Hailey Ferster

Contrary to the review left most recently by Mr. M.J. Schudlick, every experience my family and I have had, were nothing short of awesome. Food is delicious, atmosphere is super unique and fun and service has been great. While they are now under new ownership, they have been in the process of updating their hours and menu. Which, they have been more than accommodating in letting everyone know days in advance of any and all changes over on their Facebook. If you ever have questions about their hours or menu’s, that is your best place to look! So glad Mill Creek is back!

Eileen Scheid

They had a supply issue so several items were not available. The one server they had was very cordial but since a 2 person operation things took awhile. The food we received was delicious and she was very attentive. The atmosphere is rustic and cozy, will continue to go there.

mrbobf

Outstanding cafe! We had the quesadillas and the Irish Bene (pronounced "Bennie"). Both were just perfect, plenty big enough portions and outstanding flavors. Service was excellent: fast and friendly. Menu just right for all preferences along with reasonable pricing. Crowd was lively but not loud, thanks to the good room acoustics. Back patio has big potential, just needs a little TLC. A seasonal tent cover would help extend their capacity. Overall, we highly recommend this great establishment!

Alyssa

We Ordered a quesadilla and chicken wings for lunch, they both were excellent. The wings were cooked perfectly and so decently priced. I have absolutely found my new spot for wings. Customer service was excellent as well. So so friendly!

Stan&Diane Friesen

So glad the Mill Creek Ice Cream Shop is open! Friendly, courteous service- now including boba!

+1

Kurt Krueger

High quality food prepared with care in a lovely space. Can’t wait to come back for more. Added bonus is the pet friendly outdoor dinning.

Ronie B

Fresh tasting food! Great service ! Make reservations you will not be disappointed.

Ben S

We love this place! Service is friendly and genuine. The food is great, so much so that the most popular dishes sometimes sell out, but we appreciate a place that makes food fresh and goes through it in a day. We had the fried chicken, fried fish, fried shrimp and a cheeseburger and all of it was spot-on. Whoever runs the fryer knows his/her stuff... Our server, Zack was great - even our children mentioned how 'cool' he was. This place is a destination in its own right, and we're lucky to have it here in town...

Charles Ciggia

Awesome food, many healthy alternatives vs the norm. Service was second to none. We will be back soon!

Tamitha Browning

Great service and amazing food options. Ordered the Black and Bleu wrap and freshly made lemonade.

Brett Mccue

Food was delicious. Caleb our server was very knowledgeable and attentative. Local craft beer on tap a plus

Sarrah Lombardo

This was my first time here, however my aunt and Grandmother come here often. This fish fry- both beer battered and panko, were delicious! The dinner portion was enough for 2 people or leftovers. The sweet potato fries, homemade tartar, and Woodstead sauce made this dish even better. I cannot wait to be back in the area to dine here again! ***Picture of my plate was after I had devoured most of it.

Kelk70

Had an Awesome breakfast here! Blueberry stuffed pancakes were So Yummy! Breakfast sandwich was fresh & not greasy like some places have! Excellent home fries! Our server was friendly & prompt. We will definitely be back!

Kevin B. Leigh

What a pleasant surprise. we’re here on vacationAnd we’re just driving around looking for a coffee shop, discovered the Mill Creek. From the one the moment we walked in the front door we were welcomed with delicious smells, wonderful service, and a cozy environment. The prices were reasonable, food was delicious, service was exceptional. A real gem in the Honeoye Lake community.

Aaron Peterson

Sausage breakfast sando is delicious. House made sausage. Irish benie is made with delicious shredded corned beef.