Ashlee Holmes

Wow. We LOVED this place! We went here for lunch on a Saturday. We had a group of 15, but don't have to wait more than 20 minutes to get seated all together. Our waiter Anthony was the best! We all had cocktails, and I have to say their house margarita is as good as some top shelf margaritas I've had at some Mexican restaurants! As an app we had some different salads and their blistered shisito peppers. The peppers are served with a spicy ranch sauce that is BOMB. Definitely order these! We all had pizza, and the margherita, the Italian meats, and the Illuminati were our favorites! The Illuminati was sweet and spicy, then has a tangy kick from the gorgonzola. Solid pizza choice 👌. The pizza is wood fired and so yummy! Definitely pop in here if you're hungry for pizza while in Wimberly!

Zahed Hossain

As per the locals, it's the best pizza in town. The taste is good. Waiting time to get a table was 35 minutes for us and another 40 minutes to get the food. Service and atmosphere were good.

+3

Romy

The overall experience was wonderful!Food came out hot and prompt. Was delicious. The only comment I have for potential improvement would be the Shrimp Scampi, there was not enough sauce for the noodles, it very much tasted simply like noodles and shrimp no butter or lemon etc. The pizzas were absolutely phenomenal. Some of the best pizza I have savored. The salads are fresh and delicious. The Calamari was yummy and hot. Overall this was a great place and I would recommend!

+3

Daniel García Ordaz (The Poet Mariachi)

Pretty busy place in this very touristy town square, yet the food was delicious. Wouldn’t say it’s fast—not as a knock on the place, just saying it ain’t fast food on account of one has to take into account the parking lots are busy around the square, which is several blocks. Once you’re there, it’s pretty quick really. Great service and friendly staff. Impressive oven. Great outdoor area for kids and families. Pizza was delicious (Margherita): fresh ingredients, great crust! Caprese Salad was truly remarkable! Highly recommend!!

+2

Lillianna Huerta

I cannot stress enough how amazing this place was! The pizza was fantastic! Cooked to perfection. My husband loved the Italian sandwich. My drink was also so good! The service was great. The restaurant was also so clean and had a nice dine-in area and a beautiful area to sit outside. We are definitely stopping here again next time we're in town!

Frankly, I have never ate a better pizza! Service was good, but the waitress was so hurry because a lot of customers. Play area for kids are very good!

Tyler Tillerson

The wait was worth it... but boy did we wait. We arrived right as lunch crowd was starting on Saturday, but got seated in about 10 minutes. However, it was another 40 minutes (ordering and waiting) before our pizza and salad arrived. We had the Margarita Pizza (the basil pesto was super tasty) and the House Salad with a crazy good southwest ranch on it. Again, really good food but if you're in a hurry (or starving), be warned during peak hours.

Jessana DeAngelis

Great place. Very busy, but we didn't wait overly long for our order. We ordered to-go at the bar, and it was about 20-25 min to get a pizza and the meatball app. Got the Illuminati pizza, it was delicious ~ a little underdone, but not terribly. The meatballs were very good, though the sauce seemed more like a wing sauce than a meatball sauce, it was very thin and spicy, not at all what I expected. I liked both the sauce and the meatballs, but not particularly together. The service and atmosphere were great. It was my first time there, but I look forward to going back again, especially to dine-in.

Jorge Urbina

Cool place. Friendly service. Margaritas were SALTY and undrinkable. Told the server to double check the syrups. They mught have mistaken the sugar for salt. Ordered two margaritas and had to send both back. We ordered something else instead The fried asparagus were delicious

Mike Cole

Good little pizza spot, got a pie and a couple of drinks. Cool little outside area which is kid friendly. Nice inside semi outside bar with decent amount of seats. Staff very friendly and attentive.

We put our name on the waitlist and were told 30 mins. We went across the street since they had a bar and live music. Community pizza will let you get a drink while you are waiting but there’s isn’t anywhere to sit. After about an hour I went to check on where we were on the waitlist. The hostess had entered our number wrong so that’s why we never were called. The beer selection wasn’t great. They are a little pricey in my opinion. They do have a great area for the kids to run around and play which is nice. The wait staff was very accommodating to our special requests. Overall we enjoyed the visit and we will probably return.

Atmosphere was great. Service pretty good, It was super busy so I get it. The Reuben sandwich...... Not good, at all. The meat was so incredibly chewy , way too much thousand Island chewy bread. It felt like leftovers. For a better Reuben sandwich go to leaning pear .

Jimmy Lough

The pizza was good with quality toppings and a nice crispy wood fired crust. The dough was a little overly salty. Service was a little inattentive but we got our food real quick.

Dorinda Obsta

We were here Friday night. The service was terrible our waitress would walk right by when we were trying to flag her down. Helped other tables around us and didn’t check on us. The hostess were more attentive. Now let’s get onto the food! The spinach artichoke dip was fantastic but could have used more bread or even crackers for the amount they give you. We asked for more bread and 4 more pieces was $1. The pizza was AMAZING! We would come back for the pizza but would certainly get it to go! I ordered the bolognese and it came out lukewarm and I would have sent it back to get warmed up but our waitress disappeared again. The kitchen staff brought out the pizzas and I just asked for a to go container it will be great as leftovers when I can make it hot. The patio and kids area are lovely if you aren’t in a hurry or it the weather cooperates. If you want good pizza this place won’t disappoint in that arena but you might want to get it to go.

Charles Oliver

Firstly the food was great, the pizza had the perfect amount of crunch amd chew, the center was a bit floppy. The rosemary fries were great, no complaints there. Now to the negitives, It did take us a very long time to get our drinks from the bar, also the line to the bar being right next to our table made eating very uncomfortable. Every few minutes I had to ask someone not to put their butt right in my face while I was eating.

Donald Owings

Haven't been here since the reopening. Great atmosphere and decor, however the food missed the mark. It was Halloween and we had made reservations ahead of time in anticipation of a long wait. We got 2 appetizers and 2 pizzas. Not the quality or great taste prior to the remodel. The kids cheese pizza had an off taste and the dough was under cooked and soggy. Pretty hard to mess up a cheese pizza. Dough mouth feel came across as sour. The appetizers were small and price point didnt justify the serving size or quality. Off night for the kitchen? Perhaps. We will give them another try i guess, not good enough to be motivated to do it. I will update review when and if we do.