Emily

Cash only and a small place - there’s only 5 tables inside. One of the most genuine Italian restaurants I’ve been to. They perfectly prepared the clams so they didn’t have sand in them which is pretty hard to do. Everything was great. Got hot chocolate to go. Seems like they make a lot of things from scratch. Update: I come here all the time still and my favorite thing to order is the spaghetti and meatballs. The tiramisu is really good too. They offer sparkling water at a really cheap cost.

K DJ

Stumbled upon this little gem of an Italian restaurant by chance. It’s no bigger than a broom closet, but the food, the atmosphere, and especially the staff are absolutely unforgettable. Flavorful dishes made with quality ingredients and lots of love. A huge recommendation!

Em L

My friend and I can’t stop raving about this place! We adored the food, the service, the atmosphere - I’m already thinking about going back. You could tell they cooked everything with love. I got the linguine pescatora and while they were out of clams, they included extra mussels instead. Regardless, the dish was immaculately flavorful! There isn’t much seating indoors, but I would say it made the experience extra special because we got lucky and were seated immediately (we got there shortly after 1 on a Sunday). Shout out for the warm, friendly and attentive service. This restaurant is truly the whole package (but just a heads up, it is a cash only establishment.)

Loren

The pasta was freshly made and phenomenal. The service was also great. Just be aware that there’s very little seating and it’s very casual, one server (I believe the owner). It’s not fancy, but it is authentic, fantastic food.

renzo marmolejo

As shown in the photos we got the 1)Gricia 2)Veal tortellini 3)mussels in marinara sauce 4)sautéed artichokes 5) last but not least tiramisu !!! Everything blew us away. The flavors were so rich and perfectly balanced. I’m excited to go back and try more things items on the menu. I commuted from Queens and waited about an hour to be seated. It was definitely worth it. I’d do it all over. Lillo and Lisa are very welcoming and friendly! Already planning my next visit.

Sharon Russell-Fowler

What a hidden delight. Even though it’s a cash only location, as well as having only seating for 12, it’s worth the wait. They don’t take reservations, so be prepared to wait as you look through the window and watch the delectable meals come out of their kitchen. Happy I read the reviews that brought me here. A very happy patron!

Emily Faber

Literally everything about our meal here was perfect. The service was amazing, and I am still dreaming about the incredible lemon ravioli. We got three different pastas to split between the two of us (we couldn't decide on just two!), and we walked away with delicious leftovers to enjoy later. We also got the strawberry tiramisu to-go, and it was one of the best desserts I've ever had.

Sarah Khalbuss

Cash only! 4 tables, super cute spot that has raving reviews. I showed up around 2:30 for a late lunch. The menu was actually pretty big surprisingly but I knew I wanted a salad and a creamy pasta. I decided on the Regina salad, a tuna and bean salad and the lobster ravioli. I got sparkling water with lemon. I loved the thick balsamic on the salad. Fresh and simple with a clearly good olive oil. The lobster ravioli was INCREDIBLE. Bury me in the pink sauce. The prices here are awesome! The dishes come with some bread to sop up the sauce.

Maru C

THE Best Italian Restaurant I’ve been to in the states. Must go. Amazing mushroom pasta. Amazing. Plus the price was very affordable, $70 for two people including tax n tip, for everything from the pictures below.

Matthew McCann

Incredible, delicious and authentic. Lillo truly cares about each customer and ensures you have an Italian experience. It’s the top 3 best Italian restaurant I have been to! The amatriciana sauce was perfect 🍝 Just wish you could at least bring your own wine.

Maria

Incredibly well made pastas served by an impressive two man kitchen. The dishes are all authentic Italian recipes cooked to perfection and you will certainly feel like you’re in a Roman restaurant. *Cash only

Jo P

This place is fantastic. The food reminds me of my fathers cooking, who is also has a small italian restaurant. The flavors blend together and the pasta is great quality. You just walk in and grab a seat. I highly recommend everyone try Lillo. Although Id love to keep it a hidden gem, id deserves all the hype, especially with its prices. We got the Fettucine with Speck and Carciofi and the Fettucine with Speck and Zucchine. Update march 15, 2024: Still love it here. Tried the Amatriciana this time and it was great. The tiramisu is so fluffy and delicious. Really love how cozy and no-frills it is here

Fred Jay

Step into Lillo Cucina Italiana for cozy vibes and unbeatable Italian cuisine in Brooklyn. From perfectly cooked dishes to incredible sauces, every bite is a delight. With reasonable prices, it's a top pick for a memorable dining experience. Highly recommended for those craving authentic Italian flavors in a welcoming atmosphere.

Michael Farkas

Just like an Italy, where you can walk into a nameless storefront and have one of the best meals of your life, Lillo delivers proper and classic dishes that make you feel like you're being fed by a Nonna. His forte are the Roman pastas, and his desserts, as he hails from Rome and is an accomplished baker and chef. Even his sandwiches are second to none. Every meal here is a feel-good experience.

+13