Menú
Romeo & Juliet's Bakery & Caffe
PosDo

© 2026 PosDo · v3.0

Tonawanda

Romeo & Juliet's Bakery & Caffe

★★★★★ 4.5 · 100 reseñas

Nestled in the heart of Tonawanda at 2512 Sheridan Dr #9410, Romeo & Juliet's Bakery & Caffe offers a warm and inviting atmosphere where coffee meets classic bakery delights. Our charming location, just steps away from the hustle and bustle of daily life, provides the perfect bac...

Romeo & Juliet's Bakery & Caffe

Coffee · Tonawanda

Find your love story in every cup, Tonawanda

4.5 · 417 ressenyes Google
www.rjcaffe.com

Sobre Romeo & Juliet's Bakery & Caffe

Nestled in the heart of Tonawanda at 2512 Sheridan Dr #9410, Romeo & Juliet's Bakery & Caffe offers a warm and inviting atmosphere where coffee meets classic bakery delights. Our charming location, just steps away from the hustle and bustle of daily life, provides the perfect backdrop for a momentar...

Nestled in the heart of Tonawanda at 2512 Sheridan Dr #9410, Romeo & Juliet's Bakery & Caffe offers a warm and inviting atmosphere where coffee meets classic bakery delights. Our charming location, just steps away from the hustle and bustle of daily life, provides the perfect backdrop for a momentary escape or a cozy gathering with friends. We pride ourselves on our diverse dining options, blending expertly crafted coffee with an array of delectable pastries, cakes, and other sweet treats that have earned us a 4.5/5 rating from delighted customers (based on 417 reviews). Our menu is designed to satisfy every palate, offering not just sustenance but a genuine sense of community and joy. Step into our cozy café, and let the aromas of fresh-baked goods and rich coffee fill your senses as you explore our carefully curated selection. We look forward to crafting moments that last with each sip and bite.

Què diuen els clients de Romeo & Juliet's Bakery & Caffe

Romeo & Juliet's Bakery & Caffe is praised for its delicious Italian cuisine, especially the pizza and desserts like cannoli. The service is frequently mentioned as excellent, with attentive waitresses like Samantha and Bella. Some customers found the pizza skimpy for the price.

Plats populars

pizza (6) cannoli chicken piccata Monet Panini Romeo & Julietta cheese ravioli steak, spinach, mushroom panini Quatrro Formaggio Pizza

Ideal per a

Informal Locals

Tip: Try the pizza and desserts, especially the cannoli. Consider going between lunch and dinner for a quieter experience.

Services

📶 WiFi 🌳 Terrasse 🅿️ Parking Accessible 🍽️ Déjeuner 🌙 Dîner 🥗 Vegetarian Coffee
🎯 Casual 🛋️ Cozy 💕 Romantic 👨‍👩‍👧 Family 👥 Groups

Què veure a prop

Curtiss Park
A 644m

Curtiss Park

parque

Veure detalls

Dades de Wikidata

Preguntes freqüents sobre Romeo & Juliet's Bakery & Caffe

Romeo & Juliet's Bakery & Caffe es troba a 2512 Sheridan Dr #9410, Tonawanda, NY 14150, Tonawanda.
Romeo & Juliet's Bakery & Caffe ofereix cuina coffee.
Romeo & Juliet's Bakery & Caffe té horari d'atenció. Consulta el perfil per horaris actualitzats.
Romeo & Juliet's Bakery & Caffe ofereix els serveis següents: menjar al local, per emportar.
Els plats més recomanats a Romeo & Juliet's Bakery & Caffe segons les opinions dels clients són: pizza, cannoli, chicken piccata, Monet Panini, Romeo & Julietta.
Romeo & Juliet's Bakery & Caffe és ideal per a informal, locals.
Romeo & Juliet's Bakery & Caffe is praised for its delicious Italian cuisine, especially the pizza and desserts like cannoli. The service is frequently mentioned as excellent, with attentive waitresses like Samantha and Bella. Some customers found the pizza skimpy for the price.
Try the pizza and desserts, especially the cannoli. Consider going between lunch and dinner for a quieter experience.
417
Ressenyes

Opinions de Romeo & Juliet's Bakery & Caffe Tonawanda

4.5
417
5★
72%
4★
18%
3★
4%
2★
2%
1★
4%
Ressenyes (100)
S
Sue Burns

Quaint Italian restaurant and bakery. Outside seating available.

R
Red Hendrix

Great fresh food friendly staff and save room for dessert if you can portions are HUGE Still Great

V
Victoria Tafoya

Delicious food made fresh, great ambiance and wonderful service. I will be coming back soon.

D
Davon R

Cake was super good. And staff was super friendly. Picked up some cake slices to bring my friends. Decently priced for cake that good.

