Michael Winter

Visiting Florida from Brooklyn, NY... so I know my pizza! I read the good reviews and had to try it myself. I've been to quite a few highly rated pizza places here only to be disappointed. I ordered a Sicilian with everything. I included the pic of it... Awesome looking Yes !! And a pic of an individual slice. Needless to say.. IT WAS AWESOME!!! Finally found a pizzeria that makes NY pizza ! Spoke a bit with Craig the owner, turns out he was born a few blocks where I was born in Brooklyn ! Great Guy, Great Staff and a Superb Pizza. Stop there and try !! You will not have any regrets .. just a review from me, a guy from Brooklyn! Going back to try their dinner specials next.

Melissa D

Heard about Amici's through a gift certificate I got in the mail when I moved. We got a free large cheese pizza. It was crispy and flavorful, not too oily. Staff at checkout were very friendly!

Maria Anaya

If you’re in Coconut Creek and craving the best pizza in town, this is the place! They always use fresh ingredients, the flavors are unbeatable, and you can tell they really care about quality. My personal favorite isn’t even on the menu, cheese, chopped tomato, onion, and artichoke. If they ever add it officially, it’s going to be the star of the show! The crust is perfectly toasted, the cheese is generous and melty, and every bite is pure happiness. Plus, the atmosphere is warm and family friendly, making it the perfect spot for a casual night out or a weekend treat. Highly recommend!

Leah Lopez

Amici’s really hit the spot! The upside down pizza was insanely good—crispy, cheesy, and full of flavor. I also tried the wings and Caesar salad, and both were super tasty and fresh. The whole place had a great vibe, cozy, clean, and perfect for hanging out. But what really stood out was the service & everyone was so friendly and on point. You can tell they really care. Definitely one of my new favorite spots!

John P

Their cheese pie, they’re upside down pie, second to none in the North Broward Boca area. They never disappoint. Fantastic family owned… any other dishes never disappoint

Michael McDaniel

Love it!! First time and surely wasn’t disappointed on our first orders. The dough had a nice taste and texture; just the right balance. The calzone topping was overloaded. Ambience was very homey and with a friendly crew giving good service. Surely will drop by again to taste the pizza and other dishes on the menu.

Lou Garlobo

Met the owner and his daughter—such a wonderful family business! They’ve been serving the community for about 18 years, and you can truly taste the passion in every bite. The pizza is absolutely amazing, the atmosphere is warm and welcoming, and it’s definitely a spot you need to eat at. Highly recommend!

Tova

Had a 1/2 cheese 1/2 pepperoni pizza made me feel like I was back in NYC! Best pizza I have had in South Florida. Will definitely be returning to try their award winning wings. Place is clean and staff is friendly. Great experience!

Dee gold

Wow! Came here for dinner at random and wow! The service is excellent, everyone is friendly and the food is fuggedaboudit! We had chicken and veal parmigiana and it was amazing. The garlic breadsticks hit boss level. Even the salad with house vinaigrette was on point. Thanks to all for a great experience.

Went here on a Friday night with some friends and everybody was freaking out about how good the pizza and the wings were. New favorite pizza place! I highly recommend the “Upside Down” pizza.

Best pizza in Broward county. Staff is super friendly!! Love the people

I am a stickler for good "NY Style" pizza. I've experience so much good pizza over my 42 years. I am very scrutinizing over my pizza. This is literally my favorite pizza place in south Florida. No joke. Two slices each the size of your face with the most ridiculously perfect ratio of cheese to sauce to crust. It's a savory experience unlike most. It feels like home too

Best pizza I’ve had in a long time. I rate pizzerias by their sauce, pizza crust, and pasta fagioli. They excelled at all three! Please come try it! Delicious and great service!!

People are so kind and the food is even better! Best pizza spot in the area

Best pizza in Coconut Creek! Great Food. Great People. Simple.

