with the prices once my service was so bad the second time. *Tip for manager: Kindness and respect goes a long way. I get it that food service is hard, but as a repeat customer the service must be consistent even when other employees are not there. I hope the next time I come back I can be greeted by Austin and Mario and not the other rude staff.

C
Chappy

Completely missed the mark ! Dined in, ordered Sicilian pie with three toppings on half and 2 drinks, $40 ? Pretty steep cost but I figured it was probably going to be worth it basing it on previous experiences. (Very expensive for pizza, i don't know what I was thinking by not questioning it) I was wrong, it went bad ! Fresh, dine in pie comes out luke warm, at best ! How does one accomplish that ? Not paying attention ? No TLC ? Owner not on the premises ? No quality control ? Or maybe someone was just embarrassed about forgetting to put the order in and they rushed it or something. Whatever it was it wasn't a good experience and if I wasn't asked by my wife not to make an issue out of it, I would have probably not have been very pleasant. I needed time to cool off. I will go back again, every time prior we've had good experiences but it'll only be one time if they don't hit it out of the park next time.

M
Michael Diraffaele

The pizza is pretty good, the problem I have is the price of a eggplant parm hero. It’s like $16. It wasn’t that great for that price. The eggplant wasn’t impressive at all. The quality is average. Garlic knots were good but they sent 3 really good ones and three small harder ones with less flavor.

A
Adam Kaufman

Mario's Pizza is a solid neighborhood spot with friendly staff who always make you feel welcome. The food is generally good, and I've had some great meals here. However, the inconsistency in their sauce keeps me from giving them a higher rating. Sometimes, it's just too sweet, which throws off the flavor of the pizza. If they could get that right more consistently, this would easily be a 4-star place. Still, it's worth a visit for the warm service and decent food!

M
Mike G

Weird order experience. Never been to a pizzeria in NY that requires payment before they will start your order of 2 slices. Hefty HEFTY price tag at $18.79 for a margarita slice and caprese slice and 2x 20oz bottles of soda. Cashier had no idea that it was a caprese on a slice and we had to go over that it was Mozzarella tomato balsamic basil on the slice. cheap cheese causing a lot of grease to pour out of the corner of the box making a mess. The margharita slice tomato sauce apparently uses tomato paste in it, and they didn't hydrate it enough and it was bland. No snap to the crust under the pizza. Has some good flavors, but this needs to be done right to bring them to surface. Won't be back. They need to cut their prices AND improve their food. It's a good thing this pizzeria isn't in NYC with the price and the taste. Maybe the pasta is better.

E
Ed

I love Mario’s I been a customer for a long time food is good and all,but lately when I call to place my order to pickup they put me in hold and never get back to me, so today I hanged up and walk in the store they where doing nothing just looking at each other!

J
Jo Guti

I ordered fettuccine alfredo with chicken. Portion was good. Alfredo sauce was water down. No taste (no flavor), barely any sauce. I order the same from across the street, last week ( la Scala) 100 times better. Mario's people were nice and place looks clean.

T
Taylor Elizabeth

extremely overpriced. ordered a salad that was completely rotten the entire way through!

J
Jesus Castro

Felt the food was overpriced for the lack of quality. The macaroni slice was stale macaroni and hard dough. Bbq slice was decent. Wings aren't too bad but expensive. For two slices, 10 wings, and two drinks I paid $36.

T
Tommy T

Food is great, buffalo chic slice is a favorite of mine but felt uncomfortable today with the gathering in the side room i was asked to leave a review by someone who appears to be a customer or a staff member couldn't tell tbh She also told me to join her prayer circle which is sponsored by the pizzeria i really dont feel ok with a business telling me what religion i am part of

JoAnn P
JoAnn P

Not a fan of the choice of music when I came in yesterday around 2pm. The atmosphere made me feel uncomfortable starting with the attitude from the counter lady as well as the very loud music in another language. You used to play good music not sure what happend Play some pop hits or country music

V
Vito G

Delivery order of burger and chicken tortilla soup. Burger was wrapped in aluminum wrap, bun was soaking wet from steam and falling apart, burger was greasy. Soup had virtually no chicken, looked like watered down salsa. Both seem like they sat for a while in the store. Delivery driver was good though.

