Who doesn't love a place that sells a pushpop

Excellent Lobster Rolls! Friendly staff, nice atmosphere. All around a great experience!

Tasty food and friendly, fast service.

OMG OMG. We are saying at my grandmas and grandpas house and we went to this restaurant yesterday for lunch bc we were at the light house . So we decided to go here and get some food and I got the chicken fingers AND OMG they were so good. If you want the best chicken fingers go to this place

Great locally run place. Can’t picture a better spot for a beverage after biking out there

A cafe with a nice view

The food was delicious and the staff members were friendly. The service was exceptional and ambiance was great.

Cool place on Hill next to light house big view lots of games to play with bar overlooking the water food good fresh fish. Must see

We make a lot of motorcycle rides through Heaven's Own MC Outreach, out here last year , great folks,

The food was great. Nice to take a break here after a walk along the coast.

Anna thank you so much for the drinks today you are absolutely awesome enjoy your day everyone come here and have a drink

Great place for a quick bite and definitely gorgeous views 👌

Great wine and fireplace!!! Bar tender had a crush on me. Highly recommend!!!

Best bar in montauk! Service is great. Prices reasonable. Friendly bartenders and service!

Beautiful view’s!!

Beautiful view and so much fun with the Two Shoes playing on the deck

the food OK, but the view you get with your meal is the best

Food was good and filling. Prices are quite reasonable, given the restaurant’s location. We paid $50 for a shrimp salad, burger, one of the daily specials, and drinks. The dining area is spacious and clean. Service was friendly and speedy.

Went here on 8/15. Meh songs on loop, cranky service worker (seems to be the norm in Montauk), but the food was absolutely on point. Got the fish & chips. Fish was beer battered and fries were double fried. That cook was a miracle worker.

Affordable price with the gorgeous view of the sea and the lighthouse. Must stop by if you are visiting the lighthouse.

Love what they've done with this building! So cozy, a true tavern with good food, great drinks, warm atmosphere to watch a game, play a board game with family, or watch the boats on the ocean. Pet friendly.

It was a little early but they let us in. Very cozy place with good service, friendly staff and super nice owner. There is a nautical launge balcony with ocean front cinema view and light house. It’s the kind of place you can go any time of the day to eat and hang out in good vibe.

A bit pricey but given that all the mixes for the drinks are home made, I completely understand why. The lime and coconut was yummy.

Stop by and enjoy the local beer and some bar food. Relax and enjoy the view of the ocean and light house. After you are done, hike toward the rocks near the lighthouse.

The food here was phenomenal. I had the mussels (delicious) and quite possibly the best crab cake of my life. I’d come back here just to eat - it really is that good.

Was here a couple of hrs ago have to say that nothing hit the spot more after fishing the night tide than having a hot of the skillet egg sandwhich and fresh brewed coffee at this spot. I would recommend any one visiting montauk point state park to step inside the light house grill and partake in good eats. I suggested some of my fishing buddies grab a bite there too its super convenient and the staff couldn't be a any more welcoming and ready to feed you. Tight lines and full stomachs

George's- Named after George Washington who had the Montauk lighthouse built . Fireplace. Great service. Good food. Terrific music. A must stop when seeing the Montaul Lighthouse or anytime.

Great and convenient little Cafe. Tasty beers on tap and full bar pre-made sandwiches and chicken fingers etc. I had a cheeseburger it was awesome. Friendly staff

LỘC Nguyễn tấn

Great experience! Friendly staff and a very cozy vibe

Olivia C

Friendly staff, indoor and outdoor seating, with great views. Cash, credit or charge, activities for the kids, alcoholic & non-alcoholic beverages. Games for the kids while you wait for your food. The food is freshly made to order. Table service. You're able to walk down to the beach after or before you eat.

fellsteruk

Was well worth the four hours drive from manhattan to sample one of the best lobster rolls I’ve ever had. However the true star of the show has to be the French fries, crispy for days. Super friendly, nice staff well worth a visit !

Matt

Stopped in for a bite to eat while at the lighthouse. I decided to take my chance with a lobster roll. It was pretty good for $25 and came with the fries. It was not overdone with Mayo and had nice chunks. I prefer a chunky lobster roll compared to a slaw some places out here try to make it. They accept credit cards also which is a plus. I’d give it a try again. 👍

Nurse Kris

Nice place to eat with wonderful view of the light house. May who served us is very nice too.

Eamon Wood

The service was first rate, food was good and setting can't be beat. Great spot, inside and out to relax with a drink and enjoy the water. Staff is very nice and allowed me to work most of the day without trouble.

Les Bowman

Stopped in during the AM hours, staff was still setting up. Although we were the only patrons, the manager came over and made a fire for us to warm up while we enjoyed our New England Clam Chowder 👍🏼👍🏼 Large Spacious facility, both indoor and outdoor friendly for large groups

Wenzel Srb

We had the fish tacos, tasted really well. And the view is great as well. Parking is $8. Def. worth a visit.