Friendly and accommodating service and staff. This New York style pizza place has such a wide variety of pizzas, pastas and more to choose from. Everything we ordered was absolutely delicious. The Garlic Parmesan Fries are a must try! Thank you Craig for being so attentive. We will definitely be back soon.

Ordered catering for a work event and the manager Craig was so accommodating! The staff helped me bring my food to my car although it was small and helped me! Love Amici’s

If you are looking for some top notch pizza, Amici’s does not disappoint. And trust me I know good pizza. I come from a Sicilian family with a pizza brick oven in our backyard where we make fresh pizza all the time. I decided on a basic pepperoni pizza. I am a huge fan of a pizza with a crispy dough. Amici’s Pizza has just the right amount of crisp to it and it folds perfectly to eat it. Not to mention our waitress was super sweet and very attentive to our table. The staff was super friendly and provided excellent service. Hands down the best pizza i have ever found in south Florida. Definitely will be returning for more of their amazing food!!

This place is so tasty! I gave it a try because of the google reviews and boy oh boy they are not lying! I tried a pizza with mushrooms & pepperonis and I could not get enough. I also had their wings & HIGHLY recommend the Buf-a-Que wings. They are perfectly cooked with just the right amount of sweetness and heat. 10/10 will order again. I recommend giving a call to avoid the online order fee, but either way, it is still worth a try.

I love the penne alla vodka and service is spectacular 👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻

Excellent pizza! My favorite is with grilled chicken on top. Delicious

This place is a truly an authentic Italian pizzeria restaurant! We stumbled across this place by accident and so happy we did.. The owner is such a pleasant man and his daughter is a doll! The good the best you will get in Boca! I have never had a bad experience in all the time coming here! It is truly perfection!! Thank you for bringing Italy to Boca my friend!

Great people, awesome food, loved our dinner.

My family and I have been eating at Amici's for a little over 3 years, we haven't been in a while, and my 4 year old was literally asking for their lasagna (I can't believe she remembered) so I went in with her today. From the warm welcome from the owner and his daughter, to the amazing food and service, you haven't had the best pizza in town until you've had Amici's! Also try the lasagna 😉 you won't regret it. Ohhhh and of course the brownie! Needless to say, they had to roll us out of there today.

I live right down the street and Its my go to spot for pizza! Great Family place with nice weekly specials to save a few bucks. Considering how hard it is to find and keep a good pizza man Amicis pizza is pretty consistent. Family owned and operated. And if youre from NY or NJ you all know good diner food, amici got great Diner style french fries and Chicken Tenders!

Love the pizza here! Best crust around

Amici’s is a great atmosphere with a great owner who goes above and beyond to accommodate his customers. One of the best pizzas in town. Service is always spot on and the workers are always pleasant. You won’t be disappointed.

If you love pizza and great Italian food, Amici's is the place to go. All 7 at our table had a delicious meal. The owner came by to ensure that we were pleased with our food. Our new, favorite Italian restaurant!!

The best pizza in Florida! I am from buffalo NY where pizza is amazing and hard to beat, but Amici's comes pretty close to being one of my favorite pizza spots! That says a lot because I have lived in FL for 20 years, pizza is my favorite food and i have tried sooo many pizza restaurants over the years and they don’t come close to Amici’s! I used to work next door at the animal hospital, and even though I no longer work there and I don’t live close, i still travel for it any time i want a great slice of pizza! The customer service is great, the pizza is always hot, and I will gladly spend my money there anytime!

My neighbor recommended this restaurant and I finally made it there last week. Best eggplant parmesan I had. I asked for the sauce on the side and it was just perfect. The sauce is out of this world. Great service, friendly atmosphere. Strongly recommend. I have gone twice in one week.

I have been to this place numerous times and always very happy with the food, the atmosphere, and the service. Definitely recommend

Best pizza in North Creek! This family owned and operated business makes the most amazing pizza, it’s the place we order from every time. The pizzas are large, the sauce is sweet and lots of toppings. The Greek salad we order every time as well...it’s so good! The cannolis are my husband’s guilty pleasure, while mine is the tiramisu. The wings are pretty yummy too. The staff is like family to the local neighbors - they all know you by name when you call or come in. The owner is incredibly involved in the local community and loves to give back, so if you’re supporting their business, you’re also likely supporting another local youth sports team or nonprofit in the area (which we love). A must go and try!

