Custer's Last Stand

Lorena

On my way back from Peekamoose Blue Hole I'm happy to have found this ice cream place 😊 it was delicious 😋 and server was a very nice gentleman 😎 sorry I didn't asked for his name🤦🏻‍♀️ but I totally recommend it. I'll definitely be back next summer to both places🤗

Jerry Squillante

I have had ice cream here since 1980. Place is iconic and great for a quick pit stop for ice cream.

louis baldanza

I only ever get ice cream when I'm in Sullivan county here!! its so good will always come back every summer.

Jessica Cole

Cute little ice cream stand! Went there with my family for the 1st time and loved it! The young woman who helped us was very nice and sweet...and it's VERY affordable for a large family will be back for sure 😀

A nice little spot for ice cream I used to stop here at times with my dad on the way to visit my uncle in the area. This is a nice little spot, the portions for ice cream are very large, including the small size.

Good place for ice creams and milkshake. They also have food but it might take a while to get it. The prices are on the higher side and the portion for the fries and chicken was surprisingly small for $6.50.

Mary Naughton

A nice little spot for ice cream I used to stop here at times with my dad on the way to visit my uncle in the area. This is a nice little spot, the portions for ice cream are very large, including the small size.

HBTrails Adventures

Good place for ice creams and milkshake. They also have food but it might take a while to get it. The prices are on the higher side and the portion for the fries and chicken was surprisingly small for $6.50.

Staff was great , but the ice cream was soupy, already dripping when I received it. Taste was great but sloppy.

Joe Ranger

Staff was great , but the ice cream was soupy, already dripping when I received it. Taste was great but sloppy.

Cute spot, I got a fudge brownie hurricane with peanut butter. The flavor was good but my ice cream was almost entirely melted when they gave it to me. I finished maybe half before it was basically ice cream soup and was not appetizing enough for me to finish. My sister got one of their hard ice creams and that was good! I’d still recommend stopping by to support local. Maybe their ice cream machine was having an off day lol

The ice cream was great. Service not so much. The one woman helping us was very nice but she had two other people in there not doing anything. There was about 9 people on line waiting and she was taking the orders, preparing everything and taking the payments and making change. As far as I could tell the "manager" felt it wasn't his job to help at the window or make the ice cream and the other girl in there just watched as the other employee did everything. Not great. But the ice cream was good and made well.

Katie Miller

Cute spot, I got a fudge brownie hurricane with peanut butter. The flavor was good but my ice cream was almost entirely melted when they gave it to me. I finished maybe half before it was basically ice cream soup and was not appetizing enough for me to finish. My sister got one of their hard ice creams and that was good! I’d still recommend stopping by to support local. Maybe their ice cream machine was having an off day lol

Julia Carr

The ice cream was great. Service not so much. The one woman helping us was very nice but she had two other people in there not doing anything. There was about 9 people on line waiting and she was taking the orders, preparing everything and taking the payments and making change. As far as I could tell the "manager" felt it wasn't his job to help at the window or make the ice cream and the other girl in there just watched as the other employee did everything. Not great. But the ice cream was good and made well.

There toppings are mixed and they have nothing that says they are mixed I had peanuts in my ice cream there's nothing marking them for allergies when I told them about it they told me they're topping were mixed

Me and my family went here yesterday. The icecream was good and it was soft it didn’t taste funny. But the next day everyone literally had diarrhea. My stomach has been hurting me all day we all had to run to the bathroom a lot. I don’t know why this icecream bothered us like that but it shouldn’t have.

Paige Bonker (Grimm)

There toppings are mixed and they have nothing that says they are mixed I had peanuts in my ice cream there's nothing marking them for allergies when I told them about it they told me they're topping were mixed

rina valentine

Me and my family went here yesterday. The icecream was good and it was soft it didn’t taste funny. But the next day everyone literally had diarrhea. My stomach has been hurting me all day we all had to run to the bathroom a lot. I don’t know why this icecream bothered us like that but it shouldn’t have.

Doesn’t offer peanut free options and wouldn’t clean equipment to make sure there was no cross contamination with someone who has anaphylactic peanut allergy. Quite disappointing.

Handed us soft served ice cream already melting off the cone onto the counter. And the small hard ice cream I got wasn’t even a full scoop. Awful!

The food was so undercooked. They put 3 pieces of French fries and 3 pieces of tenders in one order. We ordered 6 orders of chicken tenders and French fries all together, and we only got 4 orders. Customer service was slow. I wish I was able to put 0 stars.

Way over priced. Only got food here. Burger was tiny. Gave us literally a few french fries with our order, like 5. Would definitely not recommend nor go back.

Was not happy with the fact they had peanuts mixed with the gummy bears told me

They are closed, when their site says they are open.

Cliff O

They are closed, when their site says they are open.

Joann Bonker

Was not happy with the fact they had peanuts mixed with the gummy bears told me

Jessica Richmond

Doesn’t offer peanut free options and wouldn’t clean equipment to make sure there was no cross contamination with someone who has anaphylactic peanut allergy. Quite disappointing.

Jennifer Nowinski

Way over priced. Only got food here. Burger was tiny. Gave us literally a few french fries with our order, like 5. Would definitely not recommend nor go back.

megan

Handed us soft served ice cream already melting off the cone onto the counter. And the small hard ice cream I got wasn’t even a full scoop. Awful!

Leila

The food was so undercooked. They put 3 pieces of French fries and 3 pieces of tenders in one order. We ordered 6 orders of chicken tenders and French fries all together, and we only got 4 orders. Customer service was slow. I wish I was able to put 0 stars.