The Gallery Four Italian Restaurant

Imagine getting to go back to your grandma's house for an authentic Italian dinner. Well, that's Gallery 4. Fantastic. Love coming here, the best clam sauce, hands down!

Catered Christmas Chicken.... so good!!. Entire family loved it. Its as authentic Italian as you are going to get. Thank you Tom and family.

A nice family owned business, the food is excellent my personal favorite the stuffed mushrooms and shrimp parm, very reasonably priced for the quality of food

Great food. Great atmosphere. Our waitress Patrice was friendly, professional and attentive. Can't wait to go back.

So worth my hour ride! The food is out of this world!! Such an amazing and welcoming family!! We make it a special outing everytime!

Good food at very reasonable prices. Great location and professional, considerate staff. No reasonable request ever refused

A true five star Italian experience, always. The owner and his family are incredibly kind, the food is scrumptious, and they have the best garlic knots in the world. Been coming here since I was a kid and each time I am so glad to provide my patronage to The Gallery Four. Highly highly recommended to all.

The place really brings me back to the pizzerias from my childhood. I order one regular slice $2.50 … the slice was smaller than I expected however although it wasn’t anything special it was your classic tasty traditional NY slice. Good ingredients and the (I’m assuming) the owner behind the counter had a friendly conversation with me which was appreciated and bumped this from 4 to 5 stars bc of the friendly service.

Good people running this place. Chicken parm was good. NOT the best but quite good. The only issue was the bread, which was a bit like ones you get in a good supermarket & NOT as good as you would get from a traditional baker. Still, I lived in SI where it's just a bit more Guidoville (my former neighbor's description). Price is excellent for LI. Would I like better bread at higher price? Not really, but would be nice to give an option to customers (just a minor suggestion).

We recently moved to Lynbrook and Gallery Four is one of our favorite restaurants for take-out. We order frequently. Our meal comes with salad and bread. Their food is delicious, fresh, and affordable. We have ordered chicken francese, lasagna, chicken parm, penne alla vodka, and garlic knots. Will continue ordering from them and trying new meals. 🙂

Fantastic place to get Italian food you got parking right outside its metered parking but long-term don't have to rush bathrooms are clean the service is great and the prices are fair

Recently used Tommy and the Gallery Four to cater a party. Like always, the food was excellent. Guests were raving about the eggplant parmigiana and shrimp francaise. The Gallery Four is an old school multi-generational Italian Restaurant where you are always greeted by an owner at the front counter, and the food never disappoints!

Its a rare thing when one leaves a restaurant completely satisfied but that's exactly what happened when we went to Gallery IV earlier tonight. I had the baked ziti and my wife had the lasagna both were excellent. Our server, and frankly everyone who worked at the restaurant was warm and friendly (I mean EXTREMELY nice). It had a real family atmosphere which we appreciated. The price (and value) were both excellent, worth every penny, if anything our meal was underpriced per the quality. Anyone reading this review should check this place out, it will not disappoint.

Gallery 4 is amazing gem in Lynbrook. The gravy is just right. It’s real home cokking. Our favorite is veal sorrentino but everything is excellent. Tom and the rest of the crew are nice peeps. They always pack the take out with precision!

Gallery Four is great! Very hospitable, the owner and staff is very friendly. Their regular pizza is amazing, sauce is delicious! One of the biggest hidden gems on Long Island

The food is phenomenal! Everything is made fresh. The people who work there are all super friendly and treat you like family. My favorite place to enjoy delicious Italian food!!

First time in the Gallery Four and definitely will not be our last. We saw the good reviews and decided to give it a try. We were immediately sat down. The service was wonderful, so friendly. The warm bread is delicious, fried calamari was some of the best we’ve had- very light and fresh. We had the chicken parm platter and clams, mussels and shrimp over pasta. Delicious. Portions are generous and pricing is extremely fair. The cannoli for dessert was fresh and really good as well. The restaurant has a very vintage feel, it was nice and cozy and clean. Lots of families and couples. We’re so happy to have found this restaurant for excellent italian cuisine and will definitely be back.

