Pizzeria 40 grados

Pretty good pizza...not too thin and not too thick. Just the right amount of toppings so as to not overwhelm and take away from it being an actual pizza. The Philly Cheesesteak fries are amazing as well ! There is a kiddie area for kids to make a pretend pizza as well (my son loved it). We were told that once a month there is a kids night where kids can even design and make their own actual pizza! Sweet! The staff (including Jen the manager😊) were so accommodating and amazing...even separating the cheese, fries and Philly Cheesesteak filling for us to reheat when we were at our rental (with directions to boot). Would definitely recommend...you will not be disappointed 😄

Pizza was absolutely delicious, best quick option overall! And the staff were super kind, nice and helpful. Definitely would recommend and want to try again another time.

My husband absolutely loves this place. Really unique pizzas with amazing flavors, hand made pasta and very fresh ingredients. His favorite is The Piggy BBQ pizza dipped in Honey Datil Pepper sauce. What he brought me home to try was super yummy. Good prices and the owner is really cool and interacts with the guests. Definitely our new favorite spot.

Great pizza. Reasonable prices. They also have a good gluten-free pizza.

+3

This place is Amazing!! Same GREAT PIZZA, under new ownership! It all starts with the BEST sauce! Fresh, cooked for 4 hours.. The pizza crust is just right not too thick, and perfectly crispy! Joey says the beer and wine license is coming soon and some added TV’s for entertainment! Our realty group, One Florida Group with eXp has named this a LOCAL FAV! The sticker is on the door! Go in and indulge in the experience!

Ordered a small El Greco. Wife ordered I believe the fettuccine garlic & oil pasta. We shared 3 garlic knots. Super great pizza and knots. Plenty of toppings. Probably the best or at least top two crusts I've had of this style. Great flavor. Wife liked the pasta. The garlic knots are hardcore with tons of fresh minced garlic, which is awesome. Definitely recommend! Upon further review (i.e. I just finished the entire pizza by myself....) I think the El Greco pizza is one of the top....3? Best pizzas I've ever had. What a lovely pie.

Food was amazing!!!!! All fresh!!!! Ordered: Lasagna Carbonara Fettuccine Cheese pizza Margarita pizza Garlic knots Caesar pizza

This pizza will transport you back to New York specially their Ultimate Pepperoni was a masterpiece. Do yourself a favor and check this place out. Kenneth Smith from Signa pay Southeast. POS Systems.

Food is absolutely fresh! Customer Service is phenomenal. Made a last minute split decision to search up a pizza place on Google, and it spewed out this gem in St. Augustine. The General Manager is awesome, and his crew goes above and beyond to make sure that the Customers have excellent food and service. We went in hangry, with two baby girls that were restless and we were all tired and it turned a stressful trip to St. Augustine into a peaceful, pleasant and enjoyable evening. Don’t deprive yourself of indulging in the food here or the feeling of family when you come to this location. I would challenge anyone to go here and bet they will have a very similar experience. Thank you all! I didn’t forget about you and the next time we’re in the area, will prioritize coming back for more great food and laughs.

This little hole in the wall is my favorite pizza in Jacksonville/St. Augustine. Loved the wings! Garlic knots are delicious, and we never had a pizza we didn't like from here! The dough they use for their pizzas is our favorite part; we always wish we had more crust! They've nailed every part of their pizza, and I highly recommend trying it out! Note that the dining room is very cozy. We primarily order out, so it's not an issue for us. Hope you enjoy as much as we do!

Everything was so fresh. Sauce was awesome, pizza was great and the kids play area was genius! Small little spot with bomb pizza and pasta.

1st time Ordered pizza through door dash and I haven’t found a good NY style pizza since moving to Florida. This was the best pizza I’ve had in Florida. It is so good the crust and flavors are 1000000000/10. Definitely going to be my go to pizza place. Just left there tonight 3/28/2025 : Ate with my family for my birthday, and the customer service is exceptional. What pleasant and kind staff they’re so nice. This is now my families go to pizza place. We love it ! It was such a nice time. Thank you for everything

I really enjoyed my pizza! Would definitely recommend getting the white pizza. I also enjoyed how the salad croutons were fried dough.

This pizza joint satisfied every member of our family, even the picky eater who won't touch tomatoes and dairy-allergic me. Everything is freshly made, and the pizza, fries, and salad were delicious. The service was very friendly and conscientious about my food issues. Definitely worth traveling a few minutes outside of the historic district!