Always delicious pizza! Honestly our favorite pizza around. Perfect dough, just the right amount of sauce, and never soggy. Pasta fagioli is hearty and comforting. Service is always excellent!

Amazing food, and amazing service. One of my favorite Italian restaurants. 100% worth the visit!

Amazing! Cozy cantina atmosphere with friendly staff. The food never disappoints. Be sure to try the parmigiana, meatballs, and brownie for dessert.

Delicious real Italian food… once you’ve had Amici’s you will keep coming back for more! Family and friendly atmosphere makes you want to dine in when you thought you were gonna take out! A+++

5 stars all the way. Love this place! Amazing pizza, wings, and family environment. Incredible staff and owner. Amicis never disappoints, never!

Amazing spot with the friendliest local owners that make the extra effort. Definitely a family-friendly spot. Pizza is always our the best! Great lunch specials too.

If I could give this place more than 5 stars I would. Owner is there a lot and is one of the coolest dudes ever. Great family owned and operated business where everything on the menu is a hit. Highly recommend.

This family owned restaurant is one of my favorite places to eat! The staff is amazing and the food is incredible. The brownies and cannolis especially!! Everyone needs to try this place!

Got the super reasonable 2 slices and a soda for $7, they call me to make sure I got the slices I want, the slices are amazing!! Bonus points for the slices they were big and were a perfect eat for me. Had the wings on a separate occasion, also top tier, ultimately worth going to for sure, will come back for future lunches and midnight snacks.

Best pizza place. Love their wings and spaghetti too. So good! My fiancee is very picky and he loves coming here. We're lucky to live close by so we would get dinner from here every other week or so. Staff is friendly too. Go Panthers!

Upside down pie. Amici’s has the best pizza in town! Excellent service, delicious pasta and pizza. The owner Craig and his family are awesome. Just love this place!

Amici's pizza is the best we've found in South Florida. Make sure you try the upside down pizza! Their wings are delicious, too. The entire staff are super nice and always make sure the customers are happy. If you're looking for great local pizza (and everything else), look no further.

I get pizza from here maybe once a month. It's seriously good. As good as any pizza I've had in NY. Just wanted to write a positive review for here since I love their pizza so much.

I had the sausage and rapini and it was phenomenal. The toasted ravioli was great also. Then I got one of their famous homemade Brownie Bricks and it too was perfect. Definitely one of my favorite Italian restaurants that I've been to

If you're looking for an excellent pie look no further than Amici's because it's definitely the best I've had in twenty years visiting Deerfield Beach. We stumbled across this establishment by accident having left Duffy's bar and grill after a few bevies and being a few doors down we decided to give them a try. What a great coincidence because this establishment is first class all the way from the staff to the quality of the food, the pizza is really delicious with plenty of toppings and cheese but the crust is their secret weapon, simply amazing! They have a full menu of dishes to chose from and judging by the customers reactions it's all excellent food.

Best locally owned place to eat in this area. Always delicious, staff is super friendly, and they have never been late with any order I have placed. Thank you for making this community better!!!

Craig is the best owner! Best pizza in town! I highly recommend if you’re in coconut creek! Everything is delicious & the service is amazing.

After residing in Coconut Creek for five years, this exquisite restaurant became my go to for the best Italian food in town. The owner and his staff were the best. They were so accommodating. So much so, I became friends with the owner, CRAIG. His food is on point. I just had the chicken parm hero, and I felt like I was back in New York on Long Island. I live in Delray Beach now with my wife and baby girl and I made it a point to stop in again because I was in the area. Trust me, you’ll leave much happier than you came in.

