Stormville Pizza

Moved into area loving pizza and gave this a shot. Best slice around! People are nice and good is great. Most try.

Small place but delicious food definitely worth a trip. Pizza is the best around and you can get a big slice, it's kind of like a trademark it's a huge delicious slice.

One of the biggest slices you'll buy! They're not kidding when they say it's home of the giant slice. The pizza is decent though, and the service is good.

Huge slice, huge taste. Supporting local restaurants is always easier when their food taste great. Hours may vary and seating is limited due to recent restrictions.

Very good pizza. So worth the visit every time.

First time customer, pizza was excellent, not doughey, thin crust, very nice tasting sauce. Was very busy inside. Will go there again and again.

This pizza is delicious. The mega slice is a bargain. Fast, friendly service. CLEAN bathrooms. Sort of a local hangout. Which is always a good sign.

The giant slice was awesome, staff was super awesome and supportive. I will be back to get some more thank you!

Best Pizza on Empire State Trail. Don’t forget to try the Giant Slice. Very friendly folks, pizza that you could only hope to get in NYC.

First time ordering. Grandma's Pizza was out of this world! I have a pizza place across from my house.... I won't be ordering from them again 😁 Stormville Pizza is excellent 👌

Went back to Stormville for the GIANT slice. So so good. Probably the best slice I have had in a long time around the area!

Still a great place to get a slice, and when I say a slice I mean a HUGE slice. Good pizza great value.

Great food! I was quite impressed.

I have been eating here since I was a teenager with my friends. Now I have a wife and kids and we drive past a bunch of other pizza places to eat here. My family loves it.

An amazing pizza place with kind owners. I've been going since I could walk! Always a treat to get a taste of the GIANT SLICE that fills you up immediately!

Living in the south now... miss stopping by with the big truck at lunch time for a huge slice and a cold drink... delicious *** up for a visit 5/17/19 !!! Awesome!!

The best slice I've had in YEARS!

Absolutely love they dont call it the home of the giant slice for nothing just amazing a most try spot in the Hudson valley.

Hugo G

Great food! I was quite impressed.

Michael David

I have been eating here since I was a teenager with my friends. Now I have a wife and kids and we drive past a bunch of other pizza places to eat here. My family loves it.

Allycat 118

An amazing pizza place with kind owners. I've been going since I could walk! Always a treat to get a taste of the GIANT SLICE that fills you up immediately!

Dwayne Kunkel

Living in the south now... miss stopping by with the big truck at lunch time for a huge slice and a cold drink... delicious *** up for a visit 5/17/19 !!! Awesome!!

Gabriel Ureña

The best slice I've had in YEARS!

Gina parent

Absolutely love they dont call it the home of the giant slice for nothing just amazing a most try spot in the Hudson valley.

As always a beautiful huge slice of pizza with lots of flavor. Friendly atmosphere.

Some very good pizza and superior service. LARGE slices. I walked in there very hungry and ordered 2 slices. The person behind the counter asked," 2? Are you sure?" I was wondering, what, am I sure? Yes! Then they brought the slices out and I understood. I had to bring one home in a box. Delicious LARGE slices. The staff was great, professional and very courteous. Highly recommend. Especially after attending the Stormville flea market.

It’s been ages since I have been here. I grew up on this place haha!! A few weeks ago I stopped by and ordered the famous plain slice. As I was eagerly waiting, I thought to myself I wonder if it still taste the same when I was a kid…. Then I got the famous large slice handed to me, took a bite.. yupppp!! The exact same taste when I was a kid. If you’re looking for an authentic amazing slice, with an unforgettable experience, this is the spot!!

By far the best pizza in upstate NY and probably NYC too. Nice GIANT slices and the taste is absolute heaven. My go to spot to stop for a bite whenever I'm near Stormville, NY. Great food and beer.

Joann S

As always a beautiful huge slice of pizza with lots of flavor. Friendly atmosphere.

Thomas M

Some very good pizza and superior service. LARGE slices. I walked in there very hungry and ordered 2 slices. The person behind the counter asked," 2? Are you sure?" I was wondering, what, am I sure? Yes! Then they brought the slices out and I understood. I had to bring one home in a box. Delicious LARGE slices. The staff was great, professional and very courteous. Highly recommend. Especially after attending the Stormville flea market.

