Michael Deyo

Michael T’s catered our annual Xmas party at work. This is the second year they have catered the event, I have only worked there 2 years, and the food was excellent! I work overnight shift and they had an omelette bar, breakfast greens, bacon, sausage waffles and fresh fruit. Highly recommend 👍👍👍

Deborah Montero

Cozy and casual, with a nice bar to go sit and have cocktails at. We had Pork Osso Buco that was out of this world! The meat was so tender and fell right off the bones. Our server was so polite and attentive. The prices are reasonable as well.

Al Wilson

We were just driving to Texas Road House, seen this place and turned around. We ate all the food before taking a picture. This dinner you can taste scallops as scallops, haddock as haddock, and shrimp as shrimp. They've done very well, not over cooked or well done. You just need to show up and savor the flavor. Top 10 on my list of places to eat ; )

Twisted Fate

I went here for the first time yesterday, on Mother's day. The food was very good, the portions are a good size and the prices were reasonable. All of our food was served nice and hot! And the best part of our experience was our waitress, Erica. She was very patient with our party of 10 and very accommodating. She got all our orders correct and always made sure we had everything we needed. I highly recommend this restaurant and plan to visit again, bringing my in-laws, because they have never been to Michael T's before.

scott Larrison

We are big fans of this local, family owned eatery, that's been a staple of Seneca Turnpike in New Hartford for years. The atmosphere is casual and the staff is friendly (our bus girl Alex was particularly pleasant!). They offer generous portions of Italian/American cuisine, including local favorites like chicken riggies and greens trunfio. The prices are reasonable and they can accommodate large groups for dinner or a special event . Reservations are recommended.

Pearl Dunn

Ordered my favorite “chicken trunfio”. Haven’t been there in a while and I think they changed the prep. Onions and peppers were “shoestring “ which I think detracts from the taste. Otherwise the meal and service was great

Courtney Coe

We placed a to-go order. 2 of The chicken marsala meals, and it was soupier than anticipated, spilled in the bag. It could just be their recipie that made it like that but it still tasted great regaurdless. Chicken supreme came with more food and had a veggie included besides the 1 side limit. We got all 3 meals with baked potato that came with the Loaded options on the side that we didn't know were included so that was a nice bonus. Each meal comes with bread and it was also very tasty. All in all a fantastic dinner.

Marnie Williams

Two dinners, one appetizer, and one soda with tip came to $75. The service was excellent. We had the chicken francaise and shrimp scampi along with mozzarella sticks. The marinara sauce was pretty good. Portions were decent, however, I would have like a couple more shrimp in the scampi. I would go back again and try their other dishes with sauce.

Katrina McMullen

My partner and I were less than impressed. The server was cold and completely unfriendly. Our appetizer was cold and our entrees were so hot you couldn't even taste the flavor almost as if the food was microwave. We wanted to take home our leftovers which I guess they take in the back to wrap up for you. We got home and discovered they didn't give us all our leftovers. Overall the $77 for two people was definitely not worth the price.

Brianna webster smith

We just went to this restaurant for our first time last week. Our waiter was fantastic, very nice, and attentive. Our food on other hand was not so great. We ordered long hots that were not hot at all more like a sweet pepper, we also ordered the spicy hot greens. The greens were very very bland and had way too many breadcrumbs in them. For our main course my husband ordered the triple plate which came with three different items including chicken parmesan, ravioli, and a pork choice. I ordered the lasagna. Both plates were very large portions but overall the taste was just mediocre.

Kevin Geremia

Michael T's Italian American restaurant is a nice place to go get a bite when in town. Now the place is always packed- which is good, but the food is just okay especially if you're used to excellent Italian food, which in Providence, we are. I wanted to order the veal parm and I asked server if the veal they used was provimi veal(the best) and she had no idea so that meant I was having chicken parm instead. So for 3 meals (1 chicken parm, 1 small kids cheese pizza and 1 vodka chicken riggie) and a water, lemonade and Shirley temple our bill totaled $57.00. Not bad, but if you're from our of town keep Mr. T's in your rear- view mirror. However, our drinks were for free so that's the plus side of things.

+7

David Duryea

Very mediocre italian food in a city noted for it. Service lack luster and slow. Had Riggies and was very disappointed.

Ross

Food is hit or miss, lacks flavor and depth -add more garlic and salt! Riggies are good but most of their tradition Italian food is below average for the Utica area. Also, parking is an absolute nightmare!