V
Vin D

Pretty upset I paid over $5 for one chicken slice and it came out cold. Cheese wasn’t even melted and didn’t taste fresh. Only one corner of the crust was semi hot? Also when I walked in it looked the manager was talking to 4 staff members while I stood there waiting for someone to help me, finally a girl came from behind me to take my order. As a manager you should at least acknowledge a customer and if you’re that busy having a meeting do it in the back.

V
Valued Customer

I called about 5 minutes ahead requesting a couple of slices. The purpose was so that the slices would be ready, as I was under a time crunch. I get there, no one is on the line or waiting, and they only put the slices in about a minute after I paid for it. Thus, my call was pointless. They did nothing. I think their food is great, but they clearly don’t value their customer’s time. I’m going to other places that actually value their customer’s time.

A
Anthony Cusi

Food and customer service lacks flavor. I waited 38 minutes for a $24 pie, which tasted like cardboard. Their sauce must come from a can and their oven is dirty. Tables are dirty, while service stood around talking. Manager was rude and refused to admit they put my pie in the oven 20 minutes after I placed the order. Go across the street to Scala's Pizza for a better experience.

S
Sunny Peace

I’m a fan of Mario’s usually but this one showed me the quality differs depending on location. The garlic knots here weren’t only worse than when I usually go to Mario’s around Long Island, they were such low quality I threw them away. It was like eating unseasoned cardboard. The pizza was small and tasted below average. If you want usual Mario’s pizza don’t come here.

c
cara thumann

got food poisoning from pizza. called and they said they’ll take a message and have someone call me back. nobody did. called AGAIN and talked to the manager and explained what had happen, he was extremely rude with me. when i asked if i could get a refund, he goes “well if that’ll make you feel better”. i will definitely not come back.

L
Leanna

We stood in front of the pizza display and not one person asked if we needed help. A man and woman were standing by the register staring at us like we had 3 heads but never once asked if we needed help. I got a specialty slice with pasta and it must have been sitting there for a long time because it was the most dry thing I've ever had. The regular slice is not horrible but it's not that great either. Bad customer service skills and bad food= never going back there again.

D
Dexter's World

Charged me $40.00 For a dinner without following instructions. Also , Delivered a product with no utensils. What are you guys doing with all this money, You're making?? Stop being cheap with your sauce portions and for crying out loud if you aren't going to provide utensils, You could atleast warn people before they throw their hard earned money, Into the garbage. Save your money, Go to another restaurant for mediocre comfort food .

N
Nina

Stop Soliciting Me To Buy Empanadas in an American-Italian Restaurant in Commack, NY. It is Weird.

S
Samara Lyons

I came here yesterday for the first time and I'm surprised of all the good reviews. Their specialty pizza in the window looked pretty good but I ordered 3 regular slices and 1 Sicilian. I have to say it was horrible a waste of money. As soon as I opened the box the pizza looked old. I asked for my pizza to be extra hot and it was cold, no cheese whatsoever, no sauce, the pizza was extremely dry and looked like it sat in the corner somewhere for a couple days. Not happy.

D
Demonic

Horrible service no one was in the place but there was 10 workers. I stood there for 10 mins in front of the counter to have someone take my order. Everyone avoided eye contact 0/10 don’t go here

M
Marc Cantave

Good food but they need to work on their customer interaction little more. When I went I didn’t feel acknowledge

A
Alex

I ordered 3 items off of uber eats. The Penne Ala Vodka and the Chicken parm hero should have been “buy one get one” free. I did not receive it. I have proof via receipt and electronic order history. We will NEVER be recommending or visiting this place again.