Andrew Hassell

Nice spot for a snack or drink if you are out visiting the light house

Randy L

Usually when you go to these little food places that are the only show in town by a park, etc. You can expect dried out frozen hamburgers or chicken sandwiches under a light. Not here! Very good food, a nice menu, and a very nice vibe can all be found here. We weren't overly hungry and just sort of popped in, but decided to have the fish and chips. The batter was crispy and the fish was flaky and hot. The fries were also cooked perfectly and salted just enough. We decided to try the mussels and were very glad we did. Even though we weren't hungry we devoured them. They were fresh and cooked to perfection in a nice flavorful sauce. We're going to make sure to go back. There's also s nice bar here that overlooks the ocean. Check it out

Satish Nagarajan

Great way to relax and unwind for a summer afternoon. . Location, Ales, Crowd and good lively music and vibe to this place. . The food wait was horrendous but relaxing and hanging out at this place more than made up for it. .

Jennifer Rao

On this cold November night - Great Music - Lively Crowd - Fast Bar Service - Roaring Fireplace - Strong Drinks - Hot Chocolate and Huge Pretzels Available - Shuffleboard - Amazing View In Patio - Fun Place to Party, especially on the night of the lighting of Montauk Lighthouse :)))))

Great place to go and relax, have a drink , watch the sunset. There was even live music!!!

Gorgeous location, nice staff, but the bathrooms were filthy.

Rustic nice place! Good food, average price

Great place for a break for a drink or two and some good conversation.

Lovely fish tacos, quite bougie prices though.

Only had drinks and a great view.

Nice views cold drinks good service...

Very busy but good food.

The food was really good and the view spectacular! This is off-season, so the menu was abbreviated. I imagine that during the season with a full menu it would be even!

Cafeteria style restaurant with yummy, standard bar fare and a pretty view. Seating is limited at peak times, unfortunately, and it's a little pricey.

,small but cozy ...good food...great chili..pls put a little more in the bowl

Beautiful view Nice. You can have a beer or a cup of tea Definitly go

It’s beautiful place to hangout it’s better to spend one or days in that.. awesome view of sea and the light house

A little pricey but great atmosphere and good beer selection.

Quick plate of fries. A band was setting up. Nice chill atmosphere.

Good food and drinks. Could use more tables. Liked island music.

This was a very pretty location and a very pretty cafe. They did a good job capturing and maintaining the kind of look you'd expect from an old building near a lighthouse. They had multiple different fun activities to do like table shuffleboard, video games, and an outdoor area that occasionally has live music. The prices of their foods are pretty high, relative to what you get. Compared to other cafes I've been to, they tend towards 2 or 3 times what I'm used to paying. You're paying for a place in a great location that isn't competing with anyone else for miles. I wouldn't suggest buying food here necessarily, but it's not a waste of time or money to do it.

Cool place, but there is no enghuh food variety.. mostly bar food. But great vibe, and view!

Sowma Mondal

George’s Lighthouse stands as a charming coastal beacon, quietly telling stories of the past while offering serene views of the sea. Located in a picturesque setting, this lighthouse is more than just a navigation aid — it is a peaceful retreat for visitors who want to escape the rush of everyday life. The structure itself, though simple in design, has a timeless beauty. Its whitewashed walls and red-capped roof reflect classic maritime architecture that blends harmoniously with the surrounding natural scenery. What makes George’s Lighthouse truly special is the calm atmosphere it creates. Whether it’s the sound of crashing waves, the occasional cry of a seagull, or the golden hue of the setting sun behind the tower, every moment spent here feels meditative. Visitors can climb to the top for a panoramic view of the coastline, and on clear days, the horizon seems to stretch forever. Though not as famous as other lighthouses, George’s Lighthouse offers a more intimate and soulful experience. It's perfect for quiet walks, photography, or simply sitting on a nearby bench and watching the sea. Anyone seeking beauty, history, and peace by the shore will find George’s Lighthouse a hidden gem worth discovering.

Melissa Naja

Good to have some spot to get some snack or drink nearby lighthouse. As you can see on the map, no place nearby just park trees and ocean so, of course, the tourist attraction places the price point will be higher than regular but people is willing to pay as there are on vacation, why not? Anyway, I got an ice cream, fried calamari and soda. I was thinking about get some cocktail, but I saw that only few workers and they were busy, so I didn't want to bother them. Service was okay, you order everything at the cashier, and they gave you a number then after your food was ready, they brought the food to your table.

+3

Galyna Shulimova

Beautiful view. Food and prices are not the best.

