Ethan Litwin

Fierro’s is back! After the sale, the quality of the pizza fell considerably and we stopped going there for a time. But we heard that the pizza was again back to standards so tried it again. The rumor proved true! Again one of the best slices on the East End.

Dae M

Pictured is two slices with extra cheese. Not that too into pizza to give an in-depth review, but these really were some of the best slices I’ve had. The man I spoke to who I believe was the owner was friendly.

Dwayne Smith-Daioczok

I got the Spaghetti 🍝 Bolognese and it was absolutely FANTASTIC!!! It was enough for 2 people to eat for 2 days. And only about $23! 💋 😘 😗 😚 😙 💋

Sasquatch Kestner

Great group behind the counter. Haven't ordered anything I haven't liked, so far. Other than traffic getting here

KT

The employees are friendly and the food is yummy. There’s seating inside and a bunch of different pizza slices to choose from. I loved the cannoli.

Ken Kohler

Delicious authentic New York style pizza by the slice or a whole pie! This place has been in business for 40 years.

Kaab Ibar

As soon you walk in the atmosphere is relaxing. The customer service was great; friendly, fast and proficient. It was like we knew the guy for a long time. The restaurant was clean. I ordered a Buffalo chicken slice and garlic knots. It was slightly above average in taste. I would recommend Fierro's for lunch or dinner. They are located next to stop and shop in a small shopping center. So you can run errands and grab good food to go. They get 5 stars due to great customer service, excellent location, clean establishment. I'll be back soon and hope you give them a try too.

Don J

Great pizza, has a family feel to it unlike the big chains. The show actually sells photos from the wall. KiI guessing they are local art. That's even more if a plus! Overall great experience.

Kevin L

Decent neighborhood atmosphere pizzeria. Ordered a Hawaiian slice and garlic knots. Came out of their pizza oven in a few minutes at just the perfect temp. Bathroom was clean and tidy. Garlic knots was perfect. The only thing I didn’t like was that there weren’t much pineapple on the slice, though there was a decent amount of ham and cheese. Good value for the money.

Jacques Bertrand

Add-on: Just remembered they add on 4% for credit cards which seems excessive as the most visa charges is 3.5%. Missed the mark this time. Large cheese pizza crust was unevenly cooked and burnt in some spots. Then they got our chicken parme order wrong and we had to wait 10 more minutes. The tables were all dirty. No one was wiping them down. I went to the location in Montauk the night before and it was was nicer.

Mary Nieto

I didn't like it, they don't heat the pizzas and the place doesn't clean it. They always complain that they don't have enough staff but they don't do anything to improve, in reality they don't have a variety to choose from and they get angry when we give our opinion, don't get upset, it's just so they can improve, And of course you don't have to worry about me never coming back again, I'd throw my money away.

Mone Anderson

The people that work in this place very racist, I just experienced blatant racism. I always come in and buy my and even tip these people. I never ever been rude to anyone. But when I come in ONLY one guy assisted me. So went in today to get my usual pizza and the man served everyone but me. A young man walked to help and told him “thank you” the man that walked away from me, yelled and screamed at me that I’m mean. And that I’m mean to everyone there. I’ve ever ever been mean to nobody. I’ve always order my pizza and sat down and ate my food and go back to work. Today I feel so bad because it’s 2025 and humans are still being mean to each other. Man are angry at woman, this so unreal.