Daniel Donnelly

Fine quality food at reasonable prices. Ample parking and friendly staff. Clean and spacious venue. Bathrooms well-maintained.

Angie F

First time here today for Mother's Day. No Mother's Day specials. The 3 toppings on our large pizza you would need a microscope to find them!! That was ridiculous!! The Greek salad and dressing always good!!

Zarek V-C

The main area in the building is a homey and very italian pizza feel. The food was great, but my only criticism was that the pizza had too much flour on it. Overall, if you ever visit Millerton New York, then you have to try Four Brothers Pizza.

Jon R.

First food was excellent. Strongly recommend the spinach pie. Second - it took way ton get our meal. Customers that came in way after us were served their food before ours. Our server was great and did the best she could. She was very apologetic. With all that, the food is still great. Would get 5 stars if not for the delay this visit. Recommend!

Greg Ezersky

Got take out. My medium pepperoni pizza was definitely a frozen one that you guys sell online. No Bueno. Disappointed you guys were always the best around. The cook is great why aren't you letting him do his thing and make me a good pizza. Sorry about the complaint but come on

Alexus Handschuh

I want to first start by saying that this review has nothing to do with the interactions with the waitress and her service! Her name is Nicole! She was nothing but honest, timely, and prompt. She even seemed very overwhelmed. The kitchen staff was distracted amongst themselves laughing In the back as the waitress was managing every seated inside, phone calls, and to go orders. First the mozzarella sticks came out still frozen and the meal came out burnt. After letting the waitress know we had no hard feelings toward her, she too admitted that the kitchen staff had been messing up on her all day. Very poor management/kitchen staff that’s not easing any of the work load of the waitresses.

Janelle Lawrence

My service was "eh" at best. The environment (diners and the person who took my order) looked at me like I didn't belong there. When I came back to pay for my food she told me my order price (which was pretty high, but whatever) as though she expected I couldn't pay. The pizza was good but the Buffalo wings were trash :/ I know this is a chain so maybe other spots are better. But I wouldn't return to any of them as of now.

rosemarie spak

We tried the eggplant Parmesan grinder and a ham grinder . Would not get those again. Eggplant was not breaded and there was hardly any eggplant on the sandwich. The whole thing fell apart. Not sure there was a My cheese either. The ham had minimal lettuce and was just ok. Will not be going there again

George

Four bros is extremely expensive. The food is not worth what they are charging. Pasta dishes are drenched in butter and salt. I don't want to pay top dollar for a meal that should be half the price of what they're charging. Due to the amount of salt and butter they use in their foods. I tell ppl all the time if you want to pay a small fortune for a toxic meal and end up with severe health issues, keep eating at four bros.

Frank Nenninger

I got screwed! Picked up a takeout order and drove home, opened the bag and I was missing a salad. I dont live down the road, this is the country and it's a 1.5 hour round trip back to this place. So I decided to call and get a refund. The girl on the other end of the line stated she can't give me a refund because she needs my cc. Really? You want me to drive back and forth for a refund? I can get a refund from a company on the otherside of the world and you can't get it done? So she gave me a number of the manager because no one of importance was working that night. I called the next day, no answer. Called the next day no answer, left message after message and nothing. This went one for a week. I finally gave up and excepted the fact I got screwed for $15. It's not about the money, I have done well in life, it's the principle of how companies treat there customers. I don't recommend this place to anyone, they don't treat people correctly.