Justin Ritchie

Local pizzeria with unique, highly addictive pizza and excellent "strombolis"! EAT HERE. GO NOW. Eating at Pizza King is a highlight of every trip back home to Evansville. The diced pepperoni and thin, slightly charred crust I've never found elsewhere. I've eaten embarrassing amounts of this pizza in a single sitting. Their strombolis (for those not from the area, we've misappropriated the term - Evansville stroms are not a true stromboli, but rather a delicious sub-like sandwich with sausage, onions, tomato sauce, and mozzarella) are fantastic. There is another great location on St. Joseph and Franklin (west side of Evansville) where I ate growing up, but I usually stay nearer to the Newburgh shop when I visit. The staff in Newburgh are great and they recognize me even though I only make it in once or twice a year. :)

Sarah Hartman

Good pizza and amazing breadsticks, staff were very friendly and accommodating.

+2

Melissa Vieira

Placed an order tonight and 1 item was a 10” pepperoni pizza. It was over cooked and tasted like it was a frozen pizza. It did not at all taste like their crust and sauce that I love so much. We also got a 16” black olive, beef and mushroom and it was good. We ate 1 piece of the pepperoni one and threw it away.

Gary Doolittle

Doesn't stay open late enough and they quit selling beer but still has a beer sign up i just read the prior post the company needs to have a mgnt change for someone that cares instead of only caring to get home with min effort when you spend hard earned money and get the service mentioned it will leave a bad taste in your mouth. REMEMBER WORD OF MOUTH IS YOUR BEST ADVERTISING

Scott Larock

Be careful if ordering from Pizza King Newburgh when using DoorDash, GrubHub, etc. They will short you on the ingredients. Here are pictures of when I went in and picked up a stromboli versus when I had one delivered and there is a huge difference between the two. If you pick it up yourself, you will get a thick, meaty stromboli. If you have it delivered, you will be eating mostly bread. **Update - I guess the owner is an idiot. When I complained about skimping on the sandwich, he said that they weren't responsible for the order once it leaves the store. But you are responsible for what you send out, DUH!!🤪

Brent Porter

What was ordered..vs.. what was received. Very disappointing And the website needs some tweaking.. pizza is very good however

Jennifer Racey

My family and I were trying to experience Pizza King for the first time. The teenage staff there were really nice but the manager was rude and hateful. There is no sign saying when the dining room was closing and she gave us attitude for just sitting down waiting for our food. I had to explain to my autistic son why we had to wait in the car in the heat so that my husband could get the food. I have never had such horrible service from a manager. As a former manager I say she needs an attitude adjustment. Never coming back here again! I feel I deserve a refund!

THIS PLACE RIPS YOU OFF. CHARGES A HANDLING FEE FOR ME PICKING UP A BOTTLED SODA OUT OF THE COOLER. I PAID CASH. ASKED THE BOY WITH PINK HAIR WHY THEY DID THIS AND HE SHRUGS HIS SHOULDER. I DONT KNOW. I ASKED, "DOES ANYBODY KNOW?" FIVE WORKERS HALF WITH PINK OR PURPLE HAIR STANDING AROUND AND NO ONE KNOWS ANYTHING. HERES THE RECEIPT. PLUS WITH THE ORDER I PLACED WITH THIS HAD A BIG PINK HAIR ON IT. WILL NEVER GO BACK THERE!!!

I went to the Newburgh Pizza King and it was horrible got two burnt strombolis... It was overpriced and not good Don't eat there

Katey Andrews

Absolutely horrible customer service! The young girl with dark hair in a ponytail was cutting my pizzas, I said they both looked burnt, she took her bare hands lifted up 1/2 of one pizza and said rudely that it was not, then looked at another employee rolling her eyes like how dare she question me. Both pizzas are burnt all over the top. Horrible experience and will not be back.

joe copley

Cheese pizza had no cheese, was over baked. People spend their hard earned money on businesses/food, but receive little in return. I will order from somewhere else the next time.

Steve Riley

Sad to say today will be the last day I visit Pizza King in newburgh. I ordered a half Stromboli and a medium all meat Pizza. The Stromboli looked like a hotdog bun that was tough as wet leather, there was no cheese what so ever and the meat was light and looked like just plain hamburger meat with sauce. The medium Pizza was very light all of the ingredients and looked and tasted like a Tony's Pizza that was bought at Walmart. I'm very sad to see this place going down the drain because whoever owns it now thinks they have to cut cost to make a big profit. I was born and raised in Newburgh and the Pizza king was always a family favorite.

Mark Ballard

This place burnt my food and refused to reimburse me unless I went out of my way to return the food myself! $71 down the drain stay away from this place they should be shut down.

Live Free Or Die

Received this via delivery. Longtime Pizza King fan likely to never order again. If you drop someone’s pizza while delivering, do the right thing and remake it. I’d have been happy waiting for a new one, because obviously this isn’t worth over $20.