M
Micky Smith

Never had a bad meal here. We love everything, especially pizza

m
maria thomas

The quality of the food is high and so delicious. Our waitress was knowledgeable, helpful and respectful.

R
Robert Boscia

Food and service were excellent. I especially appreciated that they had plain cannollis without nuts or chocolate. Thanks

M
Michael Smith

Always great food and large portions for the price. You have to try some of the cakes and desserts

M
Momof2

Delicious desserts friendly service. Very clean dininh area. Prices right on for great food.

J
JudgeBigMansion

Absolute best pizza in Buffalo if we judge quality of ingredients, flavor, gut feeling after eating, and price in that order. Ingredient quality is top notch; smaller portions, but it comes with the semi-gourmet territory, you still come out full. The tomato sauce is debatably the most impressive part, with a noticeable red wine tinge and small bits of tomato among seasonings. Flavor is the most satisfactory part of the whole pie, with the most captivating blend of flavors a pizza can offer (the pepperoni have a lot to do with that) I guarantee you will never have stomach ache coming out of a Romeo and Juliette's, their pizzas included. I have always come out feeling better than when I came in. Now the price might be the best surprise yet; I'll illustrate that through my average experience ordering there: Come in, order take out: a pizza with cheese, pepperoni, minced garlic, and 1/2 banana peppers and an eclair with half whipped cream and half custard (oh god, yes yes yes.) Wait all of 15 - 20 minutes and walk out with two works of culinary arts for *UNDER TWENTY DOLLARS*. Until a freak storm of godly proportions happens on Friday the 13th during a full, blue moon as the planets align under the Northern Lights, creating the one true pizza, Romeo and Julet's will enjoy their rule as king for all it's worth.

R
Robert Tintner

Always great! Wife and I had cold antipasto...yummy....and a pizza special with artichokes...grilled chicken and sun dried tomatoes...deserts look fantastic...but sadly...we are on a diet...

A
Amy

Food is always delicious. Service is always friendly. They even made a favorite dish for me that used to be on the menu.

A
Allison Cossitt

I go to both Sheridan Dr. locations and it's always a pleasant experience. Their pizza is truly delicious and may of the other menu items I have tried have been excellent.

b
bob caygeon

Fast service, pleasant wait staff and real home style Eye-tie food. If you want flash frozen stuff, go further up the road into Amherst. I see the owner of the previous greasy pizza place that occupied this space gave a negative review. Shameful.

E
Emma Pfohl

Amazing! food was great, we stopped on a Friday afternoon. Samantha was wonderful!!

G
Gunlord

This...is truly...the power...of Italy...seriously though, good good.

D
Diane Iannello

Just ran in to pick up some dessert. The selection made it very difficult to choose. Wanted one of everything! Cake, canolli little tarts, cookies, Napoleons. Yikes. Went with canolli, very happy with them.

K
Kristin Trevisani

Cute little place. The food and desserts were delicious! Service was great! We would definitely go back!

D
Dave

Take out pizza and a canoli. One of the best cheese and pepperoni I have had lifetime. Beautiful breads. Will be back for sure

b
bill olesiuk

I got the cheese ravioli and meatballs. Excellent. Server was friendly and wine was fine. Everything I wanted for Italian restaurant date night.

S
Samantha Guzzetta-Owens

Wonderful experience. Waitress is such a sweetheart and the food is absolutely fresh and delicious!

J
Jason Scime

Stopped in for desert... Gotta try the canoli, reasonable price delicious

K
Kriti Singh

Their Tiramisu is the best I’ve had in Buffalo.

D
Daniel S.

Phenomenal pizza and great appetizers. My spouse got the gnocchi, which were "cloud soft and extremely flavorful." The pizza was extraordinary: a crisp, toothsome crust with a flavorful sauce, piled high with toppings (savory spiced sausage, generous cheese, gently sauted vegetables). We had antipasti and tuna crostini as well, which were very good if not as spectacular as the entrees, but so generously served we will likely come for a meal of just appetizers and wine. In all, a phenomenal restaurant for Buffalo.

M
Michele D'Addario Moser

Mmmmmmm! Delicious! Delicious! Delicious! We have never been disappointed in a meal at Romeo and Juliet's. The atmosphere is quaint, and quiet and the food is outstanding. The bread is fantastic! I'm hungry writing this!

C
Courteney Rice

This place exceeded my expectations. We ordered the lobster ravioli and a large salad and both were fresh and delicious and our dinner came with a free cannoli! Very good Italian food. Highly recommend.

G
Gregory Eaton

Povera-style cooking. Appetizers were awesome, as was our main course. Lobster ravioli and calzone were superb. Homemade Italian sausage and peanut Alfredo sauce were extremely good. Prices are on the high side, but that is the price of perfection!

O
Oz

The service was very friendly and lacking nothing, and the kitchen clearly put love and pride into their food. My partner has dietary restrictions that they were happy to work around. Definitely recommended!