Great food. Love the white pizza. Love Courtney! She makes the dining experience really enjoyable.

Stopped in while out of our area and I’m so glad we did! Some of the best pizza hands down and the garlic knots were delicious. The sauce and dough was on point. Mckinley (not sure if that’s how it’s spelled) was outstanding and made the visit that much better. They even had a play corner for kids which really helped out since I was here with my 2 8 year olds, 2 3 year olds and a 6 month old. We would 100% stop in again if we’re within 30minutes. Give them a try, you won’t be disappointed.

Ok so when you first pull up its like there’s nothing around, dead strip of businesses after hours. (Dr offices, realtors) there were 3 cars in the parking lot. I was skeptical. We were recommended to eat there so we decided to keep heading in. Inside very clean, 3people working. 4 booths and a couple table setups, one huge oven and the back. At this time they serve pizza and pasta. We ordered the supreme. Pep/onion/green peppers/ mushroom. They hand toss the dough too. We were greeted by the manager, Tiago, who is from NY and two other gentlemen . They are super friendly and even remembered our friends who were in the other day that recommended them, which was cool. (Customer recognition goes a long way). We paid and sat down and while we were waiting Tiago brought us some garlic knots to try. The sauce they use is great. Perfect combination of sweet , tomato and saucy! Garlic knots were perfectly cooked. Pizza came out promptly. They brought it over to us, and got us plates/silverware (even though it was out for us to grab ourselves) First glance, pizza is HUGE! Crust was perfectly cooked- not hard as a rock but not soggy. Right thickness. Veggies were fresh! Sauce was awesome. You could fold the pizza with ease. Not too greasy but just enough to give that NY style flavor . I’d recommend this place over other local pizza places such as Antonio’s, 1000% over pizza chains and even comparable to Tony D’s Brooklyn pizza. (I’ll be back to try their margarita pizza for full comparison to them) While we were eating, Tiago came out and chatted with us. We swapped food experiences etc. he then brought out a Datil pepper wing sauce he makes for their wings, along with a house made ranch sauce to sample. First taste of the wing sauce was “oh this is sweet tasting” then BAM! Hits you with the kick. Paired with the ranch, that also has a sweetness, perfection. A little too spicy for me but those who like spice would probably love it. I’d probably actually try it again on wings . We ended our food experience with some Gelato. Yummy!!!! Overall I’ll give it a 10/10. We’re going to order pizza for our wedding for the kids from them as well and will definitely be back for more food. They are working on adding subs, so keep them in mind!!

I’ve been meaning to post something in here about 900 Degrees Pizza & Pasta for the longest time… We order in lunch from there ALL the time at work, and it is always incredible. I like mine well-done, which is how the pie in this picture was prepared. The folks that work there (the owner especially) are genuine, and really care about the quality of the stuff that leaves their door. If you’ve never had it, highly recommend eating there for your first time. Some of the best pizza in St. Augustine, blows the DOORS off most places that I hear listed as the “best”. Also, their honey datil chicken wings are the BOMB.

Hidden little gem! Amazing Stromboli’s! They will make it with anything you want in it! This is off the menu though. Their sauce is homemade and amazing. Garlic and parm on top is delicious! Waitstaff is super attentive and fast!

Update 06/05/24: I now live in NC and am in town for only a few days. I decided to pick up pizza on the way back to my air BNB and it reminded me of why I love this place. The employees are just so sweet and the canned wine is dope. Purchases the piggy pizza and a pepperoni, and both were prepared perfectly. They smell amazing and the pepperoni's I stole off my sister's pizza were delicious. Please support them however you can. The only other pizza in town I like is five star anytime between 9pm and 3am. Finally. Delicious pizza that isn't in downtown STA. I will shamefully admit this is our second time eating this in a week. First had a delivery from DoorDash, and went in to eat today as we are now fully vaccinated. The place is small, clean, and adorable. They have a selection of soft drinks, water, and beer. They might have wine, but I didn't notice. The owner and staff are super friendly, and exactly what you want from a lovely pizza place. Both times we ordered the Piggy pizza. AMAZING. Delicious delivered and fresh. We also had the white pizza delivered, and tried the ultimate pepperoni in house. The crust was delicious, toppings delicious. My husband, who hates mushrooms, loved the mushrooms. Garlic knots were also very good. The personal size is certainly enough for two, but why not get one for each person? I am now in love with this place, and am trying to figure out when I'll order again, while my husband is driving home and we have a whole pizza in the backseat. I would definitely recommend trying it out.

