Horseman Bagels

Despite a long line the staff were friendly and efficient. The bagels were fresh and delicious.

These bagels are amazing! My favorite is the rosemary garlic. I've had their bacon egg and cheese and the bacon is always perfect, the cheese is empty, and the bagel is always perfectly toasted. The bagels are bigger than your usual size and the flavor and texture are better than I could ever expect out of a ring of dough. The people are very lovely and it's always a nice feeling walking into the store. Ordering to pick up is always quick. Absolutely recommend over the more popular bagel spots in the area. They might be more popular but they definitely don't satisfy like horseman does.

First time In sleepy hallow and I’ll 100% be back for the bagels and service here. The bagels are huge and delicious especially the everything bagel and cinnamon raisin one. They have a variety of cream cheese and the scallion one is mouthwatering. Thank you to Karen for her exceptional service, she really took care of me and surprised me with a cinnamon bagel to try which I absolutely loved. 10/10 experience

Bagels were delicious. The scallion cream cheese was amazing!!

Best Bagels Ever! As a visitor from Los Angeles, I've eaten a lot of bagels, but this Sleepy Hollow spot is the absolute best! The owner and his son are incredibly friendly, making you feel right at home. The bagels are amazing – huge, delicious, and so flavorful. You get a ton of food for your money, and the prices are fantastic. The staff are super friendly and quick too. I even brought some back to LA, and I wish I could've brought more to have them every day! This isn't just a bagel shop it's a must-visit. If you want awesome food, great prices, and friendly faces, you have to go here.

I spent two weeks in New York state and ate many bagels , by far the best I had was from here. I'm sad being back in Ireland , wondering how long it may be before I get a chance to go here again. If you're near sleepy hollow make sure you get down here

We absolutely loved visiting Horseman bagels. They are freshly made and delicious. The bagels had the perfect amount of chewy and crispy, crackly crust. My husband got the lox spread and said it was fresh and tasty. The building itself is very small, with limited seating.

Wonderfully made fresh bagels. I came on a Saturday for a breakfast sandwich and the service was excellent with little wait time. The small seating area provides pleasant views of a busy intersection in Sleepy Hollow and it’s a great place to admire the sunrise. Highly recommend.

Not your typical bagel spot. You can tell the cream cheese is made here fresh - don’t forget to ask for toasted! As a side note, their bacon is really good.

Had a lunch here during my first visit to Sleepy Hollow. I was intrigued by the logo. They have a lot of choices for the flavours and the bread type. My husband and I both got smoked salmon bagel with pumpernickel bread for him and onion for me. Both were generous and delicious. Also the price was very good for the quantity and quality. Service was very friendly and quick. The only downside was that there wasn’t any toilets inside.

Came in because we saw some t-shirts in the window and to check out their baked goods. Cookies were good, and the staff was friendly. If your looking for some t-shirts they have a nice selection as well.

The staff member was super nice and very helpful with making decisions and giving suggestions on what to get! The food was delicious! We are from out of town but would recommend to everyone who is visiting as well!

Absolutely amazing bagels. They are in Tarrytown New York so you expect a bagel to be great because New York bagels are the best, but these are exceptional. They have the most amazing choices. I recommend you give them a try and if those that you are with would prefer something a bit more sweet, they share their shop with a Carvel!!

First time trying Horseman bagels location. Staff friendly. Bagels soft and very delicious. My Husband had an Everything Bagel, Egg and Extra Cheese. I had a Rainbow Bagel with scallon cream cheese. Two small coffee, great temperature, taste smooth. Highly recommend. Update 2/5/2024 Went today and had an everything bagel with Rose Cream Cheese. Highly recommend. Update 3/4/2024 Went today, Rainbow bagel with veggie cream cheese. No rose cream cheese today. Highly recommend. Update 3/22/2024 Friendly staff. Great coffee. Great selection of bagels. Free Parking site. Highly recommend.

