A Pizza & More

The food... atmosphere and of course these amazing drink flight options are just wonderful. Stop in a taste everything... it's so worth it.

Kris Monette

Delicious pizza! I had the 5-star (with bacon). Fresh, quality ingredients. Friendly service too.

William OGorman

The food... atmosphere and of course these amazing drink flight options are just wonderful. Stop in a taste everything... it's so worth it.

Upendra Atlanta

Awesome food. Best hospitality!! Tim made us the best pizza with a secret ingredient (habinero sauce).. for people who love spicy food this is the best, delicious is an understatement!!

I was pleasantly surprised they made half and half specialty pizzas, the delivery was faster than expected and pizza was DELICIOUS. We’ll be ordering again soon!

I’ve always gotten pizza from this place. I would go to this place every single day if I could a pizza is always so good. It’s better than pudgy’s way better.

This place is hands down the best pizza I have had in years!!!!! Everyone says nyc style and this has been the only place to deliver that!! The people are awesome fun and friendly I will not go to any other place I'm a pizza junkie and this place makes me proud I moved here jeep it up guys!!!! Also I lost my apartment to a fire I was telling them about it and when I went to pay they comped my meal. Never expected that!

Good lunch deal. 2 slices with toppings & 32oz fountain drink and delivered for $15 which includes the tip. A lot cheaper than Door Dash. Very Good pizza, super filling. Slices are as big as your face. The only place in Cortland where you can get legit NY style pizza.

Me & my friend go here just about every Friday. They have great pizza, salads, fries,& thee best Sicilian chicken sandwhich, which is my fav thing to eat in town! Staff is always super friendly, playing fun music & they have great prices.

10/10. Doesn't look like a crime scene anymore. Went when it did because it's just that good.

Jim Wolf

I’ve always gotten pizza from this place. I would go to this place every single day if I could a pizza is always so good. It’s better than pudgy’s way better.

Julia Kostiv

10/10. Doesn't look like a crime scene anymore. Went when it did because it's just that good.

FreeStyle1983

This place is hands down the best pizza I have had in years!!!!! Everyone says nyc style and this has been the only place to deliver that!! The people are awesome fun and friendly I will not go to any other place I'm a pizza junkie and this place makes me proud I moved here jeep it up guys!!!! Also I lost my apartment to a fire I was telling them about it and when I went to pay they comped my meal. Never expected that!

Auroraxxfacekilla

Me & my friend go here just about every Friday. They have great pizza, salads, fries,& thee best Sicilian chicken sandwhich, which is my fav thing to eat in town! Staff is always super friendly, playing fun music & they have great prices.

Christine Drake

Good lunch deal. 2 slices with toppings & 32oz fountain drink and delivered for $15 which includes the tip. A lot cheaper than Door Dash. Very Good pizza, super filling. Slices are as big as your face. The only place in Cortland where you can get legit NY style pizza.

Might be the best pizza I have ever had. Nice size slices but a bit over priced by a couple dollars. I would usually eat every now and then.

Nice sized pies for the price. Be careful of their sausage, it my be spicy for some people. Garlic knots were great.

Very friendly people and wonderful food! If you order a dinner like I did, eggplant parmesan, you will be so happy with the amount of delicious food for the price. Give them a try.

I have had good memories of Pizza & More from my time in Cortland. I wish they stayed open later on Friday and Saturday because it is refreshing to get a slice that is handcrafted compared to the other establishments near/off main street.

Excellent chicken bacon ranch pizza and good size slices. Will not give free water so expect to pay for drinks. Also is a touch pricey as compared to other pizza places.

It's good.. I've tried different things on the menu, which I never do. But the sight of a new dish makes you want to try it.. When I first had them, they were at decent prices. But now, I mean to feed your family..... You're easily looking at$40-$50 .. But again it is good. I'm from the city of NY, and this has been 1of the closest tasting pizza shops upstate NY

Pizza was really good, cooked perfect with a good amount of toppings. The hot wings actually had a bit of a kick, but nothing too killer. They were extra crispy just as I asked. The only reason I give 4 stars is they got a topping wrong on the pizza (onions instead of mushrooms). I would try them again.

