This place makes the best cauliflower crust pizza I’ve ever had.

Most people say that new York city has the best pizza but in my opinion I think this is one of the best pizzerias out there.

Great selection of hand tossed pizza with all the most popular flavors. Quick and easy. Fast and delicious.

When we first drove up to the restaurant you wouldn't think that amazing pizza comes out of here. Let me assure you that it most certainly does..

Never disappointed when my family and I go there for our order. Plus it's always delicious every time!

We order from 440 Frequently and we are never disappointed. We love their pizza and stromboli's.

Pizza never disappoints! I’ll travel 45 minutes just for this pizza . Best in Kingston !

They’re always nice and courteous! Their food is great! And they deliver quickly! I always use them!

Amazing pizza. Way better then Sami pizza. And the service at 440 is super fast and you don't wait forever like you do at Sami pizza. Amazing!!!!! :)

This place successfully converted me from a Chicago Style pizza fan to a New York Style fan! Great Pizza!

Great pizza was working in the area and I'm fr NJ AND THIS PIZZA IS 🔥 . REAL NY PIZZA TASTY LIL SALT IN SAUCE DELICIOUS

They made me two slices of sausage quick!

The white pizza is dynamite! Cheap and yummy, nice people at the counter.

The food is always good. The sticky wings are really good!

Amazing pizza and staff go there at least once a week. Good luck guys.

Me and my brother always get pizza from here.. The garlic knots are the best!

Great wings. Great pizza. Javier and the crew are good guys.

Food was great. I had meat lovers and TACO pizza. Sammi had mac & cheese and buffalo chicken pizza. It was very good. Thank you

The sticky and the lemon pepper wings are incredible. The lemon pepper is a dry rub but would be great as a sauce, they should look into that. They cook their wings crispy which I like. Tried the garlic knots the other night and they were....ok. But I'll keep going back for the wings.

ISO a thin crust pizza? Look no further! Yummy mushroom pie, lots of cheese and perfectly thin crust. Price is good too and service is quick.

I've enjoyed the different daily specials over the years here because they are a great deal and are DELISH. I love the stromboli and order it with mushrooms and spinachs and/or olives. But then, today, 440 really delivered! We had 10 pizzas for a big event and wow! Magnificent! The veggie pies were especially enjoyable. The red sauce that comes with the garlic bread is also better than most. Bravo!

Was recommended to me. I travel for a living, always asking what place has great new york style pizza. Very rare to find a great new york. Get some!

440 Pizza is the best in town. They make so much pizza all day and night, they got it down to a science. Big, floppy slices, baked to perfection. And garlic! Love that. Try their brownies, too.

My boyfriend and I come here every week on our cheat day. The pizza is so crispy, fresh out of the oven soft every time we go! The staff is always very warm and welcoming! If you want New York, NY pizza... this is where to go !

They don’t kid around when you ask for their Meat Lover’s pizza. It sure was meat heavy and I loved it! Not greasy at all! They deliver fast and their prices are amazing for such huge pies. It’s okay if you can’t finish it because it’s still gonna be as good for breakfast. 😉

I was in NY visiting my family, all the way from California. So glad I did, I was able to attend opening weekend at 440 Pizzeria. Such a great atmosphere, polite friendly staff, clean inviting restaurant, and the pizza was delicious!!!! I grew up in NY, but we moved to California and I haven't been able to find a good pizza place where I live. So glad I was able to eat at 440 Pizzeria. They don't pretend to be any other pizza place then who they are!!! Great job, wish you the best of luck, and the next time I'm in NY you better believe I'll be stopping by!!!

Great customer service and even if it isn't on the menu they will still work with you like they do with me, if I could give them a better rating I would. They also offer two medium 1 normal topping pizzas, garlic sticks, 10 wings, and a 2-liter bottle of soda for $25 before taxes and they call it the family deal, you can't beat a deal like that in these hard times

Definitely mine and my family’s go to for dinner food is good prices are great and the staff is always friendly and polite I definitely recommend 440 pizza!

Great Pizza! Amongst some of my absolute favorite NY style pizza. Crisp crust, tart and flavorful sauce, good toppings. Will keep coming back for sure!

Service was excellent made the perfect pizza for us thin and crispy is what I ordered and what I got. Service was accommodating and pleasant. No hesitation giving it 5 stars

Been going here for years despite the 20 minute drive from my house. Their buffalo chicken pizza is to die for and their employees and the owner are some of the nicest people. Great wings too!

