IndyKevin317

I love that Rose’s is open so late. The pizza is usually pretty fresh because they are always busy. I’d stick with the popular choices to be safe. Some menu items look like they have been sitting around for a while. You will be surprised at how good a plain slice of cheese ($4.10) pizza tastes. You really don’t need any of the fancy stuff. Great place to go when waiting for a train at Penn Station.

+3

krutartha shah

The pizza tastes so authentic — the crust is perfect and the cheese is rich and flavorful. You can really tell the quality in every bite. Honestly, it’s 100 times better than the Sbarro right next door.

Ms. Matamoros

I love this place as I’ve been coming here for years. I remember it as far back as when it was where Duane Reade is now. The girls that sold beer used to know me by name. After they close for construction, it’s changed. And of course it has but what pissed me off is this. When you pay for your beer with a card, it takes a long time for the tip screen to come on. I only realize that when I went to pay and it was asking for a tip when I didn’t swipe my card yet. Anyway, I clicked skipped and waited for the screen to clear to pay. I like to give my tip in cash so that’s what I did. After I swiped my card, I wanted to wait for the tip screen to come on and the lady that sells the beer said, “don’t worry, you can go.” But the tip screen hadn’t come on yet and there was someone right behind me. Knowing this, I stepped to the side and waited. After a good 30-45 secs, the tip screen for MY CARD came on. I asked the guy to press skip for me and left. Here’s my thing, people can either be pressing it without realizing that they didn’t swipe yet or the people that sell the beer can be pressing it themselves. I’m not trying to say they are doing it, but it’s a possibility. I don’t trust people to press skip for me, so please fix it. Also, please tip the ladies serving the beer. I have nothing against them, but she should at least let people know to wait until the tip screen comes in. Might get her a bigger tip, I know I would have.

Harrison C. Davies

🍕🚉🍕 This place definitely earns its claim to fame as a highly regarded Penn Station pizzeria. The food is fresh and warm, but honestly, so are plenty of other spots nearby. What really sets this place apart is its commuter-friendly setup and prideful service. They make it easy for you to grab a slice on the go, and that personal touch alone is worth a stop.

+4

Austin Boley

A solid pizza shop that’s right outside of MSG and just a short walking distance from the Amtrak Station. Food is very reasonably priced and the pizza slices are good sized. The tomato sauce is a little too sweet, but overall not a bad slice.

+1

Joe O

Very nice little NYC pizza joint. Had your typical wide variety of NY C style thin pizza. Solid crisp pizza and garlic knots. Wife and I loved the sauce and fresh mozzarella.

Richard Torbett

We were impressed with how fast the line moves and the amount and types of pizza they have available. They throw each order back in the oven and serve it hot. The upstairs seating area could be cleaner.

Rob Strotman

This wonderful location is right by Madison square garden and is open past 3:00 a.m. the guys working there are really friendly and the pizzas are quite good. I would recommend asking them to heat your pizza a little longer than they normally do just so that the cheese, which is piled fairly thickly, completely melts. They also have soda on draft and I tried four different styles of pizza and they were all delicious. There are constantly people coming into this restaurant day and night so it has to be good, right? Trust me. It's not the best pie in New York City but it is definitely a good pizza.

Frugal Cyclist

Not too shabby. Above average pizza for $3.50 regular slice & $4.50 topping slice, tax extra. I prefer the authentic pizza spots where you pay what you see on the menu, tax inclusive. 3% surcharge for credit cards. $9.50 for 20 oz Allagash white on tap. Drinking beer out of a plastic cup just ruins the vibe. The plus is this is right across from Penn Station LIRR. Better to wait here than standing underground…

+10

Came in for 2 slices. A neopolitan and square Sicilian. Neo was ok sauce very sweet. Square had raw dough. Brought it back asking for replacement. Cashier who id self as manager was argumentative with me. I requested refund instead. He gave me my money back. Won't go back.

I went in the bathroom was disgusting. And the guys at the front were extremely rude they were very arrogant and disrespectful. I ordered some pizza to go and the guy at the front was very rude he literally threw the pizza at me and then spoke his language to the guy at the register who was also very rude. I will never come again or recommend anyone to to go here. They are disgusting humans and dont deserve our business

JOANNA BINYCHAKI

We bought 4 slices to go (take away) and all were like that at the bottom - This is NOT healthy at all to be eaten. We are not animals. Stuff should be more careful in this store. We do NOT recommend.

Rosh Kali

Ordered a pepperoni grandma, and 3 plain slices, 6.50 each, total was 27.39. They told us our "plain slice" was a vodka slice and its 6.50, wasnt trying to cause a scene or nothing but never going back, they over charged me intentionally and i dont appreciate that because when I asked to clarify they double downed. 0 vodka sauce to be found, still waiting. I dont know if it was cause i was an immigrant but never going back, there's better places to get pizza in the city anyway.