The bagels are simply delicious. I had the spread with scallions and lox on a plain toasted bagel, while my companion had Strawberry cream cheese on a Toasted egg bagel. They were incredibly fresh, overstuffed, and every mouthful was delicious. Highly recommend!

This place easily has the best bagels in the Tarrytown/sleepy Hollow area. They’re crispy and doughy at the same time and they’re big. The service is faster and more personal than other breakfast/bagel places in the area. And ice cream! Definitely recommend.

Horseman bagels is one of the best spots in the Tri state area! First off, the Zaatar Flagel is the star of the show, chefs kiss, drop everything and get one! The bagels are light, fluffy, yet substantial, and the spreads are sensational! The flavors here are nuanced, yet so impactful! To top it all off, Saeed, (I hope I spelled your name correctly) is an incredibly warm, enthusiastic, expert that deserves all the accolades for bringing such passion and flavor to Westchester! My sister and I came as she was visiting me, and this meal is still something we talk about! Thank you for being a core memory for us, and I can’t wait to visit again!

The workers were very kind and the bagels themselves taste incredible. Definitely a nice spot to stop by for a quick bite to eat or a tasty dessert.

I have been there with my Girlfriend at 04.11, we are coming from Mielec,Poland. Yours bagels was soo good.

David Garcia

Wonderfully made fresh bagels. I came on a Saturday for a breakfast sandwich and the service was excellent with little wait time. The small seating area provides pleasant views of a busy intersection in Sleepy Hollow and it’s a great place to admire the sunrise. Highly recommend.

amanda eagleston

We absolutely loved visiting Horseman bagels. They are freshly made and delicious. The bagels had the perfect amount of chewy and crispy, crackly crust. My husband got the lox spread and said it was fresh and tasty. The building itself is very small, with limited seating.

Zachary Debottis

Not your typical bagel spot. You can tell the cream cheese is made here fresh - don’t forget to ask for toasted! As a side note, their bacon is really good.

Melanie Mengüş

Had a lunch here during my first visit to Sleepy Hollow. I was intrigued by the logo. They have a lot of choices for the flavours and the bread type. My husband and I both got smoked salmon bagel with pumpernickel bread for him and onion for me. Both were generous and delicious. Also the price was very good for the quantity and quality. Service was very friendly and quick. The only downside was that there wasn’t any toilets inside.

Cassy Marx

Came in because we saw some t-shirts in the window and to check out their baked goods. Cookies were good, and the staff was friendly. If your looking for some t-shirts they have a nice selection as well.

Naomi Wolski

The staff member was super nice and very helpful with making decisions and giving suggestions on what to get! The food was delicious! We are from out of town but would recommend to everyone who is visiting as well!

Charlotte Pennella

Absolutely amazing bagels. They are in Tarrytown New York so you expect a bagel to be great because New York bagels are the best, but these are exceptional. They have the most amazing choices. I recommend you give them a try and if those that you are with would prefer something a bit more sweet, they share their shop with a Carvel!!

TheRamzesxP

I have been there with my Girlfriend at 04.11, we are coming from Mielec,Poland. Yours bagels was soo good.

Rissa

First time trying Horseman bagels location. Staff friendly. Bagels soft and very delicious. My Husband had an Everything Bagel, Egg and Extra Cheese. I had a Rainbow Bagel with scallon cream cheese. Two small coffee, great temperature, taste smooth. Highly recommend. Update 2/5/2024 Went today and had an everything bagel with Rose Cream Cheese. Highly recommend. Update 3/4/2024 Went today, Rainbow bagel with veggie cream cheese. No rose cream cheese today. Highly recommend. Update 3/22/2024 Friendly staff. Great coffee. Great selection of bagels. Free Parking site. Highly recommend.

Kerry Theriault

Bagels were delicious. The scallion cream cheese was amazing!!

