Randy Russelburg (Big Randy)

I’ve ordered online for delivery for a second time, and every time it hits just the right place. The only place in Evansville that I feel comfortable getting the old dishes from back when I was a kid. Thanks for being there for me!

Ken Deacon

This place has the best catfish I've had in a long time. Their seasoning is perfect. Had the combo platter. Everything was cooked perfectly. Our server was very friendly and timely. Overall, great dining! Prices were definitely low for the amount of food served. Will return, without a doubt. Would advise to anyone who loves seafood!!

burrmez765 •

Food was beautifully displayed and delicious. Servers were very friendly.

Vicki Dalton

We celebrated my dad’s birthday at Catfish Willy’s. The food was great, but the service was even better. Krisalyn was awesome! She was very attentive and genuinely pleasant. She even took a family pic for us! We’ll be return customers.

Dani Jacobs

Everything about our meal and service was awesome. Jorrel was great. We had shrimp and lobster dip and oysters as appetizers, our meal was catfish fillets with red potatoes and mahi mahi tacos with tangy coleslaw. We will definitely be back.

Andi

Love Catfish Willy's. I miss the Owensboro location since I'm hardly in Evansville. And when I go to Evansville, I forget that it's there. Ordered my Gator fries and they were wonderful as always but it seems the portion was smaller than it used to be especially for an appetizer. My daughter ordered the kids' cheeseburger, plain (no cheese too) with pickles and it came out perfect. The only problem was that I requested the food to come out together and I was halfway done with my Gator fries when she finally got her burger.

Dioshia Fox

Jorell was a wonderful waiter from the beginning to the end. He was very knowledgeable about the menu and offered delicious suggestions. He was attentive to us as customers and eager to do a great job. Stop in and see him whenever your in the area. The $10 lunch specials are amazing from the catfish, shrimp boil, chopped cheese and various other options.

Tatum Spurgeon

It has been a very good experience. I've never had a seafood boil before and I am happy to day this place met my expectations and had an awesome atmosphere!! Highly recommend

Sydnie Stevens

I had an amazing experience at CatFish Willy's! The food was absolutely delicious - I loved every bite! But what really made our visit stand out was the exceptional service. The staff were incredibly kind, welcoming, and attentive. They made us feel right at home. And the atmosphere? So much fun! The vibe was lively and energetic, with a great ambiance that added to our overall enjoyment. Can't wait to go back and do it all again! 5 stars isn't enough - I'd give it 10 stars if I could!

grace miller

I took my partner here on a date and it was wonderful! Angie our server was very friendly and had great recommendations! It is the best seafood in Indiana for sure! (If you are coming for a seafood boil get the whole shabang seasoning!!! Add broccoli) also the loaded gator fries were amazing! I will be coming back!

Landon Wilson

Really great place to eat. Food was delicious, we had the crab meat shrimp dip and the crocodile fries. Both were delicious. I had the fish and shrimp with the lemon pepper batter and it was really good. Other's in our group got the shrimp tacos, a boil, steak and shrimp. Everyone was pleased. I liked the wall paintings too. Service was great they also were digital/tablet for ordering.

+3

Katie Parm

Ordered the crab boil ramen and I wish I could give it 1800 stars because that’s how fire it was. Started off with the gator fries but you literally can’t wrong starting there.. and didn’t. It was so amazing and so flavorful 10/10!!! Wonderful service as well! Our server was Courtney!

Patricia Zamora

My first Seafood experience in Indiana landed on target 🎯. My seafood cravings have been satisfied 😁 and Willie's is now my go to for Seafood! 😍 I arrived around 2pm for a late lunch; I was seated immediately. They had the Lobster Roll on special, and as recommended, I loved loved loved it 😀 The roll was so soft and the warm lobster so delicious, the fries were seasoned so well, and the beer was served just as requested. I highly recommend this dish. The service was impeccable, the waitress was very patient with me and very kind. The restaurants decor is on point, a lot of cute things to look at. I will definitely return!!

+10

Mac Kenzie Watson

I’m in Evansville for business and was looking for something different. I stumbled upon Catfish Willy’s and was not disappointed. From the moment I walked in, I was visually stimulated by the bright and clean atmosphere. Jorell quickly came to greet me and he was nothing short of amazing. He listened to my requests and walked me through a couple options on the menu to meet those requests. I ultimately chose the gator nachos 🔥 and grilled catfish tacos with the grilled red potatoes. Absolutely amazing! Clean, hot, fresh food with great presentation and service. Can’t wait to come back to Evansville just to have some more of this wonderful food.

Mary-Jane Taylor

Me and my fiancé went there for date night and had the most amazing meal ever. I love seafood but this is definitely the best I’ve had in Evansville. Our server, Nick had such and amazing vibe. He is a really cool person and made the experience 10 times better. Plus the sharks and birds hanging from the ceiling was super cool too. Definitely coming again and you should go too!

