The Reserve

One of my favorite places to grab a drink with a friend or multiple friends.The atmosphere here is unmatched by any other place in the area. I’ve tried multiple drinks on the menu and my personal favorite is the 1929 spritz !! It’s so refreshing.

Absolutely phenomenal experience. Service is top notch. Drinks are exquisite. (Get the bean counter, you will fall in love) Atmosphere stopped me in my tracks when I walked through the door and is second to none in the area. Did not try the food our first time around but 1000% will be back to do so. I imagine I will be here often, and if the food is anything like the rest it will be perfect.

Mary Bradshaw Duncan

There are comfortable couches and club chairs set about the setting of an antique bank complete with money vault left in place adding to the lounge decor. Savannah our server made all our choices clear because I wasn't used to cocktail flights and smoked drinks. I enjoyed the tequila flight, charcuterie board and hamburger sliders with bacon jam. I am considering having my 70th birthday in the private room upstairs where you just order $500 worth of cocktails and food. Everyone around us was having a very happy time. The menu changes seasonally.

Jourdan Duryea

So happy to have a true Cocktail Lounge (and Sunday Brunch) spot in the area! Highly recommend spending the afternoon trying *almost* every cocktail on the menu with a group of friends or one of their tequila tasting flight options! You also cannot go wrong with their house made Bloody Mary on a Sunday. This is truly an experience centered and detail oriented establishment from the moment you open the door.

Andy Linares

Brunch was great. Drinks were great. Service was outstanding. Place is beautiful and super comfortable. An hour from home, but I’ll be back!

Kathleen Cole

Unforgettable experience! From the moment I stepped through the entrance, I was transported back in time to the Prohibition era. The ambiance was spot-on. The cocktails were absolutely top-notch visually and in terms of flavor. The mixologist, Phil clearly has a passion for his craft! I highly recommend trying the Private Banker or the vast collection of Bourbons & Tequilas. The Reserve is a gem that’s perfect for a night out with friends or a special date. I can’t wait to return and explore more of their inventive cocktail menu. Highly recommend!!

Carolyn Hoffman

Our bartender Jen was wonderful! We shared a bourbon tasting flight and an order of Duck Fat Fries. The sherry aoli is superb!! We will be back for a full dinner.

Eric Posner

Here for the first time and The Reserve did not disappoint! Everything was great and food was absolutely amazing!! Compliments to the chef and staff for an incredible place.

Nicole Molino

Literally every drink on the menu is amazing- even if it’s a liquor you don’t typically like, you will probably like it here. 10/10 ambiance and service. This spot is a must try!

Dylan Nelson

The Reserve is one of the best cocktail bar environments I have ever been to. Located in an old bank, it has an old school feel with very unique drink choices. The staff was very friendly and the food paired perfectly with the cocktails. I ordered an old fashioned and they were able to user a smoker to give it incredible flavor. I'll definitely becoming back and highly recommend it to anyone who’s into cocktails

Jillian Dulaney

Cocktails were delicious! Food was perfect for a nice small bite! Atmosphere was fantastic!!! 10/10 recommend!!! I loved everything about my experience

Kayleigh Banse

One of my favorite places to grab a drink with a friend or multiple friends.The atmosphere here is unmatched by any other place in the area. I’ve tried multiple drinks on the menu and my personal favorite is the 1929 spritz !! It’s so refreshing.

Mia Ambrosini

Absolutely phenomenal experience. Service is top notch. Drinks are exquisite. (Get the bean counter, you will fall in love) Atmosphere stopped me in my tracks when I walked through the door and is second to none in the area. Did not try the food our first time around but 1000% will be back to do so. I imagine I will be here often, and if the food is anything like the rest it will be perfect.

Shafkat Haque

This is an incredible spot me and my wife found! We did a little cabin getaway and were looking for a bar, instead we ended up finding this speakeasy. I got the Tommy Gun and man was I blown away. These drinks are incredible and so are their bites. The staff is very welcoming and friendly- 10/10 would recommend to anyone in the area!

China Serpe

Amazing place! a recently opened place in our area - loved the vibes of the place, and the food/drinks are AMAZING. Had the best drink of my life here, the Ruby Reserve. 10/10, would come here 1000x more!

We had a wonderful experience at The Reserve! The atmosphere was fantastic, and it served as the perfect backdrop for our family celebration. A special thank you to our server, Alyssa, for making our visit so enjoyable. She was incredibly professional and attentive, ensuring we had everything we needed throughout our meal. Her friendly demeanor and excellent service truly elevated our evening. She was very patient and accommodating with our children, which made our family dinner much more relaxed and pleasant.

Reserve Bar in Port Jervis is a gem! 🥂 The atmosphere is classy but still comfortable — perfect for date night or a night out with friends. Their drink selection is on point, with creative cocktails, wine choices, and solid bartending. The service is attentive and friendly, so you never feel rushed or ignored. Whether you’re there for a nightcap or a full evening of drinks and conversation, Reserve Bar delivers. Highly recommend giving it a try!

10/10 – Exceptional Experience at The Reserve in Port Jervis! From start to finish, my visit to The Reserve, in Port Jervis was nothing short of amazing. I can’t recommend it enough – it deserves a solid **10+ out of 10**! The service was top-notch – attentive, friendly, and knowledgeable. The staff made us feel right at home without being overbearing, and you could tell they genuinely care about giving you the best dining experience. The food was absolutely delicious. Every dish was crafted with care, and you could taste the high quality of ingredients. Whether you’re a fan of classic flavors or more adventurous options, The Reserve offers something for everyone. As for the atmosphere, it perfectly balances modern elegance with historic charm. They’ve done an incredible job preserving the original vibe of the space while adding contemporary touches. It feels like stepping into a piece of history, with a warmth and comfort that makes you want to linger. If you're in the area, do yourself a favor and make a reservation – you won’t be disappointed!

