This place is incredible! The management is very nice and the food is amazing and affordable. Definitely recommend it!

Made a quick stop in Dansville and wanted to get dinner. We made a great choice good food and great service.

Best pizza. It's a must stop place when I can to Dansville to see my family

Great pizza & awesome, friendly service!!!! Clean & well priced.

First time ordering here and it was phenomenal!!! Will sooo be ordering from there again for sure

Freshly made pizza dough, and sause, great staff, and Great prices!!

The best pizza around. the subs are top notch always fresh

Drove to dansville just for this pizza. Soo good, definitely best around that area!!!!

I enjoy going here on Fridays for the thin crust pepperoni pizza and wings.

Favorite pizza place in the town of dansvile. Their plates are good as well.

Pizza was really good and one of the best. We had soup, wings and craft beer as well. It was all freshly prepared and delicious

Always awesome here - food is fantastic and the service is as good as you’d expect - love coming time and time again!

Great food and the staff is always friendly. Good prices and fast service as well.

Great pizza! Super clean restaurant. Friendly service.

The pizza was delicious and super cheap, I would come here again for sure!

Food is great, service is amazing. I always feel like family when I eat there. It's a great environment to be in. The open hours listed by Google are wrong and need updating however.

Dough from scratch every day. Best pizza in town.

Love there pizza and the subs are amazing. Great reason to come to dansville! Have some good food and then go see a movie! Right next to eacher.

Great pizza at a middle ground price. We started going here after issues with out last pizza place and haven't looked back.

Had the veggie pizza. Really very filling and tasted great. Would definitely recommend

Just received my delivery order, have to say I'm very happy! The pizza is delicious,made just how I ordered!

Love their subs!! Don't want them from anywhere else. Always a good atmosphere 👌 👏.

Tony and his crew offer the best pizza in town. Quick fast service with delicious food, and always with a smile.

Excellent customer service. They also do a little magic with their crust. Best I've had in a looong time.

Tony's a few months ago tony's had good chocolate chip cookies. Now something has changed an now they are not as good.

Awesome wings! Great Pizza!! All fresh ingredients. Loved eating here

Really good pizza and fast service. I'm from NYC and i really enjoyed the pizza. Great prices

Absolutely the best pizza in Danville ny. Clean polite and awesome taste.

Simply the best in town. You are family when you enter Tony's. A verity of Pizza type selection and related items. This is the place to eat.

Tony's is the go-to place in Dansville. Tony and Salome and wonderful hosts, always a kind word. The food here is amazing! I

Of all the other pizza shops, in Dansville and surrounding areas, Tony's is the place to get pizza done right. Its a small, comfortable and very clean establishment, both in the eating and cooking areas. Stop in for a slice and have a brew. You won't be disappointed

Tony's is my favorite place to go in Dansville! The food is always great and the staff are super friendly. Coming to Tony's is about the food and the experience... Everyone from the owner on down are AWESOME!

Had a great experience here tonight. I just walked in, and I could tell they were very busy. Still, they managed to get my chicken finger sub order for me in about 15 minutes. Didn’t even have to call ahead! Ample chicken on the sandwich...left me satisfied.

Went to stony brook after a long hike we called them for a large pizza.. during the quarantine. They said 25 minutes please wear a mask.... 25 minutes later and a home made mask out of a tops paper bag we got our thin crust pizza.. 3 hours later we are still talking about how good that damn pizza was

I live in Texas now and every time I come to visit this is the first place I go!! I literally come 1600 mile for this pizza!!

Great place! Grab the pizza if you around. It’s best place to have a quality pizza

We were wondering when we happened upon this cozy Pizzeria. We both ordered slices, they were large with lots of meat on the.

Their subs are the best around. The cold Mustang is a perfect Italian style sub and can’t go wrong with the chicken finger and tomatoes sub.

Friendly staff, great food. Pizza and wings are some of my favorite in the area!

Pizza was amazing, service was amazing as well. I highly recommend Tony's if you are looking for authentic pizza. Place is small but cozy.

We love Tony's! We order from here every other week and we will continue doing so for years to come. Amazing food, very clean and the people that work there are incredibly nice. Keep up the amazing work!

My husband and I stopped at Tony's last night for the first time to grab dinner! We will definitely go back when in that area! The folks working were friendly and welcoming, and the food was delicious! We took advantage of their sip and slice deal and also ordered wings! Pizza slices were hot and delicious and the wings were fantastic! We have no complaints. In addition to great food, the price for beer and wine was stellar (3.50 for a glass of wine!!). If you are looking for a casual place with great food-we would recommend Tony's!

