46th Street Pizza

Never a bad experience. Pizza is good and the dinners are great. Always friendly and fast

This is definitely my go to for pizza restaurants. Everything is delicious. The service is tremendous and very friendly. Everyone must try this place.

Best pizza in San Antonio closest to NY pizza. Gotta get the large. The texture and taste is different than a medium or small believe it or not.

Eduardo Perez

Best pizza in San Antonio closest to NY pizza. Gotta get the large. The texture and taste is different than a medium or small believe it or not.

Damian Wagner

Never a bad experience. Pizza is good and the dinners are great. Always friendly and fast

Michael Flores

This is definitely my go to for pizza restaurants. Everything is delicious. The service is tremendous and very friendly. Everyone must try this place.

Rob M

As a NYC guy this is pretty good pizza but you can get more bang for your buck at Grampies which also has great NYC pizza. This place was good on pat booker but whoever runs this place are so incredibly cheap with toppings you hardly taste them. Compare say a sausage slice against grampies and you will see what I'm saying.

Michael

Lived in NY for 13 yrs. These guys are the closest to NY pizza in SA, can’t believe some of the low star reviews. I used to go to the one on I-10, now they are even closer!

Melissa Anderson

I always love they're chicken Alfredo Pizza. The staff is amazing. Everybody's good. Wonderful Pizza is delicious. I just wish DoorDash could figure out how to add mushrooms. So I usually go pick it up because the store always gets it right 😉

lacy wheeler

This very well be my favorite pizza EVER! I’m a sucker for NY style pizza and they put just the right amount of cheese and sauce for my liking…. Seems to be heavy on the cheese and light on the sauce, and that’s RIGHT up my alley. I have been twice and I WILL be back! I truly love their pizza!!!

Being from New York, it is near impossible to find decent pizza anywhere. That being said, 46th puts up a good fight. It is the best tasting pizza we have found in San Antonio in the few years we have lived here. We always order our pizza extra crispy and yummmmy! Their wings are also delicious and we always get an order. We have sat down a number of times to try different entrees and haven’t been impressed but that won’t stop us for coming back to satisfy our pizza cravings.

Customer service: 5/5 Pizza quality: 4.5/5 Cost/availability: 3.5/5 My main gripe is that they didn’t have “by the slice” available, so me a single dude, had to buy a small pizza which I could only eat half of. If you advertise it, the sell it. Maybe they had a bad month… but I didn’t have any negative experience with the food or customer service. Dude was super friendly and they had a steady stream of customers, even at 4:00 pm. Pizza was hot and fresh and tasty. Maybe needed a bit more cheese, but that’s personal preference. All in all I’ll look past the by the slice thing and wont base my rating solely on that. 4/5

Perfect thin crust pizza ... will be back

Sabrina

Being from New York, it is near impossible to find decent pizza anywhere. That being said, 46th puts up a good fight. It is the best tasting pizza we have found in San Antonio in the few years we have lived here. We always order our pizza extra crispy and yummmmy! Their wings are also delicious and we always get an order. We have sat down a number of times to try different entrees and haven’t been impressed but that won’t stop us for coming back to satisfy our pizza cravings.

Shawn S

Customer service: 5/5 Pizza quality: 4.5/5 Cost/availability: 3.5/5 My main gripe is that they didn’t have “by the slice” available, so me a single dude, had to buy a small pizza which I could only eat half of. If you advertise it, the sell it. Maybe they had a bad month… but I didn’t have any negative experience with the food or customer service. Dude was super friendly and they had a steady stream of customers, even at 4:00 pm. Pizza was hot and fresh and tasty. Maybe needed a bit more cheese, but that’s personal preference. All in all I’ll look past the by the slice thing and wont base my rating solely on that. 4/5

J B

Perfect thin crust pizza ... will be back

This place was just ok for me . We had the Margherita Pizza, it cld have used more flavor. I felt it was a bit bland. The place was clean, nice atmosphere, great location. I will go back, to try another pizza to give it another chance though.

Teena Maree

This place was just ok for me . We had the Margherita Pizza, it cld have used more flavor. I felt it was a bit bland. The place was clean, nice atmosphere, great location. I will go back, to try another pizza to give it another chance though.

I order pizza by the slice. I asked if I could order with ricotta and I'll pay extra and guy said "no, I won't make it that way." OK, then I won't give you a 5 stars.