This is PHENOMENAL PIZZA! I rarely write reviews but this has to be known to the world! The SAUCE, the CRUST, and the Cheese had me blown away! Also the OWNER came out and chatted with us and it’s an amazing atmosphere! If you haven’t tried this place you NEED To!

I exagerate not when I say this is the best pizza parlor in all the Coconut Creek and neighboring communities! If you’re on the hunt for the perfect pizza joint, Amici’s Pizzeria Cafe is the place to go. From the moment you walk in, you’re greeted like family—true to the name “Amici,” which means “friends” in Italian. But it’s not just the warm hospitality that keeps people coming back—it’s the pizza, them wings (the best!), the pasta, the calzones 😋…pretty much anything you order from menu you will love. Every bite of pretty much anything you order will testify it’s made fresh and much detail. Beyond the food, the vibe is relaxed, clean, and perfect for both a casual night out or a quick lunch stop. The staff? Friendly, fast, and clearly passionate about what they do. The owners (The Valvo’s) are a top notch family that will give you that “Mi casa, tu casa (my house, your house) feel! Amici’s isn’t just a pizza place—it’s a community favorite, a comfort food haven, and hands down one of the best culinary experiences in town. Go hungry, leave happy.🍕

Arriving at this little Italian restaurant was a total alternative stop....I started heading out for a steak restaurant, but the place i chose was so over crowded I ended up here on a fluke! But, to my surprise I found this friendly quality Italian joint...and I say joint because its small inside with limited seating, with a few tables outside...so if your eating in you might have to wait for a table if they are super busy....I sat down right away, no problem. I ordered veal parm meal, and the portions were just right from the salad to the bread sticks...and then the entrée and side of meatballs were perfect. My eyes were bigger than my stomach, but I finished as much as I could....enjoyed it all, I think the meatballs were a combo of meat and pork....I favor all meat WASP still like my mom used to make, but these were really good too, and the sauce everything was in tasted homemade! I'll be back soon. Thanks all, be safe. Charles

Great pizza, great wings and the upside down pizza should not be missed. It’s always fun for our family or perfect for a date night. Family owned and operated.

I was referred to your restaurant by my partner who had eaten the night before and was so impressed with the food & owner Craig and staff, I decided to give them a try for myself, I ordered a whole mess of these incredible tasty BBQ wings that were like no other I had before. I can’t wait to go back there with my wife and have another meal I would recommend this restaurant to anyone who wants great food and great service. Sincerely Scotty Davis Pool Pros Of Hollywood

Hole in the wall. Top shelf. From the food and the Staff. Complete 10. Sauce. Crust. Simply nailed it 👍

Great Pizza, fantastic garlic wings, and bread was excellent. I’m stuffed!

First time ordering from here. Delicious pizza. Had the bbq chicken. Crust was crispy and tasty, not soggy at all and bbq sauce was delicious. Will try again.

We were in town for a lacrosse tournament and happened upon this restaurant. The food was delicious and the staff was friendly, kind and polite. Would recommend highly if you are looking for actual Italian food that is great in taste. 5 stars.

I think the random walk-in for a good slice of pizza is overlooked sometimes. This place always has a great selection of slices, walk in, they warm it up but it's some of the best pizza I've have. I pretty much love everything from this place, I could go on forever. But awesome place for food, service is always great, can't go wrong. They're baked Italian wings are unbelievable, so if you're not in the mood for pizza, you need to get the wings, or maybe both.

I visited for lunch with my mom and my 2 kids. We had a wonderful lunch. The pizza was perfect, I brought a few slices home to my husband and he loved them as well. The service was great, and the ambiance was exactly what we were looking for. I also had the Amici’s salad and it was the best salad I’ve had in a while. It had eggplant, mushrooms, zucchini. We can’t wait to go back. The owner and his daughter took care of us which made it even more special.

A wonderful restaurant with delicious Italian food and service that makes you feel at home. We bring all our friends here and everyone loves it! We drive from Boca because it’s worth it

Amazing food Amazing service!! best pizza in town truly!!

