Justin Rogers-Cooper

Lush interior with antebellum and/or Victorian vibe, even better at night with low light and cushiony, dense crowd. Cocktails are top flight in all senses, making it good for dates, celebrations, and impressivity. Be patient with the table service. Negroni on tap. Beers and wine also available. Super close to Barclays/Atlantic. Go ready to spend, if not to sip. Bill comes in a book.

+6

Jeremy Ondo

Really nice little cocktail spot. They have an inventive, yet approachable list of house cocktails in addition to the classics. There is also beer and wine, but we let the bartender make us something delicious. We had the “Southern Belle” and the “Swing Revival”. Both were well made and tasted great. I’ll come back next time I’m in the area.

Vicky D

It's a cozy bar near Barclay's which is great for concerts. It's small so getting a table can be tough. The drinks are spendy, but really good. Would skip the food cause nobody in our party really enjoy what we ordered. Nice enough staff, but they were a bit overwhelmed cause there was only one server onsite. I would go back but only for the drinks.

Melissa Andrade

It's great for evening dates (dim lit), or solo at the bar. Bartenders are friendly. Tables are small (for a date). The menu is share-friendly/small plates and leans into Mediterranean flavors. You have a good mix of classic cocktails + new-age bar techniques (milk punch, carbonated). It's a solid spot + they have tables out front on the sidewalk - good for people watching.

m lc

first time there, loved the cocktails and ambience. unfortunately, the young lady at the door was borderline rude and very unwelcoming. i noticed same attitude given to other arriving clients. some ppl arent cut for hospitality. we almost left after being “greeted” like that. the server w the red beanie hat was nice and explained the drinks to us

Jacqueline G

I really liked it here! At first I thought it was too noisy but I realized I was just being silly. It's a very cozy environment to bring your partner or some friends to chat and have some drinks. Our waiter was very friendly and very attentive. I originally was going to eat anything but then I decided to order the grilled cheese and I'm really glad I did. The bread was pretty crunchy but overall it was really good and it was great with the pesto sauce on the side. Would definitely recommend coming here! The drinks were pretty pricey but overall good.

+3

Danny Surujbali

Sweet Polly is a great addition to the area. The space is cozy and romantic for couples yet can accolade smaller groups for a nice hang. The food was very good and the mixologist concocted some really nice drinks. The only issue I had was with our mixologist, although the drinks were good, he had a slight tude or maybe just lacked personality. Would certainly go back!

Regan Kelly

Service and drinks were fine, the room though is uncomfortable - chairs loom high over the tables, which are tiny. There's a total of 3 hooks for the entire room, so winter coats have nowhere to go - it's just laid out really weird and awkward.

Stuart Miller

The cheese and charcuterie platter was embarrassing, with only a few slices of chorizo and 2 miniature portions of cheeses (and beer nuts of all things). Preposterously priced at $25 I think it's the worst such platter I've ever had. Their wine options were slim and not good at all either. If I ever go back it'll be for the cocktails as I'm told they are good. They'd need to be to keep this place in business.

M C.

This was my first time hanging out in this area, and I initially thought it would be a good spot for me. As a restaurant and full bar owner, I brought my team there to explore something new. I usually avoid writing reviews because I understand how businesses operate, but this experience was disappointing from start to finish. Honestly, I’m not even sure if the person serving us was a manager, owner, or staff, but the attitude was unacceptable. After seeing other reviews mentioning similar issues, it’s clear this isn’t an isolated incident. As someone who just built a business nearby, I’ll stick to growing mine with solid strategies and word of mouth. Unfortunately, I won’t be returning.