P
Paul Reynolds

Best paninis in town. Service can be a little slow at times, but a great place to meet and chat.

L
Lisa Davis

We come here on a pretty regular basis. Good service and great food definitely keep us coming back. It's got a really cozy feel in the dining area which we love. Some of our favorites on the menu are their chicken parm, the eggplant parm, the chicken with roasted peppers panini and their pizza's are delicious! Their personal pizzas are quite large. The crust is thin, crispy and delicious. Sometimes my husband and I will order one pizza and one salad and split them. For appetizers the stuffed peppers are a must try! It comes with 5 deliciously stuffed peppers. We highly recommend Romeo and Juliet's.

J
Joe A

Romeo & Juliet's is our go to for takeout events. I just hosted a gathering of over 25 people at my house and Josh did an amazing job with the food. Highly recommend trying them out.

A
Amit Arora

Awesome food. “Very Authentic”, I was told by an Italian friend. I liked how they had so many vegetarian friendly options. I ordered the stuffed bell pepper and it was just finger licking delicious. Will visit again !

D
Debra Brocculeri

My teenage granddaughter just loves this place , it’s always her choice of restaurants . Pizzas are great , service is exceptional and omg the desserts ! I like to stop by just on my way home from work to pick up a cake or bread 💕

C
Claire Pennell-Hall

Have been enjoying R&J for years. Call and check on their specials (especially Tonawanda) because they’re delicious-gnocchi Asiago, chicken piccata, shrimp scampi. Molto bene!! Claire

L
Lauren Talcott

The food was tasty and great. Large sizes. I have had them a few times now and still great quality each time. Highly recommend especially for a night in with a group of family or friends.

C
Chris Weimer

Haven't been here in a long time - only stopped in for desserts tonight, excellent as always! 11/16/2024 update - stopped for dinner, everything was excellent.

K
Katherine Smythe

Great menu selections. Pleasant eating experience. Good prices. Save room because the homemade desserts are delicious. Wait staff are friendly and helpful. Outdoor seating is available, but street traffic is loud, but bearable. Well worth your time to visit them and have a meal. Good wine selections too. Probably not good for little children.

J
Jennifer Stachnik

The nicest random act of kindness happened here. We asked for our bill and the waitress informed us the other party had paid it for us. We paid it forward for another customer. The bread is served with butter or olive spread. We asked about garlic butter and they made a garlic dipping oil for us. The sausage pepper kale soup was spicy and delicious. The cannolis were exquisite and part of the lunch special. Excellent food, attentive service. Check this place out!

C
Colleen Burke

My husband and I stopped in on Saturday night. The place was packed and we started to leave as we had a very tight timeline for dinner. We were stopped and told that if we didn’t mind eating in the entryway area (cute little table that was secluded and perfect for our parent’s night out date night), they could serve us. I explained we were on a deadline to pick up our kids and was assured we’d have our food in plenty of time. The staff was so pleasant and went out of their way to make sure we got our food and drink with time to enjoy it before we had to go pick up our kids. I walk here for lunch sometimes and the service is always great. A true gem for our town.

J
Jason Frey

Absolutely incredible restaurant - staff is friendly and food is the best. What more could you ask for?

J
Jessamine Jagow

Very good!!! Loved the dessert selection and take away options!

S
Steve Cherico

What a great experience. Needed cannollis and lobster tails to go for a long ride back to Maryland. The filled the cannolis as we waited. She packed them and wrapped them for travel in a cooler at her suggestion. She cared enough to ensure they stayed fresh for when we got back home. You don't find that much anymore. The deserts were incredibly tasty and properly dry thanks to the attentiveness of their staff. You can't go wrong by eating here or getting it to go. Thank you to the wonderful staff that we were lucky to meet.

M
Mark Gallimore

Excellent food for families, dates, or take-out. We've been there many times, and keep going back. Very friendly service, especially if you bring kids. Your only risk is succumbing to the dessert case after your meal!

T
Tim Fremming

Great restaurant! My friend and I stopped here for lunch and the food was nothing but great quality! The staff couldn't have been friendlier and they were great in helping us with any questions or. Their coffee and desserts were out of this world and a great way to cap it all off. Everything taste fresh and homemade. I just wish the restaurant was a little bigger.

a
autumn g

This place is a hidden gem. We got the Arancini appetizer, paparadelle bolognese and pepperoni pizza and it didn’t disappoint. Way better than any Italian chain restaurant in the area. Their pastries look delicious, we will be definitely coming back to try them!

B
BlueLaguna1

I am writing this is relation to an order through skip the dishes but I felt it needed a larger audience. My order arrived incorrect (not the restaurant's fault) and was noticed almost immediately by the restaurant. After reaching out to me, Josh delivered the correct order with a little extra on top less than 10 minutes from seeing the problem. This is going above and beyond in every way and I recommend trying it and seeing for yourself the care they have for their customers. Also the food was delicious, I will be eating there in person very soon.