Met the owner and his daughter—such a wonderful family business! They’ve been serving the community for about 18 years, and you can truly taste the passion in every bite. The pizza is absolutely amazing, the atmosphere is warm and welcoming, and it’s definitely a spot you need to eat at. Highly recommend!

Amici’s is known for its service, family atmosphere, and delicious food. The level of service and attention we receive at each visit is unmatched, the staff are caring, and great at recommendations if you can’t decide what to order. The pizza is amazing and the pasta options are incredible. The portions are generous. The owners give back to the community and we are so proud to support Amici’s. We have gone as a small party and a large party and have had a great experience all around each and every time! Looking forward to our next visit.

Hands down best pizza in town. Consistency is key and they always, always make it perfect. The crust is crunchy and the top is cheesy. We order at least once a week and it’s always perfect!

WOW! Get the upside down pizza! . Much more than just pizza! We were greeted promptly and sat in the dining room. Cozy little place. Friday night at 6 PM and it was packed. Delivery orders and pick up orders zooming out of the store one after another. Smiles on every face that worked there. we had a large, upside down pizza, half pepperoni, along with wings and chicken Parmesan sub. Service was top-notch and the food was awesome.. Thanks for a great experience. RJ and family

Kids put the iPad DOWN To EAT Here! Seriously, you have to eat here. Absolutely the most delicious pizza/calzzone,- any meal is just fantastic 🌟

Some of the best pizza I’ve ever had, and always big portions for a great price. Just make sure you dump a lotta Parmesan on if you get a plain cheese slice

Incredibly friendly staff, one of the Chefs came out personally to give me my food! I order the rustic Italian wings and let me tell you the flavor and the chicken falling from the bone are to die for…next time I am aiming for their specialty pizzas!

Amici’s is amazing. The pizza here comes out fresh and crispy each time. The dough is sturdy and hold up with toppings very well! The best experience you can have there is a pizza and wings combo. Their wings are double breaded and stay so crispy. I personally get the BBQ wings. The sauce they use is better than any BBQ wing sauce I’ve ever had. Been going here since I was a kid, and it’s only gotten better as I’ve grown older! Don’t leave without grabbing a brownie brick, you’ll thank me later.

This pizza saved my marriage. We couldn’t decide on a place to eat and were sick of the typical chain pizza joints. After some searching this ended up being exactly what I was looking for. Authentic custom pizzas that helped us know where to go when we craved pizza. And if we have the time we’d rather go in person because the staff are very inviting and kind. A great environment and good pizza that doesn’t make us feel sick after eating it. Great stuff.

Wow wow wow, best Pizzeria in South Florida!!! Been coming here for over 10 years. The food is amazing, the service is stellar and the owner is one of a kind. They make you feel like family even though I'm not Italian. I bring out of town guest in, frequently. A variety of food with a lovely touch of excellence!!!! Highly recommended!!!

Amici’s is AMAZING! The pizza is so good, the chicken and broccoli is actually insane… so fresh, flavorful, and cooked perfectly. The service is just as great, everyone is super kind and welcoming. You can tell they care about what they do. Definitely one of my go-to spots. Highly recommend!

We just moved to Winston Park and after a VERY long day of cleaning and unpacking, finally realized around 8:30pm that we should order some dinner. Craig, the owner, picked up the phone and let me know that they had been closed for over half an hour. I must of sounded so bummed because he offered to make us a pizza even though he had already begun cleaning up. I was so surprised someone picked up the phone, let alone making a pizza after closing. It brought tears to my eyes. He didn't have to do it but the fact that he did really speaks volumes to his character. We were really worried we wouldn't be able to find pizza like back home and this pizza did not disappoint. My hubby and daughter usually don't eat the crust, but this crust was so light and crispy, they ate it. The sauce was perfectly seasoned and there was plenty of cheese on it. Just the way I like it. We definitely recommend Amici's and plan to order a pie every weekend. Thank you Craig for the warm welcome to the neighborhood and the yummy brownie surprise, you're the best!