Gallery four is a family run business that still has old restaurant values with high quality ingredients hand made fresh dishes …. It’s not fancy but the food and service is the absolute best you will get !!! I highly recommend trying it you will not be disappointed!!! Mike and his family are definitely going to take care of you like you are a part of the family !! Pizzas are all made with fresh pizza dough pasta dishes are the best authenticity made with the right ingredients they have the best giant warm chocolate chip cookies fresh out of the pizza oven !!!

Prices are a steal for the quantity and quality of the food!! Personally Their sauce is one of my favorites. Garlic bread is delishes! Every meal comes with salad and a side of pasta you won't leave hungry. Chicken Parm is my favorite here and my wife gets the veal scaloppine sorrentino and raves about it. If you haven't tried this hidden gem you should!!

Voted Best Pizza on Long Island. True Italian spot working hard to make his pizza as authentic as he can while making it affordable. The regular slice is incredible. Add fresh garlic (if you like garlic) or any other topping you prefer for an additional dollar, let them warm it up for you and make it crispy, and you're in a good place. To top it off, the staff is very friendly and genuine.

Reading the reviews of this place lead me to believe this was an acclaim pizza spot in Lynbrook, so I checked them out. Regular cheese slice and pepperoni. They didn't have much of a selection, the only thing on display were the pepperoni and and spinach pin wheels, along with chicken rolls. The pies were tucked away behind the counter. This is a "cheese" lovers pizza spot. They're very generous on the cheese. Almost as if I asked for extra cheese, didn't disappoint at all, it wasn't sliding off the slice either. The sauce was pretty good ,not Amazing but it went well on a slightly charred dough, sadly not a fan of the crust a little tough. Pepperoni slice was also generously covered , crust same situation. Good pizza friendly service.

I have been going here since I was a child. My staple used to be mussels marinara but had the stuffed chicken tonight. Both are delicious! Staff is always very friendly.

Danielle Lawson

The food is phenomenal! Everything is made fresh. The people who work there are all super friendly and treat you like family. My favorite place to enjoy delicious Italian food!!

Angela C

First time in the Gallery Four and definitely will not be our last. We saw the good reviews and decided to give it a try. We were immediately sat down. The service was wonderful, so friendly. The warm bread is delicious, fried calamari was some of the best we’ve had- very light and fresh. We had the chicken parm platter and clams, mussels and shrimp over pasta. Delicious. Portions are generous and pricing is extremely fair. The cannoli for dessert was fresh and really good as well. The restaurant has a very vintage feel, it was nice and cozy and clean. Lots of families and couples. We’re so happy to have found this restaurant for excellent italian cuisine and will definitely be back.

Beth Englert

Gallery four is a family run business that still has old restaurant values with high quality ingredients hand made fresh dishes …. It’s not fancy but the food and service is the absolute best you will get !!! I highly recommend trying it you will not be disappointed!!! Mike and his family are definitely going to take care of you like you are a part of the family !! Pizzas are all made with fresh pizza dough pasta dishes are the best authenticity made with the right ingredients they have the best giant warm chocolate chip cookies fresh out of the pizza oven !!!

nick shakespeare

Prices are a steal for the quantity and quality of the food!! Personally Their sauce is one of my favorites. Garlic bread is delishes! Every meal comes with salad and a side of pasta you won't leave hungry. Chicken Parm is my favorite here and my wife gets the veal scaloppine sorrentino and raves about it. If you haven't tried this hidden gem you should!!

J

Voted Best Pizza on Long Island. True Italian spot working hard to make his pizza as authentic as he can while making it affordable. The regular slice is incredible. Add fresh garlic (if you like garlic) or any other topping you prefer for an additional dollar, let them warm it up for you and make it crispy, and you're in a good place. To top it off, the staff is very friendly and genuine.