Florence Pellegrino

It’s been ages since I have been here. I grew up on this place haha!! A few weeks ago I stopped by and ordered the famous plain slice. As I was eagerly waiting, I thought to myself I wonder if it still taste the same when I was a kid…. Then I got the famous large slice handed to me, took a bite.. yupppp!! The exact same taste when I was a kid. If you’re looking for an authentic amazing slice, with an unforgettable experience, this is the spot!!

Unique Gore

By far the best pizza in upstate NY and probably NYC too. Nice GIANT slices and the taste is absolute heaven. My go to spot to stop for a bite whenever I'm near Stormville, NY. Great food and beer.

Really big slices of pizza!!😜

Pizza was great. Service was excellent especially because I take forever to order when it's not italian owned. Yes, I stereotype.

The GIANT slice was very tasty! Worth the trip! Can't wait to try something else!

Steve B

The GIANT slice was very tasty! Worth the trip! Can't wait to try something else!

I tried the renowned "Super Slice" for $4.95, $5.35, with tax. It was good. I give the slice a 5 out of 5. I'll submit another rating pending future visits.

Jack LoBianco

I tried the renowned "Super Slice" for $4.95, $5.35, with tax. It was good. I give the slice a 5 out of 5. I'll submit another rating pending future visits.

We ordered a large pie and for a large pie it was rather small. Taste wise it was just okay. I’ve tasted way better elsewhere.

We came in for giant slice of pizza and a beer which we do every time we visit New York and I have to say it's not the same the sauce and cheese didn't taste as a good maybe using cheap ingredients.Dont care to go out of my way again!! Quality is everything!!

I'm always ordering from them, The guy who I'm guessing either owns it or is a manager is super nice! I'm always getting chicken fingers and fries and they're really good, Pizza is good but the calamari, didn't really hit home for me. Calamari is easy to mess up, I get it, but they looked like tiny onion rings and were rubbery as heck. I'm a seafood LOVER, so I'm very picky with how seafood is prepared. I'm still going to continue getting food from there, just not the calamari

victoria ragu

I'm always ordering from them, The guy who I'm guessing either owns it or is a manager is super nice! I'm always getting chicken fingers and fries and they're really good, Pizza is good but the calamari, didn't really hit home for me. Calamari is easy to mess up, I get it, but they looked like tiny onion rings and were rubbery as heck. I'm a seafood LOVER, so I'm very picky with how seafood is prepared. I'm still going to continue getting food from there, just not the calamari

Pizza was good but over price why over price cuz its the price they have on the wall for a lager pie was 14.50 I got a L pie and a 2 liter soda and I payed 21 dollars, wa I got look like a small pie , so I find it over price

I actually give them 1 1/2 stars because when I walked in there were two guys working. They both glanced at me, didn't acknowledge me until I said something to them. Then it was what will you have and then nothing. Can anyone say "customer service "? Oh, wait this family walks in and their glance turns to smiles and "hi, what can I do for you?" And conversation. Okay. The pizza comes and for some reason it's bland. Maybe I'm just used to the taste of N.Y.C. pizza. But no, I've eaten pizza in other states and it's this place only. They get the 1 1/2 because they're slices are the largest I've ever had.

Mikal Smith

I actually give them 1 1/2 stars because when I walked in there were two guys working. They both glanced at me, didn't acknowledge me until I said something to them. Then it was what will you have and then nothing. Can anyone say "customer service "? Oh, wait this family walks in and their glance turns to smiles and "hi, what can I do for you?" And conversation. Okay. The pizza comes and for some reason it's bland. Maybe I'm just used to the taste of N.Y.C. pizza. But no, I've eaten pizza in other states and it's this place only. They get the 1 1/2 because they're slices are the largest I've ever had.

Donny is a pretty good guy, unfortunately he has allowed his immigrant labor to run the store. A certain employee is absolutely horrible and I can't believe that he has not been fired. He is horrible with dealing with customers. He constantly gets orders wrong. He pretends he doesnt see you when you walk in. On top of that he constantly overcharges at the register. How hard is it to charge the price that the menu says? I'm not sure if this is incompetence or if this extra money is being sent home. Please get rid of this guy and I will start coming there again.

