Jon Shover

Do yourself a favor, and make it a priority to stop in here when in town! Best pizza around with a classic thin crust style and the best Caesar salad you can get anywhere.

Shruthi Senthilmani

great spot for pizza and beer in sleepy hollow! we tried out this underrated restaurant and honestly it was a great! the atmosphere was amazing and wasn’t hard to get tables. the pizza was lowkey one of the best i’ve had for such a good price. the have draft beer which paired well with pizza. great for groups and couples for lunch/dinner.

John Koprowicz

Not only great food, but great music and service. Pizza is very good and is better than most than you would find in NYC. Sleepy Hollow, NY treasure and fun spot!

c v

Who’da thought a tavern would have terrific pizza and lots of great toppings and pizza options! We were pleasantly surprised after hiking to find this gem. Not to mention meeting a like minded couple at the bar and becoming friends!!! The salads, the prices and the portions along with back yard space, this is our new hotspot!

Ryan Birmingham

Good music, friendly staff, and overall a cool spot. The pizza was great - 2 pizzas for 2 people was the right amount. Took a little while but worth it!

Lori Generose

Honestly, probably the best wings I’ve had in quite some time because I don’t like super breaded wings I like baked wings that are flash fried and that’s exactly what these are. I asked for them to mix their buffalo sauce with honey to give it like a hot and honey sauce, and it was amazing. My friends had the pizza and they said it was also incredible. We came here before a concert at the state theatre and would 1000% come back if the opportunity presents itself. Parking was on the street and very easy to navigate. I wish these wings were in my neighborhood because I’d be having them every Friday night for take out!!!

nasha nicole

The food was delicious. Went in to grab a quick lunch. So happy I got their garlic knots, it's the way I like mine with loads of garlic! The wings were cooked well and had a good flavor. The pizza was really delicious and if you like a very thin, crispy crust then you'll love this one. Got the Hot Honey Pizza, white pizza with Fresno peppers, Franks Red Hot, chicken cutlet and Mike's Hot Honey which brought this to another level. It was super busy during lunch and the wait time for food was a little long. The food was good though and our servers were busy but still stopped by often to give us updates. Nice quaint, cozy spot. On street parking if you can find a spot. Very busy for a Monday.

+4

Kimberlee Febus

Very cozy little bar, and restaurant. Came here on a Monday 12:30 pm before heading back home I seen this place on Instagram and had to stop by. Best choice I made! ☺️ The waitress we had was super amazing. Her name was Cat.🐱and loved her cat tattoo. She recommended the garlic knots and the garlic chicken wings. They were to die for also had cheese and meatball pizza that was delicious as well. Will be definitely stopping by when visiting the area. Thank you for the good experience. 🎃🐾🐱

+1

It's an okay place to grab a bite. Indoor seating is rather cramped and it was chilly so the outside seating was not popular. Staff super friendly. First time trying it since we were exploring sleepy hallow. Reasonably priced. A bit dark. Pizza was okay. The fried mozzarella is a must-have with the spicy marinara.

John Cerullo Jr

Creative bar-style pizza's with simple salads and app's to pair. Great craft beer tap list with brews from Hill Farmstead, Trillium, and Other Half. Unfortunately, the bartender taking table orders wasn't the most helpful...

Space Dandy

Delicious pizza flavors, wonderful service, great atmosphere. A great spot to meet up with friends for a small bite and have a few drinks. Cash and credit are both accepted. Street parking only, which is very limited. The pizza is about a personal 12' bar-style pie. One to three people could share a pie easily. Highly recommend the pepperoni, hot honey, BBQ chicken, and the Beekman Ave pizzas. Each has great flavor and variety for everyone to try. 05/2024

+18

COLDSEMENOVA

The atmosphere was actually really nice — cozy and welcoming, and the staff were kind and attentive. However, our pizza came out completely cold. The servers offered to take it back or remake it, but that would’ve taken another 30 minutes, which was disappointing. So while I appreciated the people and the vibe, the food itself was honestly cold, crusty, and not enjoyable at all.

Bill Chuck

We took out these three pizzas. I found them each inedible. I'm fine with blackened tuna. I'm fine with blackened salmon. I'm not good with blackened pizza. What a huge disappointment.