Rob Oatman

We had considered this place a few times and finally got around to it. The dining room is nice. The pepperoni pizza was LOADED with cheese. Yummy, yummy. I almost ate too much. The fries were zesty, but came out after the pizza. They were also served with ketchup that had turned brown inside its packets. Room for improvement there. No fountain drinks available, either. But the pizza was in the top half of all I have tasted this year. Really good.

+4

Hack3D

Nice place, food was pretty good 4 star food. 3% charge on debit purchase and tip request on a pick up order lost a star.

Michael Cutro

Stop here for a quick bite to eat. In palaski New York, I did not have their pizza. I tried a meatball parmesan sandwich. I thought the bread was good, but the meatballs were not up to my liking. I would give this place a rating of 3 stars again. It was my first time going there.

David Duryea

Ordered takeout. Pizza is mediocre and very greasy. Wings not at all crispy and sauce has a sweet element not typically found in NY hot wings which we didn't like. I would not return.

Fur-Elise Fortney

I order delivery and every single time they forget the blue cheese for the wings that I'm ordering and paying for and the ranch. 5th time now that this has happened and despite the continuous mistake. I called to complain and I'm told theirs absolutely nothing they can do because they are too busy. Update. One year later. I ordered a large pizza, wings, a steak sub and buffalo bites with a side of garlic butter..... the sub was amazing. Absolutely no complaints there. It was well cooked. Flavorful and Absolutely delish. The wings as well... 100% on point. They also remembered my sauce cups. However, how the hell does a place like this recieve an order for buffalo bites and add no buffalo sauce? Make it makes sense. And why is their more mushrooms than meat on a sausage, pepperoni, and mushroom pizza?

Princess Sugar

I try my best to always be fair and honest with every Google review I make and attempt to review every establishment and location I visit. We recently stayed 10 days near Sandy Island and one day had a craving for pizza. After looking online, we decided to try Paulanjo's Pizza. We were split on our opinion in regards to the pizza. My husband didn't mind it, but we both agreed it was a little 'gummy'. Perhaps a bit undercooked or too much of the chunky sauce. I know pizza is one of those items that everyone has a wide range of preferences on. Personally, I prefer a crispy style crust, but this type of pizza is better eaten with a fork and knife. The dining room was comfortable. There were a few pieces of artwork that gave me a good laugh. The main reason for my below average review, however, is neither based on a reflection of the food or service but the bathroom. After eating, I needed to use the restroom and was a bit grossed out. Nearly every surface was filthy. Had I used the bathroom prior to ordering our food, I honestly would have suggested another place to eat. The bathroom door was supposed to be white but was nearly black from handprint marks. The toilet and sink were covered in grime. There was a horrible smell, and the walls too were covered in a thick layer of dust, cobwebs, and dead bugs. I realize that Pulaski is a well-known fishing village, but when you go somewhere to eat, you would expect it to feel clean. I hope this review encourages staff to take this into consideration. A good scrub and deep clean, fixing some maintenance issues, and checking each pizza to ensure consistency and quality, I think, could make Paulanjo's a great option to eat. I would be willing to give this place another shot this summer if some changes are made and update my review.

Christopher Cangello

Dont oder delivery. They cant get it right. Weve ordered a number of times. This last time was 2 pizzas extra cheese and the there were bare spots. Ordered 6 blue cheese to go with all the wings and got one. I called and they best thwy could do was make excuses and offer a six dollar credit. The worst part is this order was 100 bucks...2 pizzas and 20 wings thats it so yeah they are expensive on top of it. Im not one to waste my time on social medai or making review comments. But when you take my money for yoir over priced junk and then blow me off basically, you deserve a black eye. Customer service is a lost art and definitely lost on these folks. We will go down the street to the competition from now on. Unfortunate considering we order several times a month and larger orders.

Dee LePorte

I ordered a pizza to be delivered at 5:30 pm. I was told that it would be delivered within 30 minutes. I called back an hour later and was informed that it was out for delivery. Finally at 6:50 pm it arrived barely warm. I was told that there were 7 deliveries before mine. Nice. I will not order from Paulanjos again. Sad. I've been a customer for decades.😡

Guy Race

Ordered a pizza sub and 20 wings the sub came with absolutely no sauce or cheese worst pizza sub I have ever ate wings were good but for 47 bucks plus’s drivers tip of 12 bucks was the worst 59 bucks I have ever spent. I’d rather go to DG and get a hot pocket. I used to order from here a lot but every time the quality goes down and prices go up

Kyle Starr

Nothing home made. My buddy n I both got 12" tuna . Worst $18 dollar with a soda tuna I ever tried to eat in my 50 years. My other buddy got some kind of salad said it was Awful too. Maybe the pizza 🍕 is good but I won't be back. Was going to get a meatball sub I asked if they where homemade they said NO. Cheese sticks where good but cold. Frys where good but not many. They need to step up the fresh food game.