Stopped in for the first time today, will be my last. Two men were behind the counter. They both ignored my presence, they never acknowledged me. While I was waiting one of them who was at the food prep area making something took napkins and wiped the sweat from his head, over the food, no gloves, didn't stop to wash his hands and went back to what he was doing, absolutely disgusting. I walked out.

Stormville pizza used to be very good... ate there today got 2 slices and order of knots.... the knots are so dry and bland they taste pre made... the pizza did not have nearly enough cheese and it was horrible tasting.... and way over priced.

I ordered a chicken parm pie yesterday and was eating the leftovers today when I see hair in the slice. It’s a thin black longish piece of hair. Please wear hairnets people this is disgusting. It’s embedded in the cheese… I cannot believe I paid $25 for this.

I hope this isn’t what you guys put out everyday

Toadette I

I ordered a chicken parm pie yesterday and was eating the leftovers today when I see hair in the slice. It’s a thin black longish piece of hair. Please wear hairnets people this is disgusting. It’s embedded in the cheese… I cannot believe I paid $25 for this.

Lucky Luciano

I hope this isn’t what you guys put out everyday

Food was overpriced. Felt rushed to pay while I waited for my. Wasn't informed of upcharges and didn't even get my complete order. There was more sauce and cheese in the sandwich than chicken. Will never go back.

I ordered a sandwich which had brown wilted lettuce on it (didn't notice until halfway through). I was sick for the next 18 hours or so. Even if it wasn't the lettuce that made me sick (it was the lettuce) this place still deserves 1 star for serving the grossest produce.

I live down the road so I called in three plain slices to go. Whoever took my order, did it incorrectly they told me 20 minutes I knew something was wrong. I got there and I said to the guy three plain slices I just called in. He told me 10 minutes. I thought maybe they had a big party going on and backed up that they didn’t have plain slices left 10 more minutes on top of the five it took me to get there I waited. The kid walks over with three pies. I said what is that? I ordered three slices. I further had to wait five more minutes for them to just pull out a pie that I can have three slices to go. The guy charged me $16 for three slices. I will never come here again even if the food tastes good. Worst service I ever encountered. I felt bad they made 3 pies for no reason but that’s not my fault I reiterated 3 slices.

This alleged pizza shop sets a world record for being the absolute worst pizza parlor on the East Coast. They brag about large slices. Their large slices are not a bargain when they're almost $5. Only a half a mile away I can get two slices of beautiful pizza for the same price. If a food establishment looks like a dump when you walk in you can only imagine how unsanitary their food is being prepared. I just can't believe anyone is a repeat customer of this disgusting establishment. Food is lousy service lousy decor and ambience does not exist.

Shakeef Bailey

Food was overpriced. Felt rushed to pay while I waited for my. Wasn't informed of upcharges and didn't even get my complete order. There was more sauce and cheese in the sandwich than chicken. Will never go back.

K

I ordered a sandwich which had brown wilted lettuce on it (didn't notice until halfway through). I was sick for the next 18 hours or so. Even if it wasn't the lettuce that made me sick (it was the lettuce) this place still deserves 1 star for serving the grossest produce.

Tabitha

I live down the road so I called in three plain slices to go. Whoever took my order, did it incorrectly they told me 20 minutes I knew something was wrong. I got there and I said to the guy three plain slices I just called in. He told me 10 minutes. I thought maybe they had a big party going on and backed up that they didn’t have plain slices left 10 more minutes on top of the five it took me to get there I waited. The kid walks over with three pies. I said what is that? I ordered three slices. I further had to wait five more minutes for them to just pull out a pie that I can have three slices to go. The guy charged me $16 for three slices. I will never come here again even if the food tastes good. Worst service I ever encountered. I felt bad they made 3 pies for no reason but that’s not my fault I reiterated 3 slices.

pissedcow

This alleged pizza shop sets a world record for being the absolute worst pizza parlor on the East Coast. They brag about large slices. Their large slices are not a bargain when they're almost $5. Only a half a mile away I can get two slices of beautiful pizza for the same price. If a food establishment looks like a dump when you walk in you can only imagine how unsanitary their food is being prepared. I just can't believe anyone is a repeat customer of this disgusting establishment. Food is lousy service lousy decor and ambience does not exist.