Haven't had Tony's pizza in well over a year. Finally came back, and the pizza is just as good as I remember. Hands down the most consistent pizza in the area. Thank you guys for always making excellent food.

I love this pizzeria! It has the best tasting pizza in the town, in my opinion! Especially if you ask for "Jack's sauce". (He was the previous owner, his sauce is preserved thanks to Tony) I actually have a craving for some chicken fingers right now.. I highly recommend this place a try.

I love Tony's Pizzeria. Tony's pizzas are great ( especially with Tony's sauce) and their subs are excellent. I have had almost everything on their menu and have NEVER been disappointed. Also, their customer service is impeccable, everyone is always polite and friendly. Keep up the good work!

Stopped over while on our road trip from Canada. The pizza and sub were amazing. The staff was super friendly and helpful. Would highly recommend.

The staff were very friendly. We ordered takeout and the food was excellent and nicely priced. I highly recommend the pizza!

Bre and maria make a great team and there service was fantastic. I went there the other day my wife and I love it she has 4 th stage lung and brain cancer and goes though spells she will pass out she did it in Tony maria ran out to help me and my wife she is a angel she didn't even think she just did it not many people will do that my wife has bruises all over her arm from cancer maria didn't care she is a god sent thank you Maria sooooooo much

Carlie T

Went for a quick weekday lunch while I was checking out the Fairy Doors. Staff was friendly, food came out fast and was delicious. Very reasonable prices and a really convenient location. They also have some cool historical pictures inside.

Rick Vattimo

Great pizza in a classic Main Street pizzeria. Clean comfortable and fast, friendly service. Decent prices and again an excellent pizza.

Malley Landino

Place is clean and kitchen is open, very friendly and professional workers, the food is a little spicy with Tony's spin on food, love a owner that puts there creations in effect I prefer spicy and think it's the best pizzaria on the block.

Matt Slocum

Friendly staff, fresh sauce made daily, delicious pizza, all with reasonable prices. Our pizza was delicious, and we can't wait to go back for more!

Stephanie Mosher

Been ordering subs, they are made right every time. Jalapeños are nice and fresh/hot like they should be. The staff is always great.

Kathleen Wilcox

So far our favorite place in Dansville for pizza. We look forward to trying the sandwiches and homemade soup. Update! Hands down the best pizza in town! I enjoy everything they make here! My family doesn't eat out anywhere else..

Tank Keepers

If your ever near here you should definitely stop by and grab a pizza. One of the better pizzas I have had in my life. The crust was light and fluffy, sauce had a real nice crisp taste to it, overall it made for a really good pizza. And the pizza is definitely a LARGE! The breadsticks with cheese were also very good. So as I said if your ever driving past stop by and get a pizza.

Alain-Christian

You’re probably here for the pizza, right? Well don’t sleep on the sandwiches; they’re delicious! I ordered a six inch “assorted” and it was so good I had to order another! The meats were fresh, the veggies were crisp and the bread was warm but not crunchy. It was a very satisfying mix of textures. The bread almost melts as you’re eating it, does what I’m saying make sense? I picked the white bread. I ordered mine with their house sandwich dressing. The dressing just elevates everything in the sandwich and makes it even more flavorful. You have to try it! I’m not from the area but for those if you who are you owe it to yourselves to try their “assorted” sandwich. It’s better than that sandwich chain. You know which one I’m talking about. Next time you think of going there give Tony’s a shot. Full disclosure I had mine without cheese but I’m sure it’s delicious that way regardless. Support your local shops! I’ll try to stop here whenever I’m traveling cross state. Peace & Love

ajay sharma

One of the best Veggie Pizza that I have eaten in USA. I was traveling back from Niagara and found this. Other reviews justify this place. The toppings include mushrooms, broccoli, cauliflower, carrot, onions and pepper. They have a premix and it is frickin awesome.

Kevin Markman

Nice spot in the village of Dansville. Picnic table to eat outside and a small venue for seating inside. Helpful staff and quality service. Food was good and well made. Good wraps and light and crispy curly fries. Recommend for a good bite.

+3

Crystal Clark

First time here. Very good pizza. I like more cheese but it still was great. Wings were cooked just right, they were not hard like other places. Friendly and clean place. Will definitely will be coming back and letting everyone know.

