Evan Stein

Really enjoyed our meal here, very generous portions and fair prices. Hard to find solid BBQ in Westchester that actually tastes smoky without being drowned in sauce. Also with their own gluten free menu for those who need accommodations. Will for sure be back!

Marianne Quattrociocchi

We ate here twice while visiting in the area and I would come here every time it was that good. The staff is friendly, efficient and professional. All the food was wonderful - the prices were fair; the portions were large,; the presentation was good, and it was delicious. We ordered diverse meals from chicken fajitas, brisket (best I ever had), to salmon. The parking lot is adequate. The style is rustic. Definitely will be back.

Janel Harris

What a great dinner! On Halloween, we decided to go to "The Firehouse" in Peekskill before a show at "The Paramount." We both had amazing burgers, salad, and fries! Burgers were incredible!!!!! Our waiter was super and attentive. We enjoyed watching different sport events in an area with tables. There is also a large bar with high chair tables in the bar area. A MUST visit casual bar in Peekskill area, in an atmosphere with superb food and parking lot as well as street parking.

Allen Soohoo

I went not expecting too much. But I was very suprised. The food was amazing

Reverend Vito DiCantante

A nice little place... Cool interior... Good food!

Mike C

Stopped for lunch at NY Firehouse Grille. Super friendly staff that makes you fell welcomed. I had the beef brisket sandwich with sweet potatoe fries! I knew it was going to be too large to dip in the sauce, so I made it into an open have sandwich. You can easily cut the brisket with a butter knife and it was excellent! Will definitely have to come back again!

john langworthy

I was looking for a convenient location the meet some old friends. I saw the NY Firehouse Grill online. I met brothers, Billy and Joey O at the Grill. It was a blast! Troy behind the bar was super cool, as we're the owners! We had a front row seat for the Yankees and Mets. The food was hot and delicious. The pub has a real cozy vibe! Troy delivered the beer with quickness and with a smile! We look forward to getting back in the near future. John L. Sherman, CT

Mike Viveros

IF I COULD LEAVE SEVEN STARTS I WOULD! We had Firehouse Grille cater an event at our firehouse and I cannot express how incredible they were! I thought I'd tasted decent ribs before, but they changed the game. I don't even know how they were even able to put it on my plate, as the meat just fell off. So tender and cooked to absolute perfection. And the cornbread? OMG, I can still taste it, absolutely astounding!!! Their staff was over the top with helpful and friendly service. They made sure everything was perfect from start to finish. It's rare to find such a terrific bunch dedicated to making your event a success. Highly recommend! Will most certainly hire them again for future events and can't wait to eat there in person. THANK YOU FOR EVERYTHING!!!!!!

Amanda

We met the most amazing waitress Alana. She was super attentive and welcoming for my fiance, infant daughter and I on our first visit to this establishment. Upon ordering, the food was quick and delicious. Not one thing was a miss. Cornbread is out of this world!!! Burgers are delicious. I love that you can build your own burger. Im looking forward to visiting again soon! I wish I knew this place was so close to home a long time ago!

Mike

Wanted to go here for quite sometime....finally made it 😃 I had a burger and my wife ordered the flamed fish tacos. Food was very good. Atmosphere was great, as they had all the football games on in the bar area. Service was outstanding. We will definitely be back.

Willow Brooks

First time visit and we had a great time. Seated quickly our server was amazing super friendly and nice. He checked in on us frequently. We got our food pretty quick and we loved all of it. My husband got a burger and he said it was great, I got the beef brisket sandwich and it was amazing. Well definitely come back next time we visit!

I got a Silician slice with pepperoni. Hubby got a Chicken Bacon ranch slice and our son got a plain slice and an order of mozzarella sticks. Everything was really good. Oh and he got one drink and it came to about $22. Seems pricey to me but good

Food was excellent. We all got cheese pizza, side penne pasta with butter and garlic, side rigatoni alla vodka. I really think they have the best pizza in the area. Very nice people as well!

I recommend I ordered 2 times and I have no complaints staff are professional and courteous

Small community pizzeria that delivers exactly what you want from such an establishment. This review is based on one visit, and the only thing I could point to as a negative is that I would have liked the crust to be crispy. A delicious slice needs a great blend of dough, sauce, and cheese, and Forno's delivers. If they maintain this quality with the rest of their food, it should be just as good.

Nick

The menu is very extensive and the food is amazing! The atmosphere is incredible with TVs everywhere and a cozy feel. One downside is that the parking lot was very dark and the door to get in wasn't obvious (it was around 5:30 in the Winter). The other was that the service was so slow with no real check ins for the table. I'm not one to complain about many things though so while the service wasn't the best, the food and atmosphere definitely made up for it! Also, we were a group of about 10 and with one waiter for the whole restaurant, I can see how that was a challenge.

Enmanuel Salvador Burgos

Our party of three dined in, and we found the food to be exceptionally well-prepared and flavorful. My sole minor critique pertains to the mushroom side dish. The establishment was quite busy, and the presence of only one server for all tables resulted in a somewhat extended service time.

+2

Frank S. Ross Sr.