Amazing food. Great place for a nice quiet night out. I got the snow crab and shrimp Cajun Ramen and it was delicious!

Amazing food. Great place for a nice quiet night out. I got the snow crab and shrimp Cajun ramen and it was delicious!

Amazing food. Great place for a nice quiet night out. I got the snow crab and shrimp Cajun Ramen and it was delicious!

Amazing food. Great place for a nice quiet night out. I got the snow crab and shrimp Cajun Ramen and it was delicious!

Food was incredible. The gator bite fries were sooo good. Went the for the burgers and they did not disappoint! Great service.

food was incredible. The gator bite fries were sooo good. Went the for the burgers and they did not disappoint! Great service.

Food was incredible. The gator bite fries were sooo good. Went the for the burgers and they did not disappoint! Great service.

Food was incredible. The gator bite fries were sooo good. Went the for the burgers and they did not disappoint! Great service.

The food was very good - the fried fish was really well fried. Perfect. The staff are friendly and present, and the whole place is covered in fun murals. Highly recommend!

We had a really good dining experience here. The beer was real cold and the food was tasty. We ordered our beers and our food. There was only one waitress but she provided quick, friendly service…

FANTASTIC!! I had a rough couple of days and i was craving crab, my boyfriend was craving catfish, and we had just recently heard about y'all. As a girl who grew up in the deep south, i had been mi…

We are here while visiting my family in Evansville. We shared a crab fries appetizer for the table. I ordered the crab stuffed tilapia as well as three others at the table. My son bordered the sh…

Great experience. I am an old man that really likes fiddlers. There aren’t any restaurants that still serve them, Knob Tavern excluded. However. This place far exceeds them. Anyhoo, if you have a ha…

Oh my goodness! Our meal was fabulous, and our server Bre was so sweet!! I had the shrimp and mussels boil and it was amazing. ❤️ My granddaughter had the snow crab, Lobster and shrimp boil. We …

Oh my goodness! Our meal was fabulous, and our server Bre was so sweet!! I had the shrimp and mussels boil and it was amazing. ❤️ My granddaughter had the snow crab, Lobster and shrimp boil. We wi…

Oh my goodness! Our meal was fabulous, and our server Bre was so sweet!! I had the shrimp and mussels boil and it was amazing. ❤️ My granddaughter had the snow crab, Lobster and shrimp boil. We …

Have been many times. We love going..Shrimp and crawfish boils are my favorite and gator fries are awesome. I have had some of the fried stuff a time or 2 also but the boils are the way to go if yo…

Tasty boils in a nicely themed tropical setting. Gator fries are a great appetizer. Outstanding service. Reasonable prices for quantity. Only negative is only (1) 1/2-ear of corn. Best of the …

Tasty boils in a nicely themed tropical setting. Gator fries are a great appetizer. Outstanding service. Reasonable prices for quantity. Only negative is only (1) 1/2-ear of corn. Best of the …

Tasty boils in a nicely themed tropical setting. Gator fries are a great appetizer. Outstanding service. Reasonable prices for quantity. Only negative is only (1) 1/2-ear of corn. Best of the …

Ordered the boil #2 With light seasoning. The food came out perfect. The lobster crab and clams were cooked just right. Add the seasoning was perfect. Our server Shannon did a great job. Would re…

Some of the best seafood I've had I got the king crab legs add a half a pound of shrimp half a pound of sausage and broccoli can't remember exactly what the flavor was called we got I think it was The Works Maybe it was all the flavors combined very good flavor crab shrimp were cooked perfect I didn't care for the broccoli taste like it was grilled before it was put in the bag had a charred taste to it the only reason I didn't give five stars our waitress was great brownie bite an ice cream dessert was the perfect ending! Great place to grab some seafood will definitely return

Jessica Spooner

The food and service were great! The atmosphere needs some work. I'm guessing they aren't super popular but they should work on keeping the place a little cleaner and make sure that everything is working. The bathroom locks didn't work and there were some messes throughout the restaurant.

Micah Boyd

Okay this is a local owned GEM. We got our food within like 10 minutes or less of ordering. I got the lobster roll and fries. The fries were perfect, flavor of the lobster roll was chef’s kiss 🤌🏼 My husband got the shrimp n grits. The flavor was poppin again, but we have had better grits. We split the hush puppies and they were decent. Overall the food was wonderful. The service was 10/10. My only complaint is that the portion sizes are smollllllll. Like real small.