Decent pizza and wings. College hangout. We stopped with a group of teenagers after an event near Cortland. They were very accommodating. So I gave them 4 stars. Food wasn't specail but the staff was. Got plenty, all were full and no complaints. Give blue cheese and celery with the wings. Place was busy.

sal wilks-escobar

It's good.. I've tried different things on the menu, which I never do. But the sight of a new dish makes you want to try it.. When I first had them, they were at decent prices. But now, I mean to feed your family..... You're easily looking at$40-$50 .. But again it is good. I'm from the city of NY, and this has been 1of the closest tasting pizza shops upstate NY

Nancy Novak

Decent pizza and wings. College hangout. We stopped with a group of teenagers after an event near Cortland. They were very accommodating. So I gave them 4 stars. Food wasn't specail but the staff was. Got plenty, all were full and no complaints. Give blue cheese and celery with the wings. Place was busy.

Kevin Flanagan

Pizza was really good, cooked perfect with a good amount of toppings. The hot wings actually had a bit of a kick, but nothing too killer. They were extra crispy just as I asked. The only reason I give 4 stars is they got a topping wrong on the pizza (onions instead of mushrooms). I would try them again.

I order wings all the time from here and they are great but tonight I want to try something different I order a 1/2 lb of boneless wings honey BBQ I got honey mustard and there was only maybe 6 to 8 wing's and the gyro had more dressing and veggies then the meat the FF were not cook all the way and some of them were cold not to happy with this order tonight

The wings we asked for crispy, their definition of crispy is different than mine....more like shriveled up and the tiniest wings I've ever seen. Pizza was good however we had to cut the pizza ourselves.

It’s…. Fine. Its college pizza so obviously you’re not expecting high quality. They’re open for what goes for late in Cortland. Their menu says a whole is $19.24 after tax. Actually, they will charge you $22.50, so just be aware that they are adding extra to their bill without providing notice.

FLEDGE 444

The pizza we ordered was okay. The garlic knots were chewy and the garlic had a vinegar taste like the garlic was pre minced garlic you get in a jar. Tasted like pickled garlic which im not of fan of. The deep fried food was dark but inside it was undercooked which tells me the oil in the deep fryer possibly needs to be changed. I see from other reviews that others had better experiences, but for me that wasn't the case. Maybe it was an off night for this establishment so I will give it a shot another time. If I get the same results with the food again I won't be ordering food from here anymore. I gave 3 stars because the pizza was okay at best and the woman on the phone and the delivery driver were both pleasant to deal with, but the garlic knots and appetizers weren't good in my opinion.

I have been a fairly-regular of this establishment for several (at least 20 years). Generally, I have been satisfied with both their product and service. However...my latest order to them gives me pause... I ordered 2 "ziti and sausage" dinners. Upon delivery 2 salads, 2 rolls, and 2 tin foil "plates" were included. However, there was no sausage. Being a rather timid individual, I did not decide to call them back until 2 nights later. But upon doing so (and reaching that night's manager), I was told that I should have called them the very night. In addition, he informed me that he was "busy with the college crowd". Being a Saturday night, I was completely understanding. At that point, I expressed my understanding, accepted that I should have been more pushy on the night involved, and expected no recompense. To that, his response was "well...we'll try to do better." To be short and simple -- it leaves a bitter taste in the mouth. And to be further honest...it may be my final order to this establishment. If they don't care...then neither do I.

I can't write a complaint about the quality of the food. I can however write about the over zealous prices. $50 for a large 4 topping pizza, and 10 wings, waaayy too much. $3.25 PER TOPPING for a large pizza. Idk about you but I know that 3 mushrooms sliced certainly doesn't cost more than maybe 50 cents. Pepperoni is cheap, and so is sausage, especially when you consider the amount put on the pizza. Wings are outlandish when you consider that each wing only contains about a Tbsp max of meat. So essentially when you order 10 wings you get MAYBE a little more than half a cup of meat for $17! Go for steak and shrimp instead. You get much more for your money.

Ordered mozzarella sticks, boneless chicken wings medium sauce and an antipasto salad. The wings were so dry and hard could barely bite them. They also did not have medium sauce. It was more like mild if that. Not flavorful at all. The mozzarella sticks were also flavorless. The marinara sauce was blah. Looked at the salad and doesn't look anything like the picture on their website. Now for the delivery guy. I specifically stated on my order that they had to go in the 2 outside doors to get to my apartment. He stood outside knocking on the outside door. Dumb dumb dumb Will NOT be ordering from them again. Hope you have better luck with your order than I had with mine.