C
CEO and Fabulous

I ordered from them for the first time this evening through Uber; and all I can say is YUMMY! I don’t believe in giving reviews unless I can whole heartily give a 5 star review because I’m a firm believer that mistakes happen, bad days happen and for people to bash another local company due to an off day is ridiculous. However, this restaurant is by far thee most delicious I have had in quite some time. Their antipasto appetizer made me feel like I was back in Rome, if you haven’t tried them your missing out on something amazing! You guys are absolutely delicious :) I will be ordering again and again ........SUPER YUMMY

A
Alicia Weller

I was really surprised by this restaurant. I came in free of any expectations and my senses were absolutely blown away! The smell of the bakery and italian food draws you in from the door . The first thing you see is the case of delectable baked goods. ready to be picked up and devoured. Turn the corner and there is a small intimate seating area with a fire place. Its cozy! As far as the food goes it will not disappoint. Every dish has an explosion of flavor and the waitress can even male hand craft sodas and was very passionate about her job. She catered to my son and daughter and went out of her way to make sure that they were happy.

M
Mary Jane Zak

Hello ... I'm all about Food Quality, Service with A Smile & Accuracy In a Very Clean Environment! Well Thus IS the Place for YOU; PLUS Reasonably priced! MJ ☮️

M
Mark Tripi

Absolutely the best lobster ravioli ever I’ve ever had

N
Nicholas Bennett

I honestly can’t believe this place wasn’t busier — it truly deserves all the attention! 😲 The staff were super friendly and worked seamlessly together, which made the whole experience smooth and welcoming 🙌😊 The food itself was absolutely delicious and beautifully presented 🍽️✨ Every bite was flavorful, and the portions were generous enough that we left completely stuffed! Even though we were full, we couldn’t resist taking some desserts to go 🍰🍫 They were just as amazing as the meal and a perfect way to end the visit. The atmosphere is cozy and inviting, making it feel like a real local gem in the neighborhood 🏡💖 We’ll definitely be coming back soon — great food, friendly staff, and a spot that feels both special and approachable. Highly recommend giving this place a try if you haven’t yet! 🌟🎉

S
S C

Haven’t had their food, but the desserts are amazing. My favorite is the Cannoli.

Marina B
Marina B

Excellent all around. The desserts are amazing!!

Linda Roach
Linda Roach

The service was excellent. She checked with us & & was very nice. Also stepped aside so we could enjoy the delicious food

Allyson Goff
Allyson Goff

My first time there with an old friend... I was pleasantly surprised how good the food was (ITALIAN) I'm quite fussy, everything was supurb. I wish i wouldn't have bypassed the desserts .. i may take a special trip just for that. Huge assortment

J B
J B

I highly recommend the Pepperoni and Mozzarella pizza and the Quattro Formaggio pizza. These pizzas tasted so fresh and homemade. Everything was ready exactly when we were told to pick it up and it was still hot by the time we got home. Next time we’ll get another kind of pizza and continue to come back! Definitely a must-try spot in Tonawanda.

Sean Grohman
Sean Grohman

I can’t believe that this place wasn’t packed. The staff were very friendly and didn’t hesitate to help each other out. The food was delicious and presented well. We were stuffed afterwards, but got our deserts to go. We’ll definitely be back to our local gem.

Sharon Hammersmith
Sharon Hammersmith

Five stars goes out to our waitress Samantha she was very nice and accommodating to our needs and my husband had the chicken piccata and I have the Monet Panini excellent 😋😁

steve c
steve c

Best pizza in Buffalo. The End. Their thin crust, though not the standard of buffalo pizza, is perfection. Wonderful sauce on the best crust with perfectly melted cheese. P.s. get a cannoli or 20.

Mike Graz
Mike Graz

Romeo and Juliet has been producing excellent Italian cuisine at multiple locations for years know. They have great selection of Italian desserts as well. Some of the best pizza in my opinion. Definitely try them out.

Jennifer R
Jennifer R

As always, wonderful service and delicious food! We tried the cheese ravioli (cooked al dente....just the way I like!) with pesto, pine nuts, & roasted tomatoes and the steak, spinach, mushroom panini. Romeo & Juliet's has a huge case of homemade desserts/cookies/cannoli/biscotti and it would be a sin to pass them by.

Bill Little
Bill Little

Romeo and Juliet's is awesome. The food is always delicious, and the desserts are outstanding. Our waitress Bella was very friendly and attentive. She made sure to answer all our questions about the menu/specials.