Amici’s is the BEST pizza in south Florida! Not only is the pizza incredibly delicious but the other food offered is amazing as well. Even though the food is unbelievable, it’s the staff that is the best part of amici’s. They treat us like family and the services is always top notch. We go every Friday with our family and we try and bring as many people as possible because it has become like home for us.

Hands down the best pizza shop in the área of Coconut Creek! The wings are amazing, the pasta always on point…and the pizza? Always done just right! Great atmosphere, plenty of food, plenty of options on the menú and the prices are great. Safe area, plenty of parking, on point music…just a great place to go whether by yourself or with friends or family or both!

My family and I absolutely love Amici’s! It’s my 2 year old son’s favorite pizza and we go there almost every Saturday, ha! Their wings and alfredo pasta are top notch 😍 tbh, anything there is yummy. Service is awesome, too! Highly recommend.

Went to amici’s last Friday and we had such a great time!! The food is amazing!! The mozzarella wedges were TO DIE FOR! We love a good cheese pull and that’s what we got! They had a big party come in and they quickly set tables for them and adjusted them accordingly and that group looked like they were having a great time too!! Will recommend them to everyone!!

We absolutely love Amici's, we order at least once a week. It's the only pizza and wings our 3 year old son will eat and it's become a staple in our household. If you haven't tried it, it's a must! Everything on their menu is DELICIOUS!

As a SFL native living in Broward my whole life, I literally travel to eat, and this place hands down has some of the best pizza I've ever had in my life! From the service to the actual food everything is fresh and taste great. The funny part about all of this, is I didn't even want pizza, I wanted wings but the smell sold me alone! This is my new number 1 spot!

My family and I love this place! Never disappoints. The food, customer service, and team are consistently amazing - especially considering they are usually slammed with onsite customers and a nonstop stream of takeout/pickup orders!

Never heard of this place. Looking for a quick bite. Had a small pizza delivered. I prefer a crisp crust, not soggy with greasy pie, and this was perfect. The taste was good also. I will be back. Thx

The chicken cutlet caesar salad is so tasty. We had the Eggplant hot sub and it was delicious. You have to try this place. Just downright homemade food and great employees.

Andrea

My family and I love this place! Never disappoints. The food, customer service, and team are consistently amazing - especially considering they are usually slammed with onsite customers and a nonstop stream of takeout/pickup orders!

TONY GENTILE

The chicken cutlet caesar salad is so tasty. We had the Eggplant hot sub and it was delicious. You have to try this place. Just downright homemade food and great employees.

Michael Slupecki

Never heard of this place. Looking for a quick bite. Had a small pizza delivered. I prefer a crisp crust, not soggy with greasy pie, and this was perfect. The taste was good also. I will be back. Thx

Raef Israel

Hands down best pizza in town. Consistency is key and they always, always make it perfect. The crust is crunchy and the top is cheesy. We order at least once a week and it’s always perfect!

jerrad gilliam

As a SFL native living in Broward my whole life, I literally travel to eat, and this place hands down has some of the best pizza I've ever had in my life! From the service to the actual food everything is fresh and taste great. The funny part about all of this, is I didn't even want pizza, I wanted wings but the smell sold me alone! This is my new number 1 spot!

Carolina Hindhaugh

Amici’s is known for its service, family atmosphere, and delicious food. The level of service and attention we receive at each visit is unmatched, the staff are caring, and great at recommendations if you can’t decide what to order. The pizza is amazing and the pasta options are incredible. The portions are generous. The owners give back to the community and we are so proud to support Amici’s. We have gone as a small party and a large party and have had a great experience all around each and every time! Looking forward to our next visit.