Drinks and food are outstanding. I love the unique selections for drinks. Happy to have upscale cocktail options locally at an affordable price

Manny Quinzi

Reserve Bar in Port Jervis is a gem! 🥂 The atmosphere is classy but still comfortable — perfect for date night or a night out with friends. Their drink selection is on point, with creative cocktails, wine choices, and solid bartending. The service is attentive and friendly, so you never feel rushed or ignored. Whether you’re there for a nightcap or a full evening of drinks and conversation, Reserve Bar delivers. Highly recommend giving it a try!

jonathan tatis

10/10 – Exceptional Experience at The Reserve in Port Jervis! From start to finish, my visit to The Reserve, in Port Jervis was nothing short of amazing. I can’t recommend it enough – it deserves a solid **10+ out of 10**! The service was top-notch – attentive, friendly, and knowledgeable. The staff made us feel right at home without being overbearing, and you could tell they genuinely care about giving you the best dining experience. The food was absolutely delicious. Every dish was crafted with care, and you could taste the high quality of ingredients. Whether you’re a fan of classic flavors or more adventurous options, The Reserve offers something for everyone. As for the atmosphere, it perfectly balances modern elegance with historic charm. They’ve done an incredible job preserving the original vibe of the space while adding contemporary touches. It feels like stepping into a piece of history, with a warmth and comfort that makes you want to linger. If you're in the area, do yourself a favor and make a reservation – you won’t be disappointed!

Jessica Hurley

Excellent Atmosphere, Outstanding Service, and Flavorful Food I visited The Reserve about a week ago after hearing great things through word of mouth—and I’m glad I did! The setting is upscale and welcoming, with a really polished vibe that made a great first impression. I was greeted right away by Phil, who was professional, kind, and super helpful. He guided me through the menu and made sure I was taken care of from the start. The menu is a bit selective, which I understand, and since I don’t eat meat (except for poultry), I decided to try the truffle fries—and they did not disappoint! They were flavorful, crisp, and truly enjoyable. I also had the pleasure of meeting CJ, one of the chefs. He was extremely professional, friendly, and carried himself with great mannerism. It’s always a bonus when the kitchen staff is just as engaging as the front-of-house. Overall, my experience at The Reserve was excellent. Great food, great people, and a great atmosphere—I’ll definitely be back!

The Reserve evokes a 1930s, speak-easy ambience. Located in a former bank, the main area is a giant cube with a soar-away ceiling. Low profile couches and armchairs form comfortable islands for conversation. In short, The Reserve is a really cool place to hangout and the drinks were good.

Craig McKay

The Reserve evokes a 1930s, speak-easy ambience. Located in a former bank, the main area is a giant cube with a soar-away ceiling. Low profile couches and armchairs form comfortable islands for conversation. In short, The Reserve is a really cool place to hangout and the drinks were good.

Bill Thoet

Beautiful bar in downtown Port Jervis. Has an incredible selection and very personable staff. Might be a little upscale for Port Jervis and the prices are near Manhattan, so I fear it might have a hard time surviving.

Not a bad spot...will venture back. Our sever was sooo busy as I elive she wqs the only one on staff at the tine but she was pleasant and as attentive as she could be conaidering. Brunch was our first experience. The expresso martini flight was good. I tried the eggs Benedict (without the hollandaise sauce...not a sauce fan) trio and was OK with it. We will revisit for an evening out to see what it is like. Be prepared to do a lot of reaching as the seats are low along with the tables.

Nathaniel Prunetree

Not a bad spot...will venture back. Our sever was sooo busy as I elive she wqs the only one on staff at the tine but she was pleasant and as attentive as she could be conaidering. Brunch was our first experience. The expresso martini flight was good. I tried the eggs Benedict (without the hollandaise sauce...not a sauce fan) trio and was OK with it. We will revisit for an evening out to see what it is like. Be prepared to do a lot of reaching as the seats are low along with the tables.

food, drinks and atmosphere are great. unfortunately the service is horrible. i’ve given this place so many chances and the service is horrible everytime. they are rarely busy, and still the waitresses and drinks take 15 minutes. I was just there with one other person for brunch, we were the only people there other than a few at the bar. and nobody came to take our order for 25 minutes. i ended up having to go to the bar to place it, and than it took another 10 minutes to get the drinks. by the time we got the drinks we were just over it and didnt even want to order food anymore.

Unfortunately you HAVE to sit at the bar to get semi appropriate service. My cousin and I who both have worked in hospitality for many years walked in around 7:45pm on a SATURDAY night, was sat, and were ignored for over 10-15 minutes, we then made the decision to leave. There was one party and a couple of people at the bar. This is a prime example on why businesses are not successful in this town. Also if you go to brunch just know they stop serving food at 5pm on Sundays as that is not advertised either. The food is good, drinks are great, but just know you will be waiting and not given the appropriate attention. On a business perspective this isn’t a good look.

Mia Gentile

Unfortunately you HAVE to sit at the bar to get semi appropriate service. My cousin and I who both have worked in hospitality for many years walked in around 7:45pm on a SATURDAY night, was sat, and were ignored for over 10-15 minutes, we then made the decision to leave. There was one party and a couple of people at the bar. This is a prime example on why businesses are not successful in this town. Also if you go to brunch just know they stop serving food at 5pm on Sundays as that is not advertised either. The food is good, drinks are great, but just know you will be waiting and not given the appropriate attention. On a business perspective this isn’t a good look.