Freddy Villalona

This was by far one of the best whiskey selection I have seen in the city. There were so many options I had no idea what to order. They also have higher-end whiskeys that are not on the menu or limited editions. Just ask the bartender and he will go through a few options. I went with Blanton's since it is often hard to find. I will definitely come back to this spot. Aside from whiskey, they also have beers, tequila, and mezcal. The food and small plates are very delicious and they even have vegan options. Definitely a spot to visit in a near and far future. #whiskey #bar #food #bourbon #scotch

+8

Joe Lupo

We have visited American Whiskey several times, each time our experience has been wonderful. The bar staff is very welcoming and very knowledgeable when asked about the amazing craft whiskeys they serve. It has become our "go to spot" when we're in the city.

Melissa Gaynor

Went on a Wednesday afternoon for drinks and some snacks. We got seated right away for our group of 5. Only tried one drink, but it was delicious. Also got the tater tots with black pepper mayo which were a nice side. Would definitely consider coming back!

Siphiwe Muze

Great venue and location. The staff is lovely to work with too. Shout out to Pam and Kelly!

+2

Megha J

This a friendly, spacious bar with a fun, theme-appropriate decor. The bartenders are very friendly. Mine made me a pretty good whiskey toddy! I ordered tater tots for a snack and they were fresh and texturally perfect, and came in a decent-sized portion. I’d definitely stop in for a post-work drink again.

Yolanda Shoshana

I was at American Whiskey for a bourbon and barbecue dinner. The food was so good! The brisket was tender, which is how I like it. Ribs were juicy, tender, and on point. Then there were sides which paired well with the meat. If you are midtown and need a place to eat before a concert or game, check this spot out. It's a mix of locals and tourists. Enjoy!

U N

Unfortunately we waited over an hour for our food despite a reservation. Everything was ordered off the menu with no substitutions requested. Server didn’t even come back to check on our drink orders or request if we wanted refills (despite drinks being empty for 30 minutes). Sat by the door, was very cold. Once we got food, half came out, 20 mins the other half came out but still missing multiple parts of the order. Sandwiches drenched in oil, bread not toasted and overall I could have done better in my own kitchen. Very disappointed. My sandwich was $20, but was on plain, untoasted white bread and came out cold, no fries or anything on the side. Will not be returning.

J Flan

Stopped by American Whiskey before a game at MSG because the location is perfect. Unfortunately, that’s where the positives end. Service was painfully slow as it took over 30 minutes just to get our first drink, and the bartenders barely acknowledged us. We were also told they weren’t seating tables for another hour, which made zero sense. For a place that calls itself a whiskey bar, the drinks were shockingly bad. They don’t have sour mix for a whiskey sour, and the old fashioneds were a mess. No muddled fruit, bottled syrup, way too many bitters, and some mystery “juice.” Great location, bad execution. Do yourself a favor and grab a drink literally anywhere else but here!

Pablo Gonzalez

Horrible service and got charged $11 for not even a pint size and $18 for a terrible Moscow mule. Avoid this place.

Matthew Smentkowski

Service was absolutely horrible. They brought out apps and dinner together everything was warm and soggy.I would not suggest going here it's a complete dumpster fire.