Miguel Cruz

Reading the reviews of this place lead me to believe this was an acclaim pizza spot in Lynbrook, so I checked them out. Regular cheese slice and pepperoni. They didn't have much of a selection, the only thing on display were the pepperoni and and spinach pin wheels, along with chicken rolls. The pies were tucked away behind the counter. This is a "cheese" lovers pizza spot. They're very generous on the cheese. Almost as if I asked for extra cheese, didn't disappoint at all, it wasn't sliding off the slice either. The sauce was pretty good ,not Amazing but it went well on a slightly charred dough, sadly not a fan of the crust a little tough. Pepperoni slice was also generously covered , crust same situation. Good pizza friendly service.

Anna Klatt

I have been going here since I was a child. My staple used to be mussels marinara but had the stuffed chicken tonight. Both are delicious! Staff is always very friendly.

Laura Casanueva

Not just the best pizza around, the best pizza ever!!! Best restaurant, best employees, can’t say anything negative!!

Went here on a whim, and it was fantastic. To start off, the staff inside is very friendly. The waitress was very attentive and kind. Inside reminds me of an old-school Italian spot that used to be in Brooklyn, as does the food. Needless to say everything exceeded my expectations, which were already high basing them on previous reviews. Definitely will be returning.

Great food....still. Not sure if they're serving in the dining room yet but I'm waiting for it. Great service, great prices and great people work there. I know they've been a fixture in Lynbrook for many years and that they're a family owned business that I want to keep here for many more years. For great Italian food, even when you have to get it to go...please patronize The Gallery Four. You won't be sorry. 🍴🍷🍝🍕🏅🇮🇹

I good family owned, old school, Italian restaurant/pizzeria with the back room, red & white checkered table clothes that we associate with good Italian food. Sauce, Meatballs, Sausage, Chicken Parm are always excellent with your choice of pasta! I have never had a bad meal here. Always leave full and happy! Good hospitality & good eats!

The Gallery Four has been my go-to new pizza place for the last several months. We ordered several pizzas for a movie night party that we hosted. The pizza was a hit with all of our guests as they asked where we ordered from. The pizza and service are consistently great. I ordered five pizzas and someone on staff offered to help bring some to my car and put them in my trunk which was really nice and unexpected.The crust, sauce and cheese are consistent. When I order from them, I'm confident that what I am getting with.

One of my favorite restaurants old school Italian food ! If the gallery was in Manhattan it would be like rayos impossible to get a table. They make you feel like family whey dinning at the gallery! I had mancotii it was like being at a Sunday dinner at my grandma's home ! Highly recommend!!!

Family owned and run. Serving the community for half a century. Nostalgic peg boards and signs reminds me of the golden years of NY pizza. Full dining room for parties or Sunday dinner. Classic Italian American dishes. Great eggplant parm. Great chicken parm. Excellent pizza. Great bang for your buck, 90s prices basically. I would definitely recommend if your in the Lynbrook area and support a local family owned institution.

A hidden gem. Excellent food at fair prices!

I recently had the pleasure of dining at Gallery Four Pizzeria in Lynbrook, and I must say that it was an exceptional experience. The ambiance was cozy and inviting, with a charming gallery-like decor that added a unique touch to the overall atmosphere. However, what truly stood out to me was the quality of their food, particularly their chopped baked clams. Let me start by saying that I am a seafood enthusiast, and I have tried chopped baked clams at numerous restaurants. The version served at Gallery Four Pizzeria, though, surpassed my expectations. The clams were incredibly fresh and cooked to perfection. Each bite was a burst of flavors, blending the delicate taste of clams with a savory mix of herbs, breadcrumbs, and seasonings. What I loved most about Gallery Four's chopped baked clams was the balance of textures. The clams were finely chopped, allowing for a more even distribution of flavors. The breadcrumbs provided a delightful crunch while still maintaining a moist and tender interior. It was evident that the dish was made with great care and attention to detail. Furthermore, the presentation of the chopped baked clams was visually appealing. Served in individual shells, they were beautifully arranged and garnished with fresh parsley, adding a touch of vibrancy to the dish. The portion size was generous, ensuring that I was satisfied without feeling overwhelmed. The service at Gallery Four Pizzeria was also commendable. The staff was attentive, friendly, and knowledgeable about the menu. They were more than happy to answer any questions I had and provide recommendations based on my preferences. The overall dining experience was seamless and enjoyable. While Gallery Four Pizzeria offers a variety of delectable dishes, including their renowned pizzas, it is their chopped baked clams that truly stole the show for me. If you are a seafood lover like myself, I highly recommend giving them a try. The combination of fresh ingredients, skillful preparation, and exceptional flavors make Gallery Four's chopped baked clams a standout dish that is worth savoring.