Karen Helsel

The bagels are simply delicious. I had the spread with scallions and lox on a plain toasted bagel, while my companion had Strawberry cream cheese on a Toasted egg bagel. They were incredibly fresh, overstuffed, and every mouthful was delicious. Highly recommend!

Sam

This place easily has the best bagels in the Tarrytown/sleepy Hollow area. They’re crispy and doughy at the same time and they’re big. The service is faster and more personal than other breakfast/bagel places in the area. And ice cream! Definitely recommend.

Really good bagels. A good variety of flavors as well as cream cheeses and other add-ons. For parking go up the hill road to the right of the building and the first left is a good sized lot with a staircase down to the front entrance. Staff is friendly and quick. Good food anytime of the year

Gfan

Really good bagels. A good variety of flavors as well as cream cheeses and other add-ons. For parking go up the hill road to the right of the building and the first left is a good sized lot with a staircase down to the front entrance. Staff is friendly and quick. Good food anytime of the year

Delicious breakfast sandwhich and the rosemary garlic bagel was amazing. Only issue is little to no seating and little to no parking. Otherwise staff was very friendly and the food was definitely worth it.

Good bagels! Well priced. Wish they had more sweet cream cheese. A lot of savory options but only 2 for sweet so just got plain but they do know how much cream cheese goes into a bagel(a lot!) Will stop every time we go to sleep hollow/tarrytown

I ordered a bagel sandwich, the bagel was good but the ham/egg/cheese was not terribly appetizing. I ended up tossing half the bagel away. Its wasn't cut all the way through so I had to try to rip everything in half to finish the cut...definitely turned into a mess.

Small spot with some seating inside and out. Was a bit disappointed that they ran out of plain bagels fairly early for lunch around noon. Got a BEC on garlic bagel instead and the garlic was a little overpowering for the sandwich but decent.

Kate

Small spot with some seating inside and out. Was a bit disappointed that they ran out of plain bagels fairly early for lunch around noon. Got a BEC on garlic bagel instead and the garlic was a little overpowering for the sandwich but decent.

Really just a deli counter. Only a few small tables to sit at. I thought there was more to it from the pics. Bagels were delish though!

Strawberry cream cheese seems to be just pink cream cheese. Really good bagels though, with limited selection if you get there after 11 am!

The lox spread was tasty with plenty of lox. The everything bagel mediocre--light without a lot of chew and a little sweet. Service was prompt and pleasant.

BEC was too salty. Looks better than it tastes. Tried friend’s lox bagel - better. Not worth the long line

Mei Deng

BEC was too salty. Looks better than it tastes. Tried friend’s lox bagel - better. Not worth the long line

Every time we go here we have had a great experience. When we have ordered online, however, there always seems to be at least one thing wrong. Mostly, we have wanted toasted bagels and the bagels are definitely not toasted. Much better to go in person than order online.

Place inside needs an update. But mostly the prices are outrageous..grabbed a large coffee, Bagel with butter and one with Cream cheese..$16. Coffee tastes like its 3 days old to boot..They wanted over $25 dollars for a dozen bagels. They do not display prices, so ask first. Definitely will not be going here again. Not worth the price of admission.

Emily Nevill

The lox spread was tasty with plenty of lox. The everything bagel mediocre--light without a lot of chew and a little sweet. Service was prompt and pleasant.

Caroline Busse

Every time we go here we have had a great experience. When we have ordered online, however, there always seems to be at least one thing wrong. Mostly, we have wanted toasted bagels and the bagels are definitely not toasted. Much better to go in person than order online.

Frank

Place inside needs an update. But mostly the prices are outrageous..grabbed a large coffee, Bagel with butter and one with Cream cheese..$16. Coffee tastes like its 3 days old to boot..They wanted over $25 dollars for a dozen bagels. They do not display prices, so ask first. Definitely will not be going here again. Not worth the price of admission.