Very very good pizza. Crust is awesome. Nice lunch special, friendly staff. Highly recommend driving a little extra if need be. Even if just getting the regular cheese pizza. I like leaving it in the oven a couple extra minutes. Guess my diet will need to take a back seat every now and then🙃 . ENJOY

We order here all the time and first time ordering these Mozzarella Wedges (they didn't have mozzarella sticks) anyways... These were bad... This thing was soo burnt it was hard to bite into and there was no cheese inside the first one, it was nasty... 2nd one had cheese but it was all the way at the bottom.. The pizza this time tasted different... It wasnt the same taste... It was sooo greasy and just not that good this time... I still give this place 4 stars cuz food here is good but mayb that night they were just having an off day.. i dont know... We didnt eat it all..

Very good pizza and great chicken wings. I have a few complaints…I have had several pizzas delivered and all the cheese and sauce is slid to one side so check your pizza before giving a $10 tip…..I know they close a 9 but they usually take delivery orders till they close. Apparently tonight “the kitchen is already closed” at 8:17. The owner is awesome! Several months ago They forgot part of my order so I called and he delivered it on his way home. No big deal things happen but he went above and beyond to make it right. All in all I love this place and would recommend it to family and friends.

john troia

Very good pizza and great chicken wings. I have a few complaints…I have had several pizzas delivered and all the cheese and sauce is slid to one side so check your pizza before giving a $10 tip…..I know they close a 9 but they usually take delivery orders till they close. Apparently tonight “the kitchen is already closed” at 8:17. The owner is awesome! Several months ago They forgot part of my order so I called and he delivered it on his way home. No big deal things happen but he went above and beyond to make it right. All in all I love this place and would recommend it to family and friends.

Pizza is good, but it's not enough New York style. What I mean by New York style is the smell and taste the thinnest of the dough. Wings are good. But the customer service and atmosphere are amazing.

Chung Ng

Pizza is good, but it's not enough New York style. What I mean by New York style is the smell and taste the thinnest of the dough. Wings are good. But the customer service and atmosphere are amazing.

We had 2 pizzas, and they were both way over cook, almost burnt. This was our 2nd time, and now remember why we don't go there. The sause was very tasty, but the burnt bread and toppings no so much. While waiting for the pizza, I noticed that even the premade pizza was a little burnt. The place itself was nice, reminded me of Jersey. Employees were polite and nice.

Located in the Westcreek Plaza next door to Duffy's, Amici's Pizzeria reminds me of those family owned pizzerias in The Bronx where I used to stop in for a pizza slice and a can of soda after school. It's a small business with a casual ambiance and limited seating. Other than pizza, Amici's also offer: * Specialty pizzas/calzones/panini/wings * Hot & cold subs * Entrees & pasta dinners * Salads/antipasti/sides * kids meal/desserts * Daily lunch specials * Hot & cold beverages/beer & wine I approached a friendly female employee and asked if pizza slices are sold at this time. She replied "yes" and showed me various pizzas in the display case where I can make my choice. I didn't get the name; yet I chose a no sauce slice topped with ricotta, spinach, and plum tomatoes. Waited a few minutes while the slice got heated. Never had a pizza with no tomato sauce before...it was unusual and something I would have to get accustomed to, but it was tasty. The crust was hard but I didn't mind. Prices are moderate, but their lunch specials are reasonable.

The pizza here is incredible! The food is good. The service is not so great. My party of 7 was yelled at by the waitress because we had split checks. We were regulars there every Friday evening. She was not happy and procided to yell at us in the small restaurant. When we asked for a manager, she said she is the manager. I love their pizza, however we will not be back. Edit: turns out it was the owners daughter.

Mary Stafford

The pizza here is incredible! The food is good. The service is not so great. My party of 7 was yelled at by the waitress because we had split checks. We were regulars there every Friday evening. She was not happy and procided to yell at us in the small restaurant. When we asked for a manager, she said she is the manager. I love their pizza, however we will not be back. Edit: turns out it was the owners daughter.

jonah ginsburg

Ive had several things from here, all of them mediocre at best. But this pizza was the final nail in the coffin. The crust was unbelievably bad, almost like a sourdough. Sauce flavorless and toppings slapped on top with zero respect.

