Carnegie Deli

We love it after show dinner

We had a fantastic late-night dinner here post broadway show. Everything from the service to the food was excellent.

FULL DISCLOSURE: This review is for their old location. The pastrami here was absolutely top notch and stacked at least 8 inches high. The real highlight here is the cheesecake (which is available to purchase online and ship to all over the U.S.). It is absolutely BY FAR THE BEST CHEESECAKE I have ever had. Sat next to Dennis Rodman my last time there and he was super chill.

I trust this place for consistent satisfaction. Love this place. The menu offers many choices and the staff treats you well. All their offerings are tasty and enjoyable. I stumbled across this enjoyable spot while using search apps.

If you’re a fan of hearty, classic deli fare, this place is an absolute must-visit! I recently tried their corned beef sandwich and CHOCOLATE COVERED cheesecake, and both were outstanding. The corned beef sandwich was awesome. The meat was tender and flavorful. The bread was perfectly toasted and held the weight of the all the meat nicely. And then there was the cheesecake bites. Wow. The rich, creamy filling was so good and also had the perfect balance of sweetness with the chocolate. Whether you're in the mood for a satisfying deli sandwich or a delicious dessert, you won't be disappointed. Service was nice and quick as well. Highly recommended!

Cheesecake to remember? I hope so! Had this back 10 years ago now, and hopeful the recipe has remained the same. I've married a cheesecake fanatic, with a very discerning palette. As I recall, this baked cheesecake is a show stopper, and we are hoping our search for the perfect cheesecake is over since coming back to the USA.

Visited 2 days in a row for breakfast. And the host recognized us from the most likely hundreds to a thousand people and on top of that remembered we wanted a window table if available. He did accommodate us on day two. Absolutely great staff and food. We will definitely be returning here as we visit NYC regularly.

Carnegie deli pastrami sandwich 🥪 is the best sandwich ever. U get a whole lot of meat. And you can make a second sandwich out of it, if you want. Took me 2 days to finish it, I ordered my sandwich online . You can eat in but it's soooo busy so many people. Be prepared to spend $32.00 for a sandwich. I just had craving for that sandwich, I won't be going back any time soon.

Fatma Abuja

We love it after show dinner

Jennie Rivera

I trust this place for consistent satisfaction. Love this place. The menu offers many choices and the staff treats you well. All their offerings are tasty and enjoyable. I stumbled across this enjoyable spot while using search apps.

Kingdom Motors

FULL DISCLOSURE: This review is for their old location. The pastrami here was absolutely top notch and stacked at least 8 inches high. The real highlight here is the cheesecake (which is available to purchase online and ship to all over the U.S.). It is absolutely BY FAR THE BEST CHEESECAKE I have ever had. Sat next to Dennis Rodman my last time there and he was super chill.

Kat Spratley

Cheesecake to remember? I hope so! Had this back 10 years ago now, and hopeful the recipe has remained the same. I've married a cheesecake fanatic, with a very discerning palette. As I recall, this baked cheesecake is a show stopper, and we are hoping our search for the perfect cheesecake is over since coming back to the USA.

Shirley Brown (Skittles)

Carnegie deli pastrami sandwich 🥪 is the best sandwich ever. U get a whole lot of meat. And you can make a second sandwich out of it, if you want. Took me 2 days to finish it, I ordered my sandwich online . You can eat in but it's soooo busy so many people. Be prepared to spend $32.00 for a sandwich. I just had craving for that sandwich, I won't be going back any time soon.

Kayla VanGarderen

If you’re a fan of hearty, classic deli fare, this place is an absolute must-visit! I recently tried their corned beef sandwich and CHOCOLATE COVERED cheesecake, and both were outstanding. The corned beef sandwich was awesome. The meat was tender and flavorful. The bread was perfectly toasted and held the weight of the all the meat nicely. And then there was the cheesecake bites. Wow. The rich, creamy filling was so good and also had the perfect balance of sweetness with the chocolate. Whether you're in the mood for a satisfying deli sandwich or a delicious dessert, you won't be disappointed. Service was nice and quick as well. Highly recommended!

Meghan Havriliak

Was there for breakfast, service was great! Juliana was very attentive. Food was amazing!! Nutella/ banana pancakes were to die for!! Will definitely be returning!

William Bartel

Visited 2 days in a row for breakfast. And the host recognized us from the most likely hundreds to a thousand people and on top of that remembered we wanted a window table if available. He did accommodate us on day two. Absolutely great staff and food. We will definitely be returning here as we visit NYC regularly.

Stephanie Dunn

We had a fantastic late-night dinner here post broadway show. Everything from the service to the food was excellent.

Kate Greenaway

Legendary Place snd sandwiches. I don’t know why some people posted bad reviews. It is fantastic and a destination everyone should visit at least once. I know I’ll be back next time I get back to New York.

Carnegi Deli on 7th Ave was always my favorite restaurant in New York, so sorry they've closed it years ago. The Madison Square Garden location has the same quality sandwiches and cheesecakes but lacks the magic of the original place. Hope one day they can reopen a new restaurant and place back all the celebrities pictures on the walls.