The price of things always changes. I order the same exact thing multiple times a week and every time the price is different. Today i ordered a gryo extra meat, menu price $7.50 without the extra meat they told me $11.26 on the phone and then show up with a slip for $16.26 so extra meat is double cost today? I have been told the extra meat should cost $1.50-3.00 depending on who picks up the phone . I have even talked to the owner (Tony) and still this happens. It is clear that someone is either adding extra money on top of orders to skim money or that employees are not trained how to bill correctly. Either way im done getting ripped off!! The food is normally good but NOT THAT GOOD.

I ordered a pizza and chicken tenders, 45 minutes later we got a pizza and wings. I called to notify them of the mistake and they said they would bring it over immediately. I waited and waited then called back 40 minutes later. She said “it’s heading out the door now”. I waited and waited again until an entire HOUR went by and still no food. I called and they seemed confused as to where the order even was. She had to ask the manager and told me “it’s being delivered”. The food definitely is not good enough to be waiting this long. I think some organization would really help them lol

Gianna Fezza

I ordered a pizza and chicken tenders, 45 minutes later we got a pizza and wings. I called to notify them of the mistake and they said they would bring it over immediately. I waited and waited then called back 40 minutes later. She said “it’s heading out the door now”. I waited and waited again until an entire HOUR went by and still no food. I called and they seemed confused as to where the order even was. She had to ask the manager and told me “it’s being delivered”. The food definitely is not good enough to be waiting this long. I think some organization would really help them lol

Stacy Verbeck

I can't write a complaint about the quality of the food. I can however write about the over zealous prices. $50 for a large 4 topping pizza, and 10 wings, waaayy too much. $3.25 PER TOPPING for a large pizza. Idk about you but I know that 3 mushrooms sliced certainly doesn't cost more than maybe 50 cents. Pepperoni is cheap, and so is sausage, especially when you consider the amount put on the pizza. Wings are outlandish when you consider that each wing only contains about a Tbsp max of meat. So essentially when you order 10 wings you get MAYBE a little more than half a cup of meat for $17! Go for steak and shrimp instead. You get much more for your money.

Brian Shelley

I have been a fairly-regular of this establishment for several (at least 20 years). Generally, I have been satisfied with both their product and service. However...my latest order to them gives me pause... I ordered 2 "ziti and sausage" dinners. Upon delivery 2 salads, 2 rolls, and 2 tin foil "plates" were included. However, there was no sausage. Being a rather timid individual, I did not decide to call them back until 2 nights later. But upon doing so (and reaching that night's manager), I was told that I should have called them the very night. In addition, he informed me that he was "busy with the college crowd". Being a Saturday night, I was completely understanding. At that point, I expressed my understanding, accepted that I should have been more pushy on the night involved, and expected no recompense. To that, his response was "well...we'll try to do better." To be short and simple -- it leaves a bitter taste in the mouth. And to be further honest...it may be my final order to this establishment. If they don't care...then neither do I.

I had a stromboli yesterday and all I found was lots of cheese and dough.Abou 3 peppers, a few slices of pepperoni and shaved sausage and few bites of ham. Very dissapointed.The price is reasonable enough but would like more ingredients.

Poor customer service, they messed up my pizza I asked for a partial refund and they refused to acknowledge that they messed it up and refused a refund even when presented with the receipt and my order clearly stated on it. There are plenty of other pizzerias in cortland no point in going to this one again.

It was to hot inside pizza and more that you could feel it as soon as you walk in and you couldn't even eat there it was so hot we just left. I'd recommend getting your air-conditioning fixed.

Ordered a large pizza from this place for delivery. Was told it would be 1 hour wich was fine. Got an email saying my pizza would be here between 7:45 and 7;55 pm. Well 8:55 rolls around and still no pizza. My wife called them to see what was going on. She got hung up on. I recommend not doing business with this place at all...

Asked for the lunch special for the three of us. I pay the lunch special price, finally I ask for our drinks and am told the special ended at 2pm (it was like 2:15). They could have told us that when taking our $$$ but No and NO drink for you! Steam shot out my ears and I will never go back there again.

This was my favorite pizza place in my home town, so I was bragging to my out of town friends. I just ordered the chicken wing pizza, and it was delivered fast! But it's too burnt to eat :/ it has hardly any chicken on it. I'm so sad, this is not the quality I've had in store on my visits home. I usually go here once or twice during every visit. I guess I will order pudgies.

What I ordered was chicken parm with spaghetti for $17. What I got was two frozen salty chicken tenders with a slice of cheese melted over it. Charging $17 for two chicken tenders over spaghetti is disgraceful, doesn’t anyone make actual breaded chicken anymore? Person on the phone was rude as well. Won’t be back.