Ive had several things from here, all of them mediocre at best. But this pizza was the final nail in the coffin. The crust was unbelievably bad, almost like a sourdough. Sauce flavorless and toppings slapped on top with zero respect.

Food was good! Unfortunately we walked in and noticed the cook was not wearing a mask while making all the food. We watched him the whole time never covered his face so we won't return.

Terrible experience. I ordered wings and pizza over the phone for pickup. They forgot the Buffalo sauce for wings instead Gave me like this strange black sauce like worchstershire sauce. And the pizza was terrible. It looks like it was made the day before. Absolutely terrible. I called and I think the owner answered and said they misunderstood me. How can u misunderstand two totally completely different sauces. Don't recommend this place. So dissapointed. They started out good at the beginning but for some reason the quality has gotten worse and worse.

We used to love this place, but things went downhill. There were a few mishaps recently, like the 10 lbs of ricotta cheese in a calzone that ran like milk. That was gross. I let that slide. The kicker was the upside down pizza we ordered with black olives that contained at least 5 olive pits. Yes, olive pits. Luckily, it didn't cause any dental accidents and our 3 children that were eating it didn't choke. When we called to notify the staff, so that it didn't reoccur to someone else, the girl that answered the phone, claiming to be the manager, acted like she could careless with childish teenager attitude. It is EXTREMELY dangerous that you allowed olive pits to make it into the food. I know mistakes happen, but the complete lack of empathy afterwords was the icing on the cake. So, we're done. A loyal customer, gone. I actually had to edit this review -- it was a 5 star with good feedback. Sad. We were good for at least 1 order a week. Dominic's is better anyways.

These prices are outrageous! Almost $40 bucks to deliver a cheese pizza down the street?! The amount of unnecessary charges to use their online ordering system is appalling- they should be ashamed

I was a regular customer, visiting every Friday night. During my most recent visit, after requesting separate checks, the manager told us our group was a nuisance each Friday, and publicly berated us in front of other guests. This was unprofessional and unacceptable. Apparently, requesting separate checks was too much for them to handle. After that, we were treated poorly. I won’t be returning.

I would give zero stars if I could. We ordered chicken francese and pizza, and the food was a complete disaster. The sauce for the chicken francese had spilled everywhere, soaking the salad. The pizza was completely undercooked — the cheese and toppings were basically soup on raw dough. The salad itself was a joke: mostly arugula with just three small pieces of cheese and one slice of prosciutto. When I called the restaurant to address the issue, instead of offering to remake the food or provide a refund (at least for the uncooked pizza), the man on the phone got extremely nasty, called me a liar, and claimed that this was “great customer service.” Absolutely unacceptable. Save your time, money, and frustration — there are far better places to eat.

Went here with a group of friends last night and it turned into the worst dining experience I’ve ever had. The food was good but the owner’s daughter who was serving us caused an embarrassing scene where she yelled at us and accused a friend of mine of talking about her behind her back and said we were “a nightmare” for her to deal with. She was apparently upset because she was asked to split a check a few ways. My friends and I are very friendly customers and usually tip well. Several of us have had restaurant jobs and we are empathetic to servers. I have never been treated so badly in my life. We were there to comfort my friend who is having a difficult time. She’s the one who was accused of talking about the server, which never happened. She broke down in tears after this and I was shaking so badly I couldn’t find my car. Don’t recommend.

Acacia

Went here with a group of friends last night and it turned into the worst dining experience I’ve ever had. The food was good but the owner’s daughter who was serving us caused an embarrassing scene where she yelled at us and accused a friend of mine of talking about her behind her back and said we were “a nightmare” for her to deal with. She was apparently upset because she was asked to split a check a few ways. My friends and I are very friendly customers and usually tip well. Several of us have had restaurant jobs and we are empathetic to servers. I have never been treated so badly in my life. We were there to comfort my friend who is having a difficult time. She’s the one who was accused of talking about the server, which never happened. She broke down in tears after this and I was shaking so badly I couldn’t find my car. Don’t recommend.