Visiting the area from Charlotte for work. This place is a quaint local venue and must be popular with locals because the place had a good crowd for a Tuesday night. The menu has a good variety of options and the prices are reasonable. My food was excellent and I will visit again before I go back home. I don't usually write reviews unless the place has something exceptionally good or bad. NY Firehouse Grille earned my time to review it. Best quality:. Great food and friendly service. 🌟🌟🌟🌟

+4

Kathy Wingfield

The guacamole had a kick to it. The wings were very good. The salads were large and tasty. The salmon and mashed potatoes were very good. The oreo pie was just okay. The smores were fantastic! They brought the main course out too soon after our appetizers, so we didn't get to finish them. You may want to order appetizers first and the main course later.

Jasmine Adrian

When i first moved here a few years ago, this used to be the spot! But now the menu is different and its just not as good. All of the fan faves are gone, the mac and cheese isnt that good anymore. The service is always great but the food is why we come, and the last 4 or 5 times we’ve been disappointed unfortunately.

Ordered many times from this place over the years. Always was satisfied with the food and pizza. Not sure what changed, but the past maybe 3 months things took a turn. The quality of the food is way down and portions for some items have been reduced while staying the same price (mostly the rolls). The pizza has remained very good although I have noticed the cheese is often all messed up from not being level during delivery making it very unpleasant to eat. I gave them the benefit of the doubt and ordered a few more different dishes after I noticed the decline, foods like Chicken Marsala now lack any sort taste and very watered down, pizza rolls are miniature sized while costing same price, ingredients missing from certain items the list goes on. After many years I think I have to move on and go to other places weekly until they fix whatever they have going on….I feel bad because everyone is so nice and respectful in there but at the end of the day, i need to feel my money is well spent.

hawk messias

The food had a great presentation, great service, great atmosphere, but the food wasn't very good

The quality has gone down as time goes on.. I would travel 15 minutes before to get there nice big slices..and when I went back they are now serving children size slices... jesus folks I understand times are tough but you cut your slices in half..there 50% smaller then they were. Like the customers wouldn't notice. please..... I got pissed when I got the car to eat my lunch... I paid almost 8.00 for these tiny pizzas... rip off!!!!!!!.. your better off getting a stuffed crust pizza.. from supermarket... for $10.00

Disappointing, I ordered a salad and it was anything but fresh. The lettuce was old and the cucumbers were slimy. The chicken was the only thing on this salad that was good. Usually Forno’s is hit or miss. This time it was definitely a miss.

I’ve eaten Hawaiian pizza from dozen of pizzerias and never have I received a plain slice with uncooked ham and pineapple just thrown on top. If they didn’t have the slice available, they should have simply said that instead of serving some bs.

Really poor. I ordered once and food was amazing. But last three times were terrible. Ordered an expensive square and got all bread and very little sauce, Cheese and toppings. Really disappointed and won't give them another shot. Better places around.

i used to like this place but was so upset on th calzone. I was hoping to have a nice piping hot calzone with sasusage and mushrooms instead got one from the shelf reheated and sausage slapped on the bottom of the calzone..not inside..add insult to injury...after 35 min and i only live a few blocks away.. sahme on you guys!

Just trash nowadays. Don't waste your money there.

I never leave a negative review because I always try to see the positive but have had a terrible experience. Let me start off by saying I am not from the Westchester area and I do not know the pricing of the food in the area. I ordered food for Delivery. I ordered one large pie and then asked the difference between two of the other pizzas they had. I ordered one slice of each. The total ended up being over $60 which was very surprising for me but again did not question it because I’m not from the area nor that I know what type of pizzeria this was just found it on Google as the closest pizzeria. The delivery was supposed to take 40 minutes to 45 minutes. It ended up arriving over an hour later. And the pizzeria is only four maybe five blocks away. When my delivery finally gets there, they had charged me for full pies when I only requested the slice. I called later on as I was in the hair salon so I could not call them or leave to discuss the matter in the pizzeria and when I called them, the person that picked up, which is the same person that took the order was very rude has absolutely no customer service. At no point was I even requesting my money back for the cold pizza with the hard cheese that was delivered late, but I was only being courteous to letting them know of the issue internally so that they can fix it. Worst customer service and we’re $60 I ever spent as the cheese was burnt and hard.

Michael Morales

My 1st and only time visiting the Firehouse Grill. Was excited to taste the wings and local taps. Upon arrival, I had to sit myself near the bar area to a high top that was empty. A minute after sitting, a server approaches me to ask how many in my party, then noted we would need to move around an hour later, and then they placed a reservation tab on the table noting a reservation would be coming. I asked were can we sit, and was advised 'I don't know, but you will need to move. I imagine they are busy, but before the rest of my party arrived, again we were approached. Mind you, the people to my left were sitting there at a table drinking a beer from their own personal bags, bar was full with folks hanging out, but no one ordering or eating. At no point were we welcomed by the hostess or anyone who approached us. We felt unwelcome and uncomfortable and ended leaving, and upon exiting, the manager came out with a clipboard, and gave us a unwelcome look. I am intrigued on how this unfortunate experience unfolded. I was confused if maybe this was a members only club. Never had the opportunity to taste the food, but I will never forget the experience.