Thomas Ranaldi

Stopped in while out of our area and I’m so glad we did! Some of the best pizza hands down and the garlic knots were delicious. The sauce and dough was on point. Mckinley (not sure if that’s how it’s spelled) was outstanding and made the visit that much better. They even had a play corner for kids which really helped out since I was here with my 2 8 year olds, 2 3 year olds and a 6 month old. We would 100% stop in again if we’re within 30minutes. Give them a try, you won’t be disappointed.

Jen Weeks

Ok so when you first pull up its like there’s nothing around, dead strip of businesses after hours. (Dr offices, realtors) there were 3 cars in the parking lot. I was skeptical. We were recommended to eat there so we decided to keep heading in. Inside very clean, 3people working. 4 booths and a couple table setups, one huge oven and the back. At this time they serve pizza and pasta. We ordered the supreme. Pep/onion/green peppers/ mushroom. They hand toss the dough too. We were greeted by the manager, Tiago, who is from NY and two other gentlemen . They are super friendly and even remembered our friends who were in the other day that recommended them, which was cool. (Customer recognition goes a long way). We paid and sat down and while we were waiting Tiago brought us some garlic knots to try. The sauce they use is great. Perfect combination of sweet , tomato and saucy! Garlic knots were perfectly cooked. Pizza came out promptly. They brought it over to us, and got us plates/silverware (even though it was out for us to grab ourselves) First glance, pizza is HUGE! Crust was perfectly cooked- not hard as a rock but not soggy. Right thickness. Veggies were fresh! Sauce was awesome. You could fold the pizza with ease. Not too greasy but just enough to give that NY style flavor . I’d recommend this place over other local pizza places such as Antonio’s, 1000% over pizza chains and even comparable to Tony D’s Brooklyn pizza. (I’ll be back to try their margarita pizza for full comparison to them) While we were eating, Tiago came out and chatted with us. We swapped food experiences etc. he then brought out a Datil pepper wing sauce he makes for their wings, along with a house made ranch sauce to sample. First taste of the wing sauce was “oh this is sweet tasting” then BAM! Hits you with the kick. Paired with the ranch, that also has a sweetness, perfection. A little too spicy for me but those who like spice would probably love it. I’d probably actually try it again on wings . We ended our food experience with some Gelato. Yummy!!!! Overall I’ll give it a 10/10. We’re going to order pizza for our wedding for the kids from them as well and will definitely be back for more food. They are working on adding subs, so keep them in mind!!

Zach Gibbs

I’ve been meaning to post something in here about 900 Degrees Pizza & Pasta for the longest time… We order in lunch from there ALL the time at work, and it is always incredible. I like mine well-done, which is how the pie in this picture was prepared. The folks that work there (the owner especially) are genuine, and really care about the quality of the stuff that leaves their door. If you’ve never had it, highly recommend eating there for your first time. Some of the best pizza in St. Augustine, blows the DOORS off most places that I hear listed as the “best”. Also, their honey datil chicken wings are the BOMB.

Jennifer Szukala

Hidden little gem! Amazing Stromboli’s! They will make it with anything you want in it! This is off the menu though. Their sauce is homemade and amazing. Garlic and parm on top is delicious! Waitstaff is super attentive and fast!

Chelsea Gibson

Update 06/05/24: I now live in NC and am in town for only a few days. I decided to pick up pizza on the way back to my air BNB and it reminded me of why I love this place. The employees are just so sweet and the canned wine is dope. Purchases the piggy pizza and a pepperoni, and both were prepared perfectly. They smell amazing and the pepperoni's I stole off my sister's pizza were delicious. Please support them however you can. The only other pizza in town I like is five star anytime between 9pm and 3am. Finally. Delicious pizza that isn't in downtown STA. I will shamefully admit this is our second time eating this in a week. First had a delivery from DoorDash, and went in to eat today as we are now fully vaccinated. The place is small, clean, and adorable. They have a selection of soft drinks, water, and beer. They might have wine, but I didn't notice. The owner and staff are super friendly, and exactly what you want from a lovely pizza place. Both times we ordered the Piggy pizza. AMAZING. Delicious delivered and fresh. We also had the white pizza delivered, and tried the ultimate pepperoni in house. The crust was delicious, toppings delicious. My husband, who hates mushrooms, loved the mushrooms. Garlic knots were also very good. The personal size is certainly enough for two, but why not get one for each person? I am now in love with this place, and am trying to figure out when I'll order again, while my husband is driving home and we have a whole pizza in the backseat. I would definitely recommend trying it out.

