Christopher Sinclair

Ordered two german meat dishes. Absolutely delicious. Friendly service. Very clean dining room with modern decor. Beautiful view of the lake. Very reasonably priced for the portion size, which was generous. 3 recommendations that don’t impact the rating: the bread brought to the table was fresh and delicious, so I wanted 2, but had to ask for more. Also, there is a duplication of descriptions on the dessert menu, so our waitress made up a description on the spot, which was incredible. Lastly - put the potato ball and pancakes on the menu as sides! 5/5, would recommend and come again.

Keith From NY

I had a steak and it was very good. It came with mashed potatoes and makes vegetables. No salad. The tables are crowded together and the silverware that I got looked like it had never seen a dishwasher. I told the waitress and she never brought a replacement set I had to get it from someone else from another table. Not impressed for the prices they charge

Lemmie Klein

Our last night on Long Island we met our friends at Millhouse Inn for dinner. My wife and I had the French Onion Soup. It was very good with lots of gooey cheese. We ordered 2 appetizers for our main dish. I had the coconut shrimp and she had the crab cakes, which arrived as 1 big crab cake.

Brittany Katzdorn

Cute little restaurant overlooking a pond with great food and occasionally live music. Food was decent. Large portions. Very busy.

Marlene is Key

I’ve dined at Millhouse Inn a few times. The parking lot will always be a challenge as it’s dirt and not so friendly on certain luxury cars. For some reason whenever I go there, it seems they’re a bit short staffed but overall it’s great service. The food portions are very generous and the menu has many selections, my mixed drink was a bit bland but I always enjoy going as the space itself is nice. I did not visit the restroom but I would recommend trying it at least once! The area itself just needs a little love.

+1

ny35fan

Hardly anyone in the dining room but the bar was very crowded. Buffalo wings were dry and overcooked. Our entrées were good and the share dessert was delicious. Our server was very sweet and the beer was cold. We've been here a few times and I would go back again.

Elise Skidmore

We tried Millhouse Inn because we're were given a gift card. We'd never been before. We enjoyed it very much. Had a chance to try some German dishes we hadn't had in ages, which were very good. The portions were large, and the service was friendly. When you enter, there's a foyer that separates the bar from the dining room. Even though the bar was busy, we didn't have to listen to it while enjoying our meal.

Kanishka Wijesekara (Kanishka)

Went to this American/German restaurant by the water with my wife for lunch. The ambience and service is amazing. Plenty of parking too. Had the German sampler and the only thing I liked about it was the bratwurst and the potato ball. The homemade ginger sauce was too sweet for my liking. My wife had the chicken ALA Rachel and that was quite good. Didn't get anything to drink since we were driving.

+5

Jen Matyas

I saw a sign for karaoke on their billboard a while ago, messaged the bar asking if they were still having it the day of and what time, and got a response saying yes, showed up and waited for 30 mins and had to ask someone what was happening and they said they cancelled it. It wasn’t posted on the website and the person never told me. What a waste of time. I tried giving it another chance and coming out tonight again tonight for trivia. Sat down to eat in the “trivia” room. Waited another 45 minutes after it was supposed to start and again had to ask someone, who told me it was cancelled. So I guess i won’t be returning. Someone needs to work on the event planning, I’m glad i didn’t have all my friends come out just to waste their time. The table we sat at had a paper topper and was under the AC and had (what looked to be mold) on it. And we looked up and that ac unit hasn’t been cleaned in god knows how long. Super disappointed. Hope you can improve on these things for your guests in the future. The food tasted good, a bit pricey for what you get but was still good, and the burger cooked correctly

donna wiemann

Do not eat here ! Unless you want food poisoning ! They serve food that is expired I ordered a steak dinner it was maybe a 1/2 inch if that ! It had definitely a funky taste it was horrible & oh and raw scallops ! Stay Away ! Not a very friendly bartender either save yourself the headache stay away ! Unless you want to sick 🤮

John Kidd

Normally very good. However I won't go back. I went out with my wife for a nice evening. It was very bad. Ordered a beer with dinner took twenty minutes to get my beer. Had to ask for bread when it came it was frozen inside. Got my salad, I was supposed to have Blue cheese salad dressing. They sent balsamic vinaigrette. When I asked the girl said oh we're out of blue cheese salad dressing. Will I have to make some more? I ate it with balsamic. Ordered sauerbraten with potato dumpling potato dumpling was cold inside. Don't think I'm ever going back. Kind of sad because it was a nice little place that typically had good food. But I'm not going back because I pay for service that I didn't get. Food was cold.