Stephanie M
Stephanie M

I am new to the area due to my job and so I decided to try Romeo & Juliet's. Today was my first time ordering from there and I have to say; my food was top notch, the service was amazing, it's clean and the deserts look unbelievable. I ordered the Romeo & Julietta. To die for! I will definitely be back! Also, I love the accent, I believe, by the owner. I feel like I'm in Italy.

Marion Hylton
Marion Hylton

Wonderful little diner with exceptional service! They are very attentive to your needs and take care of you. The food is delicious!

Angela Sampman
Angela Sampman

A friend and I were looking for a new place to have a meal. Soooooo, we came upon Romeo and Juliette's and thot let's try here. First is the walk in and surveille...ok...it's quiet as it's in betweeen lunch and dinner. Perfect as it's what I needed to relax. I despise a loud place when I need to enjoy a good meal and conversation with a friend, family member, spouse, etc. I didn't expect to be as pleased as I was. Its small and cozy. The waitress didnt seem too pleasant at first. My bad...i scrutinize everything. Anyway, we were seated in the perfect spotbi myself was eyeballing. A table along a far wall and away from other patrons. Just to have conversation not In earshot. Nothing special...just chatting with my friend. I found an outlet to charge my phone next to my chair which was great as it needed charging before we'd be finished with our meal. The waitress who turned out to be the co owner/wife was closest to the perfect waitress as in not in our face constantly,but just often enough to know when we needed a beverage refill, or to ask bbn if needed. Meal was very timely.i didn't get a photo of what I partook of, but did so of the desserts. The atmosphere was very calming, colorful in a comforting way. The music was fabulous as it was Italian and as well had older music from varied times but classics like Sinatra, Michael Buble', and many others I enjoyed altho wasn't sure of the names. The lighting was lower so as nit yo ve blinding like a cafeteria. Seating was /is comfortable. Table is a perfect size and height. There's a beautiful fireplace as well which seals the atmosphere comfort. The decor is of wine and scenery, etc. Could use an array of plants but that's just my likes. Ya know...a big rubber tree plant in each corner. Large flowering hanging plants that don't require bright light. And id love a nice candle center piece on each table with battery operated flame to keep safe from the carcinogens that burn off the wick and make us ill. Plants that clean the air. Ok enough of my particular likes. They should be 4xs the siize as it's in need of feeding the multitudes so to speak. You all need to go and eat there and meet Jenna.shell make uour visit a great one. I'm definitely patronizing this lovely restaurant again soon...with more friends and or family. I brought a meal home to my father also and he so enjoyed.

R
Ram Agarwal

great place for veggie pizzas. stuffed banana peppers r great too. quite busy. recommend reservation. overll nice experience

C
Chris McGowan

Good food and nice place. Parking is small especially during the summer when they do their patio. Try the rice balls, they are excellent.

M
Manar Al Nuaimi

Very simple friendly place to eat. Food was delicious and nutritious. It's on my list for comfy dinner

J
Jeannine Serley

Smallish dining area,nothing special about decor but really good food and service

B
Beverly D.

Stopped in on a Saturday night. It was busy so we just got pizza for take-home. Love their thin crispy crust.

M
Marissa O'Connor

Very yummy food and very friendly staff. Wish there was more on the menu to select from. Dessert and coffee was delicious!

R
Richard Martone

Consistently good, but not spectacular. Lasagna and gnocchi very satisfying. Dessert can be the highlight of your visit if you choose. Half price wine on Wednesdays.

C
Courtney Sorrento

Great ambiance, nice variety! The chocolate mousse isn't super chocolatey... It was very pretty and smooth, though. Staff was super friendly and helpful! I want to come back for dinner :)

J
Julie Knapp

Cute little Italian restaurant. Easy parking. Clean restaurant and restroom. Food arrived, as ordered, quickly. Food was decent. Bread served in the beginning was EXCELLENT. Would return again if my party wanted to.

Kristin Mancuso
Kristin Mancuso

Everything was decent. Spent $100 on lunch for 4 and just shared a few things. This was my first time at the tonawanda location. I def prefer the one on Sheridan in every way.

Jill L
Jill L

My lunch mates had no complaints about their food from any of their visits. They recommended pizza and paninis. I tried the Quatrro Formaggio Pizza, aka four cheese in English. It's was delicious. Their pizzas are all thin crust, so you'll either love that or not - dealer's choice. The offer half salads if you want to feel healthy while eating something else, or you can't make up your mind! The half salads are still big. Depending on how hungry you are, that could be your meal. The bread you get when you're first seated was good, too. They serve it with butter and ground green olives. That was new for me. They also have a dessert menu of various coffees and confections. They're in a case, so if you want to just sneak in for dessert as take away, you can. The wait staff was very friendly and accommodating.

Wendy Thompson
Wendy Thompson

Pizza was skimpy for the price. Caesar salad was not a Caesar salad. Was field greens not romaine, served with watered down Italian style dressing, with no anchovies, as they were all out A definite disappointment from the Sheridan drive location.