Marsha Newman

Another delightful place to find in Montauk! Summer hrs till 6pm, 7 on weekends. Pretty views, educational info re conservation. Good menu, and clean public rest rooms. The seagulls expect to be fed!

+14

info visconti

Went during Christmas....small selection of drinks....food selection is good.....it was quaint in the winter....it must rock in the summer....I will need to come back and see.....really nice views of the Ocean...set on the shore so there is n open patio as well...

AlbertaSpruce

The space was lovely for a music event. The backdrop was the ocean and the lighthouse. A big stop for a good amount of international tourists to see the lighthouse and montauk and the end/beginning of the island. happy to have another venue with live music available to local artists.

Beautiful views but not much to choose from on the menu.

Tuff to rate, just used bathroom which was clean!! Place was clean. Sorry that's all I have.

Lobster roll taste like tuna sandwich

Nice location by the sea. The menu choices are mostly fried comfort food. A good place for a snack, a coffee or a beer.

It's okay, not enough staff when I went, so everyone had to wait longer, but being served requires patience regardless. Food and drinks were too pricey anyway

Needs better Management that young black boy named Isaiah would make a great manager.

Place was closed in June when I visited, but has a great view. Hope they open soon.

Nice sunsets can get a drink but stopped serving food.

Food was actually pretty good, but extremely expensive. The service was excessively slow. We ordered an order of tacos and a wrap and it took 45 minutes. There was only one other table occupied.

PROS...Nice location with great views! CONS...Food was just ok and WAAY overpriced!! And there is a lack of kitchen staff, so orders were hit and miss in terms of how fast they were ready. Limited bar variety, but a bar nonetheless. Just OK.

Raymond Medina

Excellent view and decent food. Prices are also very reasonable. Biggest gripes are with the bathrooms. They could definitely stand to be upgraded and cleaned. Drinks are not top quality and a lot of mixers are used which don't taste very good. They could probably create better drinks and charge more.

They just forgot to put sausage in my sandwich

No dogs allowed to walk to the lighthouse, leave it like backpacks and other stuff in the car ???

place was closed in july.busy season.its NOT open 24 hours.nobody there plus it looked really run down and dirty

Would be zero if I could. Whoever is running this place needs to be replaced.

Tried to charge me $7 for a warm bud light can.

Gave me margarita without alcohol. Absolute waste of 15$ cocktail

Ordered fish chips, FISH FROZEN in middle. got another meal, but disgusted on how under cooked and fish ain't fresh. If I could give minus star I would.

Opening time on google maps is wrong, it’s closed until April-ish?

I love the place but it closed too early which makes it unusable for a Saturday evening should be open later then 6:00 p.m.

I do not understand how this place is getting 5 stars. I drove 2 and a half hours for a burger that was half the size of the bun, a pickle the size of my pinky toe, and fries that were soggy. On the flip side, the beer was good. But then again...pouring a beer properly isn't hard. The atmosphere is great, the food is the exact opposite. The people behind the counter are a bunch of young kids who don't want to be there. I give it 1 out of 5 meatballs. Terrible.

Considering this was the only spot to eat near this landmark... the place is disgusting. The structure out back under the roof was covered in poop, my veggie burger tasted like it was cooked on top of a meat burger (pointless) especially for an expensive burger. The piña colada machine was out of order, no lobster... I mean, why is there a run down cafe so near this beautiful location? Someone should really step in and up the standards there. Poor condition for a wealthy area.

First time there in about 2 years. Night and Day. Sat at the bar was ignored. When the person came to cooler to get other customers a beer I said is there a bartender and my wife asked if we had to get on a line. No answer, didn't have the decency to say I'll be back or answer the questions. In the time we were there saw others walk out. Now we know why.

The food is tasteless plus i had to wait about 45 minutes for a burger with salty fries . Horrible costumer service they seem they don't like to be there. Don't waste your time here. Bring cookies or something as snack for the time you are planning to stay.

I would give it 5 stars except that when we ordered a Peroni because we thought it would come in the glass bottle, the bartender started pouring it into a plastic cup before we noticed. Everyone says we need to reduce plastic waste and then they go ahead and use plastic cups! Next time, can we just have the Peroni minus the plastic?

Adam Lobdell

On October 25, 2025, I was refused service at George’s Lighthouse Bar & Grill while accompanied by my trained and vested service dog. Despite calmly explaining that he is a legally protected service animal under the ADA, the staff — an older woman with blonde hair who appeared to be a manager — still refused to seat or serve us. This experience was not only embarrassing and upsetting, but it also violates federal law protecting individuals with disabilities. I’ve since filed a formal ADA Title III complaint with the U.S. Department of Justice and the New York State Office of Parks, as this establishment operates within Montauk Point State Park. I’m sharing this so others with service animals are aware — and so the management takes this as an opportunity to train staff properly and ensure compliance with the ADA moving forward.