Carolyn Doty

We ordered a gluten free and large pepperoni with original sauce...it was amazing! Our grandson must have gluten free food. You are the ONLY place in our area that can offer him pizza! Our pizza was delicious, and hot! The crust was thick and tender, lots of sauce, cheese and pepperoni...was gone in a heartbeat. Will definitely be ordering again.

Pizza is always good here! Order took a while to be ready but that was expected

Not bad pizza very friendly people great service.

Good pizza, nice little shop. Polite staff and down to earth people.

Great pizza and lots of other food. Clean place and really friendly staff!

Best pizza in Dansville. My only wish is they had fresh mushrooms and and offered artichoke hearts 😁

Charles Hollenbeck

I like this place because it’s just what you need after a long day of hiking Letchworth and Stony Brook gorges. Quick, straightforward, and good. Very friendly staff. Also, on a Sunday, it was one of the only places in the whole town that was open.

Rasen Shuriken

Stopped by Tony’s Pizzeria and was pleasantly surprised. The pizza was fresh with a dough that really stood out—you could tell from the crust. Light, fluffy, and with just the right crunch. The cheese amount was spot on, though I would’ve liked a little more sauce. The garlic bread was the star—perfect texture with just the right amount of cheese and seasoning. Staff was friendly, and overall it’s a very nice pizza place. Definitely a spot I’d go back to.

Colleen Neidrauer

Good subs, the Italian was delicious. Good prices. Fast service.

Fanny Gardyn

The pizzas were really good. The kids enjoyed them. The staff was courteous and professional. The place was quiet. We had to wait a little bit for the food to arrive but this shows that everything was made fresh and it was worth it.

Better than average pizza but nothing here ever made me say that I absolutely wanted it again.

Asked for extra sauce on wings, got a bunch of naked wings with almost no sauce.

The pizza was okay. It was typical pizza in town. Nothing special, not bad but not great.

Nice location. Half hour wait time to get a pretty basic pizza.

Food and service was nice however prices are very high. 2 large pizza and 2 orders of wings and a salad cost almost $100. Without delivery. I feel like their prices are a little too high

Long time customer of Tony's. Last couple of pizzas were disappointing. Very dry and hardly any sauce. Ordered with mushrooms. Counted 12 pieces of shrooms on my pizza. Wow!! for a $1.75.. All great businesses seem to go downhill after a while. Step it up Tony.

Butch Comer

Tony's was very clean and the staff was friendly but the pizza was disappointing, cafeteria quality with a weird Pillsbury-like crust. There are some frozen pizzas that would be a better option. Tony's pizza seems to have a production line characteristic and lacks stretchy cheesy goodness. I would urge most Western New York pizza makers to visit the Jersey Shore and NYC and sample as many slices as they can. Maybe Tony's other food is better but the pizza made me sad.

2 large pizzas & a small salad shouldn't cost 50$. Pizza was good but it is an expensive place. Will not visit often but maybe again one day.

Ive had better pizza before. But the service was really good

Decent service. Quick to take order. The person/s running this place are OCD about COVID precautions. Pricey. Pizza was thin and crispy and a bit greasy. Flavor was bland. I felt like it was a frozen pizza with cheap pepperoni thrown on top.

Brittany Liese

I had an issue last week where I got the completely wrong toppings on my pizza and they were already closed when I had opened it at home. My kids are picky and will not eat pepperoni, so I ordered a pizza with extra cheese and mushrooms. I did not get that and tried to call immediately, but they were gone at 8:08. I called the next day after having to go out and get my kids McDonald’s as they wouldn’t eat the pizza, and they offered me to credit me a topping of mushrooms and extra cheese. My friend asked me what about the pizza underneath? I kind of agree now. I legit threw out an entire pizza and am only getting credited for a topping? I just wish the customer service would have made it right to what I had ordered. The staff was nice enough but I did not get what I ordered and I think that should have been the priority.

A Parker

Unfortunately, after Tony left the food has gone down hill a little. I’m not sure why everything tastes different… I’m guessing they started going with cheaper ingredients. But the staffing is wonderful and very friendly, and I’ll say they keep the pizza shop very clean!

K

If your craving a cheese pizza slice don’t go in the evening went there around 5:30ish they’re always out around this time, I was told they couldn’t make a fresh one because they were out the dough 🤔, I had some good experience a few years back when I 1st came to this town for some reason everything was better even the tossed salads, I remember having Romaine instead of lettuce, also a time when I got an over cooked pizza basically burnt crust But ok hopefully they will do better. My 1st experience the owners were there and they were so nice and attentive. I don’t know what’s going these days 🤷🏽‍♀️ food industry is not doing so well

Expensive and pizza was way over cooked, pepperoni was black, so over done it was dry. Over $50 for large meat lovers pizza and 15 wings.

