Had my daughter’s birthday party here after a gymnastics meet. Trish was so accommodating with our timing and making sure the food was made fresh for us when we arrived. The staff was on point and kept up with our large crowd of 35, which included around 20 kids. The food was amazing, enjoyed by both kids and parents! Shout out to Casey who tended to the parents! Highly recommend.

Lisa K

I’m from the Bronx & my husband is from Jersey. We know good pizza 😉. We’ve tried so many pizza places around here & this place makes the best pizza in the area, hands down. The staff is so nice & accommodating & Tommy makes the pies! Just look at this picture! Go there!

David

We just recently stumbled upon Rookies and i can say hands down its the best pizza and food in general in all upstate. Especially the garlic knots! The staff and owners are so friendly! We have our go to spot now! Rookies has my U.S Army Veteran seal of approval for sure! 🇺🇸 🫡

Nick M

My family and I were an hour from home and stopped here to eat. The staffed recommended the Chicken Francese along with penne vodka and the pizza. We got the Francese, penne Alfredo and pizza. I’ve gotta say this was the best Francese I’ve had in years! I’d gladly make the drive and come back to eat here!

Francis Barber

Food was amazing. Service was great. Definitely a great place to eat

Courtney Salerno

Pizza was DELISH!! Food was hot, service was prompt and very polite.

Robert Frasco

We threw a big family BBQ at the house and decided to have it catered. We ordered a lot of food and picked it up at the restaurant. They were ready for us as soon as we got there with a great welcoming attitude and even helped us load the car. The food was great everyone asked where we got it from. Well packaged and nice and hot. We will definately be back for dinner soon

Katy Bugge

We accidentally came across this pizza place a couple of weeks ago on our way home from my knee surgery in Manhattan, I got 2 margarita pizza slices and fell in love lol My personal opinion, but this is probably the best margarita pizza I've ever had in my life. I had a post-op appt today in Manhattan and decided to order a whole margarita pizza to bring home, just as good as the first time. Very kind and friendly staff also. Thank you! Well done! We will definitely be back to try more things.

Karen

My family and I were in the area and went here for pizza the other day and we were so delighted! It was Saturday night we didn't want to cook or go for a restaurant sit down meal. So pizza ticked all of the boxes to satisfy everyone. We got some appetizers, salads and pizza. We ended up staying and having our meal here, they have a bar and nice area to sit down. We will definitely be back! I recommend if you are looking for a great place to enjoy pizza and more with friends and family in the Florida, Goshen, Chester, Warwick area this is it!

Robb LoForese

Best tasting pizza in the area. Highly recommended. 👍