Amazing food here! Chicken parm was cooked to PERFECTION! I also know the owner for when I was in high school. Tom. Amazing guy! Love coming here.

Justin Restifo

A hidden gem. Excellent food at fair prices!

Michael Dombek

One of my favorite restaurants old school Italian food ! If the gallery was in Manhattan it would be like rayos impossible to get a table. They make you feel like family whey dinning at the gallery! I had mancotii it was like being at a Sunday dinner at my grandma's home ! Highly recommend!!!

Brian Gonzalez

The Gallery Four has been my go-to new pizza place for the last several months. We ordered several pizzas for a movie night party that we hosted. The pizza was a hit with all of our guests as they asked where we ordered from. The pizza and service are consistently great. I ordered five pizzas and someone on staff offered to help bring some to my car and put them in my trunk which was really nice and unexpected.The crust, sauce and cheese are consistent. When I order from them, I'm confident that what I am getting with.

James Rando

Family owned and run. Serving the community for half a century. Nostalgic peg boards and signs reminds me of the golden years of NY pizza. Full dining room for parties or Sunday dinner. Classic Italian American dishes. Great eggplant parm. Great chicken parm. Excellent pizza. Great bang for your buck, 90s prices basically. I would definitely recommend if your in the Lynbrook area and support a local family owned institution.

Big ROD

I good family owned, old school, Italian restaurant/pizzeria with the back room, red & white checkered table clothes that we associate with good Italian food. Sauce, Meatballs, Sausage, Chicken Parm are always excellent with your choice of pasta! I have never had a bad meal here. Always leave full and happy! Good hospitality & good eats!

HEADIE EDDIE'S

I recently had the pleasure of dining at Gallery Four Pizzeria in Lynbrook, and I must say that it was an exceptional experience. The ambiance was cozy and inviting, with a charming gallery-like decor that added a unique touch to the overall atmosphere. However, what truly stood out to me was the quality of their food, particularly their chopped baked clams. Let me start by saying that I am a seafood enthusiast, and I have tried chopped baked clams at numerous restaurants. The version served at Gallery Four Pizzeria, though, surpassed my expectations. The clams were incredibly fresh and cooked to perfection. Each bite was a burst of flavors, blending the delicate taste of clams with a savory mix of herbs, breadcrumbs, and seasonings. What I loved most about Gallery Four's chopped baked clams was the balance of textures. The clams were finely chopped, allowing for a more even distribution of flavors. The breadcrumbs provided a delightful crunch while still maintaining a moist and tender interior. It was evident that the dish was made with great care and attention to detail. Furthermore, the presentation of the chopped baked clams was visually appealing. Served in individual shells, they were beautifully arranged and garnished with fresh parsley, adding a touch of vibrancy to the dish. The portion size was generous, ensuring that I was satisfied without feeling overwhelmed. The service at Gallery Four Pizzeria was also commendable. The staff was attentive, friendly, and knowledgeable about the menu. They were more than happy to answer any questions I had and provide recommendations based on my preferences. The overall dining experience was seamless and enjoyable. While Gallery Four Pizzeria offers a variety of delectable dishes, including their renowned pizzas, it is their chopped baked clams that truly stole the show for me. If you are a seafood lover like myself, I highly recommend giving them a try. The combination of fresh ingredients, skillful preparation, and exceptional flavors make Gallery Four's chopped baked clams a standout dish that is worth savoring.