Zach Lankford

Ordered a small El Greco. Wife ordered I believe the fettuccine garlic & oil pasta. We shared 3 garlic knots. Super great pizza and knots. Plenty of toppings. Probably the best or at least top two crusts I've had of this style. Great flavor. Wife liked the pasta. The garlic knots are hardcore with tons of fresh minced garlic, which is awesome. Definitely recommend! Upon further review (i.e. I just finished the entire pizza by myself....) I think the El Greco pizza is one of the top....3? Best pizzas I've ever had. What a lovely pie.

Very Nice people! We stopped on from out of town thinking we were just going to buy cheap fast pizza. Let me tell you this was good. It’s different and it was nice having different taste! Very good and lots of toppings they weren’t cheap. Made sure we had everything we needed to eat on the go. We will be back

Stopped in on our way through town today. We arrived a minute after they opened and the gentleman up front was very friendly and fast with getting us our food. It’s a small and quaint place that reminded us of our hometown pizza place. We just wish our pizza back home tasted as good as the one we had here! Will definitely be stopping in again when we visit St. Augustine.

December 20, 2025 this was my first time eating at 900o Pizza and Pasta. The food was fabulous!! I had a alfredo spinach and tomato pasta dish, fabulous! Also I had a small veggie pizza, again fabulous! The service person was respectful, polite and helpful! The atmosphere was very welcoming! I definitely recommend eating here, also they offer takeout. Weather you eat in or take out, it is delicious. I believe they also offer delivery.

I haven't been this impressed with Pizza in a long time. If it was closer to me, this would be a weekly stop for us. The pizza was incredible and the garlic knots were amazing! The owner is also very nice and chatted with us while we ate. Can't wait to come back.

Hands down like 6:30 this place has the best pizza crust I’ve ever had. After a long day in St. Augustine’s Old Town, we walked in 8 deep, ordered a pepperoni and a supreme, they came out relatively quick and immediately made a good impression. Spoke to the manager about the crust, he said that the use an olive oil infused with other stuff that I’ll leave between us. Very very good! Out new pizza spot in St. Augustine 👍🏽

Small place but super clean. I loved the lights being cheese graters. We stopped by for a late lunch, and the service with one man working was excellent. The food was amazing, and came out pretty fast. Got several items to share around, and I highly recommend the garden salad and pizza.

We stopped for what we hoped would be a quick, but filling, tasty bite in the middle of St. Augustine activities. This place did NOT disappoint! We both had the lasagna and garlic knots, I also ordered a side salad. The quality of ingredients was terrific, and obvious. The food was terrific, I highly recommend!!

I recently had lunch with a friend at this restaurant. We both ordered two slices and a drink, which was the daily special. In addition to that the owner brought by a few bread knots with marinara. The pizza that we had was absolutely fantastic! Really really good! I ordered a pepperoni slice and another slice with ham and pineapple. Apparently, because my friend requested it, they brushed olive oil on the slices just as they were finishing and oh my God was that delicious. The slices were big and I wasn't even able to finish my second slice. The bread knots were delicious as well dipped in the marinara sauce. The atmosphere was great. The service was friendly and efficient. We had a great lunch experience here. I will definitely be back. This place is just a little out of the way. If it was on State Road 16 you'd have to wait to have a place to sit down. One more thing, they have an oven like you've never seen before in here and it cooks that pizza very quickly. Very interesting.

C. C.

December 20, 2025 this was my first time eating at 900o Pizza and Pasta. The food was fabulous!! I had a alfredo spinach and tomato pasta dish, fabulous! Also I had a small veggie pizza, again fabulous! The service person was respectful, polite and helpful! The atmosphere was very welcoming! I definitely recommend eating here, also they offer takeout. Weather you eat in or take out, it is delicious. I believe they also offer delivery.

Julio Medina

Hands down like 6:30 this place has the best pizza crust I’ve ever had. After a long day in St. Augustine’s Old Town, we walked in 8 deep, ordered a pepperoni and a supreme, they came out relatively quick and immediately made a good impression. Spoke to the manager about the crust, he said that the use an olive oil infused with other stuff that I’ll leave between us. Very very good! Out new pizza spot in St. Augustine 👍🏽

Sofia Maley

Everything was so fresh. Sauce was awesome, pizza was great and the kids play area was genius! Small little spot with bomb pizza and pasta.