I had the pleasure to eat here today. I wanted a good burger and they delivered. Great service and great food. This place is family owned and do great food from scratch \nIf you haven't tried them …

We had a large group come in. We had everything from seafood boil, the seafood ramen, pork tenderloin, shrimp, fried green tomatoes, gators fries. Pretty much a little bit of everything. The fo…

We had a large group come in. We had everything from seafood boil, the seafood ramen, pork tenderloin, shrimp, fried green tomatoes, gators fries. Pretty much a little bit of everything. The food w…

We ordered carryout from here to try something new and were pleasantly surprised. Really well seasoned food for the price!

My husband and I decided to try Catfish Willie's for lunch on a Wednesday. My husband ordered the warm lobster roll with fries and I had the crab stuffed whitefish with hush puppies. The lobster roll…

It's time to wake up! Evansville this restaurant is every bit as good as the Red Clawed place. The food was delicious and the portions were large. The service was quick and very friendly. The atmos…

It's time to wake up! Evansville this restaurant is every bit as good as the Red Clawed place. The food was delicious and the portions were large. The service was quick and very friendly. The atmos…

I ordered the breaded shrimp and breaded squash. The coating on the shrimp was very thick and didn't have a taste I have ever had. The squash was way overdone almost to the point of being burned…

When they were in Owensboro we would drive there at least once a month. The boil buckets were amazing with Big portions and Low prices. I would get their $20 bucket boil with 1/2 lb. of snow crab l…

Stopped in here because I’ve wanted to try the place for a long time and the wife agreed for our Valentine’s dinner. She didn’t want to take advantage of the valentines menu so we ordered different entrees. She ordered the shrimp tacos and while they were good she was a bit disappointed that she only got two for the price we paid. I got the Willy’s fish platter. It was okay but for $21 it was nothing to write home about. We ordered an appetizer that came at the same time as our entrees which wasn’t a huge deal . We paid $3.89 a piece for sweet teas that were not sweet. Our server checked on us one time throughout our entire meal while we noticed other patrons were checked on frequently. Specifically it was a family of 6 that was getting very friendly and consistent service. Me and my wife both asked each other why we’re not getting that kind of service. Our server was nice when she did check on us. I’ve seen pictures of the boils which I’m sure are great but because of the lack of service we got we decided we will not be coming back. We did agree that we left full, however.

Jennifer Paul

I ordered Hoosier burger but catfish Willy is apart of the business… This was my last time ordering here. My to-go food was thrown together with no care, and when the lady handed me my bag, she was literally slinging it around like it didn’t matter what was inside. Everything was a mess when I opened it. I used to enjoy this place, but if that’s how customers are treated now, I won’t waste my money here again.”

Got the Cajun catfish fingers with fries and hush puppies off the spring menu. The catfish was perfectly cooked, but would've liked a little more Cajun flavor. fries were good and hush puppies we…

So...I really didn't want to leave a review because Catfish Willy's has been our favorite restaurant for a while now. It literally got us through the insanity of covid as we found a place with good p…

So...I really didn't want to leave a review because catfish Willy's has been our favorite restaurant for a while now. It literally got us through the insanity of covid as we found a place with good…

Well we were in the mood for a fish dinner ...cold, been sitting since lunch I guess , salad a joke , had to beg for lemon,sauces , Xtra dressing 🙄😒 skimpy as you can get on child's French fries, charge fir children's drink & 389 pretty strong for old tea , I just didn't feel the food warranted the heavy bill. We paid tipped 🙄😒 NEVER AGAIN! No wonder the parking lot is empty Live&learn!

can't rate their food because they are either too stupid or too cheap to send utensil! I'm staying in a hotel for God's sake\nI guess my recommendation for catfish would be Knob Hill Tavern because…

can't rate their food because they are either too stupid or too cheap to send utensil! I'm staying in a hotel for God's sake\nI guess my recommendation for catfish would be Knob Hill Tavern becau…

can't rate their food because they are either too stupid or too cheap to send utensil! I'm staying in a hotel for God's sake\nI guess my recommendation for catfish would be Knob Hill Tavern because…

Very overpriced for just ordinary food nothing special about the food. I definitely wouldn't be back $50 for fish sandwich with fries, boiled shrimp, and chicken fingers this place won't be around …

The food was bad tasting and greasy The service was not at all friendly. My wife and I agreed that the price for the food was higher than the quality warranted.

The food and the service was terrible from beginning to end. The person I went with felt the same way. I ordered the crab cakes that had nothing but breading and onion in them. My friend ordered th…

I decided to try this place based on the reviews, but unfortunately, my family and I were pretty disappointed. Before leaving, we ordered the sweet potato crumble for $6.50. The bag felt weirdly light, but we didn’t think much of it until we got home and it turned out to be a complete slap in the house. Honestly, the only highlight of our visit was our server, who was absolutely wonderful.