When I came in myself I didn’t have any issues but when my boyfriend had come in to just get some tap water for our dog he was dealt with attitude and telling him he needed to buy something even though when I came in I had already bought my bagel. He told them this and still dealt with some rudeness. Also having to purchase something for some tap water is a bit beyond it but that’s just my opinion. Apart from that the bagel was ok. Nothing really special and what I had got lacked some flavor. Not sure if I came at a bad time or not. It was empty.

If you like plain bagels with cream cheese this is fine. However if you value quality bagels, the Lox were seriously unappetizing and of questionable freshness. Questionable storage methods. Ridiculously pricey for the quality.

Bagels were good. We paid cash as there is a 4% surcharge on credit card transactions. Count your change as the counter person overcharged us for two bagels and had to be told to give us the correct change. I can't comment on the atmosphere as we got takeout. It was not four cents. It was 16 cents. And the counter person was reluctant to effect the correction.

Honestly, Horseman has the best bagels in lower Westchester. Problem is, you never get what you order. We’ve been probably 15 times since they reopened, and I’d say over half have had some issue - missing cheese, missing sausage/bacon, bacon instead of sausage, wrong bagel, ketchup added when not requested. Some of these aren’t minor issues - they completely ruin the sandwich. We hit our breaking point 2 weekends ago when we ordered ahead, and the person taking our order asked if we wanted ketchup - we said no. She repeats our order back to us to confirm and everything is correct. We pick up the food and when we get home, both bagels have ketchup. I’m okay with ketchup on fries, but it completely ruins the bagel - that’s all you taste. That was sadly our last time going to horseman.

This is our absolute favorite bagel place, and that is the only reason why I’m not giving one star review. Today was a real disappointment. We arrived at 7:30am on a Friday and there were just a couple of bagels available, no coffee available, only one person working as a cashier and making the bagels, and most importantly, our order of egg and cheese was a real bummer. The cheese isn’t melted and the bagel is not fresh. There was no communication explaining that the bagels were from the day before, so the whole experience is really disappointing. I’m not sure why the bagels were so bad today, but I really hope it was a fluke!

Luiza Karnas

This is our absolute favorite bagel place, and that is the only reason why I’m not giving one star review. Today was a real disappointment. We arrived at 7:30am on a Friday and there were just a couple of bagels available, no coffee available, only one person working as a cashier and making the bagels, and most importantly, our order of egg and cheese was a real bummer. The cheese isn’t melted and the bagel is not fresh. There was no communication explaining that the bagels were from the day before, so the whole experience is really disappointing. I’m not sure why the bagels were so bad today, but I really hope it was a fluke!

I haven't been downstate in years. Literal years. I can't tell you the excitement I felt of seeing a bagel place. Starting off There is no where to park! Second, if you have a stroller, your screwed. 3rd if your pregnant there is nowhere to pee. We waited in line for 45 minutes waiting to place my order. Finally placed it, got my food, make it back to the car, and the bagels are so salty. This entire town is just obnoxious. Never again.

Kyrstin Rappazzo

I haven't been downstate in years. Literal years. I can't tell you the excitement I felt of seeing a bagel place. Starting off There is no where to park! Second, if you have a stroller, your screwed. 3rd if your pregnant there is nowhere to pee. We waited in line for 45 minutes waiting to place my order. Finally placed it, got my food, make it back to the car, and the bagels are so salty. This entire town is just obnoxious. Never again.

I asked for a cold brew and got this pumpkin spice drink partially filled with no ice…. For $7.

The staff is UNBELIEVABLY RUDE. holy smokes. Do not go in here and deal with the older lady with red hair and glasses. She is the rudest most miserable person I have ever encountered. I can’t believe someone like that works with people. $24 for two bagels and an incredibly rude experience.

Dont waste your money here. Expensive, and low quality food. Place might work down in the bronx but I expect better in this location. I wont be returning even if I am desperate!!!

Bagels had no flavor. Felt like I was eating play dough textured bagels. Bacon and egg was very bland. I bought a half dozen bagels to bring home and wish I could return them.