Plain and simple. This little gem quickly became my FAVORITE Pizza place so much that I travel almst abt 45 mins from another town to get it. Everything I've taste on the menu has been my delicious but My favorite remains the Buffalo chicken Pizza w/ blue cheese. If ever your in the midtown Kingston area and you have a taste for some damn good Pizza stop by 440 Broadway tell them I sent ya. You won't regret it.

My favorite place to go in the Kingston-Woodstock area for take-out pizza slices. Nice crust, and they are generous with their cheese.

The was great but I was in there a couple days ago to get 2 slices of pizza and there was only one person there also waiting and I wasnt even noticed by any of the works but I do want to stay this they have really really good food Ive been going there ever it switched to 440 from Sammys

We got in from out of state and this was the first place we called for a late night AirBnB dinner. The Pizza was amazing! I got a side ceaser salad that had the most delicious home made dressing , but the best part was the canolies, I feel like I can never go back to Utah now and order a canolie because it will never measure up.

Great slice and many to choose from. Nice people who are on it. My favorite place in the Hudson valley so far.

The best pickup/delivery pie in Kingston, and I’ve tried all 20+ in the area. New York style, thinnish base crust, thicker puffy circumference crust. Perfect slight undercook with base char. So consistent. Staff hustles hard like a real pizzeria..Great ingredients, classic NYC flavor, just enough grease to make you feel alive. 440 every other week is what America is all about.

James Whalen

Order the garlic knots there the best ever

L G24

Was up there on the during my vacation got in pretty late was the one place that was still open and their pizza was amazing and I am from New York City and they have very very very good pizza

Samantha Yost

My favorite pizza in the area. I'm a vegetarian and their veggie and margherita pizzas are really good. I am used to other places' soggy afterthought veg pies, but 440's is really flavorful with a good texture and balance of ingredients.

holly raskoskie

So pizza and wings are fantastic. The paninis are good. The roast beef sub just take it off the menu. The beef is brown I literally got two thick slices on a sub. By the time I folded the meat up I barely got a quarter of a sub. Disappointed.

wesley schunk

440 knocked it out of the park again with their quintessential NY pie. I immediately seek out this place as soon as I arrive from TN to visit my family because I know they will have exactly that pizza I wish I could find at home. Staff always treats us as family and cooks their food with pride. Keep it up guys.

L B-H

Wonderful tender tasty pizza crust with perfect amount of cheese and sauce on the pizza. Guys behind the counter are really nice. Small spot to sit in can get clogged with kids from school across the street, but relatively manageable. I love their mushroom pizza because they use canned mushrooms (I know, not a popular choice but it's what I like). I bought a pie to bring home with me when I left Kingston this weekend... It's that good.

Kelly Dautrich

This place is quintessential Kingston! Order by the pie or by the slice. I highly recommend the buffalo chicken pizza, the BBQ chicken pizza, the chicken bacon ranch pizza, the white pizza, as well as all your standard pizza offerings. I also recommend the garlic knots, the wings, the fried dough, and the salads (always get the blue cheese dressing, it’s great!)

Honest Opinion

Best Pizza in Kingston area! Lots of cheese, greasy and sinfully tasty. If you like pizza there old school NY style this place is authentic.

Wesley Schunk

Quintessential New York pizza. Came from Tn visiting my brother back in the summer and got talking about the place and I remembered I never got around to showing some love. This is exactly what I'm looking for when I come to visit.

Love this place. Best pizza. Great people who work there too. Very accommodating.

Fast friendly service. All food: fresh spinach mozzarella avocado chicken salad; pizza; wings; fried... all good.

This place is always good. Fried dough, amazing as well as the rest of the menu.

Best wings around

Great pizza ..wide selection of types..buffalo chicken and garlic knots to die for

Good service pizaa need a little more sauce. But good pizza overall.

Only place around you can still get wings for less than a dollar each and they’re delicious. The pizza ironically is the worst thing about the place. Not very consistent ranging from pretty good to questionable but never inedible. The rest of the menu more than makes up for it though.

I gave 5 stars in the 440 beginnings. Now the quality and service is falling short. Very sad. I struggled to give 3 stars. Last time I went my order was misunderstood I guess. No apology from staff and made me feel like it was my fault. New places are opening in Kingston so bring it back 440. I gave them another chance and wasn't disappointed. Fantastic. I've been back several times now.

Chany Mose

I love 440 but for some reason my wings are never right. Even after they assured me they are. I trust them so I never open it up before I go to check and then I get home and I’m disappointed. I asked for extra crispy extra wet sticky wings and they are always dry. I walk there so walking back to correct an order when I’m hungry doesn’t seem logical.