I ordered a chicken, bacon and ranch pizza and all they gave me was a pizza with chicken fingers and burnt cheese, I didn’t know I had to teach people who have been working there for years how to make a pizza. Waiting for my money back!

If this is the best pizza Dansville has to offer, I won't be back to this trumptarded town. Pizza was drier than expired gas station pizza and less tasty than that type of gas station pizza too. Next time I'll just stop at the gas station when I'm passing through because at least their pizza is properly priced. There was almost no cheese on this pizza and I felt like I was eating cardboard. Ordered 2 appetizers too and then realized the serving size for appetizers is so small I thought it was a prank. Prices are way way WAY too high for the quality. I'm just glad I do not live in a town where there is so few restaurants none of them have to serve quality because they literally hold a monopoly on restaurants in the area. Tony needs to take a trip to Market St. In Corning and taste a real slice of pizza. Get out your note pad and take notes Tony, you have some homework to do before you deserve to make another pizza. Lol! So sad

My boyfriend and I liked it here a lot. Until they screwed up our order that we paid for and already brought home...we called and they didn't believe us unless we drove 35 minutes back to the store to prove it to them. They went as far as telling us if we didn't want to make the drive to save the food and bring it in next time we went to Dansville. Which would have been way too long for us to save that food!!! I just wish they could have found a way to make it right with us in a more professional, logical way.. It is unfortunate because we were always supporting their business.

Pizza was very cold like it had been sitting out for a while. Was told 10 wings and got 6. Lastly i messaged with the concerns and they called and basically said what i was telling them was impossible and continued to “politely” tell me i was wrong. Do not go here there are plenty of other places, i would have preferred a frozen pizza.

If you’re a big fan of bad pizza and wildly unnecessary covid protocols then come here! I can deal with subpar pizza (which this place offers) but when I went in to get a slice (In the end of April 2021) I tried to pay the girl by handing her my money, she told me I had to place it in a basket... and then when she brought me my slice I stuck my hand out to take the plate and she walked right past me and said “I have to put it on the table”... come on... these measures were hardly warranted during the height of covid when everything was a mystery but now that most of the country is vaccinated and we KNOW that covid isn’t transmitted by passing money from hand to hand or handing someone a plate, it’s just bad customer service. Unnecessary virtue signaling at its most obnoxious. I’ll never go back.

Used to come here regularly before the pandemic, but since then would order out. This time called ahead and ordered a 2 cheese pizzas like usual because my family doesn't eat pork so obviously no pepperoni. The woman that took my order asked for my name and number. Would that be all is the only thing she asked besides that. I walk in and already the customer service isn't the greatest coming from the older woman. I take my order and leave, but only then realized they gave me pepperoni instead of a plain cheese. Walking back in with my sister I say excuse me I ordered 2 plain cheese pizzas but got pepperoni instead. Instantly the older woman starts to argue saying no you ordered pepperoni and that she wrote it down that way and read it back to me on the phone. She did no such thing. I explained I don't eat pork so I wouldn't order pepperoni. She keeps insisting. The younger woman tells her to make us new pizzas and ushers me aside to take a new customer when we weren't even done discussing everything. You could visibly see the older woman in the back glaring back and slamming things. I no longer wanted anything to do with that place so the replacement order was canceled before it was started and we walked out. I forgot to get a refund being so frustrated with that experience so I called back for a refund. The younger woman on the phone said they don't give refunds because she offered to make a replacement and that I could get the pizzas back that I returned. That makes no sense because one, they didn't get a chance to even start the new pizza because it was canceled. Two, as stated if I don't eat pork why would I go get the pizza's they messed up? I said "I don't want any pizza from you, just a simple refund". But she insisted just because of the offer there wouldn't be one. I no longer plan on supporting this business. The customer service was never the greatest before, but the food is no longer worth it.

I would never order there again. I called order 15 wings extra crispy. Ask them nicely to put them down for 23 minutes. Their normal is 15 to 20 minutes. She got upset when I asked her to put him down for an extra in a few minutes she gave me attitude, and then when I went and picked up my wings, they were definitely not extra crispy. They were soggy soft And fat, and not good to eat, and then when I called to complain and let her know that my wings were soft and soggy and not extra crispy like I asked she argue with me and then hung up on me. I called back and she hung up on me again. I hope other people don’t get that same service. I would never order there again.