E
Eternal Tem

Amazing service, staff was great, place looked awesome, baked goods were awful, I didn't finish either of em and it was 5$ a piece, hopefully non deserts are better

P
Pat Hayes

The pizza is just ok, pepperoni is not real. For as much as they charge it wouldn't hurt to buy some stick pepperoni and slice it. Atmosphere is good and service is excellent.

S
Sue Samuels

Ordered Margarita Pizza that was overcooked and dry as a bone. This will be the last time ... Sad...I have ordered these for years ...but this one was worse than my grandkids Tony's frozen pizza. The Cheese Cake rocked...loved every bite.

T
Tala Dianati

Food was good and delicious but waitresses don’t behave well. They don’t offer napkins, fork, knife, spoon, pepper, salt, sauce, etc. My table was empty.

M
Michelle Grundner

I ordered a cassata cake and it was horrible. I have ordered them before and they were delicious I dont know what happened with this one. But dobt think I will be coming back

C
Carl Wolfram

First time there , we stopped in for coffee and dessert. I had carrot cake and my wife ordered a lemon cake, both were stale sorry to say.

D
David Gardner

We’ve been here a few times and it’s usually ok. Rarely spectacular but consistent. Tonight, not so much. There was a problem with the plumbing and the dining area smelled of raw sewage. On a chilly night we elected to sit outside rather than deal with the odor. I ordered the ravioli special, sausage ravioli, and it was “meh”. Seemed like frozen ravioli which I wouldn’t expect to be on the daily special list and it was not cooked enough. Another guest had the gnocchi but sent it back and then had the Alfredo which was also less than stellar. A third guest had the cheese ravioli which was similar to the sausage ravioli. The pizza was terrific! We would have thought they would have offered some token given the experience with the raw sewage smell which forced us outside on a 60 degree evening but they did not. A manager never appeared, perhaps one wasn’t working tonight. We may be back but not anytime soon; too many other choices in the area with higher quality products, staff and customer service.

P
Patti Piracci

Visited last night, very small and crowded. Put at a small table against the wall then sat someone behind me to where I couldn't even move my chair out to get up, had to slide out. The service was exceptional and all wonderful. Put bread on table with 2 little butter ( could you spare it) and some nasty dry olive spread it was gross. I ordered the Lasagna Bolognese $16.99, well what a joke! There was 2 little chunks of hamburger, barely any cheese, and all noodle! Asked the server where the meat was and she said somewhere in there, no salad but served with green beans. The piece of bread on the plate was hard as a rock. Very disappointing and won't go back. BTW I make a much better Lasagna!

A
Akanksha Sood

2 stars solely for the servers. Food was below average. The stuffed peppers had a disgusting, chalky after taste. The pizza was burnt on the edges. The bread did not taste fresh. The only slightly decent thing was the peasant soup.

D
Darin Di Bello

The food was good, but the waitress were all chatting which is fine, and the one kept swearing on and on when she was talking, not something you want to hear when your out to eat.

W
Wes Patton

Came in to grab two slices of cake and they were very old and dry 😕

Chris McCarty
Chris McCarty

Tried this place for the first time. Got a soup, tiramasu latte, and some pastries to go. The complementary bread was pretty plain, but came with an olive spread that was nice and the bread paired well with the soup. For $8 the spicy sausage soup was 5/5. The tiramasu latte was also $8, but while Im glad it wasn't super sweet there also wasn't any flavor and there was so much ice you'd think anyone id was required to order it. 2/5 Then the pastries were disappointing. I spent $9 on a cream filled glazed pastry, thats one of their more expensive items. The glaze has some depth from the rum but the bread underneath tastes like one of those wrapped sweet breads from a 7-11. The cream filling wasnt even filling. Its little more than a dallop on top. The pastries have both the flavor and texture of something thats been frozen and defrosted. None of them tasted fresh.

A
Anne Welch

ALWAYS loved it and the great service until last visit. I called in for a pizza and was told 35 min which means they are crazy busy. I came to pick up order 37 minutes later and was greeted right away at counter, cashed out and told "the pizza is in the oven right now so it shouldn't be much longer". NO problem I don't mind. Meanwhile, take out people come in, get their food and leave. Servers say nothing to me or even engage in eye contact THIS goes on until the ONE hour point in which I grab a busy waitress who had nothing to do with my order and explain it had been one hour and I had been told a while ago that the pizza was in the oven. She very politely said she would check which I appreciated greatly as she had nothing to do with order. About five minutes later she brings me my pizza and says, "sorry for the wait" then asks if I was cashed out already. I confirmed I was "a while ago" and left. BIG mistake! Got home to discover they had placed FOUR THICK COMPLETELY RAW SLICES OF EGGPLANT ON MY PIZZA AFTER WAITING OVER AN HOUR. Here is the thing, I would have been fine if someone had said my order mistakenly didn't get in. I would have been fine with someone saying, "We are out of cooked eggplant do you mind waiting longer or can we get you something else?" BUT no, I didn't even have anyone follow up or address the situation until I involved the server that was not involved in the order. I have given this site (Tonawanda) regular business for years. Loved the food and the service. Now I can HONESTLY say I will never go back-(most definitely) not because of a wait, or human error, but because they showed a lack of character and appretiation for loyalty. Placing slabs of raw eggplant on top of my pizza was deliberate. All I would say to Romeo and Juliets now is they mistook friendliness for foolishness and as a result lost a loyal customer. I won't be back nor will I continue to recommend them and suggest them among the many communities I am involved with. CHARACTER is everything in my book.