Geovanny

Interesting pizza options, plenty of parking. Cannoli was good too! Credit cards accepted.

Marilyn

The pizza was very good. I had stop coming here because it had went down during covid. I highly recommended now

Caitlin King

It was my first time here and what we had was very good. A few different kinds of slices (pepperoni, brocolli/bacon/cheese, and mushroom) and fried ravioli. Want to try the subs next time. Menu had a variety of pizzas, subs, and pastas. They also cater and have a family pizza deal.

Samantha Brewster

My favorite pizza place in Kingston. Sweet staff, nice crunchy pizza, the best garlic knots in town, crunchy on the outside and fluffy on the inside. Can be a bit on the pricey side.

Decent pizza, not somthing I'd go out of my way for. But passing through it worked.

My ordered food and it took an hour and a 1/2 to get delivered. And when it got delivered, it was cold and grease was all through the bags it never again.

Ordered at 7:35 and came at 9:29pm I was told the time the wait would be 45min so tried to give them the benefit of the doubt. The appetizer I got was still a bit warm but the pizza I had to put back in my oven to warm it up the delivery guy did apologize. Food tasted good but if you are going to get food from them I would suggest picking it up yourself

I just ordered and they said 45 min took over hour and pizza was cold and looked funny. And the wings was hard n cold. My daughter called and complained and they did send out a new order and omg you can see a huge difference. The cheese didn't look old the first one looked like it had been sitting awhile. And the wings was decent looking and not hard. Only complaint is they don't use no seasoning the wings had no taste at all. But I'm writing this not for the quality of they food but more so to shout out they customer service in correcting the problem. They did want the food back from first order. When the guy came he said his box said keep the pizza but give the wings back. Which I don't get. But whatever.

called up after receiving our pizza because the consistency of the cheese was very strange. took a while on the phone to find out that someone training. I just wish the quality was checked before it went out the door. also, my lips are tingling from our 'mild' wings.

Ordered family special to go as a pickup. Pizzas were ok, wings were all burnt, and bad. Garlic bread was soso. Price wise still the best deal around. Hopefully it was just an odd night for them

Be careful paying with a card here.i had a $3 tip added to my $5.88 slice w/pepsi. I was debating filing a police report but since it is Thanksgiving I will look at it as a forced donation to the clearly needy individual that did this. The guy that rang me up is white and looks younger maybe in his twenties with dark hair and a beard, I’d imagine it was him and I’m sure he will do it again in the future.I’m not a cheap tipper but idk what this world has come to if an employee expects a tip on a pick up order, let alone a 60% tip on a slice of pizza!!

Good food but I noticed they have a tendency to forget dressings. I ordered extra blue cheese on four separate occasions and received none. Definitely an issue they need to address bc if it happens again I'll go elsewhere. I understand mistakes but this is repetitive! Good food though

Not impressed. Way too much cheese and not enough sauce. I got a medium pie delivered to me and the delivery driver didn’t have any change?! I had a $20 and all he had was a $10 to offer me or quarters. I worked at a pizza place and know that as a driver you should ALWAYS have change at least for a $20 minus the order The bigger than usual tip wouldn’t have bothered me so much if the pizza didn’t taste like a mediocre frozen pizza. Will not be ordering from here again

Delivery is AWFUL. Always takes over an hour and a half to get food through delivery. Ordered 2 subs at 5:50 and still don’t have them at 7:25. Pizza is pretty good but not worth the wait. If you’re gonna get it, order take out.

Ordered 1 large pizza and a 2 liter. 7:30. 9:15 finally getting my pizza. Not cut, Cold. Pizza taste good that’s what the second star is for. Disappointed in service. On a Monday to!

Kayla Araujo

I like the pizza there. I always get the baked ziti slice, however, today I called like normal and was answered by a rude kid. He was treating me some sort of way because I asked him if they had the big ziti slice considering I wasn't there and couldn't see for myself. I've ordered from here multiple times and I've never had that kind of disrespect before. You can just tell he was pissed and didn't even want to take the order, talking to me like I'm dumb or something. The food is good but will not be going back due to this.

thomas savaglio

I want to give this place more stars...however they are sacrificing quality for quantity. Canned mushrooms still wet. Meat lovers was a disappointment. PROS: -Good for highschoolers -family deal -Great Garlic Knots! CONS: -Quality (soggy, flavorless) -Small restaurant

Don't serve pizza with burnt crust. Also, Margarita pizza has FRESH basil and not to be put in the oven...put on after it's out.