AnalíaCroci

Carnegi Deli on 7th Ave was always my favorite restaurant in New York, so sorry they've closed it years ago. The Madison Square Garden location has the same quality sandwiches and cheesecakes but lacks the magic of the original place. Hope one day they can reopen a new restaurant and place back all the celebrities pictures on the walls.

I visited Carnegie Deli, a well-known establishment in the heart of the city, and I was eager to experience what all the buzz was about. I decided to try the lobster roll along with a side of fries, and while the flavors were delightful, I found the portion sizes to be quite overwhelming. The lobster roll was generously packed with tender, flavorful lobster meat, and the accompanying fries were crispy and well-seasoned. However, despite my best efforts, I couldn't finish my meal due to the sheer size of the portions. One aspect that detracted from my experience was the beverage service. I had ordered a glass of white wine to complement my meal, but the server mistakenly brought me a glass of red instead. This mix-up was disappointing, as I was looking forward to the crispness of white wine to pair with the seafood. While the red wine was decent, it didn’t quite match the culinary experience I had envisioned. In terms of ambiance, Carnegie Deli felt decidedly touristy. The bustling atmosphere and the large number of visitors made it feel less intimate and more like a place designed for quick stops rather than a leisurely dining experience. While I understand that it’s a popular spot for tourists, I prefer dining establishments that offer a more authentic local vibe. Overall, while my meal had its highlights, the combination of the oversized portions, the drink mix-up, and the tourist-heavy environment left me feeling that I wouldn’t choose to return. If you’re seeking a classic deli experience with a twist, you might find some enjoyment here, but for those looking for a more genuine atmosphere, it may be worth exploring other options.

King King

I visited Carnegie Deli, a well-known establishment in the heart of the city, and I was eager to experience what all the buzz was about. I decided to try the lobster roll along with a side of fries, and while the flavors were delightful, I found the portion sizes to be quite overwhelming. The lobster roll was generously packed with tender, flavorful lobster meat, and the accompanying fries were crispy and well-seasoned. However, despite my best efforts, I couldn't finish my meal due to the sheer size of the portions. One aspect that detracted from my experience was the beverage service. I had ordered a glass of white wine to complement my meal, but the server mistakenly brought me a glass of red instead. This mix-up was disappointing, as I was looking forward to the crispness of white wine to pair with the seafood. While the red wine was decent, it didn’t quite match the culinary experience I had envisioned. In terms of ambiance, Carnegie Deli felt decidedly touristy. The bustling atmosphere and the large number of visitors made it feel less intimate and more like a place designed for quick stops rather than a leisurely dining experience. While I understand that it’s a popular spot for tourists, I prefer dining establishments that offer a more authentic local vibe. Overall, while my meal had its highlights, the combination of the oversized portions, the drink mix-up, and the tourist-heavy environment left me feeling that I wouldn’t choose to return. If you’re seeking a classic deli experience with a twist, you might find some enjoyment here, but for those looking for a more genuine atmosphere, it may be worth exploring other options.

Very dry sandwich. Small portion of coleslaw. I just wasted $25. Scale of 1&10 I'll give it a three. Ingredients are poor quality and I don't think that they will ever change because of the location.

MsAppleofhiseye

Very dry sandwich. Small portion of coleslaw. I just wasted $25. Scale of 1&10 I'll give it a three. Ingredients are poor quality and I don't think that they will ever change because of the location.

Ok good, but service was to be adored. The deli man was not on his game this evening when I went for my annual sup. I asked him for a whole pig but he gave me a pig with a hole in it. I don't know this New York humor but I took it as insult.

Skip this place. Tried to book our out of state church teen group of 37 for breakfast for TWO days but was nickel and dimed. Kids don't drink coffee or tea. They also didn't allow us to come in a la carte at 7:30 on a weekday morning. HAD to do the group rate of $30 ish pp for KIDS for breakfast. Sadly, Carnegie Diner left 37 people with a bad taste in their mouths.

Terrible! Both loaves of bread were stale, the pastrami was so so and the corned beef was nearly pure fat!! Called and left numerous messages. Nobody answered or will return a single call. They charge way too much for gross food. Extremely poor quality and service!

Lisa Quinn

Skip this place. Tried to book our out of state church teen group of 37 for breakfast for TWO days but was nickel and dimed. Kids don't drink coffee or tea. They also didn't allow us to come in a la carte at 7:30 on a weekday morning. HAD to do the group rate of $30 ish pp for KIDS for breakfast. Sadly, Carnegie Diner left 37 people with a bad taste in their mouths.

Lida Krumshyn

Terrible! Both loaves of bread were stale, the pastrami was so so and the corned beef was nearly pure fat!! Called and left numerous messages. Nobody answered or will return a single call. They charge way too much for gross food. Extremely poor quality and service!

jemjenk

Ok good, but service was to be adored. The deli man was not on his game this evening when I went for my annual sup. I asked him for a whole pig but he gave me a pig with a hole in it. I don't know this New York humor but I took it as insult.