After a bone chilling week, I stopped in for a quick bite. DeMarco's was more than accommodating with a variety of different foods that tasted amazing. I definitely recommend anyone from the local area or beyond to try the great food, friendly staff, and calming atmosphere.

Jada Martinez

I ordered delivery for the first time from here. I have no complaints from start to finish! The person who answered the phone, spoke very clearly, respectful, and nice! Put my order in easily! Delivery took a little less than 30min, food came to us warm and ready! Personal pie was delicious!! Their zeppoles made me crave for more, my husband got chicken rolls which were phenomenal and still so warm his cheese pull was mesmerizing! The penne vodka pasta, smelled so fresh of basil, container was full, great amount of sauce and parmesan on top! i’m very picky with my choices of food, i’m also pregnant and extra picky about how i like my food. Demarcos DID NOT let me down!!! I will be returning for sure!! i’d take pictures but i ate it all too fast🫣

Nancy Frueh

Took awhile but soo delicious!!! Even cold !! Egg plant parm was Great!!!

Matthew Bouldin

Best Pizza in town... new here and first time... crust is excellent... sauce is great... very happy w the pie!!

Mike Maines

Plain pie was delicious, Calzone was 10/10, and the service was fantastic!! Would recommend if you live in the area.

Isaac

Wow! I asked for an Alfredo chicken Parm sandwich, and oh my is this good. If you like Alfredo you MUST try this. Thank you for making this I think it might need a spot on the menu!

Danielle Musella

This is the BEST pizza place! The smell when you walk in, oh my gosh, so good and the food sure does follow the smell. We ordered 3 slices and 1 whole gluten free pie. Amazing! The crust on the Gluten free pie was one of the best I've had. It had flavor, great texture, and was over all amazing for gluten free crust! I even called to ask how they do their gluten free pies to make sure I feel safe with their process since I have celiacs. Everyone i spoke with was so kind and answered all my questions. The staff is also amazing there too! The coffee italian soda is a must too. The other 3 slices we ordered were very good as well. Overall I cannot recommend this place enough, espically if you have someone with a gluten allergy/sensitivity/celiacs in your group!

Belgin Lore

My hubbie comes 3,000 miles for the veal parm!! Fantastic lasagna and veal parmigiana! The beef barley soup was so good! Love the chopped Italian salad. First place we go when we visit our family in West Milford!!

Meghan P

Was my first time ordering. Excellent customer service. Some of my food arrived wrong and they brought the correct food and let me keep the wrong part. Personal Hawaiian pie was delicious. Girl I spoke with was nice , upbeat and understanding. Keep up the good work!

Wyatt Sohjusey

This place is unreal. Usually was a Franks Pizza in west milford regular. I found a coupon in the paper for a free pizza from DeMarco’s so decided to give it a try. The food is 10/10 awesome. Since getting that free pizza my family has ordered from there 4 times in the past 7 days. The chicken buffalo with ranch sandwich is my go to and I highly recommend. All of their pastas are great as well, the penne Alfredo with chicken is absolutely delicious. Staff are also great people, I went in there and pretty much reiterated everything I’m writing in this review to them and they were loving it. 11/10 food + they deliver!!!