Malayna Mackerley

You can't find a restaurant more authentic than Tilly's. Hands down the best food I've had in awhile, and burgers are made fresh to order! Our waitress and rest of the staff were also delightful. This 50's style diner will have you in awe from the decor and atmosphere to the mouth watering food and friendly staff. It's a MUST try, and try again spot!! I'll definitely be back again... maybe even for breakfast in the morning!

Daniel Donnelly

Good food at fair prices. Desserts exquisite! My only gripe is with an order of breaded shrimp which came unshelled (discovered only after biting into the morsels). Clean bathrooms and friendly staff. Very convenient locations just off Routes 42 and 17, with ample parking out front. Wi-fi available. The Sullivan County Libertarian Party convened here for the first time on December 15th, 2019.

+4

Yan Milner

Old school diner, everything is still original since the 50’s. Very nice atmosphere. We will definitely come back here again. Delicious food 👍🏻😀👏🏻

Good service nice ppl! Food was good and so was the vibe, nice and cute! Also the bathrooms were clean

Good service nice ppl! food was good and so was the vibe, nice and cute! Also the bathrooms were clean

Good service nice ppl! Food was good and so was the vibe, nice and cute! Also the bathrooms were clean

Good service nice ppl! Food was good and so was the vibe, nice and cute! Also the bathrooms were clean

Ordered lasagna to go and it was fantastic. The staff were very helpful. I'll be back!

Ordered lasagna to go and it was fantastic. The staff were very helpful. I'll be back!

The place to go for good diner food, good prices and service . Easy parking. The place to be seen in Sullivan County

The place to go for good diner food, good prices and service . Easy parking. The place to be seen in Sullivan County

The place to go for good diner food, good prices and service . Easy parking. The place to be seen in Sullivan County

We stopped here for breakfast after checking out f Resorts Casino. It was a nice surprise. The place is clean and friendly and welcoming. Not impersonal like so many diners can be. Service was good…

We stopped here for breakfast after checking out f Resorts Casino. It was a nice surprise. The place is clean and friendly and welcoming. Not impersonal like so many diners can be. Service was good…

good food, good service, nice employee, cheap price (10-15 dollars per person), quiet, comfy seats, good air conditioning, open parking, fast service, overall I have only seen 1 flaw and the pict…

good food, good service, nice employee, cheap price (10-15 dollars per person), quiet, comfy seats, good air conditioning, open parking, fast service, overall I have only seen 1 flaw and the pictur…

Great pancakes Great coffee and friendly people. parking is easy and the atmosphere is calm.

Great pancakes Great coffee and friendly people. Parking is easy and the atmosphere is calm.

Had the chicken, mozzarella and pesto on a panini. Very delicious! Nice portion! clean diner and nice staff

Classic diner with all the choices!! We had chicken salad and potato salad both were yummy. Classic breakfast was great too! \nHandicap accessible

Enjoyed a delicious apple and grilled chicken salad. Husband had a Cobb salad which also looked great. Portions were large but we ate everything! Missed the paper towels in the restroom but the wai…

Homemade banana cream pie!\nExcellent quesadillas!\nUnfortunately they sell out of the special tres leches cake but I forgive them\ndecent bathroom.

Thank goodness for this diner. It was close to the resort, and the food was pretty good. The staff was friendly. I would return.

Great service. Excellent coffee. My grandchildren loved the chocolate chip pancakes. My omelette was good. Reasonable prices. Would go again.

Great service. Excellent coffee. My grandchildren loved the chocolate chip pancakes. My omelette was good. Reasonable prices. Would go again.

Tilly’s Bar is solid for breakfast. They open early, which I like, and it’s a good spot to start the day. Food in the morning is on point and worth going back for. Lunch is just okay. Not bad, but nothing special. I wouldn’t come back for lunch, but for breakfast, I’ll definitely return anytime.

Hadi Shadkam

Stopped here for a quick lunch. The food was okay, but the service and vibre were better than the food.

B.D. Y.

We stopped here on our way to Cooperstown, after flying in from Los Angeles, where there are very few diners. This is a great one. The menu has plenty of staples as well as more creative options.

Fallen King

Food was good, but the older blonde female waitress was the only down side. Kinda makes you feel unwelcome. If you go definitely avoid having her as your server.

CeCe James

The food and service are always perfect. The single complaint I have is that the apple crumb pie always has a freezer burn taste (not sure about the other flavors). The flavor is delicious, but the freezer burn taste almost overpowers it.

Mich Bartolo

Jan2023 party of 10: Food was deceivingly delicious. The seasoning was perfectly distributed with savory sazón and desserts were nicey sweet. They even had flan! We had brunch and the food hit the right spot at the right time. Diner had a little tiny hallway but thats okay. I would come here again with and without the homies. Oh and did I mention this place is affordable and veggie friendly.

