Jensey Root

We're so lucky to have Lil' Anthony's down the road from us!! Best pizza in Orlando. The restaurant has true small town charm and the servers make you feel like family. ♥️

Kathy Dixon

Placed an online order for delivery tonight, mistakenly received a pizza, not the calzone ordered. Called restaurant and they were so helpful and made the calzone and had it delivered so quickly. We usually dine in and have never had a problem before. Can't say enough about how courteous and professional in taking care of us tonight. Thank you again @lil Anthony pizza, we will continue to recommend to friends.

DeziB

🔥 This place is AMAZING! We’ve been traveling full-time for four years and hunt down pizza and Italian food every Friday all over the country. This spot is by far one of the best we’ve found. Literally everything was amazing. The lasagna was top-notch and the noodles are made in-house which makes such a difference. The pizza crust was perfect, crispy on the outside and soft on the inside, absolutely spot on. Michelle, the general manager, was so sweet. She checked on us often and made sure we were happy the whole time. She made it feel like home which was awesome. 🥰 She was also super sweet to my daughter and her baby doll. Thank you Michelle! The atmosphere is fun and super clean. Each table has its own theme which I think is a cool New York vibe. If you haven’t been here yet, I HIGHLY suggest you go. It’s seriously so good!😊

+1

david mitchell

New favorite pizza place. Driven by it a hundred times and finally stopped in. Family owned and very welcoming. Pizza was spot on with a perfect, slightly crispy crust and just the right amount of cheese, sauce and toppings. Music bingo night was going on which seemed very popular. Will absolutely be back.

Keith David

Awesome local pizza restaurant, great for sit-down or carry out. A real family-owned business, don't hesitate to give them a try! The Garlic Bread with Pepperoni is a full-size baguette of garlic bread, toasted and layered with pepperoni. Great to split as an app or a full meal for one. It was so good we came back again and split a Large Italian Calzone. Fantastic! Super rich and delicious calzone filling, love it! The interior of the restaurant has always been clean and comfortable while waiting for my order. My only caveat would be the wait time, generally it is on the longer side of their estimate even when arriving at the end of their prescribed time for a single item. Totally worth waiting the extra 5-10 minutes for me but if you're in a rush, just be aware. Still highly recommend and will be back again for sure!

Joa J

The pizzas were great, the decor was fun, and NY turned. The staff was friendly and attentive. Last night, they had a musical bingo or something, the customers were very happy playing and singing. Our family dinner was a delight! Thank you!

+1

Sophiettie V.

After picking up kids from school, they asked to stop to buy some pizzas. As I googled, the closest one was Lil’ Anthony’s Pizza. We enter in the pizzeria and that place just amazed us, tables with a lot of historic things, like entering in a small part of New York, a small piece of New York is here, in this amazing pizzeria. The Queens and Brooklyn Pizzas that we ordered were truly, really delicious. My kids were very impressed and me too. I highly recommend this amazing place.

Undercover Astrology

2/21/25 I ordered two cheese slices, which came to $9.99. The crust is pretty good, nice and crispy. Plenty of cheese. The pizza sauce had no flavor though. With some oregano and basil in the sauce, the pizza could be spectacular. I'm not sure I'll give them another try.

Ashley Marie Hall

Aesthetics are great but if you’re going for the food - you’ll be let down. Went for breakfast as it came highly recommended - it was very much meh. Pancakes had a weird aftertaste. Eggs were eggs. Bacon was bacon. Prices were decent. Servers were great. Can say I visited.

John Hartnett

Something changed with the food. We used to eat at L’il Anthony’s a few times a month. We ordered for the first time in over a year and were surprised that the food lacked flavor. The salad was great, but pasta, meatballs and garlic knots were not as flavorful as we remembered. Hoping it’s just an off night for them.

Supreme pizza had very little sauce on it which made the crust dry. I asked for a small cup of sauce and was told yes but never got it. Had to go to counter to get my check. Wife's soda drink was empty near end if meal.Counter person said she'd get it then walked away to clean a table and had a long conversation with bartender. Waitress finally took our money as I waited at counter. Used to go there a lot in years past but no more.

Paulo Figueiredo Filho

I've ordered a shrimp pizza and there was barely no shrimp. Literally some slices had no shrimp at all. So obviously, not happy about paying 33 dollars for a shrimp pizza with no shrimp, I've called the place and suggested some improvement - but I was dismissed with them saying that's the way they do it. Okay, keep doing it I guess, until you go out of business...

Jason Cox

Not sure what these are but I would call them dried up shriveled wings

Lindy Garcia-Metz

Ordered a cheese and sausage pizza, it was so bad I would have been better off getting a frozen pizza from the grocery store. Hardly any sauce or cheese on it and tasted like card board. I use to order from them a few years back and it was delicious but the quality has definitely gone downhill. What a waste of money.