Less than impressed with the one on main street in cortland. We ordered 3 slices of pizza and when we took the paper off of the cheese slices 75% of the cheese came off with it. Plus the other slice was burnt on the bottom and the garlic knots we ordered were also burnt.

TERRIBLE! I never leave reviews. We went in for a slice passing through one night as a Cortland Alum. I ordered a slice and they said that it would be $7.56. I said omg $7.56 for a slice. They laughed and as I left they yelled that they hoped I enjoyed my slice. It was bland and I threw it out!

This place has great food and terrible service. Last 4 times I ordered food it’s been 5-20 minutes late every time. This last time I was told 30-45 minutes and it was an hour and a half later. Called them up and said no discount can be given. I was in pizza delivery business and the customer in this situation would be given a huge discount... Great food, terrible service

Burnt burnt burnt this was what my order came like. He said his boss told him to send the burnt pizza because it more ny style? Charhed threw the dough right to the cheese then covered the real bad spots with white cheese. I spend alot of money ordering from there. They replaced it with a half cooked pizza and wouldnt give my money back.. Not real happy

I was beyond disappointed with the customer service tonight. I own property in town and just wanted pizza. I was going to order online as I typically would but it says it’s closed. Apparently they are open so I had to go into the actual location despite the busy Cortica crowd. I asked for my pizza to go and they put it on the counter on paper plates. When it came out I asked for it to go and the girl just sets a box on top of it! The restaurant was crowded how was I supposed to box it easily on top of the pizza counter over my head surrounded by people?! Meanwhile employees are just standing around. Then as I’m clearly annoyed she gives me attitude. I get home and the pizza is burnt…

Meghan Slack

I was beyond disappointed with the customer service tonight. I own property in town and just wanted pizza. I was going to order online as I typically would but it says it’s closed. Apparently they are open so I had to go into the actual location despite the busy Cortica crowd. I asked for my pizza to go and they put it on the counter on paper plates. When it came out I asked for it to go and the girl just sets a box on top of it! The restaurant was crowded how was I supposed to box it easily on top of the pizza counter over my head surrounded by people?! Meanwhile employees are just standing around. Then as I’m clearly annoyed she gives me attitude. I get home and the pizza is burnt…

We ordered $70 worth of food pizza and wings everyone who ate it got food poisoning. I called to talk to the manager she was very rude and said it takes 24 hours to get food poisoning after eating it she knows because her mom is a nurse. Waste of money and not worth being disrespected

Website and Google say open at 9AM. Went at 10AM and they said they don't open until 11AM. Yet leave the door unlocked to the public. Make it make sense.

Did not get pizza slices I ordered. Instead they gave me garlic pizza slices. Made me really sick 🤢.They were terrible. Starting to feel a little better tonight.

Passable pizza, customer service was awful, really put a bad taste in my mouth. Got yelled at for asking for a straw.

The worst pizza ever and the garlic knots weren't cooked. Will never go there again I asked for an extra crispy well done pizza and got the top extra crispy however the rest of the sheet pizza was not cooked all the way. The garlic knots weren't cooked all the way. The 2 slices that I bought for my grandson he said was okay. Worst pizza in Cortland new york and their shop smelled like it was sprayed for cockroaches . The tables and rugs were dirty. Wow just wow

Netanel Tannhauser

Passable pizza, customer service was awful, really put a bad taste in my mouth. Got yelled at for asking for a straw.

Julie Sweet

Did not get pizza slices I ordered. Instead they gave me garlic pizza slices. Made me really sick 🤢.They were terrible. Starting to feel a little better tonight.

Terri Jackson

The worst pizza ever and the garlic knots weren't cooked. Will never go there again I asked for an extra crispy well done pizza and got the top extra crispy however the rest of the sheet pizza was not cooked all the way. The garlic knots weren't cooked all the way. The 2 slices that I bought for my grandson he said was okay. Worst pizza in Cortland new york and their shop smelled like it was sprayed for cockroaches . The tables and rugs were dirty. Wow just wow

Bradley Mathewson

Ordered a large pizza from this place for delivery. Was told it would be 1 hour wich was fine. Got an email saying my pizza would be here between 7:45 and 7;55 pm. Well 8:55 rolls around and still no pizza. My wife called them to see what was going on. She got hung up on. I recommend not doing business with this place at all...