RumAndPancakes

I haven't been this impressed with Pizza in a long time. If it was closer to me, this would be a weekly stop for us. The pizza was incredible and the garlic knots were amazing! The owner is also very nice and chatted with us while we ate. Can't wait to come back.

M Chapman

Small place but super clean. I loved the lights being cheese graters. We stopped by for a late lunch, and the service with one man working was excellent. The food was amazing, and came out pretty fast. Got several items to share around, and I highly recommend the garden salad and pizza.

Diana Johnson

We stopped for what we hoped would be a quick, but filling, tasty bite in the middle of St. Augustine activities. This place did NOT disappoint! We both had the lasagna and garlic knots, I also ordered a side salad. The quality of ingredients was terrific, and obvious. The food was terrific, I highly recommend!!

Robert Wagner

I recently had lunch with a friend at this restaurant. We both ordered two slices and a drink, which was the daily special. In addition to that the owner brought by a few bread knots with marinara. The pizza that we had was absolutely fantastic! Really really good! I ordered a pepperoni slice and another slice with ham and pineapple. Apparently, because my friend requested it, they brushed olive oil on the slices just as they were finishing and oh my God was that delicious. The slices were big and I wasn't even able to finish my second slice. The bread knots were delicious as well dipped in the marinara sauce. The atmosphere was great. The service was friendly and efficient. We had a great lunch experience here. I will definitely be back. This place is just a little out of the way. If it was on State Road 16 you'd have to wait to have a place to sit down. One more thing, they have an oven like you've never seen before in here and it cooks that pizza very quickly. Very interesting.

Pizza is great! There was some confusion on our order though. Ordered extra pepperoni and got the standard. Food came out fast though. Overall... 4.5 🌟

My friend and I was wanting some pizza and came across this. We were a bit hesitate at first cause there was hardly any cars outside the business but I’m glad we went in. The inside is small but the pizza is pretty good. It’s not the best I’ve had but also very far from the worse. The oven they use is the eye catcher..! It’s pretty neat seeing what they use to cook the pizza in. Customer service was okay and the gentleman that was working the front desk didn’t know what he was doing. No fault of his own on that but he made up for it with making sure we were taken care of. Also, soda is NOT on tap.. you pay for bottles or cans.

I got four pizzas for takeout. They were very good but not as hot as I expected them to be considering I picked up at the time arranged. But nonetheless the pizza's were amazing everybody at work loved them. The white pizza blew everybody away with the garlic and arugula.

Grabbed a Large Cheese, a Supreme and an order of garlic knots. We did a take away. Everyone was very nice, the order was done quickly and it all tasted great! I didn't give 5 stars because we felt the pizzas were lacking cheese and could have used a bit more on them. But other than that we were very happy.

Marcia Pineiro

Grabbed a Large Cheese, a Supreme and an order of garlic knots. We did a take away. Everyone was very nice, the order was done quickly and it all tasted great! I didn't give 5 stars because we felt the pizzas were lacking cheese and could have used a bit more on them. But other than that we were very happy.

The place was nice and clean, and staff was friendly, I had aa pepperoni pizza, and a garden salad, the salad was great! put the pizzas crust was burnt at the bottom which made it to have burnt after taste. other than that everyting else was ok.

The first time I ordered the pizza was good but they forgot another item. The second time was a complete unorganized disaster, the pizza was poorly made and burnt and the chicken parm was just not good. I’m not sure what’s going on over there but I won’t risk ordering from them again.

Heiura

The first time I ordered the pizza was good but they forgot another item. The second time was a complete unorganized disaster, the pizza was poorly made and burnt and the chicken parm was just not good. I’m not sure what’s going on over there but I won’t risk ordering from them again.

Went here about a year ago and there was a police presence. Woman refusing to pay for pizza. It disturbed our experience here.

Our 3rd time ordering over 3 years. The first year, 2022, was great! The second year, 2023, was not great. The whole recipe was changed and more saucy than cheese. Our final year, October/November 2025 is pictured below. Burnt, dried up, hard and greasy. It went right into the trash after we tried one slice. There was one other pizza being baked so it wasn't like it was too busy to keep track of. The place was empty. Guess that should've been a red flag to begin with. Won't return.