J
Jimmy

Never visiting this establishment again. I came in for 2 slices of pizza and 2 Santi and Sam and a lady who I believe was Darnella were too busy speaking in another language I am not upset that they were speaking in spanish, but I speak spanish too and they were mocking me because I was slow to pull out my credit card. We're not that stupid

Jay Moses
Jay Moses

Stopped in this afternoon and was completely turned off by what I saw. The woman behind the counter (dark hair) was literally eating her lunch right in front of me while helping customers—totally unprofessional. Then the guy cutting my pizzas had a beard and was wearing a dirty blue sweatshirt that was dragging into the pizza. Absolutely unacceptable. At least the main pizza guy was protecting his face with a mask as I noticed he had a beard so props to him for wearing appropriate garments and face coverings. I would be embarrassed if I were that nice man to work with complete disgusting people Do they not have uniforms here? Between her eating at the counter and him looking like he just came from a construction site, it’s a total health concern. I already reported this to Suffolk County Health because this is not okay. There should NOT be sweatshirts in any restaurant and the health department was told this today. Wear clean uniforms and look professional if you’re handling food. I won’t be coming back, and I hope they get inspected ASAP.

Inicia sessió per deixar una ressenya

Inicia sessió
👑 És teu? Reclama'l GRATIS!

Elimina anuncis i gestiona el menú

Explora la teva zona

Més restaurants a Commack →
📸

33 Fotos

Explora les fotos de Marios Pizza

Marios Pizza
Marios Pizza
Marios Pizza
Marios Pizza
Marios Pizza
+28 Més
📍

Informació sobre Marios Pizza

Com arribar

17 Vanderbilt Motor Pkwy, Commack, NY 11725

Carregant mapa...
Marios Pizza
Toca per direccions

Destacats

Bona Valoració
4.2/5 estrelles
💬
Moltes Ressenyes
656 ressenyes
💰
Preu Moderat
Nivell de preus
👨‍🍳
italian
Tipus de cuina

Serveis

🍽️ Dinar
🍾 Sopar
Cafè
🍰 Postres
🥗 Opcions Vegetarianes
🥡 Per Emportar
🚚 Lliurament a Domicili
🍴 Menjar al Local

Opcions de Menjador

🍽️ Menjar al Local
🥡 Per Emportar
🚚 Lliurament a Domicili

Informació del Restaurant

Estat
Verificat pel propietari
🕐 Horario Hoy
10AM-9PM
Valoració
4.2/5
💬 Ressenyes
656
💰 Nivell de Preus
$$
⏱️ Visita típica
People typically spend 20 min here
📞 Telèfon
+1 631-499-7000
🌐 Lloc Web
commack.mariospizzeria.com
📋 Menú
Veure Menú

Comoditats

🅿️ Aparcament
Accessible amb Cadira de Rodes
🚻 Lavabo
💳 Targetes de Crèdit
📱 Pagaments Mòbils
🏘️

El Barri

Ubicació

17 Vanderbilt Motor Pkwy, Commack, NY 11725

📍 Explorar el Barri

Weather
28°
Temps actualitzat cada hora · Feines i esdeveniments actualitzats diàriament
🎮

Jocs

🎮 Guanya Punts Mentre Explores!

Juga a Find Me i canvia punts per descomptes a Marios Pizza i altres restaurants

🎮

Guanya Punts a Marios Pizza!

Juga a Find Me i canvia recompenses aquí

Guanya punts extra i canvia'ls per recompenses de Marios Pizza

🏆 Recompenses de Marios Pizza

💰

Descompte 10%

A Marios Pizza

1000 pts
Disponible
🍽️

Aperitiu Gratis

A la teva propera visita

2500 pts
Limitat
👑

Taula VIP

Experiència premium

5000 pts
Exclusiu

per canviar recompenses i guanyar punts

📋 Com funcionen les recompenses?

1

Juga a Find Me

Cada 100 punts de score = 1 punt de recompensa

2

Acumula Punts

Els workers obtenen 2x punts per partida

3

Canvia Recompenses

Descomptes, menjar gratis i experiències VIP

Trucar
Deixar ressenya a Google
👑

És teu? Reclama'l GRATIS!

Elimina anuncis i gestiona el menú

Inicia sessió i juga

Revisa el teu correu!

Sense contrasenya — t'enviem un enllaç per email

T'hem enviat un enllaç d'accés

Revisa la carpeta de spam si no el veus