Mike Migdal

Went here on a whim, and it was fantastic. To start off, the staff inside is very friendly. The waitress was very attentive and kind. Inside reminds me of an old-school Italian spot that used to be in Brooklyn, as does the food. Needless to say everything exceeded my expectations, which were already high basing them on previous reviews. Definitely will be returning.

Robin

Great food....still. Not sure if they're serving in the dining room yet but I'm waiting for it. Great service, great prices and great people work there. I know they've been a fixture in Lynbrook for many years and that they're a family owned business that I want to keep here for many more years. For great Italian food, even when you have to get it to go...please patronize The Gallery Four. You won't be sorry. 🍴🍷🍝🍕🏅🇮🇹

Was with a group of 10 so a wide variety of dishes and appetizers were ordered. Everyone seemed happy. Additionally service was good, had very friendly staff. Would go back.

Good Italian restaurant. There is a three page menu, which includes heroes, pasta, entrees, special lunches and dinners, pizza, and sides. I ordered the chicken Francaise. It was delicious, with a side of ziti with marina sauce. The dinners come with a side mixed salad. There is a full bar. The staff is very friendly. Prices are reasonable. They close early.

Food is cooked just for you,not laying around. I tell everyone I know about the Gallery. I give gift certificates to my family and tell them how goog it is. Try the calamari. Delicious. I went to Vincent's in garden city and I almost puked it tasted like it was fried and refried. It was so gross that me and my friend sent it back. Give me the Gallery four in lynbrook. You won't be disappointed. I hope someone takes me there for my birthday in December.

Food was fresh delicious. Portions were a good size. Staff was friendly and knowledgeable. Family run establishment. Wine list is not the greatest with not many options. Entire restaurant is on one level with no stairs. See no reason it could not be accessed by somebody with disabilities or difficulty walking/maneuvering stairs. Table size are not very large so small groups would be okay, 8 to the max unless you sit at separate tables.

They have some very tasty dished. I always pick up a Chicken Parm dish to go. They been there for years!

Jonquel NYC

They have some very tasty dished. I always pick up a Chicken Parm dish to go. They been there for years!

I have been here several times, and have never been disappointed. On the other hand, my expectations were low. The food is sort of generic, nothing special, but more than edible. The reason I've returned so many times is that it is conveniently located, and a couple with whom we are friendly loves the place. I was thinking three stars, but the staff is so friendly and caring that it deserves extra to thank them for the warm feelings.

We get dinner here a few times a year. Overall it’s pretty good

Libby Derenthal

We get dinner here a few times a year. Overall it’s pretty good

JohnB

I have been here several times, and have never been disappointed. On the other hand, my expectations were low. The food is sort of generic, nothing special, but more than edible. The reason I've returned so many times is that it is conveniently located, and a couple with whom we are friendly loves the place. I was thinking three stars, but the staff is so friendly and caring that it deserves extra to thank them for the warm feelings.

Fine for pizza but I went in with 6 people for meals and we should have just ordered a pie. Between the crowd we ordered a chicken parmesan a salmon dish and eggplant parm chicken with broccoli and two others I can't remember but nobody was happy with the food. All the meats were frozen so was the salmon. They were dried out and bland, absolutely tasteless and intentionally over-spiced in an attempt to mask it. We will not be visiting this place again unless we're going in for a simple slice of pizza. The old man is very nice he's been in business there for 40 years. I think it's time to retire.

I went Christmas Eve around 5pm with my bf and saw they were still open however when we went to go to order they said they were not taking anymore orders (without any explanation) which I thought was because it was late and they might have been closing. However, when we passed by at least 20 minutes later we saw they continued to take other customers after which leads me to question if they did not serve us possibly cause we are not white. Disappointing. They were not welcoming at all.

Ivette S

I went Christmas Eve around 5pm with my bf and saw they were still open however when we went to go to order they said they were not taking anymore orders (without any explanation) which I thought was because it was late and they might have been closing. However, when we passed by at least 20 minutes later we saw they continued to take other customers after which leads me to question if they did not serve us possibly cause we are not white. Disappointing. They were not welcoming at all.