+9

There is such a 1950's style vibe when you walk in the doorway. Service was great, got treated immediately. The prices are reasonable and the menu is huge! \n\nI went with the breakfast option. The…

There is such a 1950's style vibe when you walk in the doorway. Service was great, got treated immediately. The prices are reasonable and the menu is huge! \n\nI went with the breakfast option. The…

Visited as a party of 6. Shirt wait for our table. Very friendly staff. Food came out quickly. Everything we tried was very good. From wings to meatloaf!

Visited as a party of 6. Shirt wait for our table. Very friendly staff. food came out quickly. Everything we tried was very good. From wings to meatloaf!

Visited as a party of 6. Shirt wait for our table. Very friendly staff. Food came out quickly. Everything we tried was very good. From wings to meatloaf!

Visited as a party of 6. Shirt wait for our table. Very friendly staff. Food came out quickly. Everything we tried was very good. From wings to meatloaf!

Had a cup of soup and 1/2 of Pastrami sandwich. Food was ok and very reasonably priced. Looks good for breakfast, or a quick lunch

Had a cup of soup and 1/2 of Pastrami sandwich. Food was ok and very reasonably priced. Looks good for breakfast, or a quick lunch

Gave this a 4 because the rest of the family liked it. I wasn’t a fan of the Ray’s breakfast. waitress was nice, place was clean, and lots on the menu. Kids liked the Tilly’s special, and my wife l…

Gave this a 4 because the rest of the family liked it. I wasn’t a fan of the Ray’s breakfast. Waitress was nice, place was clean, and lots on the menu. Kids liked the Tilly’s special, and my wife l…

Gave this a 4 because the rest of the family liked it. I wasn’t a fan of the Ray’s breakfast. Waitress was nice, place was clean, and lots on the menu. Kids liked the Tilly’s special, and my wife l…

Rebecca Kaplan-Fisher

We stopped in for lunch today. Not very busy. He ordered the beef and lamb gyro and white bean soup, I ordered hot open roast beef. It took almost a half an hour to get lunch to the table, don't understand why there were only four other people in there. Wait staff was distant and unfriendly. Typical dining decor hasn't been updated in years. When we did get our food it was actually tasty, flavorful and good-sized portions. My husband asked for the ketchup for his french fries- she placed an open bottle of ketchup on the table. WILD. Prices are reasonable for the portions. My husband really enjoyed the white bean soup he said it was flavorful and tasty. He also said it was one of the better gyro he has eaten, the meat was flavorful and tender. Might stop in again, and try something for dinner one night.

Jay Jay

This place is a cute small place with pictures of old school actors all over, lots of pictures of Elvis, guess they big Elvis fan. Food was ok simple breakfast platter had to switch the himefries because they were cold and bland. The tuna was average and simple.

+1

So after reading some the reviews I decided to try out Tilly's. This is the half of the HUGE roast beef sandwich. See pic! It's small and no way near the reviews posted. Though the soup was great the…

So after reading some the reviews I decided to try out Tilly's. This is the half of the HUGE roast beef sandwich. See pic! It's small and no way near the reviews posted. Though the soup was great…

One of our party asked for a Buffalo Chicken Wrap and asked if the sauce used was hot sauce or Buffalo sauce and the answer was Buffalo . When the food came it was hot sauce. When the waitress was questioned , she said this what they use and if you wanr we can it over with no sauce or do you want something else. The person chose something else. When the bill came both meals were on the bill. When questioned at the register we were told we had to pay for the uneaten food or the waitress had to pay for it. How ridiculous is that. She offered the options. We were also we don’t use hot sauce, but it was on every table.

The new owners under a different name so previous reviews are not accurate. New name of place is "Marina and Chico's Diner".\nbroken stools, dirty floors, and the food was disgusting.

Tillys Dinner the old good place…. Now the new owners are running the place to the ground missing stools, dirty floors, and disgusting food. New name Marina and Chico’s diner!

Not recommended this diner is on the new management and just falling apart. Missing stools, broken tables, dirty floors, and the food was disgusting.

Tillys Dinner the old good place…. Now the new owners are running the place to the ground missing stools, dirty floors, and disgusting food. New name Marina and Chico’s diner!

Not recommended this diner is on the new management and just falling apart. Missing stools, broken tables, dirty floors, and the food was disgusting.

穆白

The experience here was terrible, and it was clear that we, as Asian customers, were being treated differently. Firstly, the service staff were completely unresponsive and didn't offer any proactive service, even after we had repeatedly tried to get their attention. Secondly, we waited a full thirty minutes after being seated before we even received a menu. When the food finally arrived, our table was the only one without cutlery, and the waiter even told us to get it ourselves. The most outrageous part was the payment process. The staff member at the counter forcefully threw our bill aside, didn't make eye contact with us at all, and was extremely impatient. This behavior was incredibly rude and made us feel completely ignored. Even more baffling was that other tables around us received smiles and attentive service, while we were completely neglected from beginning to end. The overall experience was extremely disappointing and completely unacceptable.