Papa Smurf

Wife and I ordered the calzones. She had the "Best friend" in which she loved. I had the vegetarian one and it was delightful. The potato salad was great, the lady at the counter was very nice. We have the same disregard for mayo and miracle whip... lol. All around, it was great!

Andrea “Drea” O

My Calzone was soooo melty, meaty, cheesy, and warm. The cooler mountain nights had me shivering a bit, and this warmed me up nicely. The personal pizza ended up being $30 (yikes inflation). They had some arcade games, claw machines, and other vending machines in the back. They looked like fun, but I don’t carry change. Overall it’s a pretty standard pizza place with that arcade air of nostalgia from back in the day when I’d go for pizza and game nights with my family at the local pizzeria. I’ll visit again.

+1

Christina Espinoza

Delicious pizza & hot wings! The pizza sauce was so yummy and the hot wing chicken just melted off the bone!!

Marisa Ramirez

Lots of vegetarian options (salads, calzones, pizza, paninis). The "Veggie Cali-zone" was delicious and filling- deliciously doughy and comes with a side salad.

Zachar

Great food, great service and great location. The stuffed shells with ricotta cheese were excellent. Garlic bread is included, but it's toasted just a little too much. Overall a pleasant experience in the beautiful resort community of Idyllwild!

Candice Foy

Husband and I came up from Torrance for the weekend and stopped here for lunch. We very much enjoyed this pizza. Classic American style pizza. The crust had a very nice flavor and was cooked perfectly. No weird soggy bottom or anything. We built our own with traditional crust, traditional marinara, ham, pepperoni, bell pepper, mushroom and pineapple. Staff is lovely too. And a side of ranch of course!

Lisa A

I called for take out & the gal who answered was super nice! They have a good website with the menu so I was able to order easily. Food was ready right on time and it was DELICIOUS!! I got a vegetable grind sandwich- the bun was so good & the vegetables were fresh. The cookie was amazing too. The only slight critique is I thought the potato salad needed a little salt. Otherwise perfection. Next time I’ll need to try the pizza!

Dawnie

Their gluten free pizza was delicious. Really liked the flavor of their sauce. Ordered pepperoni, mushrooms, and cheese. At first it seemed like it was a lot of cheese, but it ended up being the perfect amount. Would definitely come here again if in the area.

Samantha Tham

Pizza was very delicious but honestly kinda pricey. 42$ for a personal and a medium pieces which was about 12 slices that felt kinda tiny. Really good quality tho, although wish that with that price the service would be faster

Cayanne Mcfarlane

Good experience. Stopped by after a long backpacking trip. Mixed salad was great, I never would have thought to combine a normal salad of pasta salad, but it was actually really refreshing and the flavors went together very well. We had their spin-off of the Hawaiian pizza with cashew and Ginger, wish there would have been more Ginger to the pizza or that it was baked in, there wasn't enough to cover the rest of the pizza, it was nice with the crunch of the cashew. Great customer service, good outdoor seating in the back, not a long wait, and did the job for post hike.

Ali Hajiahmad

Idyllwild Pizza Company offers a cozy atmosphere, delicious food, and excellent service. Their pizzas are made with fresh ingredients, featuring a crispy crust, rich sauces, and perfectly melted cheese. The menu also includes other tasty options worth trying. The staff is friendly and welcoming, making the experience even more enjoyable. Plus, the wide selection of craft beers adds a great touch to your meal. Overall, it’s a fantastic spot for a relaxing and flavorful dining experience. Highly recommended!

Gideon Tong

The pizza itself is okay, it's not super oily, and it has the right ingredients, but it doesn't really hit the spot for me. I would come back again mostly because there isn't really anything other than American food in Idyllwild, but it's definitely far from an amazing pizza spot. If this place was located in the city I would probably take off another star because their pizzas aren't exactly the cheapest either, but up in Idyllwild it's not too bad. The pizza was warm to the touch when I got it but not piping hot.

Shanelle S

Local pizza spot with beer and an arcade. Came here for lunch at 11:30am (right when they opened) and there was a short line already. Indoor and outdoor tables are available. Credit cards accepted but there’s a $5 minimum. We had a large Tahquitz Supreme pizza to share among four people and that was a good portion for everyone to get 2-3 slices each. They have salads and sandwiches for those who don’t want a heavy meal. This is good for large groups and for children. They have high chairs available. Water is self-service. There are restrooms behind the bar. You order at the counter and then they’ll call your name once the food is ready.

+2

Marisol Muñoz

The pizza is good. The pasta is average, but I definitely didn't like the wings; they're baked, not fried, and there's more skin than chicken, so you can imagine what it's like to eat them 🤢 The staff are friendly and the place is comfortable. But I would NEVER eat those wings again.