patsy malpica

Pizza was okayyyyy . I’ve definitely had better a little bland and the sauce is thick Service is bad 2 ladies were infront on their phones “busy” while I was waiting for them to take my order . A guy who was doing everything making food , taking orders on phone took my order he’s the only reason I’m giving them 2 stars for service

Lauren M

Note there is a fee for credit card. Good pizza and chicken roll. My only major complaint is no gloves anywhere - they are using bare hands to handle all the food pre and post cooked. It tasted delicious and I can only hope that they wash their hands well. My spouse said that's common in Long Island..

Daniel Pino

Pizza Supreme Est. 1958 Layout/atmosphere *12 tables; TV; parking lot Food/drink *Square slice - solid; thin crust *Buffalo chicken slice - fine; late heat from seasoning on chicken; fragmented crust underneath

Shomik Das

It's an old timey pizza joint that has a decent enough pepperoni slice. The service is prompt and friendly. It's not a bad choice if it's the only option in the area. The crust is crunchy enough and the toppings are okay. Granted things are pricey now, but I do expect more even from a humble slice. Hopefully next time is better

Laura Hoffman

Very disappointed... Sauce on Square Pizza (actually slices are rectangular) was very thick, pasty & salty. Used to put a nice rectangular slice of cheese on each slice. Now a drizzle of shredded cheese to look rectangular. Dough was good. The Caesar Salad dressing was overpowered with anchovy paste & lots of grated cheese & black pepper. The dressing tasted hot from too much anchovy paste & black pepper. Also, it didn't have any slices of parmesian cheese. Most pizzerias give a small piece of Italian bread with a large salad. We didn't get any bread.

Courtney Gentry

Usually I love this place, like order 2ishx a week love. but the last few times I've ordered delivery the pizza has looked like this. The driver doesn't bring change when paying cash and this happens often... I've called a few times and have been told the owner or manager will call me but never does.

The reviews aren’t lying , just went in for a And pepperoni slice and chicken roll . Staff is very unwelcoming and rude . Don’t say hello when you walk in And it is true what you all are saying about them being selective with the customer service . I am Hispanic so is my husband we walked in they were giving us a whatever attitude and then once they seen the white men approach started to be friendly . THE EMPLOYEES WERE HISPANIC AS WELL . Que vergüenza . Say yourself the displeasure and go to dominos

Cesar Alvarez

I had a disappointing experience at this place due to its lack of cleanliness. During my visit, I ordered some pepperoni slices, and I noticed The staff member who had just handled money proceeded to grab the pizza toppings with his bare hands. He dug into the bucket of pepperoni without wearing any gloves, highly unsanitary. This lack of basic food safety practices is alarming and discouraging.

Maison Reese

Didn’t get greeted when walking in. Snatched money out of my hand and didn’t say a single word to us. An old white lady walked in and their moods immediately changed. Pizza is mid, service sucked, and vibes were completely off. Will absolutely never return.

Kevin Kohlmeyer

I ordered a few slices the girl working put them in the oven and disappeared for 10 minutes and then tried to serve me the burnt pizza. Big argument to get my money back I didn't want new pizza just wanted my money back.

Arely

Called ahead to order a grandma slice. After the left the store, I saw that it was a small size corner slice basically toast bread. This should’ve been half the price not the full price of a grandma slice. It was already too late to go back and let them know to give me a different slice or a refund.