Brother’s Pizza

The best pizza I've ever had! I've been all over the country and to Italy ! I'll always come back to this town just for brother's pizza! The pizza taste healthy and you don't feel heavy after eating a whole pie! I love the salad and all of the fresh sandwiches!

We used to frequent Brothers Pizza when I was stationed at West Point 30+ years ago. To this day I have never had pizza that could compare to Brothers. I only wish they delivered to Illinois! God bless!

We have been to all the local pizza places and this is our favorite - nice thin crust and tasty sauce and cheese. My kids especially love getting slices to enjoy right in the shop.

Always consistent and accommodating to some of the newer trends if you ask specifically, for example a thin spread of ricotta before red sauce adds a luscious lasagna flavor, they we love! He and his wife are dedicated honorable people of little small talk and chit chat, unless you frequently visit the establishment. Two thumbs up! 👍👍

Bionic MiMi

This place has been here for just about it’s whole existence. The pizza is as consistent as consistent can be in every single possible way. The slices are just the best, just grab a few napkins if you’re a slice folder, TRUST ME, and wrap the end that’s in your palm! The price is fair and they have a clean quiet place to just sit and eat. My grandson and I love stopping in for lunch!

Franki Palermo

This pizza is out of this world. So delicious and so much care is put into every pie. The staff is also so friendly. I wish I knew they were this good sooner, I would have only been ordering from them.

mike mcnamara

Solid pizza.. great price too!

what time is it

best place for pizza around! authentic and delicious 😇😇 my favorite place in highland falls to grab a bite

G'Quan Graham

Very good pizza , was very pleased and will be back.price is very affordable

David Lewis

Great people, husband and wife that own it. They make the best Calzone also sausage and pepper with meatballs, Parmesan Fantastic. Love to support small business family owned.

Robert Pfister

We used to frequent Brothers Pizza when I was stationed at West Point 30+ years ago. To this day I have never had pizza that could compare to Brothers. I only wish they delivered to Illinois! God bless!

Michael Paruolo

Brothers Pizza is a true hidden gem that exceeds expectations on every level. Tucked away in a cozy corner of the Village, this unassuming pizzeria delivers an exceptional dining experience that leaves a lasting impression. Upon entering Brothers Pizza, you are immediately struck by the inviting aroma of freshly baked pizza and the friendly, welcoming atmosphere. The interior is unpretentious yet charming, with a distinct focus on creating a comfortable space for guests to enjoy their meal. Now, let's talk about the star of the show – the pizza. Brothers Pizza takes the art of pizza-making to new heights. Each pie is crafted with care and precision, using only the finest, freshest ingredients. The result? A perfect marriage of flavors, with a thin, crispy crust that provides the ideal base for an array of delectable toppings. Whether you're a fan of classic combinations or more adventurous flavor profiles, the menu offers something for every palate. Aside from the outstanding pizza, the menu also features a variety of other mouthwatering options, including savory appetizers, fresh salads, and indulgent desserts. The attention to detail and quality extends to every dish, ensuring a truly satisfying dining experience. Brothers Pizza is a must-visit for pizza enthusiasts and food lovers alike. With its dedication to quality, inviting ambiance, and top-notch service, this establishment has undoubtedly earned its reputation as a go-to destination for exceptional pizza. Whether you're dining in or grabbing a slice to go, Brothers Gourmet Pizza is sure to leave a lasting, delicious impression.

Karyn Smith-D

We have been to all the local pizza places and this is our favorite - nice thin crust and tasty sauce and cheese. My kids especially love getting slices to enjoy right in the shop.

Robert “The Vintage Car Show” Henriksen

the best pizza around orange county..closest thing to Brooklyn pizza . go there every time i'm working in the area ,, 2 slices thin and crispy ... 1 mushroom and 1 pepperoni

Nicole Toffler

The best pizza I've ever had! I've been all over the country and to Italy ! I'll always come back to this town just for brother's pizza! The pizza taste healthy and you don't feel heavy after eating a whole pie! I love the salad and all of the fresh sandwiches!

Phillip McSwain

Always consistent and accommodating to some of the newer trends if you ask specifically, for example a thin spread of ricotta before red sauce adds a luscious lasagna flavor, they we love! He and his wife are dedicated honorable people of little small talk and chit chat, unless you frequently visit the establishment. Two thumbs up! 👍👍

Good place to eat. Calzones are the best item on the menu. I'm not sure who the rob j guy is, but his 1* review is obviously fake. You will never get a calzone here that doesn't have an overabundance of sauce on the inside.

This is a pizza place that takes me back to the day when my friends & I would go grab some pizza & have a laugh. Fresh ingredients made simple. Hero's are awesome especially the sausage & peppers! Andy is Very friendly (once you get to know him) but mostly a quiet, soft spoken person. Not alot of money to eat, in fact It is the least expensive pizza in the area. And with its distinctive style, brothers will be here long after others will be gone!

Ron Bennett

Good place to eat. Calzones are the best item on the menu. I'm not sure who the rob j guy is, but his 1* review is obviously fake. You will never get a calzone here that doesn't have an overabundance of sauce on the inside.

Sean Mulqueen

This is a pizza place that takes me back to the day when my friends & I would go grab some pizza & have a laugh. Fresh ingredients made simple. Hero's are awesome especially the sausage & peppers! Andy is Very friendly (once you get to know him) but mostly a quiet, soft spoken person. Not alot of money to eat, in fact It is the least expensive pizza in the area. And with its distinctive style, brothers will be here long after others will be gone!

pizza is delicious NY style and very affordable, however, there was a piece of plastic wrap on our pizza (from when they rested the dough), the woman was very nice, however the older white man was giving me and my friend dirty looks the ENTIRE time, even when i looked at him back he would stare me down with a nasty look, we were nothing but respectful. pizza is good but maybe do takeout so you can avoid that creepy guy.

The mushrooms were ice cold. Gross!

Future Reflections

The mushrooms were ice cold. Gross!

Aiden Wasserman

pizza is delicious NY style and very affordable, however, there was a piece of plastic wrap on our pizza (from when they rested the dough), the woman was very nice, however the older white man was giving me and my friend dirty looks the ENTIRE time, even when i looked at him back he would stare me down with a nasty look, we were nothing but respectful. pizza is good but maybe do takeout so you can avoid that creepy guy.

Restaurant is falling apart. When I went, a/c was broken and made dining area very uncomfortable. Counter person was surly and rude, and not forthcoming with answers to my "first time here" questions. Left immediately!

The guy was very rude to my wife on the phone when asking about pizza specials. No take-out menu's, no online menu's. What a bunch of poop. They only take cash so they're living in the 19th century still. Pizza definitely not worth it. If you like their pizza then I must tell you that there's better out there and you haven't experienced true pizza. I come from Chicago where Pizza is important.

Walked in to order pizza. The two workers just glared at us for five minutes. Finally, we tried to order something and they said they were "really busy" and that it would be a while. So we just left.

Brian Maher

Restaurant is falling apart. When I went, a/c was broken and made dining area very uncomfortable. Counter person was surly and rude, and not forthcoming with answers to my "first time here" questions. Left immediately!

charlie russ

Walked in to order pizza. The two workers just glared at us for five minutes. Finally, we tried to order something and they said they were "really busy" and that it would be a while. So we just left.

Dale Barker

The guy was very rude to my wife on the phone when asking about pizza specials. No take-out menu's, no online menu's. What a bunch of poop. They only take cash so they're living in the 19th century still. Pizza definitely not worth it. If you like their pizza then I must tell you that there's better out there and you haven't experienced true pizza. I come from Chicago where Pizza is important.