Atmosphere and service are good but the food is really below average. Their tomato sauce doesn’t really taste good and neither does their cheese— way too oily. Is it cheap? Yes. But it’s not worth it and it definitely doesn’t taste like NY pizza. Any reviewer who says that on here is either not from New York or just likes to lie for fun.

Sean Berg

I order pizza by the slice. I asked if I could order with ricotta and I'll pay extra and guy said "no, I won't make it that way." OK, then I won't give you a 5 stars.

Damaris Santi

Atmosphere and service are good but the food is really below average. Their tomato sauce doesn’t really taste good and neither does their cheese— way too oily. Is it cheap? Yes. But it’s not worth it and it definitely doesn’t taste like NY pizza. Any reviewer who says that on here is either not from New York or just likes to lie for fun.

Coming from New Jersey I had high expectations because it said New York style pizza and they actually had white pie, which is rare to find in San Antonio. Zero flavor, extremely dry, very skimpy on the ingredients. I had ordered broccoli and extra ricotta on mine which I did not receive. Basically, you could’ve eaten the box that it came in and received the same flavor. Not a fan 👎🏼 very expensive as well. The pizza and a Greek salad came to $40.

Shelly Ocheltree

Coming from New Jersey I had high expectations because it said New York style pizza and they actually had white pie, which is rare to find in San Antonio. Zero flavor, extremely dry, very skimpy on the ingredients. I had ordered broccoli and extra ricotta on mine which I did not receive. Basically, you could’ve eaten the box that it came in and received the same flavor. Not a fan 👎🏼 very expensive as well. The pizza and a Greek salad came to $40.

I understand y’all get busy but that’s no reason to constantly tell people that it’ll be ten minutes when in reality the pizza doesn’t get put in until you remind them. Also when we politely inform you that we’ve been waiting longer than usual, it’s probably not best to disregard customer and look behind them and say “who’s next?” I (used to) order pizza here all the time, disappointed. I’d rather eat cardboard at dominoes.

What is going on? This is the third time we go there to pick up a quick lunch they advertise a two piece salad and a drink but when you go inside, there is no pizza they tell you oh we don’t have any we could make it if you’re advertising this you should have a pie ready to heat up two slices so that your customer can take it at the time they arrive there People are picking up quick lunches. They don’t want to sit around and wait for a pizza to be made so if you’re advertising have the stuff ready so annoying the guy behind the counter. Oh no we don’t have anything I said what do you mean? Oh we have to make it with a big smile on his face. No apologies. I’m sorry but we have to make them we ran out. They can’t tell me they ran out because it’s the third time me or someone in My family goes there to pick up a quick lunch to drive back home and they have nothing in Place. management needs to know about this cause I love this pizza, but the service has been crappy. .

Ordered 24 wings, pizza, etc. The wings had no sauce. Ranch and blue cheese were included but absolutely 0 buffalo sauce. This place is starting to go down hill. How do you box 24 wings plain?

Kevin Bunch

Ordered 24 wings, pizza, etc. The wings had no sauce. Ranch and blue cheese were included but absolutely 0 buffalo sauce. This place is starting to go down hill. How do you box 24 wings plain?

Margie Martinee

What is going on? This is the third time we go there to pick up a quick lunch they advertise a two piece salad and a drink but when you go inside, there is no pizza they tell you oh we don’t have any we could make it if you’re advertising this you should have a pie ready to heat up two slices so that your customer can take it at the time they arrive there People are picking up quick lunches. They don’t want to sit around and wait for a pizza to be made so if you’re advertising have the stuff ready so annoying the guy behind the counter. Oh no we don’t have anything I said what do you mean? Oh we have to make it with a big smile on his face. No apologies. I’m sorry but we have to make them we ran out. They can’t tell me they ran out because it’s the third time me or someone in My family goes there to pick up a quick lunch to drive back home and they have nothing in Place. management needs to know about this cause I love this pizza, but the service has been crappy. .

Vince B

I understand y’all get busy but that’s no reason to constantly tell people that it’ll be ten minutes when in reality the pizza doesn’t get put in until you remind them. Also when we politely inform you that we’ve been waiting longer than usual, it’s probably not best to disregard customer and look behind them and say “who’s next?” I (used to) order pizza here all the time, disappointed. I’d rather eat cardboard at dominoes.