Placed a order at 5:53pm showed up at 7:30 pm told it would be 45 mins to a hour which was fine order showed everything was ice cold got fried oreos and fried dough all of it was soggy

Use to eat pizza here everyday but started getting worse & worse everytime. They come way later than what they tell you and the pizza is never hot it’s always lukewarm.

Not spam, pizza pie was sub par. Will have to try again for second opinion.

Horrible worst thing I ever ate They put pre cooked sausage crumbles and canned mushrooms on a already cooked pizza When I picked up a slice the toppings mostly all fell off Crust was too thick not enough sauce rubber cheese Do not recommend

🤦🏻‍♀️🤦🏻‍♀️🤦🏻‍♀️

Waited almost two hours for a sub, soda, and two slices of pizza. The person who answered the phone wasn’t Apologetic rather he was rude and condescending.

The worse service and very rude employees 90 min wait time for a pizza I’ll never go there order or recommend anyone order from them

My family called in an order at 6:30pm for our dinner and were told it would be an hour. After waiting for over 2 hours and calling once to check on the status, we asked them to cancel it altogether. It was close to 9pm by the time we gave up on 440's delivery and had to find somewhere else still open. Slice of Italy welcomed our family and made sure we were well taken care of. The food was fantastic and we were treated like family.

One of the most terrible pizzas I ever had. Bottom burnt, delivery took one hour and forty minutes ( and I live 11 houses away) never again, and it was cold. Pizza was promised in 45. My regular place was closed. They should buy a quick stop gas station.

Placed order ar 6:02pm, got it at 8:23pm, after being told an hour wait which i was perfectly fine with. Everything was ice cold. I dont suggest you let your driver take 4 deliveries at once like your worker told us when we called to see where our order was.

Ordered dinner on Friday night and it took 2 hours for the food to be delivered. The pizza was made incorrectly, the onion rings were very greasy, mashed up in a paper bag and tasted like the oil they were cooked in was old.

If I can give them a 0, I would . I ordered last week from there over 2 hrs delivery for a 1 pizza .. then I ordered from there yesterday. I picked my food up . I asked for pene ala vodka I got noodles with red sauce .. last time I order from there. They lost my Bussiness

Very poor service. Flat out ignored while other customers were serviced. However, I don’t view it as a loss. I received a better pizza from the Red Barron.

Dove

Edit: The shop responded defensively, calling this a fake review. I assure you I'm a real person with over a million views on Google Reviews. I had hoped they would take the criticism and improve their pizza, but that doesn't seem to be happening. Sorry. This was one of the worst slices I've ever had. I waited a week to write this. It's my easy for me to write bad reviews. I hate doing it. But this pizza was really really bad. If the shop changes their recipe and changes their pizza, and then comments to me that they did this, I will remove this review. But they have to change it up. It was horrible. They should go down the block to the slice shop and see how they do it. I'm writing this because this place has to change. Sorry.

Katriana Vitthuhn

We decided to try this place out as a change from our usual local haunts for delivery. Disappointing. Delivery that was promised in the normal 45 min to 1 hour came 1.5 + hours later. Our order of penne ala vodka with chicken arrived without chicken and the "vodka sauce" was simply marinara sauce with ricotta cheese blended in. My husband's chicken parmesan sub was just ok. The chicken on the sub was not a cutlet even. It was chopped chicken breast. Called to ask where our order was after more than an hour. At first were told "he just left. He'll be there momentarily". Waited 25 + more minutes. Finally our order arrives. Take note this was a Monday night. Not the weekend. Then called to let them know the order was wrong. They argued with me, put me on hold to "speak to the guy in the kitchen" and then offered to send a "new one". I denied the offer because I didn't want to wait another hour and a half plus for chicken. We will see if they refund the missing chicken from my pasta which was an up charge. Never again.

Robert Teel

Pizza is to greasy I can fill a shot glass with all the grease that drips off. 440 responded with " that's funny we have been voted the least greasy" then they blocked. No matter. Pizza wasn't that good to me.

John Dago

Without a doubt the worst pizza I've ever had I could taste the freezer burn on the toppings and that's about it. There was a strange film over the top . No sauce to speak of no flavor I've had better frozen pizzas and for 20 bucks I would have been better off picking up a Red Baron at the Dollar general and having $18 left over. I never give reviews or feedback but this was just awful sorry to say I'll probably be off Pizza in general for the next 3 months.