Ordered a White Pizza, Stromboli, and mozzarella half-moon… $71 order. Obviously, the “white pizza” ordered was just a plain cheese burnt cracker style pizza that was absolutely horrible. No sauce, no arugula, and dry. Ordered through the “slice” app and customer service refunded the cost of the pizza. If I was competing as a business owner against Bronx House Pizza, the advantage they DID had was delivery… I would have refunded the pizza and rushed out the right pizza. This experience only taught me that it’s just better to plan your day and swing by a better pizza place in your way home. Very unfortunate.

God, I hate writing bad reviews. I ordered a white pizza for delivery (which was great to have as an option) but was delivered a somehow both burnt to a crisp and ice cold pizza. I tried to get over myself and took a bite- it was just a cracker with rubber cheese on it. It also was not as advertised, some of the ingredients were missing. I drove back up to the restaurant and showed it to them asking for a remake, which they were happy to do. They remade the pizza but this one was just as burnt with rubbery cheese, no sauce, no arugula. I should have asked for a refund, but did not. The entire pizza got thrown away.

This had to be the WORST FOOD we have had in a long time! We vaca here in St.Augustine ALOT, & ordered delivery from this place. (Friendly The pizza was really thin, hardly any cheese, or toppings. And was way overdone! The half moons mozzarella was cold, & ALOT of fried stuff with barely ANY CHEESE! The wings were tough, dry & not even a good flavor. Don't waste your money at this establishment.

Been coming here for about a year and never had a bad experience before today. Called to order and was put on hold and no one came back on the line. Then I called back 3-4x and No one would answer. Ordered online (paying extra) at 5:45. Time for pickup was 6:01-6:15. Showed up after 6:20 and they said 20 more minutes. Drove home then came back at 6:55. They said sorry there's still 3 pizzas ahead of you. Went back outside and came back 10 minutes later. Got home with my pizza and it was missing the bacon topping I added and paid extra for..... and the pizza is way over cooked. Like burned

Micah Titus

This had to be the WORST FOOD we have had in a long time! We vaca here in St.Augustine ALOT, & ordered delivery from this place. (Friendly The pizza was really thin, hardly any cheese, or toppings. And was way overdone! The half moons mozzarella was cold, & ALOT of fried stuff with barely ANY CHEESE! The wings were tough, dry & not even a good flavor. Don't waste your money at this establishment.

YOUR COOL POOL

Been coming here for about a year and never had a bad experience before today. Called to order and was put on hold and no one came back on the line. Then I called back 3-4x and No one would answer. Ordered online (paying extra) at 5:45. Time for pickup was 6:01-6:15. Showed up after 6:20 and they said 20 more minutes. Drove home then came back at 6:55. They said sorry there's still 3 pizzas ahead of you. Went back outside and came back 10 minutes later. Got home with my pizza and it was missing the bacon topping I added and paid extra for..... and the pizza is way over cooked. Like burned

Sand D

Our 3rd time ordering over 3 years. The first year, 2022, was great! The second year, 2023, was not great. The whole recipe was changed and more saucy than cheese. Our final year, October/November 2025 is pictured below. Burnt, dried up, hard and greasy. It went right into the trash after we tried one slice. There was one other pizza being baked so it wasn't like it was too busy to keep track of. The place was empty. Guess that should've been a red flag to begin with. Won't return.

Trisomy Hassaikai

God, I hate writing bad reviews. I ordered a white pizza for delivery (which was great to have as an option) but was delivered a somehow both burnt to a crisp and ice cold pizza. I tried to get over myself and took a bite- it was just a cracker with rubber cheese on it. It also was not as advertised, some of the ingredients were missing. I drove back up to the restaurant and showed it to them asking for a remake, which they were happy to do. They remade the pizza but this one was just as burnt with rubbery cheese, no sauce, no arugula. I should have asked for a refund, but did not. The entire pizza got thrown away.

Bruce Cline

Ordered a White Pizza, Stromboli, and mozzarella half-moon… $71 order. Obviously, the “white pizza” ordered was just a plain cheese burnt cracker style pizza that was absolutely horrible. No sauce, no arugula, and dry. Ordered through the “slice” app and customer service refunded the cost of the pizza. If I was competing as a business owner against Bronx House Pizza, the advantage they DID had was delivery… I would have refunded the pizza and rushed out the right pizza. This experience only taught me that it’s just better to plan your day and swing by a better pizza place in your way home. Very unfortunate.