S
Sharon Fischer

Ordered pizza Portobello last night take out! It was basically 75% crust and very little mushroom or mozzarella cheese! It was eating crust only! The outer crust was full of "bubbles" Not worth $12!!

S
Sharon Verrastro

Went to lunch with 3 friends. They said they had a cauliflower crust and 1 of my friends was eager to try it. We always split a pizza. We asked the waitress if you can get the cauliflower crust with any pizza and she said yes. One of the girls had her granddaughter with her and she asked if for a personal pan pizza. The waitress replied that they only have 1size pizza so she ordered a regular pizza. When her pizza came it was 8 slices, when the cauliflower pizza came it was 4 slices ,but charged for a regular 8 slice pizza. I called the restaurant to say how unhappy we were. That our bill was $24. and change. For 4 slices and 1/2 salad $5.99. I was told we when we say it we should of ordered a second pizza!!! Not good customer service, don't order the cauliflower pizza

J
Joe Dagonese

If you are italian, then you will not enjoy this food Also 12$ for one singular arancini that was still cold in the center, mayber try microwaving it for 30 seconds more Lasagna was colossal and totally a mess Pasta con polpette is a joke, I've actually had better at Williamsville South High School I would be respectful, but since I had to pay close to 100$ for this is unacceptable. The chocolate mousse was a joke too In conclusion, everything was overpriced and total garbage.

D
Dean LoBrutto

THE WORST RESTAURANT EXPERIENCE OF OUR LIFE! If we could give ZERO stars it would still be too high a rating. From the beginning service was slow AND inattentive. It took the waitress (Samantha) 20 minutes to bring over a sample of the sauce SHE OFFERED TO GET. One of us did not get the their salad. Thirty minutes after we ordered one of us was one informed they didn't have the item. The food came AN HOUR AN TEN MINUTES AFTER we sat down. One of our dinners was literally cold. When we brought this to the waitresses attention she grabbed the plate and as she rushed away said "I gotcha". It almost fifteen minutes later and she had yet to return, offer an explanation or update. It was then, the one who received the cold plate, asked her to take it off the bill. The waitress replied, "I DON'T KNOW WHAT YOU EXPECTED" and in a snotty way. We then asked her to speak with the manager and her reply was, "I am the manager". The rude, indifferent and confrontational attitude demonstrated was astounding. In closing, only a poorly run business would such customer service train wreck in a managerial role.

K
Kathleen Buick

So highly disappointed that there was no diaper changing station in the bathroom For my baby. I saw other family's coming in and it broke my heart how great the food and quality the place was but lacked care and heart for people who are enthusiastic to bring their baby out for date night, should be ashamed and I had to change my baby on the seat at the table where our food was going to be consumed, very much disheartening and I so wanted a reason to come back and enjoy all the food goodness there. Should be ashamed.

S
Susie L.

Went there with excitement but only found out it was closed for 12 days… I understand they need the holidays off, but there is no information about they being closed on Google map or their website. Google says they are open, and even their “open” sign is on… it was a big disappointment.

J
Jamie Doane

Food was not good, which was surprising because it is usually delicious. Bought the chocolate peanut butter cake to bring home and it was stale. Definitely disappointed

Christine Magyar
Christine Magyar

This isn't a review about the food, this is more about the service. We got there at 8:30. They close at 9. I was with my family of 4 and we only wanted dessert. My husband asked if we can get a table and the waitress gave him an attitude and told us as long as we were out by 9 o'clock we could order. I knew we should have left at that point. There was already another family finishing up dinner. We got to our table. I asked for coffee and was served a lukewarm coffee and was only given half a cup. We ordered our desserts with more attitude from the waitress. We will not be coming back to this place again. If you are going to be closing at 9, you should know that you should be there for another half hour at least. Change your hours if you're not willing to stay. No tip offered and we didn't pay for the crappy coffee. Do better next time. Btw, the family was still there when we left and they ordered dessert after 9.

Eric Dommer
Eric Dommer

Small restaurant converted from older store, cool idea, nice atmosphere. Ordered stuff mushrooms, 2 soups, spinach salad and Chick Parm and Chick Marsala. Soups were great along with the mushrooms. Salad wasn’t yet touched……That’s when it all went down hill….Oblivious waitress brought luke warm dinners during soup course. We didn’t even start on the salad. The chicken was reheated over-breaded bland freezer-burned leftovers topped with a sauce to match the menu. The waitress delivered one dinner in the center of the table and asked if we needed anything else while walking away. No return until after dinner. Only 10% of the chick Marsala was touched so I asked in jest if this was supposed to be served hot….the only answer was a quick yes and the plate removed and the waitress walked away. It wasn’t busy. 445-515p. Only 2 other tables present. What a disappointment for an anniversary dinner. We will not return. If soups are your thing? Perfect. Every other reason to visit escapes me. Paid full boat for all dinners.

Vlad
Vlad

I don’t have anything good to share except I’m still looking for my pizza from yesterday. Uber choked and the restaurant choked. $47 bucks for mainly panini sandwich, desert. Pizza cost was half the order. Still 2 hungry people.

Inicia sessió per deixar una ressenya

Inicia sessió
👑 És teu? Reclama'l GRATIS!

Elimina anuncis i gestiona el menú

Explora la teva zona

Més restaurants a Tonawanda →
📸

30 Fotos

Explora les fotos de Romeo & Juliet's Bakery & Caffe

Romeo & Juliet's Bakery & Caffe
Romeo & Juliet's Bakery & Caffe
Romeo & Juliet's Bakery & Caffe
Romeo & Juliet's Bakery & Caffe
Romeo & Juliet's Bakery & Caffe
+25 Més
📍

Informació sobre Romeo & Juliet's Bakery & Caffe

Com arribar

2512 Sheridan Dr #9410, Tonawanda, NY 14150

Carregant mapa...
Romeo & Juliet's Bakery & Caffe
Toca per direccions

Destacats

Altament Valorat
4.5/5 estrelles
💬
Moltes Ressenyes
417 ressenyes
💰
Preu Moderat
Nivell de preus
👨‍🍳
coffee
Tipus de cuina

Serveis

🍽️ Dinar
🍾 Sopar
Cafè
🍰 Postres
🥗 Opcions Vegetarianes
🥡 Per Emportar
🍴 Menjar al Local

Opcions de Menjador

🍽️ Menjar al Local
🥡 Per Emportar

Informació del Restaurant

Estat
Verificat pel propietari
🕐 Horario Hoy
11AM-9PM
Valoració
4.5/5
💬 Ressenyes
417
💰 Nivell de Preus
$$
⏱️ Visita típica
People typically spend 45 min to 2 hr here
📞 Telèfon
+1 716-862-3980
🌐 Lloc Web
www.rjcaffe.com

Comoditats

📶 WiFi Gratuït
🅿️ Aparcament
🌿 Terrassa
Accessible amb Cadira de Rodes
🚻 Lavabo
💳 Targetes de Crèdit
📱 Pagaments Mòbils
🏘️

El Barri

Ubicació

2512 Sheridan Dr #9410, Tonawanda, NY 14150

📍 Explorar el Barri

Weather
20°
Temps actualitzat cada hora · Feines i esdeveniments actualitzats diàriament
Curtiss Park

park in Erie County, New York, United States of America

A 644m
🎮

Jocs

🎮 Guanya Punts Mentre Explores!

Juga a Find Me i canvia punts per descomptes a Romeo & Juliet's Bakery & Caffe i altres restaurants

🎮

Guanya Punts a Romeo & Juliet's Bakery & Caffe!

Juga a Find Me i canvia recompenses aquí

Guanya punts extra i canvia'ls per recompenses de Romeo & Juliet's Bakery & Caffe

🏆 Recompenses de Romeo & Juliet's Bakery & Caffe

💰

Descompte 10%

A Romeo & Juliet's Bakery & Caffe

1000 pts
Disponible
🍽️

Aperitiu Gratis

A la teva propera visita

2500 pts
Limitat
👑

Taula VIP

Experiència premium

5000 pts
Exclusiu

per canviar recompenses i guanyar punts

📋 Com funcionen les recompenses?

1

Juga a Find Me

Cada 100 punts de score = 1 punt de recompensa

2

Acumula Punts

Els workers obtenen 2x punts per partida

3

Canvia Recompenses

Descomptes, menjar gratis i experiències VIP

Trucar
Deixar ressenya a Google
👑

És teu? Reclama'l GRATIS!

Elimina anuncis i gestiona el menú

Inicia sessió i juga

Revisa el teu correu!

Sense contrasenya — t'enviem un enllaç per email

T'hem enviat un enllaç d'accés

Revisa la carpeta de spam si no el veus